It immediately became evident that a most determined effort was to be made to crush her claims. The honors of war were not to be allowed to rest on the head that had so ably won them. Personal and political interests were too strongly involved. If it had been a little matter it might have pa.s.sed; but this was a case of such magnitude and importance, a case that must greatly change existing estimates.
To defeat the testimony was impossible. Other means must be used.
Chicanery of every kind was resorted to.
Twice Miss Carroll"s whole file of papers were stolen from the Military Committee, who were considering her claims.
Fortunately Miss Carroll possessed the original drafts of these letters. She speedily reproduced them, and the Military Committee and Mr. Hunt, the keeper of the records, having already examined the letters, accepted the new file and ordered them to be printed, thus giving them their guarantee; so that, to all intents and purposes, they became the same as the originals.
Judge Wade advises Miss Carroll:
"I want you to set forth to these gentlemen, in your private letters, the facts about the abstracting of these papers. It has never been properly done. It is exceedingly important as evidence of the truth of your claim. Tell them how your papers were abstracted from the files twice. Send a letter to General Banning. Tell Judge Evans to ask the General to appoint a sub-committee to investigate it, so as to submit it to the general committee. Tell them all, and remind them that when one report was made in the Senate Committee by Mr. Howard the papers were abstracted from the files, as the Secretary of the Committee, Rev. Samuel Hunt, will testify. I hope the report will be a very emphatic and explicit one in setting forth your plan as you took it to Colonel Scott. It makes the strongest foundation to commence upon in the sub-committee. There will undoubtedly be a minority of Republicans, and it will be so much the better for that, because they can find no evidence to invalidate the report of the majority, and I would like to see them make the attempt. Being at the head of the War Committee, I had most to do with it. The committee not half the time were present. n.o.body knows the difficulty the War Committee had to get the army moved. We had almost to fight for that campaign."
Mr. Hunt writes from Natick, Ma.s.s.:
_March 7, 1876._
My Dear Miss Carroll:
I remember well your failure to recover twice all the papers you intrusted to the charge of the Military Committee and our inability to account for their loss.
Hoping you will have better success now, I remain as ever,
Very truly yours,
S. HUNT, _Late Secretary of Senate Military Committee._
Senator Howard tells Miss Carroll she has a right to feel disappointed that her claims should be neglected, but he says, "you know the great power of the _military_, who don"t want you to have the recognition."
"Senator Howard," she replies, "there is something in moral integrity. I understand you, but just tell the _truth_. I ask only to be sustained by truth, and am not afraid of this power."
"Miss Carroll," he says with emphasis, "you have done more for the country than them all. You told and showed where to fight and how to strike the rebellion upon its head. No one comprehends the magnitude of that service more than I."
Judge Wade"s remarks to Senator Wilson last of May, 1862 (as taken down by a reporter):
Judge Wade said he talked just right to Wilson for the delay in Miss Carroll"s matter before his committee; that Wilson said he was no more against the claim than Wade. Wade told him it would _kill_ him politically if he didn"t act soon; that it ought to kill any party who knew the truths of the great civil war and conspired to conceal them for their own purposes; that it would be a great feather in a man"s cap and a great help to his own cause to bring the matter before the country _right_, no matter _who_ it offended, and he only regretted he was not in the Senate then on this very account, and would always be sorry he had not induced Miss Carroll to come out and make claim for her rights while the rejoicing was going on at the final surrender.
Wilson said it was a big thing, and he agreed that the American people would cheerfully pay for it, if it had been so done, by contribution boxes at the cross-roads and post-offices of the country.
Mr. Tucker writes from Philadelphia in 1870:
"I saw Colonel Scott yesterday and placed your papers in his hands. He remarked that he should stand by all he had said or written in the matter, and he presumed that was all you would want."
_1872._
Judge Wade says: "I went to Morton, in the Senate, and told him that it was infamous that the Military Committee did not report at once. He said, for himself he was ready to endorse your claim fully, and had done so when Howard reported. I went on to tell him more, but he said, "I could not be more strongly convinced of the justice of that claim.
Your own statement satisfied me without anything more. If Wilson will send down for the report I will sign my name to it right now." I then went over to Wilson and told him what Morton had said, and told him he had better send down for it. Wilson said he didn"t think that was the best way of doing it, but that he would call a special meeting of the Committee and have it done. I then saw Cameron. He said he was ready and always had been."
_1873._
Judge Wade tells her: "Howe said your claim had been sent to his committee--on Claims--but that it did not properly belong there; but that he had examined the papers; that your claim was entirely just and ought to be paid."
And again: "That he had spoken to Wadleigh, a member of the Military Committee, about her claim. He said he had no question that it was clearly proved, and no doubt she would be ultimately paid by the Government."
_1874._
Judge Wade says: "I asked Logan what he was going to do about Miss Carroll"s claim." He said "he didn"t know what to say." "I told him it ought to be paid at once; that it was clearly established." Logan said, "Yes; but she claims so much." Wade replies, "She claims to have furnished the information that led to the military movements that decided the war." Logan didn"t say any more, or what he would do.
Judge Wade asked Morrill what he was going to do; that this claim had been before Congress long enough. Morrill said your claim was clearly established; "that were you applying for a t.i.tle for a new patent of discovery nothing could defeat you, but that it was indispensable to have the Military Committee act again." Wade says "he feels embarra.s.sed in appearing as an advocate, being a witness, but that he will go before the committee anyhow and insist upon action."
JEFFERSON, OHIO, _October 3, 1876_.
My Dear Miss Carroll:
I do a.s.sure you that the manner in which your most n.o.ble services and sacrifices have been treated by your country has given me more pain and anxiety than anything that ever happened to me personally; that such merit should go so long unrewarded is deeply disgraceful to the country, or rather to the agencies of the Government who have had the matter in charge. I hope and trust it will not always be so. The truth is, your services were so great they cannot be comprehended by the ordinary capacity of our public men; and then, again, your services were of such a character that they threw a shadow over the reputations of some of our would-be great men. No doubt great pains have been taken in the business of trying to defeat you, but it has always been an article of faith with me that truth and justice must ultimately triumph.
Ever yours truly,
B. F. WADE.
JEFFERSON, OHIO, _April 10, 1877_.
My Dear Miss Carroll:
There is nothing in my power I would not most gladly do for you, for none have ever done so much for the country as you, and none have had so little for it. I cannot but believe justice will be done you yet for the immense services you rendered the country in the civil war. But when I reflect what mighty work you have done for the country and how you have been treated it keeps me awake nights and fills my soul with bitterness.
Truly yours ever,
B. F. WADE.
JEFFERSON, OHIO, _September 4, 1877_.
My Dear Miss Carroll:
* * * I know you are right and I will never fail to do all I can to aid you in attaining it. Your only trouble is you have the whole army to fight, who seem better skilled in opposing you than they were in finding out the best method of fighting the enemy. I hope your health holds out and continues good, for what you have done and what you have to do would break down any weaker intellect and physical const.i.tution.