"Certainly, ma"am. There could be but one opinion, I should think."
"What could make a girl happy, if all that would not?" asked another.
"Humph! Miss Gainsborough, you are the next; what are your views on the subject?"
Esther"s mouth opened, and closed. The answer that came first to her lips was sent back. She had a fine feeling that it was not fit for the company, a feeling that is expressed in the admonition not to cast pearls before swine, though that admonition did not occur to her at the time. She had been about to appeal to the Bible; but her answer as it was given referred only to herself.
"I believe I should not call "happiness" anything that would not last,"
she said.
There was a moment"s silence. What Miss Fairbairn thought was not to be read from her face; in other faces Esther read distaste or disapprobation.
"Why, Miss Fairbairn, nothing lasts, if you come to that," cried a young lady from near the other end of the table.
"Some things more than others," the mistress of the house opined.
"Not what you call "happiness," ma"am."
"That"s a very sober view of things to take at your age, Miss Disbrow."
"Yes, ma"am," said the young lady, t.i.ttering. "It is true."
"Do you think it is true, Miss Jennings?"
There was a little hesitation. Miss Jennings said she did not know.
Miss Lawton was appealed to.
"Is there no happiness that is lasting, Miss Lawton?"
"Well, Miss Fairbairn, what we call happiness. One can"t be married but once," the young lady hazarded.
That called forth a storm of laughter. Laughter well modulated and kept within bounds, be it understood; no other was tolerated in Miss Fairbairn"s presence.
"I have _heard_ of people who had that happiness two or three times,"
the lady said demurely. "Is there, then, no happiness short of being married?"
"Oh, Miss Fairbairn! you know I do not mean that, but all the things you read to us of: the diamonds, and the beautiful dresses, and the lace, and the presents; and then the travelling, and doing whatever she liked."
"Very few people do whatever they like," murmured Miss Fairbairn.
"I mean all that. And that does not last--only for a while. The diamonds last, of course"--
"But the pleasure of wearing them might not. True. Quite right, Miss Lawton. But I come back to my question. Is there _no_ happiness on earth that lasts?"
There was silence.
"We are in a bad way, if that is our case. Miss Gainsborough, what do you say? I come back to you again. Is there any such thing on earth as happiness, according to your terms?--something that lasts?"
Esther was in doubt again how to answer.
"I think there is, ma"am," she said, with a look up at her questioner.
"Pray what is it?"
Did she know? or did she not know? Esther was not certain; was not certain that her words would find either understanding or sympathy in all that tableful. Nevertheless, the time had come when they must be spoken. Which words? for several Bible sayings were in her mind.
""Blessed is every one that feareth the Lord: that walketh in His ways.
For thou shalt eat the labour of thine hands: happy shalt them be, and it shall be well with thee.""
The most profound silence followed this utterance. It had been made in a steady and clear voice, heard well throughout the rooms, and then there was silence. Esther fancied she discerned a little sympathetic moisture in the eyes of Miss Fairbairn, but also that lady at first said nothing. At last one voice in the distance was understood to declare that its owner "did not care about eating the labour of her hands."
"No, my dear, you would surely starve," replied Miss Fairbairn. "Is that what the words mean, do you think, Miss Gainsborough?"
"I think not, ma"am."
"What then? won"t you explain?"
"There is a reference, ma"am, which I thought explained it. "Say ye to the righteous that it shall be well with him: for they shall eat the fruit of their doings." And another word perhaps explains it. "Oh fear the Lord, ye His saints; for there is no want to them that fear Him.""
"No want to them, hey?" repeated Miss Fairbairn. "That sounds very much like happiness, I confess. What do you say, Miss Lawton?--Miss Disbrow?
People that have no want unsatisfied must be happy, I should say."
Silence. Then one young lady was heard to suggest that there were no such people in the world.
"The Bible says so, Miss Baines. What can you do against that?"
"Miss Fairbairn, there is an old woman that lives near us in the country--very poor; she is an old Christian,--at least so they say,--and she is _very_ poor. She has lost all her children and grandchildren; she cannot work any more, and she lives upon charity.
That is, if you call it living. I know she often has very little indeed to live upon, and that very poor, and she is quite alone; n.o.body to take the least care for her, or of her."
"So you think she _does_ want some things. Miss Gainsborough, what have you to say to that?"
"What does _she_ think about it?" Esther asked.
She looked as she spoke at the young lady who had given the instance, but the latter took no notice, until Miss Fairbairn said,
"Miss Baines, a question was put to you."
"I am sure I don"t know," Miss Baines replied. "They _say_ she is a very happy old woman."
"You doubt it?"
"I should not be happy in her place, ma"am. I don"t see, for my part, how it is possible. And it seems to me certainly she wants a great many things."
"What do you think, Miss Gainsborough."
"I think the Bible must be true, ma"am."
"That is Faith"s answer."