"Can you find the waking impression which accounts for the human figure at the window?" asked Midwinter; "or are we to pa.s.s over the Shadow of the Man as we have pa.s.sed over the Shadow of the Woman already?"
He put the question with scrupulous courtesy of manner, but with a tone of sarcasm in his voice which caught the doctor"s ear, and set up the doctor"s controversial bristles on the instant.
"When you are picking up sh.e.l.ls on the beach, Mr. Midwinter, you usually begin with the sh.e.l.ls that lie nearest at hand," he rejoined. "We are picking up facts now; and those that are easiest to get at are the facts we will take first. Let the Shadow of the Man and the Shadow of the Woman pair off together for the present; we won"t lose sight of them, I promise you. All in good time, my dear sir; all in good time!"
He, too, was polite, and he, too, was sarcastic. The short truce between the opponents was at an end already. Midwinter returned significantly to his former place by the window. The doctor instantly turned his back on the window more significantly still. Allan, who never quarreled with anybody"s opinion, and never looked below the surface of anybody"s conduct, drummed cheerfully on the table with the handle of his knife.
"Go on, doctor!" he called out; "my wonderful memory is as fresh as ever."
"Is it?" said Mr. Hawbury, referring again to the narrative of the dream. "Do you remember what happened when you and I were gossiping with the landlady at the bar of the hotel last night?"
"Of course I do! You were kind enough to hand me a gla.s.s of brandy-and-water, which the landlady had just mixed for your own drinking. And I was obliged to refuse it because, as I told you, the taste of brandy always turns me sick and faint, mix it how you please."
"Exactly so," returned the doctor. "And here is the incident reproduced in the dream. You see the man"s shadow and the woman"s shadow together this time. You hear the pouring out of liquid (brandy from the hotel bottle, and water from the hotel jug); the gla.s.s is handed by the woman-shadow (the landlady) to the man-shadow (myself); the man-shadow hands it to you (exactly what I did); and the faintness (which you had previously described to me) follows in due course. I am shocked to identify these mysterious appearances, Mr. Midwinter, with such miserably unromantic originals as a woman who keeps a hotel, and a man who physics a country district. But your friend himself will tell you that the gla.s.s of brandy-and-water was prepared by the landlady, and that it reached him by pa.s.sing from her hand to mine. We have picked up the shadows, exactly as I antic.i.p.ated; and we have only to account now--which may be done in two words--for the manner of their appearance in the dream. After having tried to introduce the waking impression of the doctor and the landlady separately, in connection with the wrong set of circ.u.mstances, the dreaming mind comes right at the third trial, and introduces the doctor and the landlady together, in connection with the right set of circ.u.mstances. There it is in a nutsh.e.l.l!--Permit me to hand you back the ma.n.u.script, with my best thanks for your very complete and striking confirmation of the rational theory of dreams." Saying those words, Mr. Hawbury returned the written paper to Midwinter, with the pitiless politeness of a conquering man.
"Wonderful! not a point missed anywhere from beginning to end! By Jupiter!" cried Allan, with the ready reverence of intense ignorance.
"What a thing science is!"
"Not a point missed, as you say," remarked the doctor, complacently.
"And yet I doubt if we have succeeded in convincing your friend."
"You have _not_ convinced me," said Midwinter. "But I don"t presume on that account to say that you are wrong."
He spoke quietly, almost sadly. The terrible conviction of the supernatural origin of the dream, from which he had tried to escape, had possessed itself of him again. All his interest in the argument was at an end; all his sensitiveness to its irritating influences was gone. In the case of any other man, Mr. Hawbury would have been mollified by such a concession as his adversary had now made to him; but he disliked Midwinter too cordially to leave him in the peaceable enjoyment of an opinion of his own.
"Do you admit," asked the doctor, more pugnaciously than ever, "that I have traced back every event of the dream to a waking impression which preceded it in Mr. Armadale"s mind?"
"I have no wish to deny that you have done so," said Midwinter, resignedly.
"Have I identified the shadows with their living originals?"
"You have identified them to your own satisfaction, and to my friend"s satisfaction. Not to mine."
"Not to yours? Can _you_ identify them?"
"No. I can only wait till the living originals stand revealed in the future."
"Spoken like an oracle, Mr. Midwinter! Have you any idea at present of who those living originals may be?"
"I have. I believe that coming events will identify the Shadow of the Woman with a person whom my friend has not met with yet; and the Shadow of the Man with myself."
Allan attempted to speak. The doctor stopped him. "Let us clearly understand this," he said to Midwinter. "Leaving your own case out of the question for the moment, may I ask how a shadow, which has no distinguishing mark about it, is to be identified with a living woman whom your friend doesn"t know?"
Midwinter"s color rose a little. He began to feel the lash of the doctor"s logic.
"The landscape picture of the dream has its distinguishing marks," he replied; "and in that landscape the living woman will appear when the living woman is first seen."
"The same thing will happen, I suppose," pursued the doctor, "with the man-shadow which you persist in identifying with yourself. You will be a.s.sociated in the future with a statue broken in your friend"s presence, with a long window looking out on a garden, and with a shower of rain pattering against the gla.s.s? Do you say that?"
"I say that."
"And so again, I presume, with the next vision? You and the mysterious woman will be brought together in some place now unknown, and will present to Mr. Armadale some liquid yet unnamed, which will turn him faint?--Do you seriously tell me you believe this?"
"I seriously tell you I believe it."
"And, according to your view, these fulfillments of the dream will mark the progress of certain coming events, in which Mr. Armadale"s happiness, or Mr. Armadale"s safety, will be dangerously involved?"
"That is my firm conviction."
The doctor rose, laid aside his moral dissecting-knife, considered for a moment, and took it up again.
"One last question," he said. "Have you any reason to give for going out of your way to adopt such a mystical view as this, when an unanswerably rational explanation of the dream lies straight before you?"
"No reason," replied Midwinter, "that I can give, either to you or to my friend."
The doctor looked at his watch with the air of a man who is suddenly reminded that he has been wasting his time.
"We have no common ground to start from," he said; "and if we talk till doomsday, we should not agree. Excuse my leaving you rather abruptly.
It is later than I thought; and my morning"s batch of sick people are waiting for me in the surgery. I have convinced _your_ mind, Mr.
Armadale, at any rate; so the time we have given to this discussion has not been altogether lost. Pray stop here, and smoke your cigar. I shall be at your service again in less than an hour." He nodded cordially to Allan, bowed formally to Midwinter, and quitted the room.
As soon as the doctor"s back was turned, Allan left his place at the table, and appealed to his friend, with that irresistible heartiness of manner which had always found its way to Midwinter"s sympathies, from the first day when they met at the Somersetshire inn.
"Now the sparring-match between you and the doctor is over," said Allan, "I have got two words to say on my side. Will you do something for my sake which you won"t do for your own?"
Midwinter"s face brightened instantly. "I will do anything you ask me,"
he said.
"Very well. Will you let the subject of the dream drop out of our talk altogether from this time forth?"
"Yes, if you wish it."
"Will you go a step further? Will you leave off thinking about the dream?"
"It"s hard to leave off thinking about it, Allan. But I will try."
"That"s a good fellow! Now give me that trumpery bit of paper, and let"s tear it up, and have done with it."
He tried to s.n.a.t.c.h the ma.n.u.script out of his friend"s hand; but Midwinter was too quick for him, and kept it beyond his reach.
"Come! come!" pleaded Allan. "I"ve set my heart on lighting my cigar with it."
Midwinter hesitated painfully. It was hard to resist Allan; but he did resist him. "I"ll wait a little," he said, "before you light your cigar with it."
"How long? Till to-morrow?"
"Longer."
"Till we leave the Isle of Man?"