The President grinned. "I always thought you boys had your blind spots."
"We do--but when we"re confronted with a fact, we try to find out something about it--that is if the fact hits us hard enough, often enough."
"Well, you"ve been hit hard and often," the President chuckled, "What did you find out?"
"Facts," Matson said grimly, "just facts. Things that could be determined by observation and measurement. We know that the aliens are telepathic. We also know that they have a form of ESP--or perhaps a recognition of danger would be a better term--and we know its range is somewhat over a third of a mile. We know that they"re telekinetic. The lack of visible controls in their ship would tell us that, even if we hadn"t seen them move small objects at a distance. We know that they have eidetic memories, and that they can reason on an extremely high level. Other than that we know nothing. We don"t even know their physical structure. We"ve tried X-ray but they"re radio-opaque. We"ve tried using some human sensitives from the Rhine Inst.i.tute, but they"re unable to get anywhere. They just turn empathic in the aliens"
presence, and when we get them back, they do nothing but babble about the beauty of the Aztlan soul."
"Considering the difficulties, you haven"t done too badly," the President said. "I take it then, that you"re convinced that they are an advanced life form. But do you think they"re sincere in their att.i.tude toward us?"
"Oh, they"re sincere enough," Matson said. "The only trouble is that we don"t know just what they"re sincere about. You see, sir, we are in the position of a savage to whom a trader brings the luxuries of civilization. To the savage, the trader may represent purest altruism, giving away such valuable things as gla.s.s beads and machine made cloth for useless pieces of yellow rock and the skins of some native pest.
The savage hasn"t the slightest inkling that he"s being exploited. By the time he realizes he"s been had, and the yellow rock is gold and the skins are mink, he has become so dependent upon the goods for which the trader has whetted his appet.i.te that he inevitably becomes an economic slave.
"Of course you can argue that the cloth and beads are far more valuable to the savage than the gold or mink. But in the last a.n.a.lysis, value is determined by the higher culture, and by that standard, the savage gets taken. And ultimately civilization moves in and the superior culture of the trader"s race determines how the savage will act.
"Still, the savage has a basis for his acts. He is giving something for something--making a trade. But we"re not even in that position.
The aliens apparently want nothing from us. They have asked for nothing except our good will, and that isn"t a tradable item."
"But they"re altruists!" the President protested.
"Sir, do you think that they"re insane?" Matson asked curiously. "Do they appear like fanatics to you?"
"But we can"t apply our standards to them. You yourself have said that their civilization is more advanced than ours."
"Whose standards can we apply?" Matson asked. "If not ours, then whose? The only standards that we can possibly apply are our own, and in the entire history of human experience there has never been a single culture that has had a basis of pure altruism. Such a culture could not possibly exist. It would be overrun and gobbled up by its practical neighbors before it drew its first breath.
"We must a.s.sume that the culture from which these aliens come has had a practical basis in its evolutionary history. It could not have risen full blown and altruistic like Minerva from the brain of Jove. And if the culture had a practical basis in the past, it logically follows that it has a practical basis in the present. Such a survival trait as practicality would probably never be lost no matter how far the Aztlan race has evolved. Therefore, we must concede that they are practical people--people who do not give away something for nothing. But the question still remains--what do they want?
"Whatever it is, I don"t think it is anything from which we will profit. No matter how good it looks, I am convinced that cooperation with these aliens will not ultimately be to our advantage. Despite the reports of every investigative agency in this government, I cannot believe that any such thing as pure altruism exists in a sane mind.
And whatever I may believe about the Aztlans, I do not think they"re insane."
The President sighed. "You are a suspicious man, Matson, and perhaps you are right; but it doesn"t matter what you believe--or what I believe for that matter. This government has decided to accept the help the Aztlans are so graciously offering. And until the reverse is proven, we must accept the fact that the star men _are_ altruists, and work with them on that basis. You will organize your office along those lines, and extract every gram of information that you can. Even you must admit that they have knowledge that will improve our American way of life."
Matson shook his head doggedly. "I"m afraid, Sir, if you expect Aztlan science to improve the American way of life, you are going to be disappointed. It might promote an Aztlan way of life, but the reverse is hardly possible."
"It"s not my decision," the President said. "My hands are tied.
Congress voted for the deal by acclamation early this morning. I couldn"t veto it even if I wanted to."
"I cannot cooperate in what I believe is our destruction." Matson said in a flat voice.
"Then you have only one course," the President said. "I will be forced to accept your resignation." He sighed wearily.
"Personally, I think you"re making a mistake. Think it over before you decide. You"re a good man, and Lord knows the government can use good men. There are far too many fools in politics." He shrugged and stood up. The interview was over.
Matson returned to his offices, filled with cold frustration. Even the President believed he could do nothing, and these shortsighted politicians who could see nothing more than the immediate gains--there was a special h.e.l.l reserved for them. There were too many fools in politics. However, he would do what he could. His sense of duty was stronger than his resentment. He would stay on and try to cushion some of the damage which the Aztlans would inevitably cause, no matter how innocent their motives. And perhaps the President was right--perhaps the alien science would bring more good than harm.
For the next two years Matson watched the spread of Aztlan ideas throughout the world. He saw Aztlan devices bring health, food and shelter to millions in underprivileged countries, and improve the lot of those in more favored nations. He watched tyrannies and authoritarian governments fall under the pa.s.sive resistance of their peoples. He saw militarism crumble to impotence as the Aztlan influence spread through every facet of society, first as a trickle, then as a steady stream, and finally as a rushing torrent. He saw Mankind on the brink of a Golden Age--and he was unsatisfied.
Reason said that the star men were exactly what they claimed to be.
Their every action proved it. Their consistency was perfect, their motives unimpeachable, and the results of their efforts were astounding. Life on Earth was becoming pleasant for millions who never knew the meaning of the word. Living standards improved, and everywhere men were conscious of a feeling of warmth and brotherhood.
There was no question that the aliens were doing exactly what they promised.
But reason also told him that the aliens were subtly and methodically destroying everything that man had created, turning him from an individual into a satisfied puppet operated by Aztlan strings. For man is essentially lazy--always searching for the easier way. Why should he struggle to find an answer when the Aztlans had discovered it millennia ago and were perfectly willing to share their knowledge? Why should he use inept human devices when those of the aliens performed similar operations with infinitely more ease and efficiency? Why should he work when all he had to do was ask? There was plan behind their acts.
But at that point reason dissolved into pure speculation. Why were they doing this? Was it merely mistaken kindliness or was there a deeper more subtle motive? Matson didn"t know, and in that lack of knowledge lay the h.e.l.l in which he struggled.
For two years he stayed on with the OSR, watching humanity rush down an unmarked road to an uncertain future. Then he ran away. He could take no more of this blind dependence upon alien wisdom. And with the change in administration that had occurred in the fall elections he no longer had the sense of personal loyalty to the President which had kept him working at a job he despised. He wanted no part of this brave new world the aliens were creating. He wanted to be alone. Like a hermit of ancient times who abandoned society to seek his soul, Matson fled to the desert country of the South-west--as far as possible from the Aztlans and their works.
The grimly beautiful land toughened his muscles, blackened his skin, and brought him a measure of peace. Humanity retreated to remoteness except for Seth Winters, a leathery old-timer he had met on his first trip into the desert. The acquaintance had ripened to friendship. Seth furnished a knowledge of the desert country which Matson lacked, and Matson"s money provided the occasional grubstake they needed. For weeks at a time they never saw another human--and Matson was satisfied. The world could go its own way. He would go his.
Running away was the smartest thing he could have done. Others more brave perhaps, or perhaps less rational--had tried to fight, to form an underground movement to oppose these altruists from s.p.a.ce; but they were a tiny minority so divided in motives and purpose that they could not act as a unit. They were never more than a nuisance, and without popular support they never had a chance. After the failure of a complicated plot to a.s.sa.s.sinate the aliens, they were quickly rounded up and confined. And the aliens continued their work.
Matson shrugged. It was funny how little things could mark mileposts in a man"s life. If he had known of the underground he probably would have joined it and suffered the same penalty for failure. If he hadn"t fled, if he hadn"t met Seth Winters, if he hadn"t taken that last trip into the desert, if any one of a hundred little things had happened differently he would not be here. That last trip into the desert--he remembered it as though it were yesterday....
The yellow flare of a greasewood fire cast flickering spears of light into the encircling darkness. Above, in the purplish black vault of the moonless sky the stars shone down with icy splendor. The air was quiet, the evening breeze had died, and the stillness of the desert night pressed softly upon the earth. Far away, muted by distance, came the ululating wail of a coyote.
Seth Winters laid another stick of quick-burning greasewood on the fire and squinted across the smoke at Matson who was lying on his back, arms crossed behind his head, eyeing the night sky with the fascination of a dreamer.
"It"s certainly peaceful out here," Matson murmured as he rose to his feet, stretched, and sat down again looking into the tiny fire.
""Tain"t nothin" unusual, Dan"l. Not out here it ain"t. It"s been plumb peaceful on this here desert nigh onto a million years. An"
why"s it peaceful? Mainly "cuz there ain"t too many humans messin"
around in it."
"Possibly you"re right, Seth."
"Sh.o.r.e I"m right. It jest ain"t nacheral fer a bunch of h.o.m.o saps to get together without an argyment startin" somewhere. "Tain"t the nature of the critter to be peaceable. An" y"know, thet"s the part of this here sweetness an" light between nations that bothers me. Last time I was in Prescott, I set down an" read six months of newspapers--an" everything"s jest too d.a.m.n good to be true. Seems like everybody"s gettin" to love everybody else." He shook his head. "The hull world"s as sticky-sweet as mola.s.ses candy. It jest ain"t nacheral!"
"The star men are keeping their word. They said that they would bring us peace. Isn"t that what they"re doing?"
"Shucks Dan"l--that don"t give "em no call to make the world a blasted honey-pot with everybody bubblin" over with brotherly love. There ain"t no real excitement left. Even the Commies ain"t raisin" h.e.l.l like they useta. People are gettin" more like a bunch of d.a.m.n woolies every day."
"I"ll admit that Mankind had herd instincts," Matson replied lazily, "but I"ve never thought of them as particularly sheeplike. More like a wolf pack, I"d say."
"Wal, there"s nothin" wolflike about "em right now. Look, Dan"l, yuh know what a wolf pack"s like. They"re smart, tough, and mean--an" the old boss wolf is the smartest, toughest, and meanest critter in the hull pack. The others respect him "cuz he"s proved his ability to lead. But take a sheep flock now--the bellwether is jest a nice gentle old castrate thet"ll do jest whut the sheepherder wants. He"s got no originality. He"s jest a noise thet the rest foller."
"Could be."
"It sh.o.r.e is! Jes f"r instance, an" speakin" of bellwethers, have yuh ever heard of a character called Throckmorton Bixbee?"
"Can"t say I have. He sounds like a nance."
"Whutever a nance is--he"s it! But yuh"re talkin" about our next President, unless all the prophets are wrong. He"s jest as bad as his name. Of all the gutless wonders I"ve ever heard of that pilgrim takes the prize. He even looks like a rabbit!"