She looked at him. "Like I said, I heard you talking about her in the tavern when you were on your way here, and listening to that priest with you, it was like listening to a man gloating over a young virgin"s body. He was repulsive, and whether he believed the letter sent to him or not, he wanted to believe it. He really wanted Mother to be guilty. I didn"t understand then, but I do now.
"My mother is not hugely religious, Bailiff. She"s a good woman in her own way, but if it hadn"t been for her husband dying early and her dislike of the men put forward to her as replacements, she"d have wed again, from what she said. But she does have two loves: the priory, and me. And in that order, too, I think. The priory is still her first love."
Simon looked up at the ceiling of the smithy. For a change the roof appeared to be whole, although patched, but when he glanced about him at the walls, he saw the damp patches from which the plaster was falling.
Following his gaze, Rose giggled. "Yeah, it hardly looks as if she cares much, does it? But she does. The place is only suffering because of lack of money; it needs a lot to stop the rot. That"s what Mother is trying to do; just keep St Mary"s ticking over until she can get the money she needs."
"From Sir Rodney*
"That"s right. Sir Rodney is prepared to give her the cash."
"In exchange for looking after his bones and one girl whom he or his family can nominate: this Agnes. What do you know of her?"
"A bit stiff. Not the sort who"d speak to me, although she is little better than me herself, from what I hear."
Simon listened attentively as she spoke of Agnes and the rumours of her affair with Luke. When she had finished, he screwed up his face doubtfully. "You think so? It"s so easy for gossip to be spread about people for no reason."
"No reason?" Rose asked, and her laughter rose to the rafters. "Oh, Bailiff, think carefully! There"s one woman here who can tell a man"s proclivities - and that"s me! I know which men need a woman, for they use my services! I know which ones desire me but daren"t indulge themselves for fear of G.o.d"s retribution; some are pederasts, for they watch me with faces like those of men drinking vinegar; and there are some who watch me with interest, who admire my body, but who never offer me money - those, Bailiff, are the men who already enjoy their own women and have no need of a paid subst.i.tute."
"There is more than one, then?"
"Only two," she said with decision. "Luke and Elias, who is servicing Constance, the infirmarer."
Simon blew out his cheeks. "Constance? With Elias?"
"I only mention the pair as an example, but yes."
"Where? Do you mean to tell me nuns and novices bring men up to the dorter?"
"Of course not!" Rose laughed. "But all the girls know places to go. For example there"s a room behind the frater: when it"s dark the girls use it; it has hay for a bed, and the roof doesn"t leak, which makes it unique." She threw a glance of sneering contempt at the holes above her.
"How does all this help me?" Simon grumbled, getting up and scuffing his feet through the dirt on the floor. "At every advance I find another block - and now Baldwin"s got a broken head. I"m no use at this type of enquiry* He slammed his fist into his open left palm. "What can I do? The first poor girl died although no one seems to have any idea why, and now Katerine is dead as well, although she appears to have had little in common with Moll."
"Moll was religious, and Katerine wanted power," agreed Rose calmly. "But let me tell you something both did have in common: both Moll and Katerine knew secrets. Katerine spent her time seeking out pieces of news or gossip, and was not above using it to her own advantage, dropping hints in someone"s ear to make sure that she got what she wanted. Moll was not so enthusiastic about finding people"s hidden stories, but she was determined when she thought something might have an impact on the convent. She would dig or spy until she found the facts, and then she was like Katerine: she went to the one she thought was responsible, and she let them know what she knew. She didn"t do it for her own benefit like Katerine, she did it for the nunnery, but the people she blackmailed probably felt the same about it."
"Whom did she threaten?"
"Apart from me, you mean?" Rose smiled sadly. "Because both did try to threaten me. Katerine told me she"d inform my mother about my whoring, unless I paid money for her silence; only a few days later Moll took me aside and spoke to me very seriously in the gardens, trying to persuade me to leave or stop my whoring with the canons. She said that it would damage the convent and I should desist. Desist! I remember her words so well."
"Who would have told her?"
"Moll? Well, novices chatter amongst themselves just like any other girls. I had refused to pay Katerine, so I expect she was happy to spread the story of my sins."
"You disliked them?"
"Not really. I just thought they were fools. Neither of them realised that I had no interest in them. Their threats were meaningless. They needed someone who would be worried that their storytelling could get back to the wrong person. Maybe when you have found the man or woman who was threatened by those two girls, you"ll have your killer."
For the rest of the day Simon got nowhere. He spoke to many of the nuns and canons, but the solution to the mystery evaded him.
He strolled about the canons" cloister during s.e.xt, High Ma.s.s, and None. Afterwards, the canons erupted from the church, chattering excitedly and speculating about the death of Katerine. Many held to the view that she had slipped, and that her fall was neither murder nor suicide, but simply an awful accident.
Simon was convinced that the girl had been struck down in the nuns" choir, her head wrapped in rags from the aumbry, before she was carried to the roof and thrown off. Yet he had no idea who had a motive to do so.
At the rear of the long line of canons, Simon saw the grimly forbidding features of Bertrand, and reminded himself that the suffragan had not been in the priory when Moll had died, so he was surely the last person to suspect. And yet Simon could not help but wonder about the man"s open disgust for the prioress. It was clear that Bertrand would be delighted to see her removed from office. And he would demand that she be replaced with Margherita, naturally - Simon had no doubts on that score.
Simon knew he should tell the suffragan about Rose, but he had a strange reluctance to do so. G.o.d alone knew what Bertrand would do when he heard that the prioress"s spy within the canons" cloister was her own daughter, and she a wh.o.r.e!
No, Simon couldn"t see Bertrand yet. He turned away and walked to the church. It would be better to sit at Baldwin"s side up in the infirmary and consider all he had learned for a while in peace. But when he got to the connecting door, he found it was locked, and although he called, the sacrist was apparently elsewhere and didn"t hear his knocking. Reluctantly, Simon decided to find Bertrand after all.
As Simon retraced his steps, making for the frater, he was forced to step over a small pile of dog"s excrement on the way. It appeared most odd to him that someone should have allowed a dog in here - but then he recalled mention of the prioress"s terrier, and curled his lip. A convent was no place for a pet.
Only later would he realise the significance of the little pile.
Simon found the suffragan sitting at his ease in the frater, leaning back against a wall, his good hand clasping a large pot, while about him canons twittered sycophantically like a group of women. To the bailiff"s embittered eye, they appeared more unmasculine than the nuns at the other side of the church. However, something in the gossiping made him hold back and stand near the door for a moment, listening.
Jonathan was shaking his head in apparent wonder. "And you have discovered that this is true, Bishop?"
"There can be no doubt," said Bertrand. He waved his bad hand airily. "The prioress"s management of the convent has been a disaster. You can see for yourselves how run down it is getting. We need a woman in charge who can protect the place. I think we shall need to have another election soon. The prioress must accept her fate and resign."
"What if she refuses to?" asked Paul attentively.
Bertrand bestowed upon him a smile of such approval that Simon almost walked from the room. "She will have no choice, not now that you have helped me so well, Paul." He held up a hand in a declamatory fashion. "You may as well know, Brothers, that I have more information for you all. This very morning, I was with your colleague here, young Paul, and he showed me an astonishing sight. In a stable were concealed a pair of packs for a canon and a nun in order that they might run away from the cloister and commit apostasy. I knowa* he held up his hand for silence as the men began to ask questions, thrilled at his revelations. It gave him an immense sense of power.
Bertrand felt as though he held all the men in this room in the palm of his hand. He looked at them, all gripping their pots or jugs as they drank in his words avidly.
It gave him a faint pang to recall that the only confession he had got from Elias was false - he knew well enough that Elias had been at the grille when Katerine died, and no doubt the infirmarer would confirm that he had been with her when Moll died, but this was more important than a simple death. Bertrand was struggling to ensure the survival of the convent itself. To do that he was prepared to blackmail any of the canons in the room - aye, or see them thrashed, if it would help. Elias"s admission of his sins with Constance would surely hasten Lady Elizabeth"s removal.
And that was the important thing - the removal of the woman who had led the convent to this pa.s.s. The souls of thousands depended upon the convent being cleansed! The two dead girls hardly mattered, not to Bertrand. Surely they were already in heaven.
When a niggle of self-doubt caught at his conscience, he forced it from him. The fact that his actions would help his own promotion was merely a coincidence. Nothing more. He was acting selflessly for the good of St Mary"s.
When the men were still, he continued. "I know that this is not a reflection upon all of you, but it does show how poorly Lady Elizabeth has looked after St Mary"s if one of your number can consider renouncing his oaths and leading a nun astray at the same time. And then there is the matter of the prioress"s daughtera*
Aha! thought Simon. So he already knows.
"This daughter, this serpent in female form, has not only rejected her former life as a novice within the cloister and turned her back on the learning she was fortunate enough to be granted by the goodness of the Church, she has turned to a vile and degrading profession. Some of you may know what I mean," he added, glancing about him shrewdly. More than one man reddened and looked away. "Well, I do not propose to censure those who may have been tempted from the path of purity, beyond demanding that all who so forgot themselves should confess at the earliest opportunity, but this evil cancer must be rooted out. She must be ruthlessly excised from this priory; just as a man would execute an outlaw to protect society. Otherwise her malign influence could corrupt the whole place." Bertrand ran his words through his mind again. It sounded a little flowery, but overall he was pleased - he might use the same words when he reported to Bishop Stapledon.
One man at the table wasn"t impressed or pleased. Simon could see the anxiety on G.o.dfrey"s face. "If you do that, where shall she go, Bishop? She would be ostracised and left to wander about without home - or hope. Wouldn"t it be more merciful to allow her to remain anda"*
"Good G.o.d, no! Do you think we should harbour this viper? What of her foul attractions? She could well tempt more of you to stray, and it would be a gross sin on my part were I to allow her the opportunity. The unwholesome b.i.t.c.h must leave and never return."
G.o.dfrey opened his mouth to speak again, but his neighbour, Jonathan, put a warning hand on his wrist and G.o.dfrey subsided, but as he sagged back in his chair, Simon noticed how he had blanched.
One man whom Simon had not noticed among the canons was Luke. After the service, he had gone to the door as usual, to go back into the monks" side of the church, but as under the new regime he was to be locked out and excluded from the nunnery except during services, he was forced to wait for a nun to unlock the door and relock it behind him.
It was Denise the sacrist, and as she approached, he was struck by her shuffling gait. The sight made his belly churn in disgust -he had a hatred of drunken women - and yet he saw that he might be able to turn her inebriation to his advantage.
He stood patiently while she inserted the large key into the door and turned it. The lock snapped open, and she pulled the door wide, but as she did so, Luke frowned, slapping at his belt. "My purse!"
Denise peered at him owlishly. "What of it? You"ll have to get it when you come back."
"But you don"t understand - I"ve lost it," said Luke, quickly tucking it beneath a fold of his robe. "It could be anywhere."
"Then seek it in the canons" cloister," said Denise unsympathetically; she was feeling more than a little sleepy and had no wish to stand here all day. Hurriedly putting her hand to her mouth, she tried to cover up a burp, then glowered tipsily at him. "Come along, then. Time you were gone."
"I shan"t be long," Luke called over his shoulder, and began to walk back to the sacristy.
"Wait! You can"t stay here, you know what the prioress said -you have to go."
Luke stood as if undecided, but then turned and strode back to Denise"s side. "I can"t go back without it," he explained quietly. "The thing had the key to the bishop"s chest in it, and the bishop is bound to want it for his Bible after his lunch."
"What did you have his key for?" she demanded.
"Denise," he said seriously, "you know that the prioress has tried to ban me from the nunnery, but do you know why?"
"Because of your behaviour with the novices," she giggled, and clapped a hand over her mouth. It was wrong to laugh at such things here, in the nave of the church.
Luke smiled sadly. "No, Denise. That was all invented by the prioress herself. I am to be removed because she made an advance to me which I rejected. Now she wants a new priest, someone whom she can mould to her will. But Bishop Bertrand has seen this, and he is to report her behaviour to Bishop Stapledon so that Lady Elizabeth can be forced to resign her post. Then we will have anew leader."
"Margherga Margherita, you mean?"
"Yesa perhaps. Or maybe someone else. Someone in whom the bishop can place his trust. But I must fetch his key, mustn"t I?"
Denise gazed about her vacuously. "I have to go and get my food," she muttered as her belly rumbled alarmingly.
"You go, then. Leave me to find the purse, and return later to lock the door," Luke said.
It was all too confusing. Denise could feel one of her headaches coming on, and wished she was sitting back in the frater with a cool pint of wine before her. She didn"t need grief from this tomfool of a priest. The prioress had ordered her to stay and lock the door after him, but if Luke was only trying to find the key to the bishop"s chest, surely the bishop"s needs would take precedence over the prioress"s order, and that would mean that Luke could stay and search if he wanted. Serve him right if there was no food left when he returned.
"Very well, you may stay a while. But I will be back to lock the door when I have eaten my lunch."
"You were ever a kind and thoughtful woman, Denise," Luke said, and continued on his way to the sacristy. It was not until he had heard the door to the church close that he allowed himself to chuckle.
Chapter Twenty.
After her meal late in the afternoon, Agnes was sent to the prioress"s chamber to fetch a cushion for Lady Elizabeth"s chair. She found it as instructed, but once outside the room, standing on the small landing, she hesitated, then walked to the infirmary.
The room was dark, the interior lit only by guttering candles and the flickering flames of the fire. Clutching the cushion to her breast, she went to where Baldwin lay, breathing stertorously, his mouth open.
Agnes hadn"t seen him from close to before, and she studied him with interest. He was not so good-looking as Luke, she reckoned. Luke was slender and fair, with his golden hair and bright blue eyes, while this knight had the thicker body of an older man, muscled and powerful, certainly, but too old, too worn. Knackered. She shook her head. This man wasn"t someone she could fancy; she was much happier with a younger lover.
"What"re you doing here?" Hugh demanded. He entered the room belligerently, his brows black.
Immediately the curtain to Constance"s chamber twitched aside, and the infirmarer herself hurried into the room. Agnes? How long have you been in here?"
The novice retreated at the appearance of Hugh. He shoved past her rudely to stand staring at the sleeping knight, who mumbled and gave a vague groan before snuffling and settling himself once more. Sniffing suspiciously at the jug and pot at Baldwin"s side, Hugh looked back at Agnes again, who stared uncomprehendingly at him.
Constance cleared her throat. "I shall replace it with a clean one and fresh water."
Hugh nodded, but still eyed the quailing novice with a truculent glower. "Well? What were you doing snooping around in here?"
"I just wanted to see the knight - make sure he"s all right," she wailed. "The prioress sent me to get a cushion, and I thought I"d look in. That"s all."
"Did you touch him?" Hugh demanded.
Agnes felt the tears spring and run down both cheeks. "No!"
"It"s true, Master Hugh. She didn"t touch him. I was watching," said a voice from behind her, and when Agnes spun around, she saw old Joan sitting near the fire.
"Nor put anything in the jug?" Hugh demanded.
"She did nothing, master. Stop scaring the girl with your fury. It won"t do her any good to be weeping when she delivers the cushion to the prioress, will it? Agnes, come here, and sit for a moment. You need to calm yourself."
Nothing loath, Agnes gratefully walked to Joan"s side. The old woman patted her hand, and motioned to a seat. Sniffling, Agnes dropped upon it, wiping her eyes with her sleeve.
"He"s a good-looking fellow, isn"t he?" Joan said with a twinkle in her eye. "I once came up here to see a man who had fallen from a horse. It was Sir Rodney - such a fine-looking lad. We all wanted to see what men were wearing and how they had their hair cut and so on, and my friend Bridget was here before me; we both studied him and it was a bit sad really* Her gaze was unfocused as she reached back through her memory. "Nothing had changed. All was the same as when I entered the convent. But then the last King, Edward the First, was a stickler. Never let his men wear beards, never let them wear any finery. Said that fashionable clothes like the French wore were for pansies or women, not for the men he commanded. He always was a stern old devil."
"You met the King?"
Joan shook her head. "No. Only Sir Rodney*
"Was Bridget a nun?" Agnes asked.
"Yes. Many years before your time. But then she went off with Sir Rodney - to the shame of the convent. Now, wipe your face. Don"t worry - we won"t tell anyone, and it wouldn"t matter if we did. Everyone knows what it"s like to want a little taste of what the world outside is like. What did you think of the good knight?"
"Ia*Agnes hung her head. "He"s ancient - and I don"t like his beard," she confessed.
Joan chuckled and took the novice"s hand, patting it gently. "It"s all right, dear. I never liked beards either. Now help me up, and I"ll come down with you. I daresay this good servant would like to be alone to protect his master"s friend."
Hugh couldn"t help feeling relieved when he was alone in the infirmary once more. He glanced at the sleeping knight and muttered, "For the love of G.o.d, get better quickly. I can"t stand this dump much longer."
After several pints of ale Bertrand was in a cheerful mood. He had demanded the convent"s accounts from Jonathan, and now sat in the guestroom studying the large roll which detailed all transactions for the last two years. The accounts had not been ready when he had arrived on his official visitation earlier, and now they made interesting - and sorry reading.
The roll showed that the nuns had not enough grain or hay to feed their cattle, and the land was unfit for much other than pasture. There were foreign lands, way off towards Exford and Crediton, but these never seemed to bring in what even Bertrand, who was no expert in such matters, would have expected after viewing accounts from other priories, especially since he had seen money from Iddesleigh"s bailiff pa.s.sed to the treasurer while he was last here, a healthy sum.
In terms of money, it was obvious that the priory couldn"t survive. The prioress had been accused of paying her vicar too much, but there were few sums going to him according to the rolls. Perhaps the place was investing too heavily in wine and other foods, Bertrand wondered, and ran his finger along some of the columns, reading off the numbers. Even this area looked no worse than he would have expected. Then he came to a point far down, near the bottom of a page. It made him stop, blink, and peer again.
"G.o.d"s b.o.l.l.o.c.ks!" he shouted, appalled. Then clapped a hand over his mouth and blushed deeply when he caught sight of Paul"s scandalised face.
Carrying the cushion, Agnes walked down the stairs with Joan and was about to open the door to the cloister when the old nun stopped her. "Come, child, what is it? It"s clear enough that you"re depressed."