"My Vicar?"
"Have you yet had time to study this pamphlet, while on your travels perhaps? I know it has been widely circulated."
Belam gravely inclined his head.
"Then give us your considered opinion."
"I am a theologian, my Vicar, and not a natural philosopher. Therefore I have taken counsel with astronomers and others and find my own opinion in this matter generally confirmed. Which is that Vincento"s arguments in this pamphlet concerning the tides really prove nothing regarding the movement of the celestial bodies, and are not even very accurate as regards the tides themselves."
"He thinks we are all fools, to be dazzled by brilliant words into accepting whatever shoddy logic he offers us. And that we will not even realize it when we are mocked!" The vicar stood up for a moment, sighed, and then tiredly resumed his seat.
Belam chose to ignore the theory, which he did not for a moment believe, that the pamphlet"s aim was sacrilegious mockery. The real issue was vital enough. "As the vicar may possibly recall, I had occasion some years ago to write to Vincento regarding his speculations on the idea of a sun-centered universe.
Then, as now, such theorizing caused me concern in my capacity as Defender."
"We recall the occasion very well, ha hum. In fact, Messire Vincento has already been summoned here to stand trial for his violation in this pamphlet of your injunction at that time.... Belam, what were the precise words of your warning, again?"
Belam thought awhile before answering and then spoke slowly and precisely. "I wrote him, first, that mathematicians are quite free to calculate and publish whatever they wish regarding the celestial appearances or any other natural phenomena- provided they remain strictly in the realm of hypothesis.
"Secondly, it is quite a different matter to say that in fact the sun is in the center of the universe. That in fact our globe spins from west to east each day, while revolving round the sun each year. Such statements must be considered very dangerous; though not formally heretical, they are liable to injure faith by contradicting the Holy Writings."
"Your memory, Belam, is even more than usually excellent. Just when did you write this letter of injunction?"
"Fifteen years ago, my Vicar." Belam showed a dry smile momentarily. "Though I must admit that I reread our archive copy this morning." He was utterly serious again. "Thirdly and lastly, I wrote Vincento that if some real proof existed of the sun-centered universe he champions, we should then be forced to revise our interpretations of those pa.s.sages in the Holy Writings which would appear to say otherwise.
We have in the past revised our scriptural interpretations, for example in regard to the roundness of the world. But, in the absence of any such proof, the weight of authority and traditional opinion is not to be set aside."
Nabur was listening with great attentiveness. "It seems to us, Belam, that you wrote well, as usual."
"Thank you, my Vicar."
Satisfaction appeared mixed with anger in the vicarial mien. "In this pamphlet Vincento has certainly violated your injunction! The debater into whose mouth he puts his own opinions advances no convincing proofs, at least none that can be grasped by mere mortals like ourselves. And yet he does argue, at great length, that in very truth our globe spins like a toy top beneath our feet. To convince the reader of this is his plain intention. Then!" The vicar stood up dramatically. "Then, on the last page, our argument-often expressed by us as a means of compromising these difficult philosophical matters- our argument, that G.o.d may produce whatever effect He likes in the world, without being bound by scientific causes-our argument is quoted by the simpleton-debater who has been wrong about everything else, quoted as coming from "a person of high learning and wisdom, supremely above contradiction." And at this the other debaters piously declare themselves silenced and decide to adjourn for refreshment. One cannot fail to see them, and their author, laughing up their sleeves!"
While the vicar struggled to regain his breath and calm once more, there was silence in the apartment, save for the workmen"s shouts and laughter drifting in. What were they doing out there? Oh, yes, only the marble. Belam uttered a brief prayer that he might never again be required to order a stake prepared for a heretic.
When Nabur spoke again, it was in a reasonable tone. "Now, Belam. Other than this weary argument on tides, which all seem to agree is inconclusive, do you suppose there can exist anywhere any evidence for Vincento"s spinning world? Anything he might impertinently introduce at his trial to... disrupt its course?"
Belam drew himself up, slightly but perceptibly. "My Vicar, we shall of course conduct Vincento"s trial, or any other, with the greatest zeal for the truth that we can muster. Vincento may argue in his own defense-"
"Of course, of course!" Nabur interrupted with a rapid dismissive waving of his hand; it was the gesture he used at a time when another man might apologize. But then he still waited for an answer.
After frowning thoughtfully at the floor, Belam began to give what a later age would call a background briefing. "My Vicar, I have through the years made an effort to keep abreast of astronomers" thinking. I fear many of them, religious and laymen both, have become Messire Vincento"s enemies. He has a relish and skill for making others look like fools. He has arrogance, in claiming for his own all that these new devices, telescopes, discover in the heavens. An arrogant and argumentative man is hard to bear, and triply hard when he is so often in the right." Belam glanced up sharply for a moment, but Nabur had not taken the description as applying to anyone but Vincento. "My Vicar, is it not true that this pamphlet was brought to your attention by some priest-astronomer whom Vincento has offended and bested in some debate?" Though Belam knew of a number of such men, he was really only guessing.
"Hmm. It may be so, Belam, it may be so. But Vincento"s offense is real, though it may have been maliciously called to our attention."
The two of them were pacing now, with old men"s measured tread, sometimes...o...b..ting each other like perturbed planets. The Defender of the Faith said, "I raise the point to show the difficulty of obtaining unbiased testimony in this matter from other scholars. They are certainly unlikely to rush to Vincento"s defense. Nevertheless, I believe that most astronomers now perform their calculations using the mathematical a.s.sumption that the planets, or some of them, at least, revolve about the sun. Of course, that idea is not original with Vincento, nor is the idea that our globe is only a planet. It seems these a.s.sumptions make the mathematics of celestial movement more elegant and somewhat more satisfying to the scholar; fewer epicycles need be included in the orbits to make them fit the circular form-"
"Yes, yes, Vincento makes the mathematics more elegant. But stick to the point. Can he have proof, mathematical or otherwise? Plain evidence of any kind?"
"I would say rather the contrary."
"Ha!" Nabur stopped pacing and faced Belam squarely, almost smiling.
The Defender said, "Had Vincento any plain proof, I think he would have printed it here. Arid there is solid evidence against him." Belam gestured with his scholar"s hands, frail fingers unsure of technicalities but still grasping firmly whatever they were required to grasp. "It seems that if our globe did make a yearly journey round the sun, the relative positions of the fixed stars should appear to us to change from month to month, as we approached certain constellations or drew away from them. And no such displacement of the stars can be observed."
Vicar Nabur was nodding, looking satisfied.
Belam made a shrugging gesture. "Of course, it is possible to argue that the stars are simply too distant for our measurements to discover such displacement. Vincento will always have arguments, if he wants to use them.... I fear that no other astronomer is going to be able to prove him wrong, much as some of them would love to do so. No, I think we must admit that the celestial appearances would be essentially the same if we did go round the sun."
"That is enough for any reasonable man to say."
"Exactly, my Vicar. As I wrote Vincento, where there is lack of other certainty, we have no excuse for turning our backs on tradition and subst.i.tuting strained interpretations for the plain meaning of the Holy Writings." Belam"s voice was rising gradually, achieving the tone of power that it would have in court.
"We of the Temple have the solemn duty before G.o.d to uphold the truth that those Writings reveal. And, my Vicar, what I wrote to Vincento fifteen years ago is still true today-I have never been shown any proof of the motion of the world we stand on, and so I cannot believe that any such proof or any such motion exists!"
The vicar had resumed his seat. Now his face was gentle, as he raised his hands, then clamped them down decisively on the arms of his ornate work chair. "Then it is our decision that you and the other Defenders must proceed with the trial." Nabur spoke regretfully at first, though as he went on his anger gradually returned, less vehement than it had been. "We do not doubt that he can be convicted of violating your injunction. But understand, we have no wish to visit any great punishment upon our erring son."
Belam bowed his grateful a.s.sent to that.
Nabur went on, "In charity we grant that he intended no attack upon the Faith and no insult to our person. He is only headstrong, and stubborn, and intemperate in debate. And sadly lacking in grat.i.tude and humility! He must be taught that he cannot set himself up as a superior authority on all matters temporal and spiritual. Did he not once attempt to lecture you on theology?"
Belam once more inclined his head in a.s.sent, meanwhile sharply warning himself that he must guard against taking any personal satisfaction in Vincento"s approaching humiliation.
Even now Nabur could not let the subject drop, not yet. "Ah, I could curse the man! In the past, we ourself have been among the first to heap praise on his achievements. We have granted him hours of private audience. We have shown him friendliness to a degree we do not always extend to princes!
Before ascending to this chair, we ourself once even wrote a pamphlet in his praise! And now, how are we repaid?"
"I understand, my Vicar."
"I see you have requested a.s.signment to one particular time, Colonel Odegard." Colonel Lukas spoke the words around his cigar, while at the same time using the formal style of address. He was a sometime drinking acquaintance of Derron"s, who might be finding it a little difficult to strike the right balance in his role today of examining psychologist. If he had been a close friend of Derron"s he would probably have disqualified himself as examiner. But what close friends did Derron have these days among the living?
There was Chan Amling... an old cla.s.smate, yes. Bosom buddy, no. The fact was that he had none.
Lukas was looking at him. "Yes, I did," Derron answered, somewhat tardily.
Lukas shifted his cigar. "The two days Vincento spends near the town of Oibbog, delayed on his way to his trial. Waiting to cross a flooded river. Had you any particular reason for wanting that time?"
Oh, yes, he had. He had not put it into words, however, even for himself, and was not about to try to do so now. "Just that I know the locale very well. I once spent a long holiday there. It was one of those places that didn"t change very much in three, or four hundred years." Of course, the town and cathedral of Oibbog, like all the other surface landmarks of the planet, were now in the past tense. Derron"s particular reason was that the long holiday there had been with her. He caught himself sliding forward tensely on his chair again and forced himself to slump a little and relax.
Squinting through his cigar smoke, Colonel Lukas shuffled uncertainly through the papers on his desk and then threw one of his sneaky fast b.a.l.l.s. "Have you any particular reason for wanting to be an agent at all?"
For Derron that question immediately called up an image of Matt and Ay, two forms blending more and more into a single kingly figure as they receded from the moving moment of the present. Their heroic image seemed to be growing steadily larger with distance, the way a mountain in the old days on the surface had sometimes seemed to swell as you hiked away from it.
But that was not the sort of reason a man could talk about, at least not without all of a sudden sounding far too n.o.ble and dedicated.
Derron made himself slide back in his chair again. "Well, as I said, I know the period very well. I believe I can do a good job. Like everyone else, I want to win the war." He was uttering n.o.ble sentiments after all, and too many of them. Better stretch it into a joke. "I want prestige, I suppose. Accomplishment.
Promotion. You name it. Did I hit the right one yet?"
"What is the right one?" Lukas shrugged glumly. "I don"t know why I"m required to ask that-why does anyone want to be an agent?" He shaped his papers into a neat stack before him. "Now, Colonel. Just one more thing I want to bring up before certifying you as good agent material. That is the matter of your personal religious views."
"I"m not religious."
"How do you feel about religion?"
Relax, relax. "Well, frankly, I think that G.o.ds and temples are fine things for people who need crutches. I haven"t yet found any necessary."
"I see. I think this is a valid psychological point which should be raised, because there are dangers inherent in sending back to Vincento"s time anyone who is likely to find himself susceptible to ideological fever." Lukas made an apologetic gesture. "You as an historian understand better than I how thick dogmas and doctrines are in the air back there. Religious and philosophical controversy seems to draw all the energy of that era."
"Yes." Derron nodded. "I see what you mean. You don"t want a fanatic of any stripe. Well, I"m not what they call a militant atheist. My conscience will let me play any part that"s necessary." Maybe he was explaining too much, talking too much, but he had to make this point, he had to be allowed to go. "I"ll be a rabid monk and spit on Vincento if required."
"I don"t suppose Time Ops will ask that of you. All right, then, Derron. You"re in."
And Derron tried not to show too much relief.
What Operations really decided was that he would do best in the part of a traveling scholar. They gave him a name-Valzay-and started to build for him an ident.i.ty that had never historically existed. He was supposedly from Mosnar, a country distant from Vincento"s but for the most part faithful to the Holy Temple. Valzay was to be one of the itinerant intellectuals of Vincento"s time, who wandered somewhat like sacred cows across minor political and language boundaries, from one university or wealthy patron to another.
Derron and a dozen other chosen agents, mostly male, were rushed into preparation. Working singly or in pairs, they were to keep Vincento under practically continuous observation during the now doubly critical days of his life just preceding his trial and during it. Each agent or team would remain on the job for a day or two and then be relieved by another. Chan Amling, now a captain, was a.s.signed as Derron"s team partner; they would not often be together on the job, but would alternate in keeping Vincento more or less in sight. Amling was to play the role of one of the wandering friars who in Vincento"s day were quite numerous, and for the most part only loosely disciplined.
The program of preparation was hurried and rugged, beginning with the surgical implantation of communications transducers in jawbone and skull. This would enable each agent to remain in contact with Operations without having to mumble aloud or wear anything as bulky as a helmet.
There were speech and manners to be rehea.r.s.ed, some knowledge of events current in Vincento"s day to be memorized, and some knowledge to be repressed, of events in the immediate future of that time.
There were the techniques of communications and weaponry to be mastered-all this is a few days.
Amid his fatigue and concentration, Derron noticed almost without surprise that Lisa was now working in Operations, one of the calm-voiced girls who relayed orders and information to individual sentries and could do the same for slave-unit operators, or for live agents when some of them took the field.
He had only sc.r.a.ps of free time now and made no effort to use any of it to speak to her. The knowledge that he was on his way back to Oibbog had crowded almost everything else out of his mind. He felt like a man going to a rendezvous with his own true love; the people of flesh and blood around him, Lisa included, took on the semblance of shadows for him even as the dead past grew more vivid.
Then one day, as he and Amling sat in folding chairs at the side of Stage Three, resting between behavior drills, Lisa came walking past and stopped.
"Derron, I want to wish you success."
"Thanks. Pull up a chair, if you like."
She did. Amling decided he wanted to stretch his legs, and he ambled away.
Lisa said, "Derron, I shouldn"t have accused you of killing Matt. I know you didn"t want him to die, that you felt as bad as I did about it. What happened to him wasn"t your fault." She was speaking like someone who had lost a friend among other friends in war, not like someone whose life had been destroyed with the life of her beloved. "I"ve just been mastering my own internal difficulties-you know about that-but that"s no excuse for what I said. I should have known you better. I"m sorry."
"It"s all right." Derron shifted uncomfortably in his chair, sorry that she felt so bad about it. "Really, it"s...
Lisa, I thought you and I might have had- something. I suppose not the whole thing there can be between a man and a woman, but still something good."
She looked away from him, a faint frown creasing her forehead. "I had some feeling like that about Matt.
But that much of a feeling would never be enough for me."
He went on hurriedly, "As far as anything permanent and tremendous is concerned, well, I"ve tried that already, once in my life. And I"m still up to my neck in it, as you may have noticed. I"m sorry, I"ve got to get moving." And he jumped up out of his chair and hurried to where Amling and the others were not yet ready for him.
When the day came for the drop, the costumers dressed Derron in clothing that was slightly worn but good, suitable for a fairly successful gentleman-scholar on his travels far from home. In his haversack they placed a reasonable supply of food, along with a flask of brandy. Into his wallet went a moderate sum in the proper coins, silver and gold, and also a forged letter of credit on an Empire City bank. They hoped he would not need much money, and plans did not call for him to get to within a hundred miles of the Holy City. But just in case.
Chan Amling was issued a somewhat worn and soiled gray friar"s habit, but very little else, in keeping with his mendicant role. He did half-seriously request permission to take along a pair of dice, arguing that he would not be the first friar in history to go so armed. But Time Ops was soon able to establish that such equipment was scarcely standard issue for religious, even in Vincento"s time, and he turned down the request.
Both Derron and Chan had hung around their necks abominably carved wooden wedge symbols. The images differed in detail of design, but each was big enough to conceal the bulk of a miniaturized communicator and too ugly and cheap-looking for anyone to want to steal. If any of Vincento"s contemporaries should be moved to wonder audibly why Derron wore such a thing, he was to say that it was a present from his wife.
From an a.r.s.enal a.s.sembled in Stage Three, Odegard and Amling were issued st.u.r.dy travelers" staffs.
These again were dissimilar in outer detail, but both were much more effective weapons than they appeared to be. All of the agents were armed, with staffs or other innocent-appearing devices; they were all to be dropped within half a minute of one another, present-time, though, of course, they were to arrive in different places and on different days.
Their processing for this mission had been too hurried and with too much individual attention for them to get to know one another very well. But during the last few minutes before the drop, as the masquerade-costumed group bade one another good luck and good berserker hunting, there was an atmosphere of joking camaraderie in Stage Three.
Derron felt it. It crossed his mind that once again he had good friends among the living. The launching file formed on order, and he took his place in it calmly, looking forward over short Chan Amling"s gray-cowled head.
Amling turned his head slightly. "Five will get you ten," he whispered, "that I land up to my crotch in mud someplace. Out of sight of the b.l.o.o.d.y road, at least."
"No bet," said Derron automatically, as the count began. The line moved briskly forward, one figure after another in front of him abruptly vanishing from his sight. Amling made some last remark that Derron could not catch, and then Amling too was gone.
It was Derron"s turn. He swung a booted foot in a long stride out over the mercurial launching circle, then brought it down.
He was standing in darkness, and around him was the unmistakable, never-to-be forgotten feeling of open air. Except for a mere whisper of breeze and a drizzle of rain, he was immersed in an echoless silence, a great loneliness in which his materialization must have pa.s.sed unnoticed. Good.
"Reverend Brother?" he inquired of the darkness in a low voice, speaking in Vincento"s language. There was no answer; Amling might well have come down in some mud hole out of sight of the road. He had a knack for achieving what he was willing to bet on.
As Derron"s eyes grew more accustomed to the gloom, he realized that the hard surface under his own boots did indeed seem to be the stones of the old Empire highway that pa.s.sed through Oibbog.
Operations had put at least half of the team spatially on the bull"s-eye, then. Whether they had done as well temporally remained to be seen, though rain and darkness were rea.s.suring signs.
Subvocalizing, Derron tried to reach Operations for a routine check-in, but the communicator seemed utterly dead. Some kind of paradox loop would be blocking contact. Such things cropped up now and then; there was nothing to do but hope that the condition would not last long.
He waited the agreed-upon few minutes for Amling, meanwhile opening his staff at one end and consulting the compa.s.s thus revealed, to make sure of the direction he was facing on the road. Then, after calling once more to his reverend brother with no result, he began to walk, boots clopping solidly on the pavement. Lightning flashed distantly at irregular intervals. He drank deep breaths of the washed air.
He had not gone far before the transducer behind his ear gave him a sudden twinge. "... Odegard, can you read me yet? Colonel Odegard..." The male voice sounded weary and bored.
"This is Colonel Odegard; I read you."
"Colonel!" Sudden excitement. Off mike: "We"ve got contact, sir!" Back on: "Colonel, it"s plus two days and three hours here since you were dropped. Time scale has been slipping."
"Understand." Derron kept his speech subvocal. "I"m about plus five minutes since dropping. Still on the road in the rain, at night. No contact with Amling yet."
"Odegard, you"re blurring on the screens." It was Time Ops" voice speaking now. "But it looks like you"re farther from the cathedral than we intended, just about two miles. You may be outside the safety zone, so get in closer to Vincento as fast as possible." By "safety zone," of course, Time Ops meant the zone of protection against any direct violence from the berserker, a zone created by the intense concentration of sentry observation around Vincento"s lifeline. "We"ve just pulled out the team ahead of you. They report all"s well with Vincento. You say you haven"t seen Amling yet."
"Right." Derron stepped up his pace a trifle, though he was having to tap along with his staff to be sure of not floundering off the pavement into the mud.
"We haven"t found him either. Can"t see his line in this blurring on the screens. It may be just the time slippage and a paradox loop."
Lightning flared directly ahead of Derron, obligingly showing him that his road ran straight for some distance in that direction and giving him a glimpse of the cathedral spire, which was farther off than it should have been. He supposed it was about two miles away.
He reported this to Operations, meanwhile puzzling over something else that the lightning had shown him-a dully gleaming object in the center of the road ahead, lying atop a line or thin trench that seemed to have been scratched or dug across the pavement.