Check on Those we Trust.
Since those who weren"t trusted were scrutinized with the same vigour as those who were, it meant that there was at least a kind of equality.
The duty of an investigator was to scratch away at innocence until guilt was uncovered. If no guilt was uncovered then they hadn"t scratched deep enough. In the case of Brodsky the question wasn"t whether foreign diplomats met him because he was a vet but rather had this suspect become a vet in order that foreign diplomats could openly meet him. Why did he establish his practice within walking distance of the American Emba.s.sy? And whyshortly after he opened this practicedid several employees from the American Emba.s.sy obtain pets? Finally, why was it that the pets of foreign diplomats seemed to require more frequent attention than pets belonging to a typical citizen? Kuzmin had been the first to agree that there was a comical aspect to all of this and it was precisely this disarming quality which had made him uneasy. The innocence of the circ.u.mstances felt like a brilliant disguise. It felt like the MGB was being laughed at. There were few more serious crimes than that.
Having considered the case and noted his mentor"s observations, Leo made the decision that instead of arresting the suspect outright they would have him followed, reasoning that if this citizen was working as a spy then it was an opportunity to discover who he was working with and arrest them all in one swoop. Though he never said as much, he was uncomfortable making an arrest without more evidence. Of course that was a qualm he"d lived with throughout his professional life. He"d made many arrests knowing only the citizen"s name and address and the fact that someone mistrusted them. A suspect"s guilt became real as soon as they became a suspect. As for evidence, that would be acquired during their interrogation. But Leo was no longer a lackey who merely followed orders, and he"d decided to make use of his authority and do things a little differently. He was an investigator. He"d wanted to investigate. He had little doubt that he"d eventually arrest Anatoly Brodsky, he just wanted proof; some sign of guilt other than mere conjecture. In short, he wanted to feel OK about arresting him.
As part of the surveillance operation, Leo had taken the day shift, following the suspect during the hours of eight in the morning through to eight in the evening. For three days he"d observed nothing out of the ordinary. The suspect worked, ate lunch out and went home. In short he seemed a good citizen. Perhaps it had been this innocuous appearance which had dulled Leo"s senses. When, this morning, he"d been pulled aside by an irate Kuzmin, briefed on the Fyodor Andreev situationthe dead boy, the hysterical reactionand ordered to fix it immediately, he didn"t protest. Instead of putting his foot down and pointing out that he had far more important things to do he"d acquiesced. With hindsight how ridiculous it all seemed. How frustrating that he was conversing with relatives, coaxing children, whilst this suspect, this traitor, was making his escape, making a mockery of Leo. The agent delegated to maintain watch had idiotically thought nothing of the fact that there hadn"t been a single customer at the veterinary practice all day. It wasn"t until dusk that the agent had become suspicious and entered, intending to pose as a customer. He"d found the premises empty. A back window had been prised open. The suspect could"ve escaped at any time, most probably in the morning, soon after he"d arrived.
Brodsky is gone.
When Leo had heard those words he"d felt sick: he"d called an emergency meeting with Major Kuzmin at his home address. Leo now had the proof of guilt he"d been looking for but he no longer had the suspect. To his surprise his mentor had seemed gratified. The traitor"s behaviour validated his theory: their business was mistrust. If an allegation contained only one per cent truth it was better to consider the entire allegation true than to dismiss it. Leo was instructed to catch this traitor at all costs. He was not to sleep, eat, rest, he was not to do anything until that man was in their custody, whereas Kuzmin had smugly pointed outhe should have been three days ago.
Leo rubbed his eyes. He could feel a knot in his stomach. At best he seemed naive, at worst incompetent. He"d underestimated an opponent and feeling a sudden, uncharacteristic burst of anger he considered kicking the upturned table. He decided against it. He had trained himself to keep his feelings locked out of view. A junior officer hurried into the room, probably keen to help, to prove his dedication. Leo waved him away, wanting to be alone. He took a moment to calm down, staring out of the window at the snow which had begun to fall over the city. He lit a cigarette, blowing smoke on a pane of gla.s.s. What had gone wrong? The suspect must have sighted the agents tailing him and planned his escape. If he was burning doc.u.ments that meant he was keen to conceal material relating to his espionage or his current destination. Leo was sure that Brodsky had an escape plan, a way to get out of the country. He had to find some fragment of this plan.
The neighbours were a retired couple in their seventies who lived with their married son, his wife and their two children. A family of six in two rooms, not an unusual ratio. All six of them were sitting in their kitchen side by side with a junior officer standing behind them for the purpose of intimidation. Leo could see that they understood that they were all implicated in another man"s guilt. He could see their fear. Dismissing this observation as irrelevanthe"d been guilty of sentimentality once alreadyhe walked up to the table.
-Anatoly Brodsky is a traitor. If you help him in any way even by saying nothing you will be treated as an accomplice. The pressure is on you to prove your loyalty to the State. There is no pressure on us to prove your guilt. That, right now, is taken for granted.
The elderly man, the grandfather, no doubt a savvy survivor, was quick to offer every piece of information he had. Copying Leo"s choice of words, he claimed the traitor had gone to work that morning a little earlier carrying the same case as usual, wearing the same coat and hat. Not wishing to seem uncooperative the grandfather offered opinions and suggestions as to where this traitor could be, all of which Leo sensed were nothing more than desperate guesswork. The grandfather concluded by saying how much everyone in their family disliked and mistrusted Brodsky as a neighbour and how the only person who liked him was Zina Morosovna, the lady living downstairs.
Zina Morosovna was aged somewhere in her fifties and trembling like a child, a fact she was trying unsuccessfully to hide by smoking. Leo found her standing beside a cheap reproduction of a famous Stalin portraitsmooth skin, wise eyeshung prominently over her fireplace. Perhaps she thought it might protect her. Leo didn"t bother to introduce himself, or show his ident.i.ty card, cutting straight to the chase in an effort to disorient her.
-Why is it you"re such good friends with Anatoly Brodsky when everyone else in this building disliked and mistrusted him?
Zina was caught off guard; her sense of discretion blunted by her indignation at this lie: -Everyone in this building liked Anatoly. He was a good man.
-Brodsky is a spy. Yet you call him good? Treachery is a virtue?
Realizing her mistake too late, Zina began to qualify her comment.
-All I meant was that he was very considerate with the noise. He was polite.
These qualifications were stuttering and irrelevant. Leo ignored them. He took out a pad and wrote down her ill-chosen words in large visible letters.
HE WAS A GOOD MAN.
He wrote clearly so that she could see exactly what he was writing: he was writing off the next fifteen years of her life. Those words were more than enough to convict her as a collaborator. She"d receive a lengthy sentence as a political prisoner. At her age she had little chance of surviving the Gulags. He didn"t need to say any of these threats aloud. They were common currency.
Zina retreated to the corner of the room, stubbed out her cigarette and immediately regretted it, fumbling for another.
-I don"t know where Anatoly has gone but I do know that he has no family. His wife was killed in the war. His son died of tuberculosis. He rarely had any visitors. As far as I could tell he had few friends...
She paused. Anatoly had been her friend. They"d spent many nights together, eating and drinking. There was a time when she"d even hoped that he might fall in love with her but he"d showed no interest. He"d never got over the loss of his wife. Caught up in her recollections she glanced at Leo. He wasn"t impressed.
-I want to know where he is. I don"t care about his dead wife or his dead son. His life story doesn"t interest me unless it"s relevant to where he is right now.
Her life was in the balancethere was only one way to survive. But could she betray a man she loved? To her surprise the decision took less deliberation then she would"ve expected.
-Anatoly kept himself to himself. However, he did receive and send letters. Occasionally he left them with me to post. The only regular correspondence was addressed to someone in the village of Kimov. It"s somewhere north of here, I think. He mentioned that he had a friend there. I don"t remember the name of the friend. That"s the truth. That"s all I know.
Her voice was choked with guilt. While no outward display of emotion could ever be taken at face value Leo"s instincts told him that she was betraying a confidence. He ripped out the incriminating page from his note-book and handed it to her. She accepted the sheet as payment for a betrayal. He saw contempt in her eyes. He didn"t let it bother him.
The name of a rural village to the north of Moscow was a tenuous lead. If Brodsky was working as a spy it was much more likely he was being sheltered by the people he was working for. The MGB had long been convinced there was in existence a network of safe houses under foreign control. The idea of a foreign-funded traitor falling back on a personal connectiona collective farmerran contrary to the notion that he was a professional spy. And yet Leo felt sure this was a lead he should pursue. He brushed the discrepancies aside: his job was to catch this man. This was the only clue he had. Equivocation had already cost him.
He hurried to the truck parked outside and began rereading the case file, searching for something which might connect with the village of Kimov. He was interrupted by the return of his second in command, Vasili Ilyich Nikitin. Aged thirty-five, five years older than Leo, Vasili had once been one of the MGB"s most promising officers. Ruthless, compet.i.tive, he harboured no loyalties to anyone except the MGB. Leo privately considered those loyalties to be less about patriotism and more about self-interest. In his early days as an investigator Vasili had signalled his dedication by denouncing his only brother for making anti-Stalinist remarks. Apparently the brother had made a joke at Stalin"s expense. He"d been drunk at the time, celebrating his birthday. Vasili had written up the report and the brother had been given a twenty-year labour sentence. That arrest had worked in Vasili"s favour until the brother escaped three years later, killing several guards and the camp doctor in the process. He was never caught, and the embarra.s.sment of this incident hung around Vasili"s neck. If he hadn"t strenuously helped in the search for the fugitive his career might not have survived. Instead it survived in a much weakened state. With no more brothers left to denounce, Leo knew his deputy was on the lookout for some other way of getting back in favour.
Having just finished his search of the veterinary practice, Vasili was apparently pleased with himself. He handed Leo a crumpled letter which, he explained, he"d found caught behind the traitor"s writing desk. All other correspondence had been burntas it had been in the apartmentyet in his hurry the suspect had missed this one. Leo read it. The letter was from a friend telling Anatoly he was welcome to stay with him at any time. The address was partially smudged but the name of the city was clear: Kiev. Leo folded the letter and handed it back to his deputy.
-This was written by Brodsky. Not a friend. He wanted us to find it. He"s not heading to Kiev.
The letter had been hastily written. The handwriting was inconsistent, poorly disguised. The content was risible and seemed solely intended to convince the reader that the writer was a friend to whom Brodsky could turn in an hour of need. The address was deliberately smudged to prevent a quick identification of the genuine occupant and so proof of the letter"s forgery. The location of the letterdropped behind the deskseemed staged.
Vasili protested the letter"s authenticity.
-It would be negligent not to fully investigate the Kiev lead.
Though Leo had no doubts about the letter being a forgery he wondered if it wouldn"t be shrewd to send Vasili to Kiev as a precautionary measure, to protect against any possible allegation that he"d ignored evidence. He dismissed the idea: it didn"t matter how he conducted the investigation, if he failed to find the suspect his career was over.
He returned his attention to the file. According to the records, Brodsky was friends with a man called Mikhail Sviatoslavich Zinoviev, who had been discharged from the Red Army suffering chronic frostbite. Near death, several of his toes had been amputated: he"d been nursed back to health and given a discharge from military service. Brodsky had performed the operation. Leo"s finger ran along the doc.u.ment, searching for a current address.
Kimov.
Leo turned to his men, catching Vasili"s sour expression.
-We"re leaving.
Thirty Kilometres North of Moscow 15 February The roads out of Moscow were covered with icy mulch and despite the truck"s tyres being fitted with snow chains their speed had rarely risen above twenty-five kilometres per hour. Wind and snow gusted around them with such ferocity it seemed as if they had some personal stake in Leo not reaching his destination. The windscreen wipers, attached to the roof of the front cabin struggled to keep even the smallest patch of window clear. With visibility less than ten metres the truck pushed forward. It was nothing less than desperation on Leo"s part to attempt a journey in these conditions.
Hunched forward with maps spread across his lap, Leo was seated beside Vasili and their driver. All three of them were dressed as though they were outsidecoats, gloves, hats. The steel cabin with its steel roof and steel floor was heated only by the residual warmth from the rattling engine. But at least the cabin offered some protection from the weather. In the back his nine heavily armed agents travelled in no such luxury. The ZiS-151 trucks had tarpaulin roofs which cold air and even snow whipped through. Since temperatures could fall to minus thirty, all rear compartments of the ZiS-151s were fitted with wood-burning stoves bolted to the floor. These pot-bellied contraptions were able to warm only those within touching distance of them, forcing the men to huddle and regularly rotate position. Leo had sat there many times himself: after every ten minutes the two nearest the stove reluctantly moved away from the heat, relegated to the coldest position at the furthest ends of the benches while the rest of the team shuffled up.
For the first time in his career Leo could sense dissent among his team. The reason wasn"t the discomfort or the lack of sleep. His men were used to tough conditions. No, there was something else. Perhaps it was the fact that the mission could have been avoided. Perhaps they had no confidence in the Kimov lead. Yet he"d asked his men for their confidence before and he"d been given it. Tonight he felt hostility, resistance. Aside from Vasili he wasn"t used to it. He pushed the thoughts aside. Right now his popularity was the least of his concerns.
If his theory proved correct, if the suspect was in Kimov, then Leo thought it likely that he"d be on the move at first light, whether on his own or aided by his friend. Leo was taking a chance betting that they"d get to the village in time. He"d decided against deploying the local militia stationed at Zagorsk, the nearest major town, since they were in his opinion amateurish, ill-disciplined and undertrained. Even the local MGB divisions weren"t to be trusted with such an operation. Already alert to the fact he was a wanted man, Brodsky was unlikely to surrender. He might fight to the death. He needed to be taken alive. His confession was of paramount importance. Furthermore his escape had embarra.s.sed Leo personally and he was determined to make amends, determined that he should be the one to make the arrest. This wasn"t merely a matter of pride. Nor was it merely that his career depended upon success. The consequences ran deeper than that. Failure in such a high-profile espionage case might result in claims that Leo had deliberately sabotaged the investigation. Failure to recapture the suspect would further implicate him. His loyalty would be called into question.
Check on Those we Trust.
No one was exempt from that rule, not even those who enforced it.
If Brodsky wasn"t in Kimov, if Leo was wrong, then Vasili would be the first in line with a testimonial detailing how his superior officer disregarded the promising Kiev lead. Sensing his weakness, others in the directorate, like animals circling a wounded prey, would almost certainly come forward to denounce him as a poor leader while Vasili positioned himself as Leo"s logical successor. In the hierarchies of the State Security, fortunes could change overnight. For both men much depended upon the location of this traitor.
Leo glanced across at his deputy, a man both handsome and repulsive in equal measureas if his good looks were plastered over a rotten centre, a hero"s face with a henchman"s heart. There were just the tiniest visible fractures in his attractive facade, appearing at the corners of his mouth, a slight sneer that, if you knew how to interpret it, hinted at the dark thoughts lying beneath his good looks. Perhaps sensing that he was the subject of attention, Vasili turned and smiled a thin, ambiguous smile. Something pleased him. Leo knew immediately that something must be wrong.
He checked the map. With a population of less than a thousand, Kimov was a speck of dust on the Soviet canvas. He"d warned the driver not to expect any road signs. Even at fifteen kilometres per hour this village would appear and disappear in the time it would take to change gear. Yet as Leo ran his finger over the road markings he began to suspect that they"d missed their turning. They were still travelling north when they should be travelling west. Since it was nearly impossible to take any kind of bearings based upon the surrounding landscape he calculated where they were in terms of kilometres. They were too far north. The driver had overshot the mark.
-Turn around!
Leo noticed that neither the driver nor Vasili seemed surprised by the request. The driver mumbled: -But we didn"t see the exit.
-We"ve missed it. Stop the truck.
The driver gently slowed, pumping the brake in short bursts in order to avoid sliding on the ice. The truck came to a gradual stop, Leo jumped out and in blizzard conditions began to direct the driver through an awkward U-turn, the ZiS-151 being almost as wide as the road. The turn was halfway complete, with the truck at right angles to the road, when the driver seemed to ignore Leo"s instructions, reversing too far and too fast. Leo ran forward banging on the door but it was too late. One of the back tyres ran off the road. It was spinning uselessly in a snow drift. Leo"s anger was tempered by his growing suspicions regarding this driver, who seemed to exhibit an improbable level of incompetence. Vasili had organized the truck, the driver. Leo opened the cabin door, shouting over the wind: -Get out!
The driver stepped out. By now the officers in the back had also jumped out to survey the situation. They glared at Leo with disapproval. Was this annoyance at the delay, the mission itself, irritation with his leadership? He couldn"t understand it. He ordered one of the other men to take the wheel whilst the entire team, including Vasili, pushed the truck out of the snow. The tyre spun, spraying dirty slush up their uniforms. Finally the snow chains caught the road and the truck lurched forward. Leo sent the disgraced driver to sit in the back. That kind of mistake was more than enough to warrant a written report and a Gulag sentence. Vasili must have guaranteed the driver immunity, a guarantee that would only hold up if Leo failed. Leo wondered how many other members of his team had more invested in his failure than his success. Feeling alone, isolated within his own unit, he took the wheel. He"d drive. He"d navigate. He"d get them there. He could trust no one. Vasili got in beside him, wisely opting to say nothing. Leo put the truck in gear.
By the time they were on the correct road, travelling west, on an approach to Kimov the storm had pa.s.sed. A weak winter sun began to rise. Leo was exhausted. Driving through the snow had drained him. His arms and shoulders were stiff, his eyelids heavy. They were pa.s.sing through the rural heartlandsfields, forests. Turning into a gentle valley he saw the village: a cl.u.s.ter of wooden farmhouses, some on the road, some set back, all with square bases and high triangular roofs, a vista that hadn"t changed for a hundred years. This was old Russia: communities built around bucket wells and ancient myths, where the health of cattle was decided by the grace of the Dvorovoi Dvorovoi, the yard spirit, where parents told their children that if they misbehaved spirits would steal them and turn them into bark. The parents had been told the stories as children and they"d never grown out of them, spending months st.i.tching clothes only to give them away as offerings to forest nymphs, the Rusalki Rusalki, who were believed to swing from the trees and could, if they so chose, tickle a man to death. Leo had grown up in the city and these rural superst.i.tions meant nothing to him, baffled as to how their country"s ideological revolution had done little to dislodge this primitive folklore.
Leo stopped the truck at the first farmhouse. From his jacket pocket he took out a gla.s.s vial filled with small, unevenly shaped dirty white crystalspure methamphetaminea narcotic much favoured by the n.a.z.is. He"d been introduced to it while fighting on the Eastern Front as his country"s army had pushed the invaders back, absorbing prisoners of war and also some of their habits. There had been operations where Leo couldn"t afford to rest. This was one of them. Now prescribed to him by the MGB doctors, he"d used it repeatedly since the war, whenever a mission needed to run all night. Its usefulness couldn"t be underestimated. But its price was a total crash about twenty-four hours later: complete exhaustion which could only be offset by taking more or sleeping for twelve hours. Side effects had begun to manifest themselves. He"d lost weight; the definition of his face had tightened. His powers of recall had faded, precise details and names eluded him, previous cases and arrests had become muddled in his memory and he now had to write notes to himself. It was impossible to judge whether or not he"d become more paranoid as a result of the drugs since paranoia was an essential a.s.set, a virtue which should be trained and cultivated. If it had been amplified by the methamphetamines, that was all to the good.
He tapped a small amount onto his palm, then a little more, struggling to remember the correct dosage. Better too much than too little. Satisfied, he washed it down with the contents of a hip flask. The vodka stung his throat, failing to hide the acrid chemical taste, which made him want to gag. He waited for the sensation to pa.s.s, surveying his surroundings. Fresh snow covered everything. Leo was pleased. Outside Kimov itself there were few places to hide. A person would be visible for kilometres, their tracks through the snow easy to follow.
He had no idea which of these farms belonged to Mikhail Zinoviev. Since a military truck parked in the road took away any element of surprise Leo jumped out, drew his gun and moved towards the nearest house. Though the amphetamines hadn"t yet taken hold he already felt more awake, sharpened as his brain prepared itself for the inevitable narcotic surge. He approached the porch, checking his weapon.
Before he"d even knocked on the door an elderly woman with leathery skin appeared. She was wearing a blue-patterned dress with white sleeves, and an embroidered shawl wrapped around her head. She didn"t care for Leo, or his gun, his uniform, or his military truck. She was fearless and made no attempt to hide the lines of disdain carved into her brow.
-I"m looking for Mikhail Sviatoslavich Zinoviev. Is this his farmhouse? Where is he?
As though Leo were speaking a foreign language she c.o.c.ked her head to one side and made no response. It was the second time in two days that an elderly woman had squared up to him, held him in open contempt. There was something about these women which made them untouchable; his authority meant nothing to them. Fortunately the stalemate was broken when the woman"s son, a man with a strong build and nervous stammer, hurried out of the house.
-Excuse her. She"s old. What can I do for you?
Once again sons made excuses for their mothers.
-Mikhail Sviatoslavich. Where is he? Which is his farm?
Realizing that Leo wasn"t interested in arresting them, that he and his family were safe for another day, the son was greatly relieved. He gladly pointed out his friend"s farm.
Leo returned to the truck. His men had a.s.sembled. He split the team into three groups. They"d advance on the house from different sides, one each from the front and back while the third team would approach and surround the barn. Each man was armed with a 9mm Stechkin APS automatic pistol devised specially for use by the MGB. In addition one man in each group carried an AK-47. They were ready for a pitched battle, if it came to that.
-We take the traitor alive. We need his confession. If you"re in any doubt, any doubt at all, you don"t fire.
Leo repeated this command with particular emphasis to the group headed by Vasili. Killing Anatoly Brodsky would be a punishable offence. Their own safety was secondary to the life of the suspect. In response Vasili took command of his group"s AK-47.
-Just to be sure.
In an attempt to limit Vasili"s potential to sabotage this operation Leo gave them the least important area to secure.
-Your group will search the barn.
Vasili moved off. Leo grabbed his arm.
-We take him alive.
Halfway towards the house the men divided into the three groups, breaking off in different directions. Neighbours stole glances from their windows then disappeared inside. Thirty paces from the door Leo paused, allowing the other two groups to get in position. Vasili"s team encircled the barn while the third group arrived at the back of the house, all of them waiting for Leo"s signal. There was no sign of life outside. A whisper of smoke rose from the chimney. Ragged cloth hung in front of the small windows. It was impossible to see into the rooms. Except for the click of AK-47 safety catches there was silence. Suddenly a young girl stepped out from a small rectangular building, the pit toiletset back from the main house. She was humming; the sound carried across the snow. The three officers nearest Leo swung round, training their guns on her. The little girl froze, terrified. Leo raised his hands.
-Don"t shoot!
He held his breath, hoping not to hear the report of machine-gun fire. No one moved. And then the girl broke into a run, sprinting towards the house as fast as she could, screaming for her mother.
Leo felt the first amphetamine kickhis fatigue evaporated. He leapt forward, his men followed, moving in on the house like a noose tightening around a neck. The little girl threw open the front door, scampered inside. Leo was only seconds behind, hitting the front door with his shoulder, raising his gun and barging into the house. He found himself inside a small, warm kitchen surrounded by the smell of breakfast. There were two young girlsthe elder was maybe ten years old and the younger four years oldstanding by a small fire. Their mother, a stout, tough looking woman who looked like she could swallow bullets and spit them back out, was in front of them, shielding them with one hand on each of their chests. A man in his forties entered from the back room. Leo turned to him.
-Mikhail Sviatoslavich?
-Yes?