"And she asked about his wallet," Dave said. "All we could tell her was that no one ever found it...at least no one who ever turned it in to the police. I suppose it"s possible someone could have picked it out of his pocket on the ferry, stripped the cash out of it, then dropped it overside."
"It"s possible that heaven"s a rodeo, too, but not likely," Vince said drily. "If he had cash in his wallet, why did he have more-seventeen dollars in paper money-in his pants pocket?"
"Just in case," Stephanie said.
"Maybe," Vince said, "but it doesn"t feel right to me. And frankly, I find the idea of a pickpocket workin the six o"clock ferry between Tinnock and Moosie a touch more unbelievable than a commercial artist from a Denver advertising agency charterin a jet to fly to New England."
"In any case, we couldn"t tell her where his wallet went," Dave said, "or where his topcoat and suit-jacket went, or why he was found sittin out there on a stretch of beach in nothin but his pants and shirt."
"The cigarettes?" Stephanie asked. "I bet she was curious about those."
Vince barked a laugh. "Curious isn"t the right word. That pack of smokes drove her almost crazy. She couldn"t understand why he"d have had cigarettes on him. And we didn"t need her to tell us he wasn"t the kind who"d stopped for awhile and then decided to take the habit up again. Cathcart took a good look at his lungs during the autopsy, for reasons I"m sure you"ll understand-"
"He wanted to make sure he hadn"t drowned after all?" Stephanie asked.
"That"s right," Vince said. "If Dr. Cathcart had found water in the lungs beneath that chunk of meat, it would have suggested someone trying to cover up the way Mr. Cogan actually died. And while that wouldn"t have proved murder, it would"ve suggested it. Cathcart didn"t find water in Cogan"s lungs, and he didn"t find any evidence of smoking, either. Nice and pink down there, he said. Yet someplace between Cogan"s office building and Stapleton Airport, and in spite of the tearing hurry he had to"ve been in, he must"ve had his driver stop so he could pick up a pack. Either that or he had em put by already, which is what I tend to believe. Maybe with his Russian coin."
"Did you tell her that?" Stephanie asked.
"No," Vince said, and just then the telephone rang. ""Scuse me," he said, and went to answer it.
He spoke briefly, said Ayuh a time or three, then returned, stretching his back some more as he did. "That was Ellen Dunwoodie," he said. "She"s ready to talk about the great trauma she"s been through, snappin off that fire hydrant and "makin a spectacle of herself." That"s an exact quote, although I don"t think it will appear in my pulse-poundin account of the event. In any case, I think I"d better amble over there pretty soon; get the story while her recollection"s clear and before she decides to make supper. I"m lucky she n her sister eat late. Otherwise I"d be out of luck."
"And I"ve got to get after those invoices," Dave said. "Seems like there must be a dozen more than there were when we left for the Gull. I swan to goodness when you leave em alone atop a desk, they breed."
Stephanie gazed at them with real alarm. "You can"t stop now. You can"t just leave me hanging."
"No other choice," Vince said mildly. "We"ve been hanging, Steffi, and for twenty-five years now. There isn"t any jilted church secretary in this one."
"No Ellsworth city lights reflected on the clouds downeast, either," Dave said. "Not even a Teodore Riponeaux in the picture, some poor old sailorman murdered for hypothetical pirate treasure and then left to die on the foredeck in his own blood after all his shipmates had been tossed overside-and why? As a warning to other would-be treasure-hunters, by gorry! Now there"s a through-line for you, dearheart!"
Dave grinned...but then the grin faded. "Nothing like that in the case of the Colorado Kid; no string for the beads, don"t you see, and no Sherlock Holmes or Ellery Queen to string em in any case. Just a couple of guys running a newspaper with about a hundred stories a week to cover. None of em drawin much water by Boston Globe standards, but stuff people on the island like to read about, all the same. Speakin of which, weren"t you going to talk with Sam Gernerd? Find out all the details on his famous Hayride, Dance, and Picnic?"
"I was...I am...and I want to! Do you guys understand that? That I actually want to talk to him about that dumb thing?"
Vince Teague burst out laughing, and Dave joined him.
"Ayuh," Vince said, when he could talk again. "Dunno what the head of your journalism department would make of it, Steffi, he"d probably break down n cry, but I know you do." He glanced at Dave.
"We know you do."
"And I know you"ve got your own fish to fry, but you must have some ideas...some theories...after all these years..." She looked at them plaintively. "I mean...don"t you?"
They glanced at each other and again she felt that telepathy flow between them, but this time she had no sense of the thought it carried. Then Dave looked back at her. "What is it you really want to know, Stephanie? Tell us."
18.
"Do you think he was murdered?" That was what she really wanted to know. They had asked her to set the idea aside, and she had, but now the discussion of the Colorado Kid was almost over, and she thought they would allow her to put the subject back on the table.
"Why would you think that any more likely than accidental death, given everything we"ve told you?" Dave asked. He sounded genuinely curious.
"Because of the cigarettes. The cigarettes almost had to have been deliberate on his part. He just never thought it would take a year and a half for someone to discover that Colorado stamp. Cogan believed a man found dead on a beach with no identification would rate more investigation than he got."
"Yes," Vince said. He spoke in a low voice but actually clenched a fist and shook it, like a fan who has just watched a ballplayer make a key play or deliver a clutch hit. "Good girl. Good job."
Although just twenty-two, there were people Stephanie would have resented for calling her a girl. This ninety-year-old man with the thin white hair, narrow face, and piercing blue eyes was not one of them. In truth, she flushed with pleasure.
"He couldn"t know he"d draw a couple of thuds like O"Shanny and Morrison when it came time to investigate his death," Dave said. "Couldn"t know he"d have to depend on a grad student who"d spent the last couple of months holdin briefcases and goin out for coffee, not to mention a couple of old guys puttin out a weekly paper one step above a supermarket handout."
"Hang on there, brother," Vince said. "Them"s fightin words." He put up his elderly dukes, but with a grin.
"I think he did all right," Stephanie said. "In the end, I think he did just fine." And then, thinking of the woman and baby Michael (who would by this time be in his mid-twenties): "So did she, actually. Without Paul Devane and you two guys, Arla Cogan never would have gotten her insurance money."
"Some truth to that," Vince conceded. She was amused to see that something in this made him uncomfortable. Not that he"d done good, she thought, but that someone knew he had done good. They had the Internet out here; you could see a little Direct TV satellite dish on just about every house; no fishing boat set to sea anymore without the GPS switched on. Yet still the old Calvinist ideas ran deep. Let not thy left hand know what thy right hand doeth.
"What exactly do you think happened?" she asked.
"No, Steffi," Vince said. He spoke kindly but firmly. "You"re still expectin Rex Stout to come waltzin out of the closet, or Ellery Queen arm in arm with Miss Jane Marple. If we knew what happened, if we had any idea, we would have chased that idea til we dropped. And frig the Boston Globe, we would have broken any story we found on page one of the Islander. We may have been little newspapermen back in "81, and we may be little old newspapermen now, but we ain"t dead little old newspapermen. I still like the idea of a big story just fine."
"Me too," Dave said. He"d gotten up, probably with those invoices on his mind, but had now settled on the corner of his desk, swinging one large leg. "I"ve always dreamed of us havin a story that got syndicated nationwide, and that"s one dream I"ll probably die with. Go on, Vince, tell her as much as you think. She"ll keep it close. She"s one of us now."
Stephanie almost shivered with pleasure, but Vince Teague appeared not to notice. He leaned forward, fixing her light blue eyes with his, which were a much darker shade-the color of the ocean on a sunny day.
"All right," he said. "I started to think something might be funny about how he died as well as how he got here long before all that about the stamp. I started askin myself questions when I realized he had a pack of cigarettes with only one gone, although he"d been on the island since at least six-thirty. I made a real pest of myself at Bayside News."
Vince smiled at the recollection.
"I showed everyone at the shop Cogan"s picture, including the sweep-up boy. I was convinced he must have bought that pack there, unless he got it out of a vendin machine at a place like the Red Roof or the Shuffle Inn or maybe Sonny"s Sunoco. The way I figured, he must have finished his smokes while wanderin around Moosie, after gettin off the ferry, then bought a fresh supply. And I also figured that if he got em at the News, he must have gotten em shortly before eleven, which is when the News closes. That would explain why he just smoked one, and only used one of his new matches, before he died."
"But then you found out he wasn"t a smoker at all," Stephanie said.
"That"s right. His wife said so and Cathcart confirmed it. And later on I became sure that pack of smokes was a message: I came from Colorado, look for me there."
"We"ll never know for sure, but we both think that"s what it was," Dave said.
"Jee-sus," she almost whispered. "So where does that lead you?"
Once more they looked at each other and shrugged those identical shrugs. "Into a land of shadows n moonbeams," Vince said. "Places no feature writer from the Boston Globe will ever go, in other words. But there are a few things I"m sure of in my heart. Would you like to hear em?"
"Yes!"
Vince spoke slowly but deliberately, like a man feeling his way down a very dark corridor where he has been many times before.
"He knew he was goin into a desperate situation, and he knew he might go unidentified if he died. He didn"t want that to happen, quite likely because he was worried about leaving his wife broke."
"So he bought those cigarettes, hoping they"d be overlooked," Stephanie said.
Vince nodded. "Ayuh, and they were."
"But overlooked by who?"
Vince paused, then went on without answering her question. "He went down in the elevator and out through the lobby of his building. There was a car waitin to take him to Stapleton Airport, either right there or just around the corner. Maybe it was just him and the driver in that car; maybe there was someone else. We"ll never know. You asked me earlier if Cogan was wearing his overcoat when he left that morning, and I said George the Artist didn"t remember, but Arla said she never saw that overcoat no more, so maybe he was, at that. If so, I think he took it off in the car or in the airplane. I think he also took off his suit-coat jacket. I think someone either gave him the green jacket to wear in their place, or it was waitin for him."
"In the car or on the plane."
"Ayuh," Dave said.
"The cigarettes?"
"Don"t know for sure, but if I had to bet, I"d bet he already had em on him," Dave said. "He knew this was comin along...whatever this was. He"d"ve had em in his pants pocket, I think."
"Then, later, on the beach..." She saw Cogan, her mind"s-eye version of the Colorado Kid, lighting his life"s first cigarette-first and last-and then strolling down to the water"s edge with it, there on Hammock Beach, alone in the moonlight. The midnight moonlight. He takes one puff of the harsh, unfamiliar smoke. Maybe two. Then he throws the cigarette into the sea. Then...what?
What?
"The plane dropped him off in Bangor," she heard herself saying in a voice that sounded harsh and unfamiliar to herself.
"Ayuh," Dave agreed.
"And his ride from Bangor dropped him off in Tinnock."
"Ayuh." That was Vince.
"He ate a fish-and-chips basket."
"So he did," Vince agreed. "Autopsy proves it. So did my nose. I smelled the vinegar."
"Was his wallet gone by then?"
"We don"t know," Dave said. "We"ll never know. But I think so. I think he gave it up with his topcoat, his suit-coat, and his normal life. I think what he got in return was a green jacket, which he also gave up later on."
"Or had taken from his dead body," Vince said.
Stephanie shivered. She couldn"t help it. "He rides across to Moose-Lookit Island on the six o"clock ferry, bringing Gard Edwick a paper cup of coffee on the way-what could be construed as tea for the tillerman, or the ferryman."
"Yuh," Dave said. He looked very solemn.
"By then he has no wallet, no ID, just seventeen dollars and some change that maybe includes a Russian ten-ruble coin. Do you think that coin might have been...oh, I don"t know...some sort of identification-thingy, like in a spy novel? I mean, the cold war between Russia and the United States would have still been going on then, right?"
"Full blast," Vince said. "But Steffi-if you were going to d.i.c.ker with a Russian secret agent, would you use a ruble to introduce yourself?"
"No," she admitted. "But why else would he have it? To show it to someone, that"s all I can think of."
"I"ve always had the intuition that someone gave it to him," Dave said. "Maybe along with a piece of cold sirloin steak, wrapped up in a piece of tinfoil."
"Why?" she asked. "Why would they?"
Dave shook his head. "I don"t know."
"Was there tinfoil found at the scene? Maybe thrown into that sea-gra.s.s along the far edge of the beach?"
"O"Shanny and Morrison sure didn"t look," Dave said. "Me n Vince had a hunt all around Hammock Beach after that yella tape was taken down-not specifically for tinfoil, you understand, but for anything that looked like it might bear on the dead man, anything at all. We found nothing but the usual litter-candy-wrappers and such."
"If the meat was in foil or a Baggie, the Kid might very well have tossed it into the water, along with his one cigarette," Vince said.
"About that piece of meat in his throat..."
Vince was smiling a little. "I had several long conversations about that piece of steak with both Doc Robinson and Dr. Cathcart. Dave was in on a couple of em. I remember Cathcart saying to me once, this had to"ve been not more than a month before the heart attack that took his life six or seven years ago, "You go back to that old business the way a kid who"s lost a tooth goes back to the hole with the tip of his tongue." And I thought to myself, yep, that"s exactly right, exactly what it"s like. It"s like a hole I can"t stop poking at and licking into, trying to find the bottom of.
"First thing I wanted to know was if that piece of meat could have been jammed down Cogan"s throat, either with fingers or some sort of instrument like a lobster-pick, after he was dead. And that"s crossed your mind, hasn"t it?"
Stephanie nodded.
"He said it was possible but unlikely, because that piece of steak had not only been chewed, but chewed enough to be swallowed. It wasn"t really meat at all anymore, but rather what Cathcart called "organic pulp-ma.s.s." Someone else could have chewed it that much, but would have been unlikely to have planted it after doing so, for fear it would have looked insufficient to cause death. Are you with me?"
She nodded again.
"He also said that meat chewed to a pulp-ma.s.s would be hard to manipulate with an instrument. It would tend to break up when pushed from the back of the mouth into the throat. Fingers could do it, but Cathcart said he believed he would have seen signs of that, most likely straining of the jaw ligatures." He paused, thinking, then shook his head. "There"s a technical term for that kind of jaw-poppin, but I don"t remember it."
"Tell her what Robinson told you," Dave said. His eyes were sparkling. "It didn"t come to nummore"n the rest in the end, but I always thought it was wicked int"restin."
"He said there were certain muscle relaxants, some of em exotic, and Cogan"s midnight snack might have been treated with one of those," Vince said. "He might get the first few bites down all right, accounting for what was found in his stomach, and then find himself all at once with a bite he wasn"t able to swallow once it was chewed."
"That must have been it!" Stephanie cried. "Whoever dosed the meat sat there and just watched him choke! Then, when Cogan was dead, the murderer propped him up against the litter basket and took away the rest of the steak so it could never be tested! It was never a gull at all! It..." She stopped, looking at them. "Why are you shaking your heads?"
"The autopsy, dear," Vince said. "Nothing like that showed up on the blood-gas chromatograph tests."
"But if it was something exotic enough..."
"Like in an Agatha Christie yarn?" Vince asked, with a wink and a little smile. "Well, maybe...but there was also the piece of meat in his throat, don"t you know."
"Oh. Right. Dr. Cathcart had that to test, didn"t he?" She slumped a little.
"Ayuh," Vince agreed, "and did. We may be country mice, but we do have the occasional dark thought. And the closest thing to poison on that chunk of chewed-up meat was a little salt."
She was silent for a moment. Then she said (in a very low voice): "Maybe it was the kind of stuff that disappears."
"Ayuh," Dave said, and his tongue rounded the inside of one cheek. "Like the Coast Lights after an hour or two."
"Or the rest of the Lisa Cabot"s crew," Vince added.