"does on him still attend, To reach whenever he for ought does send."
We cannot lay aside anything that we have ever done or been so utterly but that that servant can find it and bring it to his lord.
We forget nothing so completely but that we shall be able to recall it. Of that awful power we may say, without irreverence, "Thou hast set our iniquities before thee, our secret sins in the light of thy countenance."
The fragmentary remembrances which we have now, lift themselves above the ocean of forgetfulness like islands in some Archipelago, the summits of sister hills, though separated by the estranging sea that covers their converging sides and the valleys where their roots unite. The solid land is there, though hidden. Drain off the sea, and there will be no more isolated peaks, but continuous land. In this life we have but the island memories heaving themselves into sight, but in the next the Lord shall "cause the sea to go back by the breath of His mouth," and the channels of the great deep of a human heart"s experiences and actions shall be laid bare. "There shall be no more sea"; but the solid land of a whole life will appear when G.o.d says, "Son, remember!"
So much, then, for my first consideration--namely, that memory in a future state will comprehend the whole of life. Another thing is, that memory in a future state will probably be so rapid as to embrace all the past life at once. We do not know, we have no conception of, the extent to which our thinking, and feeling, and remembrance, are made tardy by the slow vehicle of this bodily organisation in which the soul rides. But we have in our own lives instances enough to make us feel that there lie in us dormant, mysterious powers by which the rapidity of all our operations of thought and feeling will be enhanced marvellously, like the difference between a broad-wheeled waggon and an express train! At some turning point of your life, when some great joy flashed, or some great shadow darkened upon you all at once; when some crisis that wanted an instantaneous decision appeared--why, what regions of thought, purpose, plan, resolution; what wilderness of desolate sorrow, and what paradises of blooming gladness, your soul has gone through in a moment. Well, then, take another ill.u.s.tration: A sleeper, feeling a light finger laid upon his shoulder, does not know what it is; in an instant he awakes and says, "Is it you?" but between that touch and that word there may be a whole life run through, a whole series of long events dreamt and felt. As on the little retina of an eye there can be painted on a scale inconceivably minute, every tree and mountain-top in the whole wide panorama--so, in an instant, one may run through almost a whole lifetime of mental acts. Then, again, you remember that ill.u.s.tration, often used on this subject, about the experience of those who have been brought face to face with sudden death, and escaped it. The drowning man, when he comes to himself, tells us, that in the interval betwixt the instant when he felt he was going and the pa.s.sing away of consciousness, all his life stood before him; as if some flash in a dark midnight had lighted up a whole mountain country--there it all was! Ah, brethren! we know nothing yet about the rapidity with which we may gather before us a whole series of events; so that although we have to pa.s.s from one to another, the succession may be so swift, as to produce in our own minds the effect of all being co-existent and simultaneous. As the child flashing about him a bit of burning stick, may seem to make a circle of flame, because the flame-point moves so quickly--so memory, though it does go from point to point, and dwells for some inconceivably minute instant on each part of the remembrance, may yet be gifted with such lightning speed, with such rapidity and awful quickness of glance, as that to the man himself the effect shall be that his whole life is spread out there before him in one instant, and that he, G.o.dlike, sees the end and the beginning side by side. Yes; from the mountain of eternity we shall look down, and behold the whole plain spread before us. Down here we get lost and confused in the devious valleys that run off from the roots of the hills everywhere, and we cannot make out which way the streams are going, and what there is behind that low shoulder of hill yonder: but when we get to the summit peak, and look down, it will all shape itself into one consistent whole, and we shall see it all at once.
The memory shall be perfect--perfect in the range of its grasp, and perfect in the rapidity with which it brings up all its objects before us at every instant.
Once more: it seems as if, in another world, memory would not only contain the whole life, and the whole life simultaneously; but would perpetually attend or haunt us. A constant remembrance! It does not lie in our power even in this world, to decide very much whether we shall remember or forget. It does not come within a man"s will to forget or to remember. He cannot say, "I will remember"; for if he could, he would have remembered already. He cannot say, "I will forget"; for the very effort fixes his attention on the obnoxious thing. All that we can do, when we seek to remember, is to wander back to somewhere about that point in our life where the shy thing lurks, and hope to catch some sight of it in the leafy coverts: and all we can do, when we want to forget, is to try and fill our mind with other subjects, and in the distractions of them to lose the oppressive and burdensome thoughts. But we know that that is but a partial remedy, that we cannot succeed in doing it. There are presences that will not be put by. There are memories that _will_ start up before us, whether we are willing or not. Like the leprosy in the Israelite"s house, the foul spot works its way out through all the plaster and the paint; and the house is foul because it is there. Oh, my friend! you are a happy and a singular man if there is nothing in your life that you have tried to bury, and the obstinate thing _will_ not be buried, but meets you again when you come away from its fancied grave. I remember an old castle where they tell us of a foul murder committed in a vaulted chamber with a narrow window, by torchlight one night; and there, they say, there are the streaks and stains of blood on the black oak floor; and they have planed, and scrubbed, and planed again, and thought they were gone--but there they always are, and continually up comes the dull reddish-black stain, as if oozing itself out through the boards to witness to the b.l.o.o.d.y crime again! The superst.i.tious fable is a type of the way in which a foul thing, a sinful and bitter memory--gets ingrained into a man"s heart. He tries to banish it, and gets rid of it for a while. He goes back again, and the spots are there, and will be there for ever; and the only way to get rid of them is to destroy the soul in which they are.
Memory is not all within the power of the will on earth: and probably, memory in another world is still more involuntary and still more constant. Why? Because I read in the Bible that there is work in another world for G.o.d"s servants to do; but I do not read that there is work for anybody else but G.o.d"s servants to do. The work of an unforgiven sinner is done when he dies, and that not only because he is going into the state of retribution, but because no rebel"s work is going to be suffered in that world. The time for that is past. And so, if you will look, all the teachings of the Bible about the future state of those who are not in blessedness, give us this idea--a monotonous continuance of idleness, shutting them up to their own contemplations, the memories of the past and the agonies of the future. There are no distractions for such a man in another world. He has thought, he has conscience, he has remembrance. He has a sense of pain, of sin, of wrong, of loss. He has one "pa.s.sive fixed endurance, all eternal and the same"; but I do not read that his pain is anodyned and his sorrow soothed by any activity that his hand finds to do. And, in a most tragic sense, we may say, "there is neither work, nor labour, nor device," in that dark world where the fruits of sin are reaped in monotonous suffering and ever-present pain. A memory, brethren, that i>will_ have its own way--what a field for sorrow and lamentation that is, when G.o.d says at last, "Now go--go apart; take thy life with thee; read it over; see what thou hast done with it!" One old Roman tyrant had a punishment in which he bound the dead body of the murdered to the living body of the murderer, and left them there scaffolded. And when that voice comes, "Son, remember!" to the living soul of the G.o.dless, unbelieving, impenitent man, there is bound to him the murdered past, the dead past, his own life; and, in Milton"s awful and profound words,
"Which way I fly is h.e.l.l--myself am h.e.l.l!"
There is only one other modification of this awful faculty that I would remind you of; and that is, that in a future life memory will be a.s.sociated with a perfectly accurate knowledge of the consequences and a perfectly sensitive conscience as to the criminality of the past. You will have cause and consequence put down before you, meeting each other at last. There will be no room then to say, "I wonder how such and such a thing will work out," "I wonder how such a thing can have come upon me"; but every one will have his whole life to look back upon, and will see the childish sin that was the parent of the full-grown vice, and the everlasting sorrow that came out of that little and apparently transitory root. The conscience, which here becomes hardened by contact with sin, and enfeebled because unheeded, will then be restored to its early sensitiveness and power, as if the labourer"s h.o.r.n.y palm were to be endowed again with the softness of the infant"s little hand. If you will take and think about that, brother, _there_ is enough--without any more talk, without any more ghastly, sensual external figures--_there_ is enough to make the boldest tremble; a memory embracing all the past, a memory rapidly grasping and constantly bringing its burden, a judgment which admits of no mistakes, and a conscience which has done with palliations and excuses!
It is not difficult to see how that is an instrument of torture. It is more difficult to see how such a memory can be a source of gladness; and yet it can. The old Greeks were pressed with that difficulty: they said to themselves, If a man remembers, there can be no Elysium for him. And so they put the river of forgetfulness, the waters of Lethe, betwixt life and the happy plains. Ah, _we_ do not want any river of oblivion betwixt us and everlasting blessedness. Calvary is on this side, and that is enough! Certainly it is one of the most blessed things about "the faith that is in Christ Jesus," that it makes a man remember his own sinfulness with penitence, not with pain--that it makes the memory of past transgressions full of solemn joy, because the memory of _past_ transgressions but brings to mind the depth and rushing fullness of that river of love which has swept them all away as far as the east is from the west. Oh, brother, brother! you cannot forget your sins; but it lies within your own decision whether the remembrance shall be thankfulness and blessedness, or whether it shall be pain and loss for ever. Like some black rock that heaves itself above the surface of a sunlit sea, and the wave runs dashing over it, and the spray, as it falls down its sides, is all rainbowed and lightened, and there comes beauty into the mighty grimness of the black thing;--so a man"s transgressions rear themselves up, and G.o.d"s great love, coming sweeping itself against them and over them, makes out of the sin an occasion for the flashing more brightly of the beauty of His mercy, and turns the life of the pardoned penitent into a life of which even the sin is not pain to remember. So, then, lay your hand upon Christ Jesus. Put your heart into His keeping. Go to Him with your transgressions, He will forget them, and make it possible for you to remember them in such a way that the memory will become to you the very foundation of all your joy, and will make heaven"s anthem deeper and more harmonious when you say, "Now unto Him that hath washed us from our sins in His own blood, and hath made us kings and priests unto G.o.d, unto Him be glory for ever and ever!" And, on the other hand, _if not_, then, "Son, remember!"
will be the word that begins the future retribution, and shuts you up with a wasted past, with a gnawing conscience, and an upbraiding heart: to say,
"I backward cast my ee On prospects drear!
And forward, though I canna see, I guess and fear!"
G.o.d"S SLAVES
"Doth He thank that servant because he did the things that were commanded him! I trow not. 10. So likewise ye, when ye shall have done all those things which are commanded you, say, We are unprofitable servants: we have done that which was our duty to do."
--LUKE xvii. 9-10.
There are two difficulties about these words. One is their apparent entire want of connection with what precedes--viz., the disciples"
prayer, "Lord, increase our faith," and the other is the harshness and severity of tone which marks them, and the view of the less attractive side of man"s relation to G.o.d which is thrown into prominence in them. He must be a very churlish master who never says "Thank you," however faithful his servant"s obedience may be. And he must be a very inconsiderate master, who has only another kind of duty to lay upon the shoulders of the servant that has come in after a long day"s ploughing and feeding of cattle. Perhaps, however, the one difficulty clears away the other, and if we keep firm hold of the thought that the words of my text, and those which are a.s.sociated with them, are an answer to the prayer, "Lord, increase our faith," the stern and somewhat repelling characteristics of the words may somewhat change.
I. So I look, first, at the husk of apparent harshness and severity.
The relation between master and hired servant is not the one that is in view, but the relation between a master and the slave who is his property, who has no rights, who has no possessions, whose life and death and everything connected with him are at the absolute disposal of his master. It is a foul and wicked relation when existing between men, and it has been full of cruelty and atrocities. But Jesus Christ lays His hand upon it, and says, "That is the relation between men and G.o.d; that is the relation between men and Me."
And what is involved therein? Absolute authority; so that the slave is but, as it were, an animated instrument in the hand of the master, with no will of his own, and no rights and no possessions.
That is not all of our relation to G.o.d, blessed be His Name! But that is _in_ our relation to Him, and the highest t.i.tle that a man can have is the t.i.tle which the Apostles in after days bound upon their foreheads as a crown of honour--"A slave of Jesus Christ."
Then, if that relation is laid as being the basis of all our connection with G.o.d, whatever else there may be also involved, these two things which in the human relation are ugly and inconsiderate, and argue a very churlish and selfish nature on the part of the human master, belong essentially to our relation to G.o.d. "Which of you, having a servant, ploughing or feeding cattle, will say unto him ... when he has come from the field, Go (immediately) and sit down to meat, and will not rather say unto him, Make ready wherewith I may sup, and gird thyself and serve me, till I have eaten and drunken: and afterward thou shalt eat and drink?" You will get your supper by-and-by, but you are here to work, says the master, and when you have finished one task, that does not involve that you are to rest; it involves only that you are to take up another. And however wearisome has been the ploughing amongst the heavy clods all day long, and tramping up and down the furrows, when you come in you are to clean yourself up, and get my supper ready, "and afterward thou shalt eat and drink."
As I have said, such a speech would argue a harsh human master, but is there not a truth which is not harsh in it in reference to us and G.o.d?
Duty never ends. The eternal persistence through life of the obligation to service is what is taught us here, as being inherent in the very relation between the Lord and Owner of us all and us His slaves.
Moralists and irreligious teachers say grand things about the eternal sweep of the great law of duty. The Christian thought is the higher one, "Thou hast beset me behind and before, and laid Thine hand upon me," and wherever I am I am under obligation to serve Thee, and no past record of work absolves me from the work of the present. From the cradle to the grave I walk beneath an all-encompa.s.sing, overarching firmament of duty. As long as we draw breath we are bound to the service of Him whose slaves we are, and whose service is perfect freedom.
Such is the bearing of this apparently repulsive representation of our text, which is not so repulsive if you come to think about it.
It does not in the least set aside the natural craving for recreation and relaxation and repose. It does not overlook G.o.d"s obligation to keep His slave alive, and in good condition for doing His work, by bestowing upon him the things that are needful for him, but it does meet that temptation which comes to us all to take that rest which circ.u.mstances may make manifestly not G.o.d"s will, and it says to us, "Forget the things that are behind, and reach forth unto the things that are before." You have done a long day"s work with plough or sheep-crook. The reward for work is more work. Come away indoors now, and nearer the Master, prepare His table. "Which of you, having a servant, will not do so with him?" And that is how He does with us.
Then, the next thought here, which, as I say, has a harsh exterior, and a bitter rind, is that one of the slave doing his work, and never getting so much as "thank you" for it. But if you lift this interpretation too, into the higher region of the relation between G.o.d and His slaves down here, a great deal of the harshness drops away. For what does it come to? Just to this, that no man among us, by any amount or completeness of obedience to the will of G.o.d establishes claims on G.o.d for a reward. You have done your duty--so much the better for you, but is that any reason why you should be decorated and honoured for doing it? You have done no more than your duty. "So, likewise, ye, when ye have done all things that are commanded you"--even if that impossible condition were to be realised--"say we are unprofitable servants"; not in the bad sense in which the word is sometimes used, but in the accurate sense of not having brought any profit or advantage, more than was His before, to the Master whom we have thus served. It is a blessed thing for a man to call _himself_ an unprofitable servant; it is an awful thing for the Master to call him one. If _we_ say "we are unprofitable servants," we shall be likely to escape the solemn words from the Lord"s lips: "Take ye away the unprofitable servant, and cast him into outer darkness." There are two that may use the word, Christ the Judge, and man the judged, and if the man will use it, Christ will not. "If we judge ourselves we shall not be judged."
Now, although, as I have said about the other part of this text, it is not meant to exhaust our relations to G.o.d, or to say the all-comprehensive word about the relation of obedience to blessedness; it is meant to say
"Merit lives from man to man, And not from man, O Lord! to Thee."
No one can reasonably build upon his own obedience, or his own work, nor claim as by right, for reward, heaven or other good. So my text is the antic.i.p.ation of Paul"s teaching about the impossibility of a man"s being saved by his works, and it cuts up by the root, not only the teaching as to a treasure of "merits of the saints," and "works of supererogation," and the like; but it tells us, too, that we must beware of the germs of that self-complacent way of looking at ourselves and our own obedience, as if they had anything at all to do with our buying either the favour of G.o.d, or the rewards of the faithful servant.
II. Now, all that I have been saying may sound very harsh. Let us take a second step, and try if we can find out the kernel of grace in the harsh husk.
I hold fast by the one clue that Jesus Christ is here replying to the Apostle"s prayer, "Lord, increase our faith." He had been laying down some very hard regulations for their conduct, and, naturally, when they felt how difficult it would be to come within a thousand miles of what He had been bidding them, they turned to Him with that prayer. It suggests that faith is there, in living operation, or they would not have prayed to Him for its increase. And how does He go about the work of increasing it? In two ways, one of which does not enter into my present subject. First, by showing the disciples the power of faith, in order to stimulate them to greater effort for its possession. He promised that they might say to the fig tree, "Be thou plucked up and planted in the sea," and it should obey them.
The second way was by this context of which I am speaking now. How does it bear upon the Apostles" prayer? What is there in this teaching about the slave and his master, and the slave"s work, and the incompatibility of the notion of reward with the slave"s service, to help to strengthen faith? There is this that this teaching beats down every trace of self-confidence, and if we take it in and live by it, makes us all feel that we stand before G.o.d, whatever have been our deeds of service, with no claims arising from any virtue or righteousness of our own. We come empty-handed.
If the servant who has done all that is commanded has yet to say, "I can ask nothing from Thee, because I have done it, for it was all in the line of my duty," what are we to say, who have done so little that was commanded, and so much that was forbidden?
So, you see, the way to increased faith is not by any magical communication from Christ, as the Apostles thought, but by taking into our hearts, and making operative in our lives, the great truth that in us there is nothing that can make a claim upon G.o.d, and that we must cast ourselves, as deserving nothing, wholly into His merciful hands, and find ourselves held up by His great unmerited love. Get the bitter poison root of self-trust out of you, and then there is some chance of getting the wholesome emotion of absolute reliance on Him into you. Jesus Christ, if I might use a homely metaphor, in these words p.r.i.c.ks the bladder of self-confidence which we are apt to use to keep our heads above water. And it is only when it is p.r.i.c.ked, and we, like the Apostle, feel ourselves beginning to sink, that we fling out a hand to Him, and clutch at His outstretched hand, and cry, "Lord, save me, I perish!" One way to increase our faith is to be rooted and grounded in the a.s.surance that duty is perennial, and that our own righteousness establishes no claim whatever upon G.o.d.
III. Finally, we note the higher view into which, by faith, we come.
I have been saying, with perhaps vain repet.i.tion, that the words of our text and context do not exhaust the whole truth of man"s relation to G.o.d. They do exhaust the truth of the relation of G.o.d to any man that has not faith in his heart, because such a man is a slave in the worst sense, and any obedience that he renders to G.o.d"s will externally is the obedience of a reluctant will, and is hard and harsh, and there is no end _to_ it, and no good _from_ it. But if we accept the position, and recognise our own impotence, and non-desert, and humbly say, "Not by works of righteousness which we have done, but by His mercy He saves us," then we come into a large place. The relation of master and slave does not cover all the ground _then_. "Henceforth, I call you not slaves, but friends," And when the wearied slave comes into the house, the new task is not a new burden, for he is a son as well as a slave; but the work is a delight, and it is a joy to have something more to do for his Father.
If our service is the service of sons, sweetened by love, then there will be abundant thanks from the Father, who is not only our owner, but our lover.
For Christian service--that is to say, service based upon faith and rendered in love--_does_ minister delight to our Father in heaven, and He Himself has called it an "odour of a sweet smell, acceptable unto G.o.d." And if our service on earth has been thus elevated and transformed from the compulsory obedience of a slave to the joyful service of a son, then our reception when at sundown the plough is left in the furrow and we come into the house will be all changed too. "Which of you, having a servant, will say to him, Go and sit down to meat, and will not rather say to him, Make ready whilst I eat and drink?" That is the law for earth, but for heaven it is this, "Blessed are those servants whom the Lord, when He cometh, shall find watching. Verily, I say unto you, that He shall gird Himself, and make them to sit down to meat, and will come forth and serve them." The husk is gone now, I think, and the kernel is left. Loving service is beloved by G.o.d, and rewarded by the ministering, as a servant of servants, to us by Him who is King of kings and Lord of lords.
"Lord, increase our faith," that we may so serve Thee on earth, and so be served by Thee in heaven.
WHERE ARE THE NINE?
"And it came to pa.s.s, as He went to Jerusalem, that He pa.s.sed through the midst of Samaria and Galilee.
12. And as He entered into a certain village, there met Him ten men that were lepers, which stood afar off: 13. And they lifted up their voices, and said, Jesus, Master, have mercy on us. 14. And when He saw them, He said unto them, Go show yourselves unto the priests.
And it came to pa.s.s, that, as they went, they were cleansed. 15. And one of them, when he saw that he was healed, turned back, and with a loud voice glorified G.o.d. 16. And fell down on his face at His feet, giving Him thanks: and he was a Samaritan. 17. And Jesus answering said, Were there not ten cleansed? but where are the nine? 18. There are not found that returned to give glory to G.o.d, save this stranger. 19. And He said unto him, Arise, go thy way, thy faith hath made thee whole."--LUKE xvii. 11-19.
The melancholy group of lepers, met with in one of the villages on the borders of Samaria and Galilee, was made up of Samaritans and Jews, in what proportion we do not know. The common misery drove them together, in spite of racial hatred, as, in a flood, wolves and sheep will huddle close on a bit of high ground. Perhaps they had met in order to appeal to Jesus, thinking to move Him by their aggregated wretchedness; or possibly they were permanently segregated from others, and united in a hideous fellowship.
I. We note the lepers" cry and the Lord"s strange reply. Of course they had to stand afar off, and the distance prescribed by law obliged them to cry aloud, though it must have been an effort, for one symptom of leprosy is a hoa.r.s.e whisper. Sore need can momentarily give strange physical power. Their cry indicates some knowledge. They knew the Lord"s name, and had dim notions of His authority, for He is addressed as Jesus and as Master. They knew that He had power to heal, and they hoped that He had "mercy," which they might win for themselves by entreaty. There was the germ of trust in the cry forced from them by desperate need. But their conceptions of Him, and their consciousness of their own necessities, did not rise above the purely physical region, and He was nothing to them but a healer.
Still, low and rude as their notions were, they did present a point of contact for Christ"s "mercy," which is ever ready to flow into every heart that is lowly, as water will into all low levels. Jesus seems to have gone near to the lepers, for it was "when He saw," not when He heard, them that He spoke. It did not become Him to "cry, nor cause His voice to be heard in the street," nor would He cure as from afar, but He approaches those whom He heals, that they may see His face, and learn by it His compa.s.sion and love. His command recognised and honoured the law, but its main purpose, no doubt, was to test, and thereby to strengthen, the leper"s trust. To set out to the priest while they felt themselves full of leprosy would seem absurd, unless they believed that Jesus could and would heal them.
He gives no promise to heal, but asks for reliance on an implied promise. He has not a syllable of sympathy; His tender compa.s.sion is carefully covered up. He shuts down, as it were, the lantern-slide, and not a ray gets through. But the light was behind the screen all the while. We, too, have sometimes to act on the a.s.sumption that Jesus has granted our desires, even while we are not conscious that it is so. We, too, have sometimes to set out, as it were, for the priests, while we still feel the leprosy.
II. We note the healing granted to obedient faith. The whole ten set off at once. They had got all they wanted from the Lord, and had no more thought about Him. So they turned their backs on Him. How strange it must have been to feel, as they went along, the gradual creeping of soundness into their bones! How much more confidently they must have stepped out, as the glow of returning health a.s.serted itself more and more! The cure is a transcendent, though veiled, manifestation of Christ"s power; for it is wrought at a distance, without even a word, and with no vehicle. It is simply the silent forth-putting of His power. "He spake, and it was done" is much, for only a word which is divine can affect matter. But "He willed, and it was done," is even more.
III. We note the solitary instance of thankfulness. The nine might have said, "We are doing what the Healer bade us do; to go back to Him would be disobedience." But a grateful heart knows that to express its grat.i.tude is the highest duty, and is necessary for its own relief. How like us all it is to hurry away clutching our blessings, and never cast back a thought to the giver! This leper"s voice had returned to Him, and his "loud" acknowledgments were very different from the strained croak of his pet.i.tion for healing. He knew that he had two to thank--G.o.d and Jesus; he did not know that these two were one. His healing has brought him much nearer Jesus than before, and now he can fall at His feet. Thankfulness knits us to Jesus with a blessed bond. Nothing is so sweet to a loving heart as to pour itself out in thanks to Him.
"And he was a Samaritan." That may be Luke"s main reason for telling the story, for it corresponds to the universalistic tendency of his Gospel. But may we not learn the lesson that the common human virtues are often found abundantly in nations and individuals against whom we are apt to be deeply prejudiced? And may we not learn another lesson--that heretics and heathen may often teach orthodox believers lessons, not only of courtesy and grat.i.tude, but of higher things? A heathen is not seldom more sensitive to the beauty of Christ, and more touched by the story of His sacrifice, than we who have heard of Him all our days.
IV. We note Christ"s sad wonder at man"s ingrat.i.tude and joyful recognition of "this stranger"s" thankfulness. A tone of surprise as well as of sadness can be detected in the pathetic double questions.