Frendon was White Noise. The only homes he had ever known were governmental inst.i.tutions and the octangular sleep tubes of Common Ground. He never had a bedroom or a bicycle. He never had a backyard. Frend, as he was known, traveled the underground pathways eating the rice and beans served by the state for every meal every day. By his sixteenth birthday he had been convicted in juvenile courts of more than a dozen violent and felonious crimes. This criminal history kept him from entering the cycles of employment, which were legally a.s.sured by the Thirty-sixth Amendment to the Const.i.tution. Frendon"s const.i.tutional right was blocked by the mandatory publication of his criminal history by electronic news agencies. The legality of this record was backed up by the Supreme Court when it decided that reliance by employers on news articles about criminals, even juvenile criminals, was protected by the Fourth Amendment.
Frendon never knew his parents. He never had a chance to rise to street level. But he was no fool either. In the state prisons and detention centers he learned, via monitor, about the law and its vagaries. He studied tirelessly at Infochurch how to circ.u.mvent legal conundrums and maintain his freedom.
As a matter of fact he had become so well versed in the legal wiles of automatic justice that for some time now he had been in direct contact with Tristan the First, Dominar of the Blue Zone located on Dr. Kismet"s private island nation, Home. Together they had come up with a plan to use in one of the first fully automated cases.
"The Court has reached a decision," The Court said. "You are not qualified."
"I still wish to represent my own case," Frendon said.
"You are not qualified," The Court repeated. Frendon thought he detected a slight arrogance in the tone of his judge and jury. The latent personality of a dozen dying judges superimposed on an almost infinite array of prismatic memory.
"I would be if you allowed it."
The wait this time was even longer. Officer Brill left the room to communicate with the Outer Guard. The Outer Guard was the warden of the Sacramento jail, which was annexed to the Sac"m Justice System. Most trials lasted between ten and twenty minutes since the automated system had been installed--politicians claimed that justice had become an objective reality for the first time in the history of courts.
"Objective," Fayez Akwande had said at the Sixth Radical Congress"s annual address, "for the poor. The rich can still hire a flesh and blood lawyer, and a breathing attorney will ask for a living judge; a court appointed robot defender will never do such a thing."
Every once in a while one of the Prime Judging Units got stuck in a justice loop. This would have to run its course. The unit itself was programmed to interrupt after a certain number of repet.i.tions. Officer Brill went to report that the rest of the prisoners slated to appear before Prime Nine should be distributed among the other eleven judges. This hardly mattered because of the speed of the system. There was never any backlog in Sacramento. Every other court system in the country was waiting to install its own automatic justice system.
One hundred thirty-seven minutes and fifteen seconds later Prime Nine came to life.
"There is not enough information on which to base our decision," P-nine said. "How would you present your case?"
"As any man standing before a court of his peers," Frendon said. "I will state my circ.u.mstances and allow the jury to measure their worth."
We must see if the system is sophisticated enough to value the political nature of the law, Tristan the First, Dominar of the Blue Zone, had said to Frendon as he sat in the pews of South Boston Infochurch eighteen months before on a cold February day. These mechanical systems may be a threat to the basic freedom of corporations and that is not in the best interest of the state.
Frendon didn"t care about politics or Infochurch or even Dr. Kismet, the closest thing to G.o.d on Earth. Congress and the House of Corporate Advisors were just so many fools in his opinion--but fools who had their uses.
"There are no special circ.u.mstances," P-nine said after a brief delay. "The witnesses and physical evidence and your own confession along with your psychological profile leave a less than oh point oh oh seven three one possibility of circ.u.mstances that would alter your sentence."
"But not no possibility," Frendon said, still following the Dominar"s script.
"It is left up to the discretion of the court to decide what is probable in hearing a plaintiff"s argument."
"You mean that if AttPrime Five decided that an argument had such a low chance to work it could decide not to present it?" Frendon asked.
A red light came on at the upper left corner of Prime Nine"s gray casing. A bell somewhere chimed.
The door behind Frendon came open. He could hear Otis Brill"s squeaky rubber soles approaching.
"What are you doing, Blythe?"
"Fighting for your life, Otie."
"What?"
"Can"t you see, man? Once they automate justice and wire it up there won"t be any more freedom at all. They"ll have monitors and listening devices everywhere. One day you"ll be put on trial while sleepin" in your bed. You"ll wake up in a jail cell with an explanation of your guilt and your sentence pinned to your chest."
"You"re crazy. This is the first time that a court"s been caught up with its cases in over fifty years. And lotsa guys are found innocent. All Prime Nine does is look at the facts. He don"t care about race or s.e.x or if you"re rich or poor--"
"If I was rich I"d never see an automatic judge."
"That"s beside the point. This judge will give you a better break than any flesh-and-blood bozo who looks at you and smells Common Ground."
"You have no vision, Otis," Frendon said. "No senses to warn you of doom."
"That"s "cause I ain"t facin" no death sentence," the small guard replied. ""Cause you know that six seconds after the guilty verdict is read RMD 27 here will fry your brain with a chemical dose. Murder"s a capital crime and there"s only one sentence."
Frendon felt as if a bucket of ice had been dumped on his head. He shivered uncontrollably and RMD 27 jumped to life, perceiving the fear and possible violence brewing in its prisoner"s heart. But Frendon took deep breaths (another strategy he"d planned with the Dominar), and slowly the wetware chair settled back to an electronic doze.
"You have been deemed capable of presenting your case to the court," P-nine said.
"You will forgive me if I don"t thank you," Frendon said, this time quoting from a popular film which was too new for any of the judge"s many minds to have seen.
"What is your evidence?"
"First I would like to explain my character, The Court."
"We do not see the salience in such a presentation."
"My argument is based upon actions taken by myself and subsequent reactions taken by the legal authorities which were the cause of the so-called crime. In order to understand these reactions The Court must first understand the motivations which incited them. Therefore The Court must have an understanding of me which is not genetically based, and that can only be gleaned through personal narrative."
Frendon worried that Prime Nine would have some sort of language matrix that would tell it that the speech he had just made would never compose itself in his mind. Maybe this program could even deduce that Tristan the First was the scriptor of these words. A minute pa.s.sed. Ten seconds more.
"Narrative evidence is the weakest form of legal defense," the great gray console said. "But we will hear your evidence in whatever form you feel you must present it."
For a moment Frendon remembered a woman"s laugh. He had heard it long ago when he was in the orphan unit of New York Common Ground. He was sure that the laugh had not been his biological mother, but still he a.s.sociated it with the mother in his heart. She always laughed like that when he got away with something that might have gone wrong.
2.
"I was born White Noise, a Backgrounder, twenty-seven years ago in one of the fieftowns of greater New York," said Frendon Blythe. Another Gla.s.sone tile had slid away and a tall witness dock had risen in its place. The mahogany rostrum was elegant, with curving banisters held up by delicate slats of wood. The accused ascended the five stairs and gripped the railing. He spoke in pa.s.sionate tones. "I never knew my parents and I didn"t receive any kind of proper training. In the Common Ground below the city streets I learned everything I know from monitors and video hookups when I could get to them. Later, when I had reached the age of sixteen and was allowed to visit aboveground, I became a member of Infochurch, where I was allowed to worship the knowledge of the Dominar of the Blue Zone. There I was educated in the ways of language and the cosmic mysteries. My levels in the nine forms of intelligence were tested and I was allowed to protest and proclaim. But even the resources of the splendid Dr. Kismet are finite; I was only allowed to plug into their vids two days in a week, three hours at a time.
"Have you ever experienced what it is like to be White Noise, The Court?"
"Among the core wetware membership that comprises our main logic matrix none was ever subjected to Common Ground," Prime Nine replied. "Though some of our jurors have spent a few cycles off the labor rosters."
"Not a cycle or two, Judge," Frendon said angrily. "White Noise men and women are barred from ever working again. And the children of White Noise, as I am, might never know a day of employment in their lives."
"What is your point?"
"That you and your fictional elements have no notion of the lives led underground."
"We need not be aware of Common Ground or its psyche. We are judges of the law and the law applies equally to all."
"How can that be? If I had money I could hire my own counsel and that living, breathing lawyer could demand a flesh-and-blood judge."
"We are superior to flesh and blood. We are of many bodies, with a superior retrieval system and greater overall mind."
"Maybe a real man would have compa.s.sion for my history."
"Because you represent yourself you can demand a human magistrate. Is that your wish?"
"No, The Court. I have begun my trial and I will finish it here, with you."
"Then present your evidence."
Frendon took a deep breath and looked around the big empty room as if he were preparing to address a great audience. The only ones there were AttPrime Five, her lovely face frozen on the blue screen, and Otis Brill, who was seated in half-lotus position on the floor because there were no chairs except for RMD 27, and no one would sit in a prisoner"s chair if they didn"t have to.
"Do you know what is the biggest problem with a life of White Noise, The Court?"
"Is this question evidence?"
"Yes it is, Your Honor. It is evidence. The kind of evidence that your AttPrime software would never even suspect, the kind of evidence that all the thousands of minds that comprise your perfect logic would never know. The biggest problem with being White Noise is perpetual and unremitting boredom. Day in and day out you sit hunched over in your octagon tube or against the wall in the halls that always smell of urine and mold. Everybody around you always chattering or fighting or just sitting, waiting for a monthly shot at the vid unit or a pa.s.s to go upside to see how the cyclers survive. There"s no books made from paper because trees have more rights than we do. There"s no movies because that costs money and we aren"t real so there"s no credits to our names. Singing is illegal, who the h.e.l.l knows why? Breaking a wall down so you can share a bed with a friend is against the law too. The food is the same day after day and there"s no way out once you"ve been found wanting. There"s no way upside unless you die.
"The only way you can ever get anything is if you sell your number to some cycler who needs someone to cop to a crime. You can sell your confession for a general credit number. For three months in a cell or maybe a year of quarantine you can eat ice cream with your girlfriend or take a walk in the park."
"Are you confessing to other crimes, Frendon Blythe?" Prime Nine asked.
"Just painting a picture, The Court, of what life is like underground."
"We seek extenuating evidence not irrelevant ill.u.s.tration."
Somebody in that box was a poet, Frendon thought.
"So you see that life is pretty dull down there. That"s why there are so many suicides."
Frendon heard a sound. He turned and saw that Otis Brill had slumped over on his side and gone to sleep on the shiny tiles. He was snoring. A flutter above his head reminded him of the birds who would never be free.
Defy the logic matrix, Tristan the Dominar had said. Break down the problem into human segments that don"t add up. The church had offered Frendon unlimited access once they realized he had a logical mind. The Dominar didn"t believe in the justice system and he wanted to thwart it, Frendon was not sure why. It could have been anything--politics, corporate intrigue, or merely the ego of the man who pretended he was G.o.d"s friend. More than once Frendon had wondered if he had been talking to the real Dominar or just one of the many abbots who supervised the tens of millions of monitors running twenty-four hours a day in Infochurch pews around the world. Maybe, Frendon thought, he was just one soldier in a vast army of jobless citizens thrown at the justice system to break it all down.
But why?
He didn"t know. He didn"t care. All Frendon wanted was to not be bored, to not sit a thousand feet underground and wait for sleep or wake to gray. That"s why he"d agreed to this crazy plan of the man who called himself Dominar. That"s why he"d killed and a.s.saulted and allowed himself to be captured. Anything but what he was destined for.
Frendon looked around and saw that all the machinery was at a halt. RMD 27, AttPrime, and even Prime Nine were all still; only that blinking red light and small chiming bell, along with Otis Brill"s snores, broke the calm of the large room. Frendon realized that as long as he stood still and pretended to be thinking, the computers would leave him in peace. But he didn"t want peace. He wanted bright colors and noise, good food and s.e.x with any woman, man, or dog that wouldn"t bite him. In the absence of anything else Frendon would take pain. And in the absence of pain he would even accept death.
"I was so bored," he said, "that I started to wonder about politics. I wondered if we could make some kind of action that would close the Common Ground down. I started talking about it, to my friends at first and then to anyone who would listen. "Come join the revolution," I said to them. "Let"s burn this f.u.c.ker down."
"It wasn"t against the law. Freedom of speech has not yet been outlawed, even though the House of Corporate Advisors has drafted a bill for Congress that would put Common Ground outside the range of the Const.i.tution. But even though I was in my rights the police started following me. They checked my papers every time I was upside. They"d come down to my tube and pull me out of bed. Once they even stripped me naked and then arrested me for indecent exposure.
"I told them that I would kill them if it wasn"t against the law."
"You threatened their lives?"
"Only hypothetically. I said if it wasn"t against the law."
"But it could have been perceived as a threat."
"You have the interview in your guts," Frendon said. "Let"s take a look at it and you"ll see for yourself."
Cowled Justice disappeared from Prime Nine"s screen. It was replaced by the bloodied image of Frendon being interviewed by the police in the presence of a small wetware court reporter.
"I said," Frendon"s image said. "That I would kill you if it was legal. I would. I would. I swear I would. But it"s not legal so I can"t. Wouldn"t you like to get at me if you could?"
"You"re skating near the edge, boy," Officer Terrance Bernard, a six foot six red-nosed policeman, said.
"Yeah," his partner, Officer Omar LaTey, put in. "If anyone around here gets killed it will be you."
They were both wearing the gray uniforms of the Social Police. The Social Police were responsible for the protection and security of Common Ground"s facilities and its residents.
The image faded and Cowled Justice returned.
"They didn"t say that they couldn"t kill me. They said that I would be killed."
For fourteen seconds Prime Nine cogitated.
"Is this the extent of your evidence?"
"No. I would like to inquire about the street vids that are situated on Tenth Street and Cutter. Are there images of the supposed crime?"
"Yes. Partial coverage was recorded."
Again the image of the judge disappeared, this time replaced by a shabby street lined with brick buildings that were fairly nondescript. They seemed to be tall buildings, their roofs being higher than the range of the police camera lens showed. Close to the camera was the back of a head. Frendon knew that this head was his. In the distance two men in gray uniforms rushed forward. One had a hand weapon drawn.
"Stop!" Terrance Bernard commanded. The tiny microphone recorded the word perfectly.
The head jerked down below the camera"s range. The other policeman drew his weapon. The sound of shots was followed by Omar LaTey grabbing his leg and falling. Then Bernard"s weapon fired and immediately the image went blank. More shots were recorded and then a loud, frightening scream.
Frendon"s heart raced while witnessing the well-planned shoot-out on Cutter Avenue. He felt again the thrill of fear and excitement. He might have been killed or wounded. It was like one of those rare movies they showed for free in Common Commons on Christmas, one of those westerns starring John Wayne or Dean Martin where you killed and then rode off with your girl, your best friend, and your horse.
"Officer LaTey"s testimony is that you threatened them with your gun."
"Only after I saw them coming."
"Officer LaTey did not lie."
"Neither did I," Frendon said. It was all working perfectly, just as the Dominar had said.
"This testimony is corroborated by the evidence of the video and your confession."