Hitler returned to his mundane life as a small-time artist; but not for long. The storm-clouds were gathering over Europe. On Sunday, 28 June 1914, the sensational news broke of the a.s.sa.s.sination in Sarajevo of the heir to the Austrian throne, Archduke Franz Ferdinand, and his wife. Germany, like other countries in Europe, became gripped by war fever. By the beginning of August, the Continent was at war.
II.
For Hitler, the war was a G.o.dsend. Since his failure in the Art Academy in 1907, he had vegetated, resigned to the fact that he would not become a great artist, now cherishing a pipe-dream that he would somehow become a notable architect though with no plans for or realistic hope of fulfilling this ambition. Seven years after that failure, the "n.o.body of Vienna", now in Munich, remained a drop-out and nonent.i.ty, futilely angry at a world which had rejected him. He was still without any career prospects, without qualifications or any expectation of gaining them, without any capacity for forging close and lasting friendships, and without real hope of coming to terms with himself or with a society he despised for his own failure. The war offered him his way out. At the age of twenty-five, it gave him for the first time in his life a cause, a commitment, comradeship, an external discipline, a sort of regular employment, a sense of well-being, and more than that a sense of belonging. His regiment became home for him. When he was wounded in 1916 his first words to his superior officer were: "It"s not so bad, Herr Oberleutnant, eh? I can stay with you, stay with the regiment." Later in the war, the prospect of leaving the regiment may well have influenced his wish not to be considered for promotion. And at the end of the war, he had good practical reasons for staying in the army as long as possible: the army had by then been his "career" for four years, and he had no other job to go back to or look forward to. The war and its aftermath made Hitler. After Vienna, it was the second formative period in decisively shaping his personality.
At the beginning of August 1914, Hitler was among the tens of thousands in Munich in the thrall of emotional delirium, pa.s.sionately enthused by the prospect of war. As for so many others, his elation would later turn to deep embitterment. With Hitler, the emotional pendulum set moving by the onset of war swung more violently than for most. "Overpowered by stormy enthusiasm," he wrote, "I fell down on my knees and thanked Heaven from an overflowing heart for granting me the good fortune of being permitted to live at this time." That on this occasion his words were true cannot be doubted. Years later, noticing a photograph taken by Heinrich Hoffmann (who was to become his court photographer) of the huge patriotic demonstration in front of the Feldherrnhalle on Munich"s Odeonsplatz on 2 August 1914, the day after the German declaration of war on Russia, Hitler pointed out that he had been among the emotional crowd that day, carried away with nationalist fervour, hoa.r.s.e with singing "Die Wacht am Rhein" and "Deutschland, Deutschland uber alles". Hoffmann immediately set to work on enlargements, and discovered the face of the twenty-five-year-old Hitler in the centre of the photograph, gripped and enraptured by the war hysteria. The subsequent ma.s.s reproduction of the photograph helped contribute to the establishment of the Fuhrer myth and to Hoffmann"s immense profits.
It was doubtless under the impact of the same elation swaying tens of thousands of young men in Munich and many other cities in Europe during those days to rush to join up that, according to his own account, on 3 August, immediately following the Feldherrnhalle demonstration, Hitler submitted a personal pet.i.tion to King Ludwig III of Bavaria to serve as an Austrian in the Bavarian army. The granting of his request by the cabinet office, he went on, arrived, to his unbounded joy, the very next day. Though this version has been accepted in most accounts, it is scarcely credible. In the confusion of those days, it would have required truly remarkable bureaucratic efficiency for Hitler"s request to have been approved overnight. In any case, not the cabinet office but the war ministry was alone empowered to accept foreigners (including Austrians) as volunteers. In reality, Hitler owed his service in the Bavarian army not to bureaucratic efficiency, but to bureaucratic oversight. Detailed inquiries carried out by the Bavarian authorities in 1924 were unable to clarify precisely how, instead of being returned to Austria in August 1914 as should have happened, he came to serve in the Bavarian army. It was presumed that he was among the flood of volunteers who rushed to their nearest place of recruitment in the first days of August, leading, the report added, to not unnatural inconsistencies and breaches of the strict letter of the law. "In all probability," commented the report, "the question of Hitler"s nationality was never even raised." Hitler, it was concluded, almost certainly entered the Bavarian army by error.
Probably, as. .h.i.tler wrote in a brief autobiographical sketch in 1921, he volunteered on 5 August 1914 for service in the First Bavarian Infantry Regiment. Like many others in these first chaotic days, he was initially sent away again since there was no immediate use for him. On 16 August he was summoned to report at Recruiting Depot VI in Munich for kitting out by the Second Reserve Battalion of the Second Infantry Regiment. By the beginning of September he had been a.s.signed to the newly formed Bavarian Reserve Infantry Regiment 16 (known from the name of its first commander as the "List Regiment"), largely comprising raw recruits. After a few weeks of hurried training, they were ready for the front. In the early hours of 21 October, the troop train carrying Hitler left for the battlefields of Flanders.
On 29 October, within six days of arriving in Lille, Hitler"s battalion had its baptism of fire on the Menin Road near Ypres. In letters from the front to Joseph Popp and to a Munich acquaintance, Ernst Hepp, Hitler wrote that after four days of fighting, the List Regiment"s fighting force had been reduced from 3,600 to 611 men. The initial losses were indeed a staggering 70 per cent. Hitler"s initial idealism, he said later, gave way on seeing the thousands killed and injured, to the realization "that life is a constant horrible struggle". From now on, death was a daily companion. It immunized him completely against any sensitivity to human suffering. Even more than in the Viennese doss-house, he closed his eyes to sorrow and pity. Struggle, survival, victory: these were all that counted.
On 3 November 1914 (with effect from 1 November), Hitler was promoted to corporal. It was his last promotion of the war, though he could certainly have been expected to advance further, as least as far as non-commissioned officer (Unteroffizier). Later in the war, he was in fact nominated for promotion by Max Amann, then a staff sergeant, subsequently Hitler"s press baron, and the regimental staff considered making him Unteroffizier Unteroffizier. Fritz Wiedemann, the regimental adjutant who in the 1930s became for a time one of the Fuhrer"s adjutants, testified after the end of the Third Reich that Hitler"s superiors had thought him lacking in leadership qualities. However, both Amann and Wiedemann made clear that Hitler, probably because he would have been then transferred from the regimental staff, actually refused to be considered for promotion.
Hitler had been a.s.signed on 9 November to the regimental staff as an orderly one of a group of eight to ten dispatch runners, whose task was to carry orders, on foot or sometimes by bicycle, from the regimental command post to the battalion and company leaders at the front, three kilometres away. Strikingly, in his Mein Kampf Mein Kampf account, Hitler omitted to mention that he was a dispatch runner, implying that he actually spent the war in the trenches. But the attempts of his political enemies in the early 1930s to belittle the dangers involved in the duties of the dispatch runner and decry Hitler"s war service, accusing him of shirking and cowardice, were misplaced. When, as was not uncommon, the front was relatively quiet, there were certainly times when the dispatch runners could laze around at staff headquarters, where conditions were greatly better than in the trenches. It was in such conditions at regimental headquarters in Fournes en Weppes, near Fromelles in northern France, where Hitler spent nearly half of his wartime service, that he could find the time to paint pictures and read (if his own account can be believed) the works of Schopenhauer that he claimed he carried around with him. Even so, the dangers faced by the dispatch runners during battles, carrying messages to the front through the firing line, were real enough. The losses among dispatch runners were relatively high. If at all possible, two runners would be sent with a message to ensure that it would get through if one happened to be killed. Three of the eight runners attached to the regimental staff were killed and another one wounded in a confrontation with French troops on 15 November. Hitler himself not for the only time in his life had luck on his side two days later when a French sh.e.l.l exploded in the regimental forward command post minutes after he had gone out, leaving almost the entire staff there dead or wounded. Among the seriously wounded was the regimental commander Oberstleutnant Philipp Engelhardt, who had been about to propose Hitler for the Iron Cross for his part, a.s.sisted by a colleague, in protecting the commander"s life under fire a few days earlier. On 2 December, Hitler was finally presented with the Iron Cross, Second Cla.s.s, one of four dispatch runners among the sixty men from his regiment to receive the honour. It was, he said, "the happiest day of my life". account, Hitler omitted to mention that he was a dispatch runner, implying that he actually spent the war in the trenches. But the attempts of his political enemies in the early 1930s to belittle the dangers involved in the duties of the dispatch runner and decry Hitler"s war service, accusing him of shirking and cowardice, were misplaced. When, as was not uncommon, the front was relatively quiet, there were certainly times when the dispatch runners could laze around at staff headquarters, where conditions were greatly better than in the trenches. It was in such conditions at regimental headquarters in Fournes en Weppes, near Fromelles in northern France, where Hitler spent nearly half of his wartime service, that he could find the time to paint pictures and read (if his own account can be believed) the works of Schopenhauer that he claimed he carried around with him. Even so, the dangers faced by the dispatch runners during battles, carrying messages to the front through the firing line, were real enough. The losses among dispatch runners were relatively high. If at all possible, two runners would be sent with a message to ensure that it would get through if one happened to be killed. Three of the eight runners attached to the regimental staff were killed and another one wounded in a confrontation with French troops on 15 November. Hitler himself not for the only time in his life had luck on his side two days later when a French sh.e.l.l exploded in the regimental forward command post minutes after he had gone out, leaving almost the entire staff there dead or wounded. Among the seriously wounded was the regimental commander Oberstleutnant Philipp Engelhardt, who had been about to propose Hitler for the Iron Cross for his part, a.s.sisted by a colleague, in protecting the commander"s life under fire a few days earlier. On 2 December, Hitler was finally presented with the Iron Cross, Second Cla.s.s, one of four dispatch runners among the sixty men from his regiment to receive the honour. It was, he said, "the happiest day of my life".
From all indications, Hitler was a committed, rather than simply conscientious and dutiful, soldier, and did not lack physical courage. His superiors held him in high regard. His immediate comrades, mainly the group of dispatch runners, respected him and, it seems, even quite liked him, though he could also plainly irritate as well as puzzle them. His lack of a sense of fun made him an easy target for good-natured ribbing. "What about looking around for a Mamsell?" suggested a telephonist one day. "I"d die of shame looking for s.e.x with a French girl," interjected Hitler, to a burst of laughter from the others. "Look at the monk," one said. Hitler"s retort was: "Have you no German sense of honour left at all?" Though his quirkiness singled him out from the rest of his group, Hitler"s relations with his immediate comrades were generally good. Most of them later became members of the NSDAP, and, when, as usually happened, they reminded Reich Chancellor Hitler of the time that they had been his comrades in arms, he made sure they were catered for with cash donations and positions as minor functionaries. For all that they got on well with him, they thought "Adi", as they called him, was distinctly odd. They referred to him as "the artist" and were struck by the fact that he received no mail or parcels (even at Christmas) after about mid-1915, never spoke of family or friends, neither smoked nor drank, showed no interest in visits to brothels, and used to sit for hours in a corner of the dug-out, brooding or reading. Photographs of him during the war show a thin, gaunt face dominated by a thick, dark, bushy moustache. He was usually on the edge of his group, expressionless where others were smiling. One of his closest comrades, Balthasar Brandmayer, a stonemason from Bruckmuhl in the Bad Aibling district of Upper Bavaria, later described his first impressions of Hitler at the end of May 1915: almost skeletal in appearance, dark eyes hooded in a sallow complexion, untrimmed moustache, sitting in a corner buried in a newspaper, occasionally taking a sip of tea, seldom joining in the banter of the group. He seemed an oddity, shaking his head disapprovingly at silly, light-hearted remarks, not even joining in the usual soldiers" moans, gripes, and jibes. "Haven"t you ever loved a girl?" Brandmayer asked Hitler. "Look, Brandmoiri," was the straight-faced reply, "I"ve never had time for anything like that, and I"ll never get round to it." His only real affection seems to have been for his dog, Foxl, a white terrier that had strayed across from enemy lines. Hitler taught it tricks, revelling in how attached it was to him and how glad it was to see him when he returned from duty. He was distraught late in the war when his unit had to move on and Foxl could not be found. "The swine who took him from me doesn"t know what he did to me," was his comment many years later. He felt as strongly about none of the thousands of humans he saw slaughtered about him.
About the war itself, Hitler was utterly fanatical. No humanitarian feelings could be allowed to interfere with the ruthless prosecution of German interests. He vehemently disapproved of the spontaneous gestures of friendship at Christmas 1914, when German and British troops met in no man"s land, shaking hands and singing carols together. "There should be no question of something like that during war," he protested. His comrades knew that they could always provoke Hitler with defeatist comments, real or contrived. All they had to do was to claim the war would be lost and Hitler would go off at the deep end. "For us the war can"t be lost" were invariably his last words. The lengthy letter he sent on 5 February 1915 to his Munich acquaintance, a.s.sessor Ernst Hepp, concluded with an insight into his view of the war redolent of the prejudices that had been consuming him since his Vienna days: Each of us has only one wish, that it may soon come to the final reckoning with the gang, to the showdown, cost what it will, and that those of us who have the fortune to see their homeland again will find it purer and cleansed of alien influence (Fremdlanderei), that through the sacrifices and suffering that so many hundred thousand of us make daily, that through the stream of blood that flows here day for day against an international world of enemies, not only will Germany"s external enemies be smashed, but that our inner internationalism will also be broken. That would be worth more to me than all territorial gains.
This was how he saw the colossal slaughter; not in terms of human suffering, but as worthwhile for the making of a better, racially cleansed, Germany. Hitler evidently carried such deep-seated sentiments throughout the war. But this political outburst, tagged on to a long description of military events and wartime conditions, was unusual. He appears to have spoken little to his comrades on political matters. Perhaps the fact that his comrades thought him peculiar hindered him from giving voice to his strong opinions. He appears, too, to have scarcely mentioned the Jews. Several former comrades claimed after 1945 that Hitler had at most made a few off-hand though commonplace comments about the Jews in those years, but that they had no inkling then of the unbounded hatred that was so visible after 1918. Balthasar Brandmayer recalled on the other hand in his reminiscences, first published in 1932, that during the war he had "often not understood Adolf Hitler when he called the Jew the wire-puller behind all misfortune". According to Brandmayer, Hitler became more politically involved in the latter years of the war and made no secret of his feelings on what he saw as the Social Democrat instigators of growing unrest in Germany. Such comments, like all sources that postdate Hitler"s rise to prominence and, as in this case, glorify the prescience of the future leader, have to be treated with caution. But it is difficult to dismiss them out of hand. It indeed does seem very likely, as his own account in Mein Kampf Mein Kampf claims, that Hitler"s political prejudices sharpened in the latter part of the war, during and after his first period of leave in Germany in 1916. claims, that Hitler"s political prejudices sharpened in the latter part of the war, during and after his first period of leave in Germany in 1916.
Between March 1915 and September 1916, the List Regiment fought in the trenches near Fromelles, defending a two-kilometre stretch of the stalemated front. Heavy battles with the British were fought in May 1915 and July 1916, but in one and a half years, the front barely moved a few metres. On 27 September 1916, two months after heavy fighting in the second battle of Fromelles, when a British offensive was staved off with difficulty, the regiment moved southwards and by 2 October was engaged on the Somme. Within days, Hitler was wounded in the left thigh when a sh.e.l.l exploded in the dispatch runners" dug-out, killing and wounding several of them. After treatment in a field hospital, he spent almost two months, from 9 October until 1 December 1916, in the Red Cross hospital at Beelitz, near Berlin. He had not been in Germany for two years. He soon noticed how different the mood was from the heady days of August 1914. He was appalled to hear men in the hospital bragging about their malingering or how they had managed to inflict minor injuries on themselves to make sure they could escape from the front. He encountered much the same low morale and widespread discontent in Berlin during the period of his recuperation. It was his first time in the city, and allowed him to pay a visit to the Nationalgalerie. But Munich shocked him most of all. He scarcely recognized the city: "Anger, discontent, cursing, wherever you went!" Morale was poor; people were dispirited; conditions were miserable; and, as was traditional in Bavaria, the blame was placed on the Prussians. Hitler himself, according to his own account written about eight years later, saw in all this only the work of the Jews. He was struck too, so he said, by the number of Jews in clerical positions "nearly every clerk was a Jew and nearly every Jew was a clerk" compared with how few of them were serving at the front. (In fact, this was a base calumny: there was as good as no difference between the proportion of Jews and non-Jews in the German army, relative to their numbers in the total population, and many Jews served some in the List Regiment with great distinction.) There is no reason to presume, as has sometimes been the case, that this account of his anti-Jewish feelings in 1916 was a backwards projection of feelings that in reality only existed from 191819 onwards. Though, as we have noted, Hitler did not stand out for his antisemitism in the recollections of some of his former wartime comrades, two of them did refer to his negative comments about the Jews. And Hitler would have been voicing sentiments that were increasingly to be heard in the streets of Munich as anti-Jewish prejudice became more widespread and more ferocious in the second half of the war.
Hitler wanted to get back to the front as soon as possible, and above all to rejoin his old regiment. He eventually returned to it on 5 March 1917 in its new position a few miles to the north of Vimy. In the summer it was back to the same ground near Ypres that the regiment had fought over almost three years earlier, to counter the major Flanders offensive launched by the British in mid-July 1917. Battered by the heavy fighting, the regiment was relieved at the beginning of August and transported to Alsace. At the end of September, Hitler took normal leave for the first time. He had no wish to go back to Munich, which had dispirited him so much, and went to Berlin instead, to stay with the parents of one of his comrades. His postcards to friends in the regiment spoke of how much he enjoyed his eighteen-day leave, and how thrilled he was by Berlin and its museums. In mid-October, he returned to his regiment, which had just moved from Alsace to Champagne. Bitter fighting in April 1918 brought huge losses, and during the last two weeks of July the regiment was involved in the second battle of the Marne. It was the last major German offensive of the war. By early August, when it collapsed in the face of a tenacious Allied counter-offensive, German losses in the previous four months of savage combat had amounted to around 800,000 men. The failure of the offensive marked the point where, with reserves depleted and morale plummeting, Germany"s military leadership was compelled to recognize that the war was lost.
On 4 August 1918, Hitler received the Iron Cross, First Cla.s.s a rare achievement for a corporal from the regimental commander, Major von Tubeuf. By a stroke of irony, he had a Jewish officer, Leutnant Hugo Gutmann, to thank for the nomination. The story was later to be found in all school books that the Fuhrer had received the EK I for single-handedly capturing fifteen French soldiers. The truth, as usual, was somewhat more prosaic. From the available evidence, including the recommendation of the List Regiment"s Deputy Commander Freiherr von G.o.din on 31 July 1918, the award was made as it was also to a fellow dispatch runner for bravery shown in delivering an important dispatch, following a breakdown in telephone communications, from command headquarters to the front through heavy fire. Gutmann, from what he subsequently said, had promised both dispatch runners the EK I if they succeeded in delivering the message. But since the action was, though certainly courageous, not strikingly exceptional, it was only after several weeks of his belabouring the divisional commander that permission for the award was granted.
By mid-August 1918, the List Regiment had moved to Cambrai to help combat a British offensive near Bapaume, and a month later was back in action once more in the vicinity of Wytschaete and Messines, where Hitler had received his EK II almost four years earlier. This time Hitler was away from the battlefields. In late August he had been sent for a week to Nuremberg for telephone communications training, and on 10 September he began his second period of eighteen days" leave, again in Berlin. Immediately on his return, at the end of September, his unit was put under pressure from British a.s.saults near Comines. Gas was now in extensive use in offensives, and protection against it was minimal and primitive. The List Regiment, like others, suffered badly. On the night of 1314 October, Hitler himself fell victim to mustard gas on the heights south of Wervick, part of the southern front near Ypres. He and several comrades, retreating from their dug-out during a gas attack, were partially blinded by the gas and found their way to safety only by clinging on to each other and following a comrade who was slightly less badly afflicted. After initial treatment in Flanders, Hitler was transported on 21 October 1918 to the military hospital in Pasewalk, near Stettin, in Pomerania.
The war was over for him. And, little though he knew it, the Army High Command was already manoeuvring to extricate itself from blame for a war it accepted was lost and a peace which would soon have to be negotiated. It was in Pasewalk, recovering from his temporary blindness, that Hitler was to learn the shattering news of defeat and revolution what he called "the greatest villainy of the century".
III.
In reality, of course, there had been no treachery, no stab-in-the-back. This was pure invention of the Right, a legend the n.a.z.is would use as a central element of their propaganda armoury. Unrest at home was a consequence, not a cause, of military failure. Germany had been militarily defeated and was close to the end of its tether though nothing had prepared people for capitulation. In fact, triumphalist propaganda was still coming from the High Command in late October 1918. The army was by then exhausted, and in the previous four months had suffered heavier losses than at any time during the war. Desertions and "shirking" deliberately ducking duty (estimated at close on a million men in the last months of the war) rose dramatically. At home, the mood was one of mounting protest embittered, angry, and increasingly rebellious. The revolution was not fabricated by Bolshevik sympathizers and unpatriotic troublemakers, but grew out of the profound disillusionment and rising unrest which had set in even as early as 1915 and from 1916 onwards had flowed into what finally became a torrent of disaffection. The society which had seemingly entered the war in total patriotic unity ended it completely riven and traumatized by the experience.
Amid the social division, there were certain common targets of aggression. War profiteering a theme on which Hitler was able to play so effectively in the Munich beerhalls in 1920 rankled deeply. Closely related was the bitter resentment at those running the black market. Petty officialdom, with its unremitting and intensified bureaucratic intervention into every sphere of daily life, was a further target. But the fury did not confine itself to the interference and incompetence of petty bureaucrats. These were merely the face of a state whose authority was crumbling visibly, a state in terminal disarray and disintegration.
Not least, in the search for scapegoats, Jews increasingly became the focus of intensified hatred and aggression from the middle of the war onwards. The sentiments had all been heard before. What was new was the extent to which radical antisemitism was now being propagated, and the degree to which it was evidently falling on fertile ground. Heinrich Cla, the leader of the arch-nationalist Pan-Germans, could report in October 1917 that antisemitism had "already reached enormous proportions" and that "the struggle for survival was now beginning for the Jews". Events in Russia in 1917 further stirred the pot of simmering hatred, adding the vital ingredient to become thereafter the keystone of antisemitic agitation of the Jews portrayed as running secret international organizations directed at fomenting world revolution. As it was realized that the war was lost, antisemitic hysteria, whipped up by the Pan-Germanists, reached fever pitch. Cla used the notorious words of Heinrich von Kleist, aimed at the French in 1813, when a "Jewish Committee" with the purpose of "exploiting the situation to sound the clarion call against Judaism and to use the Jews as lightning rods for all injustices" was set up by the Pan-Germans in September 1918: "Kill them; the world court is not asking you for your reasons!"
IV.
The atmosphere of disintegration and collapsing morale, the climate of political and ideological radicalization, in the last two war years could not but make the deepest impression on a Hitler who had welcomed the war so rapturously, had supported German aims so fanatically, and had from the outset condemned all defeatist suggestions so vehemently. He was repelled by many att.i.tudes he encountered at the front. But, as we have seen, it was during the three periods, amounting in total to over three months, that he spent in Germany either on leave or recovering from injury in the last two war years that he experienced a level of disaffection at the running of the war which was new and deeply appalling to him. He had been shocked at the atmosphere in Berlin and, even more so, Munich in 1916. As the war dragged on, he became incensed by the talk of revolution, and incandescent at news of the munitions strike in favour of early peace without annexations which had spread briefly at the end of January 1918 from Berlin to other major industrial cities (though with little actual effect on munitions supplies).
The last two years of the war, between his convalescence in Beelitz in October 1916 and his hospitalization in Pasewalk in October 1918, can probably be seen as a vital staging-post in Hitler"s ideological development. The prejudices and phobias carried over from the Vienna years were now plainly evident in his embittered rage about the collapse of the war effort the first cause in his life to which he had totally bound himself, the summation of all that he had believed in. But they had not yet been fully rationalized into the component parts of a political ideology. That would only emerge fully during Hitler"s own "political training" in the Reichswehr in the course of 1919.
What part the hospitalization in Pasewalk played in the shaping of Hitler"s ideology, what significance it had for the shaping of the future party leader and dictator, has been much disputed and, in truth, is not easy to evaluate. In Hitler"s own account it has a pivotal place. Recovering from his temporary blindness, but unable to read newspapers, so he wrote, Hitler heard rumours of pending revolution but did not fully comprehend them. The arrival of some mutineering sailors was the first tangible sign of serious disturbance, but Hitler and fellow-patients from Bavaria presumed the unrest would be crushed within a few days. However, it became soon clear "the most terrible certainty of my life" that a general revolution had taken place. On 10 November, a pastor addressed the patients in sorrowful terms about the end of the monarchy and informed them that Germany was now a republic, that the war was lost and that Germans had to place themselves at the mercy of the victors. At this, Hitler later wrote: I could stand it no longer. It became impossible for me to sit still one minute more. Again everything went black before my eyes; I tottered and groped my way back to the dormitory, threw myself on my bunk, and dug my burning head into my blanket and pillow.
Since the day when I had stood at my mother"s grave, I had not wept ... But now I could not help it ...
And so it had all been in vain ... Did all this happen only so that a gang of wretched criminals could lay hands on the fatherland? ...
The more I tried to achieve clarity on the monstrous event in this hour, the more the shame of indignation and disgrace burned my brow. What was all the pain in my eyes compared to this misery?
There followed terrible days and even worse nights I knew that all was lost ... In these nights hatred grew in me, hatred for those responsible for this deed.
In the days that followed, my own fate became known to me.
I could not help but laugh at the thought of my own future which only a short time before had given me such bitter concern ...
He drew, according to his own account, the conclusion that: "There is no making pacts with Jews; there can only be the hard: either-or." And he made the decision that changed his life: "I, for my part, decided to go into politics."
Hitler referred to his Pasewalk experience on a number of occasions in the early 1920s, sometimes even with embellishments. Some have been tempted to read into Hitler"s colourful accounts an hallucination which holds the key to his manic ideological obsessions, his "mission" to save Germany, and his rapport with a German people themselves traumatized by defeat and national humiliation. The balance of probabilities suggests a less dramatic process of ideological development and political awareness.
Without question, Hitler was more than just deeply outraged by the news of the revolution. He felt it to be an absolute and unpardonable betrayal of all that he believed in, and, in pain, discomfort, and bitterness, looked for the culprits who would provide him with an explanation of how his world had collapsed. There is no need to doubt that for Hitler these intensely disturbing few days did amount to no less than a traumatic experience. From the following year onwards, his entire political activity was driven by the trauma of 1918 aimed at expunging the defeat and revolution which had betrayed all that he had believed in, and eliminating those he held responsible.
But if there is any strength in the suggestion we have put forward that Hitler acquired his deep-seated prejudices, including his antisemitism, in Vienna, and had them revitalized during the last two war years, if without rationalizing them into a composite ideology, then there is no need to mystify the Pasewalk experience through seeing it as a sudden, dramatic conversion to paranoid antisemitism. Rather, Pasewalk might be viewed as the time when, as. .h.i.tler lay tormented and seeking an explanation of how his world had been shattered, his own rationalization started to fall into place. Devastated by the events unfolding in Munich, Berlin, and other cities, he must have read into them outright confirmation of the views he had always held from the Vienna days on Jews and Social Democrats, on Marxism and internationalism, on pacifism and democracy. Even so, it was still only the beginning beginning of the rationalization. The full fusion of his antisemitism and anti-Marxism was yet to come. There is no authentic evidence that Hitler, up to and including this point, had said a word about Bolshevism. Nor would he do so, even in his early public speeches in Munich, before 1920. The connection of Bolshevism with his internal hate-figures, its incorporation into and adoption of a central place in his "world-view", came only during his time in the Reichswehr in the summer of 1919. And later still came the preoccupation with "living s.p.a.ce" only emerging into a dominant theme during the composition of of the rationalization. The full fusion of his antisemitism and anti-Marxism was yet to come. There is no authentic evidence that Hitler, up to and including this point, had said a word about Bolshevism. Nor would he do so, even in his early public speeches in Munich, before 1920. The connection of Bolshevism with his internal hate-figures, its incorporation into and adoption of a central place in his "world-view", came only during his time in the Reichswehr in the summer of 1919. And later still came the preoccupation with "living s.p.a.ce" only emerging into a dominant theme during the composition of Mein Kampf Mein Kampf between 1924 and 1926. Pasewalk was a crucial step on the way to Hitler"s rationalization of his prejudices. But even more important, in all probability, was the time he spent in the Reichswehr in 1919. between 1924 and 1926. Pasewalk was a crucial step on the way to Hitler"s rationalization of his prejudices. But even more important, in all probability, was the time he spent in the Reichswehr in 1919.
The last implausible point of Hitler"s Pasewalk story is that he resolved there and then to enter politics. In none of his speeches before the putsch in November 1923 did Hitler say a word about deciding in autumn 1918 to enter politics. In fact, Hitler was in no position in Pasewalk to "decide" to enter politics or anything else. The end of the war meant that, like most other soldiers, he faced demobilization. The army had been his home for four years. But now once more his future was uncertain.
When he left Pasewalk on 19 November 1918 to return, via Berlin, to Munich, he had savings totalling only 15 Marks 30 Pfennige in his Munich account. No career awaited him. Nor did he make any effort to enter politics. Indeed, it is not easy to see how he could have done so. Neither family nor "connections" were available to gain him some minor patronage in a political party. A "decision" to enter politics, should Hitler have made one in Pasewalk, would have been empty of meaning. Only staying in the army offered him the hope of avoiding the evil day when he would once more have to face up to the fact that, four turbulent years on, he was no nearer his chosen career as an architect than he had been in 1914, and was without any prospects whatsoever. The future looked bleak. A return to the lonely existence of the pre-war small-time painter had no appeal. But little else beckoned. The army gave him his chance. He was able to stave off demobilization longer than almost all his former comrades, and to keep on the payroll, until 31 March 1920.
It was in the army in 1919 that his ideology finally took shape. Above all, the army, in the extraordinary circ.u.mstances of 1919, turned Hitler into a propagandist the most talented demagogue of his day. Not a deliberate choice, but making the most of the conditions in which he found himself, provided Hitler with his entry into politics. Opportunism and a good slice of luck were more instrumental than strength of will.
4.
The Beerhall Agitator
I.
On 21 November 1918, two days after leaving hospital in Pasewalk, Hitler was back in Munich. Approaching thirty years of age, without education, career, or prospects, his only plans were to stay in the army, which had been his home and provided for him since 1914, as long as possible. He came back to a Munich he scarcely recognized. The barracks to which he returned were run by soldiers" councils. The revolutionary Bavarian government, in the shape of a provisional National Council, was in the hands of the Social Democrats and the more radical Independent Social Democrats (the USPD). The Minister President, Kurt Eisner, was a radical; and he was a Jew.
The revolution in Bavaria had preceded that in the Reich itself. It took place in circ.u.mstances and developed in ways that were to leave a profound mark on Hitler, and to fit more than the events in Berlin into what became the n.a.z.i caricature of the 1918 revolution. It was more radical, with the leadership in the hands of the Independents; it degenerated into near-anarchy, then into a short-lived attempt to create a Communist-run Soviet-style system; this in turn led to a few days though a few days which seared the consciousness of Bavarians for many years to come that amounted to a mini-civil war, ending in bloodshed and brutality; and a number of the revolutionary leaders happened to be Jewish, some of them east European Jews with Bolshevik sympathies and connections. Moreover, the leader of the Bavarian revolution, the Jewish journalist and left-wing socialist Kurt Eisner, a prominent peace-campaigner in the USPD since the split with the Majority Social Democrats in 1917, together with some of his USPD colleagues, had unquestionably tried to stir up industrial unrest during the "January Strike" in 1918, and had been arrested for his actions. That was to fit nicely into the Right"s "stab-in-the-back" legend.
The provisional government that was soon const.i.tuted under Eisner"s leadership was from the outset a highly unstable coalition, mainly composed of the radical but largely idealistic USPD and the "moderate" SPD (which had not even wanted a revolution). Moreover, it stood no chance of mastering the daunting social and economic problems it faced. The a.s.sa.s.sination of Eisner by a young, aristocratic former officer, currently a student at Munich University, Graf Anton von Arco-Valley, on 21 February 1919, provided then the signal for a deterioration into chaos and near-anarchy. Members of the USPD and anarchists proclaimed a "Councils Republic" in Bavaria. The initial failure of attempts at counter-revolution simply strengthened the resolve of the revolutionary hotheads and ushered in the last phase of the Bavarian revolution: the full Communist takeover in the second, or "real" Raterepublik an attempt to introduce a Soviet-style system in Bavaria. It lasted little more than a fortnight. But it ended in violence, bloodshed, and deep recrimination, imposing a baleful legacy on the political climate of Bavaria.
It would be hard to exaggerate the impact on political consciousness in Bavaria of the events between November 1918 and May 1919, and quite especially of the Raterepublik. At its very mildest, it was experienced in Munich itself as a time of curtailed freedom, severe food shortages, press censorship, general strike, sequestration of foodstuffs, coal, and items of clothing, and general disorder and chaos. But, of more lasting significance, it went down in popular memory as a "rule of horror" imposed by foreign elements in the service of Soviet Communism. The image, constructed and ma.s.sively sh.o.r.ed up by rightist propaganda throughout the Reich as well as in Bavaria itself, was that of alien Bolshevik and Jewish forces taking over the state, threatening inst.i.tutions, traditions, order, and property, presiding over chaos and mayhem, perpetrating terrible acts of violence, and causing anarchy of advantage only to Germany"s enemies. The real gainers from the disastrous weeks of the Raterepublik were the radical Right, which had been given the fuel to stoke the fear and hatred of Bolshevism among the Bavarian peasantry and middle cla.s.ses. Not least, extreme counter-revolutionary violence had come to be accepted as a legitimate response to the perceived Bolshevik threat and now became a regular feature of the political scene.
Its flirt with left-wing socialism over, Bavaria turned in the following years into a bastion of the conservative Right and a magnet for right-wing extremists throughout Germany. These were the conditions in which the "making of Adolf Hitler" could take place.
The history of the Bavarian revolution was almost tailor-made for n.a.z.i propaganda. Not just the legend of the "stab-in-the-back", but the notion of an international Jewish conspiracy could be made to sound plausible in the light of the Munich Raterepublik. Though right-wing extremism had no stronger traditions in Bavaria than elsewhere up to this point, the new climate provided it with unique opportunities and the favour of a sympathetic establishment. Many of Hitler"s early followers were deeply influenced by the experience of the turbulent months of post-revolutionary Bavaria. For Hitler himself, the significance of the period of revolution and Raterepublik in Munich can hardly be overrated.
II.
On his return to Munich, Hitler had been a.s.signed to the 7th Company of the 1st Reserve Battalion of the 2nd Infantry Regiment, where, a few days later, he met up again with several wartime comrades. A fortnight later, he and one of these comrades, Ernst Schmidt, were among the fifteen men from his company (and 140 men in all) a.s.signed to guard duties at the Traunstein prisoner-of-war camp. Probably, as Schmidt later recounted, Hitler suggested they let their names go forward when volunteers were called for to make up the deputation. Hitler, remarked Schmidt, did not have much to say about the revolution, "but it was plain enough to see how bitter he felt". Both, according to Schmidt, were repelled by the changed conditions in the Munich barracks, now in the hands of the soldiers" councils, where old standards of authority, discipline, and morale had collapsed. If that was indeed the reason for volunteering, Hitler and Schmidt could have found no improvement on reaching Traunstein. The camp, meant to contain 1,000 prisoners but much overcrowded, was also run by the soldiers" councils which Hitler allegedly so detested. Discipline was poor, and the guards, according to one source, included some of the worst elements among the troops who like Hitler saw the army "as a means of maintaining a carefree existence at the expense of the state". Hitler and Schmidt had an easy time of things, mainly on gate-duty, at Traunstein. They were there in all for almost two months, during which time the prisoners-of-war, mainly Russians, were transported elsewhere. By the beginning of February the camp was completely cleared and disbanded. Probably in late January, as Schmidt hinted, Hitler returned to Munich. Then, for just over two weeks, beginning on 20 February, he was a.s.signed to guard duty at the Hauptbahnhof, where a unit of his company was responsible for maintaining order, particularly among the many soldiers travelling to and from Munich.
A routine order of the demobilization battalion on 3 April 1919 referred to Hitler by name as the representative (Vertrauensmann) of his company. The strong likelihood is, in fact, that he had held this position since 15 February. The duties of the representatives included cooperation with the propaganda department of the socialist government in order to convey "educational" material to the troops. Hitler"s first political duties took place, therefore, in the service of the revolutionary regime run by the SPD and USPD. It is little wonder that in Mein Kampf Mein Kampf he quickly pa.s.sed over his own experience of the traumatic revolutionary period in Bavaria. he quickly pa.s.sed over his own experience of the traumatic revolutionary period in Bavaria.
In fact, he would have had to explain away the even more embarra.s.sing fact of his continued involvement at the very height of Munich"s "red dictatorship". On 14 April, the day after the communist Raterepublik had been proclaimed, the Munich soldiers" councils approved fresh elections of all barrack representatives to ensure that the Munich garrison stood loyally behind the new regime. In the elections the following day Hitler was chosen as Deputy Battalion Representative. Not only, then, did Hitler do nothing to a.s.sist in the crushing of Munich"s "Red Republic"; he was an elected representative of his battalion during the whole period of its existence.
Already in the 1920s, and continuing into the 1930s, there were rumours, never fully countered, that Hitler had initially sympathized with the Majority SPD following the revolution. There were even reported rumours though without any supportive evidence that Hitler had spoken of joining the SPD. In a pointed remark when defending Hermann Esser, one of his earliest supporters, in 1921 against attacks from within the party, Hitler commented: "Everyone was at one time a Social Democrat."
In itself, Hitler"s possible support for the Majority Social Democrats in the revolutionary upheaval is less unlikely than it might at first sight appear. The political situation was extremely confused and uncertain. A number of strange bedfellows, including several who later came to belong to Hitler"s entourage, initially found themselves on the Left during the revolution. Esser, who became the first propaganda chief of the NSDAP, had been for a while a journalist on a Social Democratic newspaper. Sepp Dietrich, later a general in the Waffen-SS and head of Hitler"s SS-Leibstandarte, was elected chairman of a soldiers" council in November 1918. Hitler"s long-time chauffeur Julius Schreck had served in the "Red Army" at the end of April 1919. Gottfried Feder, whose views on "interest slavery" so gripped Hitler"s imagination in summer 1919, had sent a statement of his position to the socialist government headed by Kurt Eisner the previous November. And Balthasar Brandmayer, one of Hitler"s closest wartime comrades and a later fervent supporter, recounted how he at first welcomed the end of the monarchies, the establishment of a republic, and the onset of a new era. Ideological muddle-headedness, political confusion, and opportunism, combined frequently to produce fickle and shifting allegiances.
That, as has been implied, Hitler was inwardly sympathetic to Social Democracy and formed his own characteristic racist-nationalist Weltanschauung Weltanschauung only following an ideological volte-face under the influence of his "schooling" in the Reichswehr after the collapse of the Raterepublik is, however, harder to believe. If Hitler felt compelled to lean outwardly towards the Majority Social Democrats during the revolutionary months, it was not prompted by conviction but by sheer opportunism aimed at avoiding for as long as possible demobilization from the army. only following an ideological volte-face under the influence of his "schooling" in the Reichswehr after the collapse of the Raterepublik is, however, harder to believe. If Hitler felt compelled to lean outwardly towards the Majority Social Democrats during the revolutionary months, it was not prompted by conviction but by sheer opportunism aimed at avoiding for as long as possible demobilization from the army.
Whatever his opportunism and pa.s.sivity, Hitler"s antagonism to the revolutionary Left was probably evident to those around him in the barracks during the months of mounting turmoil in Munich. If indeed, as was later alleged, he voiced support for the Social Democrats in preference to the Communists, it was presumably viewed as a choice of the lesser of two evils, or even, by those in Hitler"s unit who knew him of old, as an opportune adjustment betraying none of his real nationalist, pan-German sympathies. Ernst Schmidt, for example, who by then had been discharged but was still in regular touch with him, spoke later of Hitler"s "utter repugnance" at the events in Munich. The nineteen votes cast for "Hittler" on 16 April, electing him as the second company representative the winner, Johann Bluml, received 39 votes on the Battalion Council, may well have been from those who saw him in this light. That there were tensions within the barracks, and between the soldiers" elected representatives, might be read out of the subsequent denunciation by Hitler of two colleagues on the Battalion Council at the Munich tribunal investigating the actions of the soldiers of his regiment during the Raterepublik. Hitler was probably known to those around him, at the latest towards the end of April, for the counter-revolutionary he really was, whose actual sympathies were indistinguishable from those of the "white" troops preparing to storm the city. Significant, above all, is that within a week of the end of the rule of the councils, Hitler had been nominated by whom is not known to serve on a three-man committee to explore whether members of the Reserve Battalion of the 2nd Infantry Regiment had been actively involved in the Raterepublik. This speaks in favour of the recognition within his battalion of his deep antagonism to "red" rule. At any rate, his new role now prevented Hitler being discharged, along with the rest of the Munich garrison, by the end of May 1919. More importantly, it brought him for the first time into the orbit of counter-revolutionary politics within the Reichswehr. This, rather than any psychological trauma in Pasewalk at the news of the defeat, any dramatic decision to rescue Germany from the "November criminals", was, within the following months, to open up his path into the maelstrom of extreme right-wing politics in Munich.
III.
On 11 May 1919, under the command of Generalmajor von Mohl, the Bayerische Reichswehr Gruppenkommando Nr.4 ("Gruko" for short) was created from the Bavarian units that had been involved in the crushing of the Raterepublik. With the Bavarian government "exiled" in Bamberg until the end of August, Munich its centre crammed with barricades, barbed wire, and army control-points was throughout the spring and summer a city effectively under military rule. Recognizing twin tasks of extensive surveillance of the political scene and combating by means of propaganda and indoctrination "dangerous" att.i.tudes prevalent in the transitional army, Gruko took over in May 1919 the "Information Department" (Nachrichtenabteilung, Abt. Ib/P) which had been immediately established in Munich at the suppression of the Raterepublik. The "education" of the troops in a "correct" anti-Bolshevik, nationalist fashion was rapidly regarded as a priority, and "speaker courses" were devised in order to train "suitable personalities from the troops" who would remain for some considerable time in the army and function as propaganda agents with qualities of persuasion capable of negating subversive ideas. The organization of a series of "anti-Bolshevik courses", beginning in early June, was placed in the hands of Captain Karl Mayr, who, a short while earlier, on 30 May, had taken over the command of the Information Department. Mayr, one of the "midwives" of Hitler"s political "career", could certainly have claimed prime responsibility for its initial launch.
In 1919, Mayr"s influence in the Munich Reichswehr extended beyond his rank as captain, and he was endowed with considerable funds to build up a team of agents or informants, organize the series of "educational" courses to train selected officers and men in "correct" political and ideological thinking, and finance "patriotic" parties, publications, and organizations. Mayr first met Hitler in May 1919, after the crushing of the "Red Army". Hitler"s involvement in his battalion"s investigations into subversive actions during the Raterepublik may have drawn him to Mayr"s attention. And we saw that Hitler had already been engaged in propaganda work in his barracks earlier in the spring though on behalf of the socialist government. He had the right credentials and ideal potential for Mayr"s purposes. When he first met Hitler, Mayr wrote much later, "he was like a tired stray dog looking for a master", and "ready to throw in his lot with anyone who would show him kindness ... He was totally unconcerned about the German people and their destinies."
The name "Hittler Adolf" appears on one of the early lists of names of informants (V-Leute or or V-Manner V-Manner) drawn up by the Information Department Ib/P at the end of May or beginning of June 1919. Within days he had been a.s.signed to the first of the anti-Bolshevik "instruction courses", to take place in Munich University between 5 and 12 June 1919. For the first time, Hitler was to receive here some form of directed political "education". This, as he acknowledged, was important to him; as was the fact that he realized for the first time that he could make an impact on those around him. Here he heard lectures from prominent figures in Munich, hand-picked by Mayr, partly through personal acquaintance, on "German History since the Reformation", "The Political History of the War", "Socialism in Theory and Practice", "Our Economic Situation and the Peace Conditions", and "The Connection between Domestic and Foreign Policy". Among the speakers, too, was Gottfried Feder, who had made a name for himself among the Pan-Germans as an economics expert. His lecture on the "breaking of interest slavery" (a slogan Hitler recognized as having propaganda potential), on which he had already published a "manifesto" highly regarded in nationalist circles distinguishing between "productive" capital and "rapacious" capital (which he a.s.sociated with the Jews), made a deep impression on Hitler, and eventually led to Feder"s role as the economics "guru" of the early n.a.z.i Party. The history lectures were delivered by the Munich historian Professor Karl Alexander von Muller, who had known Mayr at school. Following his first lecture, he came across a small group in the emptying lecture hall surrounding a man addressing them in a pa.s.sionate, strikingly guttural, tone. He mentioned to Mayr after his next lecture that one of his trainees had natural rhetorical talent. Von Muller pointed out where he was sitting. Mayr recognized him immediately: it was "Hitler from the List Regiment".
Hitler himself thought this incident he said he had been roused to intervene by one of the partic.i.p.ants defending the Jews had led directly to his deployment as an "educational officer" (Bildungsoffizier) (Bildungsoffizier). However, he was never a Bildungsoffizier Bildungsoffizier, but remained a mere informant, a V-Mann V-Mann. Plainly, the incident helped to focus Mayr"s attention on Hitler. But it was certainly Mayr"s regular close observation of Hitler"s activity for his department rather than a single incident that led to the latter"s selection as one of a squad of twenty-six instructors all drawn from the partic.i.p.ants in the Munich "instruction courses" to be sent to conduct a five-day course at the Reichswehr camp at Lechfeld, near Augsburg. The course, beginning on 20 August 1919, the day after Hitler"s arrival in the camp, was arranged in response to complaints about the political unreliability of men stationed there, many having returned from being held as prisoners-of-war and now awaiting discharge. The task of the squad was to inculcate nationalist and anti-Bolshevik sentiments in the troops, described as "infected" by Bolshevism and Spartacism. It was in effect the continuation of what the instructors themselves had been exposed to in Munich.
Alongside the commander of the unit, Rudolf Beyschlag, Hitler undertook the lion"s share of the work, including helping to stir discussion of Beyschlag"s lectures on, for example, "Who Bears the Guilt for the World War?" and "From the Days of the Munich Raterepublik". He himself gave lectures on "Peace Conditions and Reconstruction", "Emigration", and "Social and Economic Catchwords". He threw himself with pa.s.sion into the work. His engagement was total. And he immediately found he could strike a chord with his audience, that the way he spoke roused the soldiers listening to him from their pa.s.sivity and cynicism. Hitler was in his element. For the first time in his life, he had found something at which he was an unqualified success. Almost by chance, he had stumbled across his greatest talent. As he himself put it, he could "speak".
Partic.i.p.ants" reports on the course confirm that Hitler was not exaggerating the impact he made in Lechfeld: he was without question the star performer. A central feature of his demagogic armoury was antisemitism. In his ferocious attacks on the Jews, he was, however, doing no more than reflect sentiments which were widespread at the time among the people of Munich, as reports on the popular mood demonstrated. The responses to Hitler"s addresses at Lechfeld indicate how accessible the soldiers were to his way of speaking. The commander of the Lechfeld camp, Oberleutnant Bendt, even felt obliged to request Hitler to tone down his antisemitism, in order to prevent possible objections to the lectures as provoking antisemitic agitation. This followed a lecture by Hitler on capitalism, in which he had "touched on" the "Jewish Question". It is the first reference to Hitler speaking publicly about the Jews.
Within the group, and certainly in the eyes of his superior, Captain Mayr, Hitler must have acquired the reputation of an "expert" on the "Jewish Question". When Mayr was asked, in a letter of 4 September 1919 from a former partic.i.p.ant on one of the "instruction courses", Adolf Gemlich from Ulm, for clarification of the "Jewish Question", particularly in relation to the policies of the Social Democratic government, he pa.s.sed it to Hitler whom he evidently regarded highly for an answer. Hitler"s well-known reply to Gemlich, dated 16 September 1919, is his first recorded written statement about the "Jewish Question". He wrote that antisemitism should be based not on emotion, but on "facts", the first of which was that Jewry was a race, not a religion. Emotive antisemitism would produce pogroms, he continued; antisemitism based on "reason" must, on the other hand, lead to the systematic removal of the rights of Jews. "Its final aim," he concluded, "must unshakeably be the removal of the Jews altogether."
The Gemlich letter reveals for the first time key basic elements of Hitler"s Weltanschauung Weltanschauung which from then on remained unaltered to the last days in the Berlin bunker: antisemitism resting on race theory; and the creation of a unifying nationalism founded on the need to combat the external and internal power of the Jews. which from then on remained unaltered to the last days in the Berlin bunker: antisemitism resting on race theory; and the creation of a unifying nationalism founded on the need to combat the external and internal power of the Jews.
IV.
Following his success at Lechfeld, he was by this time plainly Mayr"s favourite and right-hand man. Among the duties of the informants a.s.signed to Mayr was the surveillance of fifty political parties and organizations ranging from the extreme Right to the far Left in Munich. It was as an informant that Hitler was sent, on Friday, 12 September 1919, to report on a meeting of the German Workers" Party in Munich"s Sterneckerbrau. He was accompanied by at least two former comrades from Lechfeld. The speaker was to have been the volkisch volkisch poet and publicist Dietrich Eckart, but he was ill and Gottfried Feder stood in to lecture on the "breaking of interest slavery". According to his own account, Hitler had heard the lecture before, so took to observing the party itself, which he held to be a "boring organization", no different from the many other small parties sprouting in every corner of Munich at that time. He was about to leave when, in the discussion following the lecture, an invited guest, a Professor Baumann, attacked Feder and then spoke in favour of Bavarian separatism. At this. .h.i.tler intervened so heatedly that Baumann, totally deflated, took his hat and left even while Hitler was still speaking, looking "like a wet poodle". The party chairman, Anton Drexler, was so impressed by Hitler"s intervention that at the end of the meeting he pushed a copy of his own pamphlet, poet and publicist Dietrich Eckart, but he was ill and Gottfried Feder stood in to lecture on the "breaking of interest slavery". According to his own account, Hitler had heard the lecture before, so took to observing the party itself, which he held to be a "boring organization", no different from the many other small parties sprouting in every corner of Munich at that time. He was about to leave when, in the discussion following the lecture, an invited guest, a Professor Baumann, attacked Feder and then spoke in favour of Bavarian separatism. At this. .h.i.tler intervened so heatedly that Baumann, totally deflated, took his hat and left even while Hitler was still speaking, looking "like a wet poodle". The party chairman, Anton Drexler, was so impressed by Hitler"s intervention that at the end of the meeting he pushed a copy of his own pamphlet, My Political Awakening My Political Awakening, into his hand, inviting him to return in a few days if he were interested in joining the new movement. "Goodness, he"s got a gob. We could use him," Drexler was reported to have remarked. According to Hitler"s own account, he read Drexler"s pamphlet in the middle of a sleepless night, and it struck a chord with him, reminding him, he claimed, of his own "political awakening" twelve years earlier. Within a week of attending the meeting, he then received a postcard informing him that he had been accepted as a member, and should attend a committee meeting of the party a few days later to discuss the matter. Though his immediate reaction, he wrote, was a negative one he allegedly wanted to found a party of his own curiosity overcame him and he went along to a dimly-lit meeting of the small leadership group in the Altes Rosenbad, a shabby pub in Herrenstrae. He sympathized with the political aims of those he met. But he was appalled, he later wrote, at the small-minded organization he encountered "club life of the worst manner and sort", he dubbed it. After a few days of indecision, he added, he finally made up his mind to join. What determined him was the