"I don"t know. It seemed like voices from our youth--Lina."
She had no resentment of his use of her name in the tone with which she asked: "Did you hate that so much?"
"No; the loss of it."
They both fetched a deep breath.
"The Uccellis have a villa near the baths of Lucca," said Mrs. Bowen.
"They have asked me to go."
"Do you think of going?" inquired Colville. "I"ve always fancied it must be pleasant there."
"No; I declined. Sometimes I think I will just stay on in Florence."
"I dare say you"d find it perfectly comfortable. There"s nothing like having the range of one"s own house in summer." He looked out of the window on the blue-black sky.
""And deepening through their silent spheres, Heaven over heaven rose the night,""
he quoted. "It"s wonderful! Do you remember how I used to read _Mariana in the South_ to you and poor Jenny? How it must have bored her! What an a.s.s I was!"
"Yes," said Mrs. Bowen breathlessly, in sympathy with his reminiscence rather than in agreement with his self-denunciation.
Colville broke into a laugh, and then she began to laugh to; but not quite willingly as it seemed.
Effie started from her sleep. "What--what is it?" she asked, stretching and shivering as half-wakened children do.
"Bed-time," said her mother promptly, taking her hand to lead her away.
"Say good-night to Mr. Colville."
The child turned and kissed him. "Good night," she murmured.
"Good night, you sleepy little soul!" It seemed to Colville that he must be a pretty good man, after all, if this little thing loved him so.
"Do you always kiss Mr. Colville good-night?" asked her mother when she began to undo her hair for her in her room.
"Sometimes. Don"t you think it"s nice?"
"Oh yes; nice enough."
Colville sat by the window a long time thinking Mrs. Bowen might come back; but she did not return.
Mr. Waters came to see him the next afternoon at his hotel.
"Are you pretty comfortable here?" he asked.
"Well, it"s a change," said Colville. "I miss the little one awfully."
"She"s a winning child," admitted the old man. "That combination of conventionality and _navete_ is very captivating. I notice it in the mother."
"Yes, the mother has it too. Have you seen them to-day?"
"Yes; Mrs. Bowen was sorry to be out when you came."
"I had the misfortune to miss them. I had a great mind to go again to-night."
The old man said nothing to this. "The fact is," Colville went on, "I"m so habituated to being there that I"m rather spoiled."
"Ah, it"s a nice place," Mr. Waters admitted.
"Of course I made all the haste I could to get away, and I have the reward of a good conscience. But I don"t find that the reward is very great."
The old gentleman smiled. "The difficulty is to know conscience from self-interest."
"Oh, there"s no doubt of it in my case," said Colville. "If I"d consulted my own comfort and advantage, I should still be at Palazzo Pinti."
"I dare say they would have been glad to keep you."
"Do you really think so?" asked Colville, with sudden seriousness. "I wish you would tell me why. Have you any reason--grounds? Pshaw! I"m absurd!" He sank back into the easy-chair from whose depths he had pulled himself in the eagerness of his demand, and wiped his forehead with his handkerchief. "Mr. Waters, you remember my telling you of my engagement to Miss Graham?"
"Yes."
"That is broken off--if it were ever really on. It was a great mistake for both of us--a tragical one for her, poor child, a ridiculous one for me. My only consolation is that it was a mistake and no more; but I don"t conceal from myself that I might have prevented it altogether if I had behaved with greater wisdom and dignity at the outset. But I"m afraid I was flattered by an illusion of hers that ought to have pained and alarmed me, and the rest followed inevitably, though I was always just on the point of escaping the consequences of my weakness--my wickedness."
"Ah, there is something extremely interesting in all that," said the old minister thoughtfully. "The situation used to be figured under the old idea of a compact with the devil. His debtor was always on the point of escaping, as you say, but I recollect no instance in which he did not pay at last. The myth must have arisen from man"s recognition of the inexorable sequence of cause from effect, in the moral world, which even repentance cannot avert. Goethe tries to imagine an atonement for Faust"s trespa.s.s against one human soul in his benefactions to the race at large; but it is a very cloudy business."
"It isn"t quite a parallel case," said Colville, rather sulkily. He had, in fact, suffered more under Mr. Waters"s generalisation than he could from a more personal philosophy of the affair.
"Oh no; I didn"t think that," consented the old man.
"And I don"t think I shall undertake any extended scheme of drainage or subsoiling in atonement for my little dream," Colville continued, resenting the parity of outline that grew upon him in spite of his protest. They were both silent for a while, and then Colville cried out, "Yes, yes; they are alike. _I_ dreamed, too, of recovering and restoring my own lost and broken past in the love of a young soul, and it was in essence the same cruelly egotistic dream; and it"s nothing in my defence that it was all formless and undirected at first, and that as soon as I recognised it I abhorred it."
"Oh yes, it is," replied the old man, with perfect equanimity. "Your a.s.sertion is the hysterical excess of Puritanism in all times and places. In the moral world we are responsible only for the wrong that we intend. It can"t he otherwise."
"And the evil that"s suffered from the wrong we didn"t intend?"
"Ah, perhaps that isn"t evil."
"It"s pain!"
"It"s pain, yes."
"And to have wrung a young and innocent heart with the anguish of self-doubt, with the fear of wrong to another, with the shame of an error such as I allowed, perhaps encouraged her to make--"
"Yes," said the old man. "The young suffer terribly. But they recover.
Afterward we don"t suffer so much, but we don"t recover. I wouldn"t defend you against yourself if I thought you seriously in the wrong. If you know yourself to be, you shouldn"t let me."
Thus put upon his honour, Colville was a long time thoughtful. "How can I tell?" he asked. "You know the facts; you can judge."