Granted, it"s tough to maintain credibility after decades of paramilitary actions that could charitably be described as ineffective. Remember the mock invasion of Elliott Key, when armed Alpha 66-ers wound up captured by park rangers?
Episodes like that don"t help the cause. The urge to vindicate one"s self with new dramatics must be tempting. Plans abound, but the execution remains flawed.
Thirteen months ago, the Coast Guard grabbed a load of arms, including grenade launchers, from an Alpha 66 boat off Cuba. Last May, Customs agents followed another craft with engine trouble to a marina in the Middle Keys, where they confiscated grenades, pipe bombs and heavy weapons.
Perhaps the group needs to invest less on weaponry, and more on boat maintenance.
Another weak spot is public relations. After the embarra.s.sing bust in May, Alpha leaders declared that the boat had been on a "military mission" against targets in Cuba. That would be a major violation of U.S. law.
So, at trial, the story changed from one of patriotic bravery to one of ignorance. Lawyers for the commandos said their clients had no clue how the guns and explosives got stowed aboard their fishing boat. A Key West jury believed them.
Confusion also occurred last fall, after Alpha 66 warned that it would begin taking violent action against foreign tourists in Cuba.
The U.S. State Department condemned the manifesto and threatened federal prosecution. Alpha leaders a.s.serted that attacks against visitors in Havana would be carried out not by Alpha"s Miami wing, but by secret sympathizers on the island. As if that made it all right.
That the FBI tolerates such silliness proves that it doesn"t take the group too seriously. But suppose a steering cable breaks on an explosive-laden Alpha 66 vessel, sending it crashing into innocent boaters in Government Cut. Given Alpha"s checkered history, the scenario is not so farfetched.
The feds should either prosecute these guys, or buy them brand new Evinrudes.
The other rafters suffer with silence August 21, 1994 In the torrent of reaction to President Clinton"s strict new policy toward Cuban refugees, scarcely a word has been uttered about the Haitians.
The same politicians now bellowing in outrage about the interdiction of Cuban rafters made not a peep of protest when Clinton took the same step to halt the influx of boat people from Haiti.
Today, at the U.S. Navy base in Guantanamo Bay, more than 15,000 Haitians are held in miserable detention. It"s essentially one of the world"s largest prisons.
Except when there"s a riot, as there was recently, the Haitian detainees are mostly forgotten by the press and politicians. That"s partly because n.o.body has a good idea what to do with them, or what to do about Haiti.
Just like the Cubans, the Haitians fled an economic nightmare caused by repression, corruption and a harsh U.S. trade embargo.
Like the Cubans, the Haitians were so desperate that they set out for Florida in flimsy, overcrowded crafts. And, like the Cubans, many perished on the journey.
There are differences. The Haitians have no special immigration law giving them status in the United States. Their exile community is smaller, and much weaker in political clout, than that of Cuban Americans.
And finally, of course, Haitians are black. You will never see, in your lifetime, a coalition of conservative Democrats and Republicans on the floor of Congress demanding automatic asylum for Haitians fleeing the Cedras regime. Never.
Yet most of the same right-wingers who vaguely demand that Clinton take stronger action against Fidel Castro oppose an invasion of Haiti. Why? Because very few votes-or campaign contributions-are to be gained from that position.
Those now blasting the president say he should focus not on the refugees, but on toppling Castro. But they don"t say how.
We"ve already got an embargo-what about a military blockade? Brilliant.
The Haitian blockade has international approval. A blockade of Cuba doesn"t, and wouldn"t. Not only would it violate the trading rights of neutral nations, it would generate more misplaced sympathy for Fidel.
More importantly, a blockade is an act of war. Not even Bob Dole wants a war with Cuba; too many Americans would die. The truth is that, short of sending troops, only so much can be done to destabilize Castro.
In the meantime, it"s insane not to protect our own borders. Stopping refugees at sea is a heartbreaking affair, but the alternative is to throw open the doors to every hungry soul in the Caribbean-not just Cubans and Haitians, but everybody.
Oh, we"ve got acres of open s.p.a.ce...in Montana, Wyoming, Utah and Nevada. But Caribbean refugees tend to stay here in South Florida, and we"re already jammed to the gills with people.
Another Mariel would be catastrophic. Florida would be swamped, and Castro would get a new lease on life.
Gov. Lawton Chiles was right to demand fast federal action, and Clinton was right to begin intercepting rafters. The word will quickly spread in Cuba, and the number of those taking to the sea will begin to drop.
Among Clinton"s most venomous critics is the aptly named Newt Gingrich who, being from Georgia, has no firsthand experience with immigration problems. Newt says the new Cuba policy displays a "mixed morality."
As usual, Newt"s confused. Mixed morality is imprisoning one group of economic refugees while welcoming others.
When Rep. Gingrich visits Guantanamo to show support for the Cubans detained there, perhaps he"ll find time to chat with some Haitians as well.
They"ll be the black ones, Newt. The ones you forgot about.
Protests create anger, gridlock-not friends May 11, 1995 What a great idea for civil disobedience: Let"s block an expressway!
Brilliant. Let"s see how many thousands of working people we can tick off on a sweltering afternoon! Won"t that help the cause!
The plan is to call attention to the fate of 13 rafters returned to Cuba by the U.S. government. And Monday"s mess on State Road 836 did attract all the TV stations, as did Wednesday"s multiple street blockades.
What the protesters have failed to antic.i.p.ate is the fierce backlash. An elementary rule of pro test: You don"t win public support by antagonizing the public.
Those stuck in a man-made traffic mora.s.s aren"t thinking about rafters or the implications of U.S. immigration policy.
They"re thinking: Where are the cops? Why aren"t these yahoos being hauled away?
They"re thinking: I"m late for work. I might lose my job.
I"m late for court. I"m late for a sales meeting. I"m late for a doctor"s appointment.
My children are waiting at the day-care center. My mother"s waiting at home for her medical prescription.
My baby"s in the car and it"s 95 degrees out here.
What do these people think they"re doing?
All over town, small numbers of Cuban-American protesters are staging "spontaneous" traffic blockages. Everyone else is out of patience. The havoc bred rancor, starting at the 836 tollbooth.
The public relations damage from such a brainless, inconsiderate stunt is incalculable. Those protesting President Clinton"s new Cuba policy are a minority who ought to be trying to win converts, not alienate those who might otherwise be sympathetic.
I was a long blessed way from the traffic jams, but I know how drivers felt. What a senseless tragedy if some elderly motorist, trapped between exits, had died from a heart attack or a stroke.
Nothing is gained by disrupting the lives and livelihoods of ordinary folks who had nothing to do with the Cuba deal. It"s infinitely more logical to hop a bus to Washington, B.C., and block traffic at the White House. Of course, the police there wouldn"t be quite so tolerant.
That"s the irony. Outside of Miami, hardly anybody in the country cares much about what"s happening in Cuba. Polls show that more Americans are upset about the admission of the Guantanamo refugees than about the new repatriation policy.
In fact, a WPLG-Channel 10 poll reveals similar feelings here in Dade, including a sharp division within the Cuban-American community. The last thing that protesters can afford to do is undermine their support here at home, but that"s what they do when they block traffic.
It"s reckless, pointless and counterproductive.
Civil demonstrations are a core part of American democracy, and of the Miami exile movement. Marches and rallies take place frequently, and are almost always well-organized and nonviolent.
On Tuesday, a couple of local politicians, to show support for the refugees, got themselves peacefully arrested outside the White House. That"s a tradition.
Another is the hunger strike, such as the one taking place outside the Herald. Equally irresistible to TV cameras, these protests make their point-and they make the 6 o"clock news.
Meanwhile, n.o.body"s day gets snarled. n.o.body"s welfare is endangered. n.o.body gets stuck in the hot sun. n.o.body"s fuming and cursing. n.o.body"s worried sick about their kids, their jobs or their doctor"s appointments.
There are many ways to keep the pa.s.sion and anger in political demonstrations without provoking scorn and hostility.
All those motorists stranded by protests were plenty angry, but not at Bill Clinton or Fidel Castro.
Flotilla really empty vessel of exile protest August 31, 1995 On Sat.u.r.day, another flotilla sets sail for Cuba.
The best thing that could happen is that nothing will happen. The worst thing that could happen is that somebody decides to be a martyr.
Organizer Ramon Saul Sanchez has promised there will no repeat of July"s fiasco-at-sea, when flotilla vessels entered Cuba"s territorial waters and defied government patrols.
That confrontation ended when a flotilla craft was intentionally side-swiped by Cuban gunboats-an incident that caused an uproar in Dade County and deafening silence in the court of world opinion.
Scarcely a peep of protest against Fidel Castro was heard outside Miami. Many foreign governments plainly felt the Cuban president showed restraint in not blasting the seafaring intruders out of the water.
World leaders who care nothing for Castro"s regime will still defend Cuba"s sovereign right to protect its own borders. That"s why July"s flotilla excursion was an international flop.
This time Castro says he won"t be so patient with the exiles. Maybe he"s bluffing, maybe not.
Last month, flotilla supporters in private planes buzzed downtown Havana in a deliberate breach of Cuban air s.p.a.ce. Since then, anti-aircraft batteries have been placed near the harbor.
I don"t care how good a pilot you are, a Cessna will only go so fast. Chuck Yeager himself wouldn"t fly one over a machine-gun nest. Then again, Yeager never fantasized about martyrdom.
Whether any would-be martyrs join Sat.u.r.day"s flotilla is a big question. But if any protesters seriously think that getting themselves shot will galvanize the global community against Castro, they"re foolishly mistaken.
Ramon Saul Sanchez, who once favored paramilitary action against Havana, now advocates nonviolent strategies in pushing for a democratic Cuba.
Yet his July flotilla, billed as a solemn and peaceable ceremony, disintegrated into a taunt. Its reckless cat-and-mouse tactics nearly provoked Castro"s patrol commanders into unsheathing their heavy guns.
This time, Sanchez says, his boats won"t cross Cuba"s 12-mile territorial limit. But they will be carrying outboard-propelled inflatable rafts.
Twinkling with mischief, Sanchez won"t divulge the mission of the little rafts. Presumably, protesters intend to dart into Cuban waters and do something-drop leaflets, shoot off flares, moon the gunboats. Who knows what.
The rest of the world will only shake their heads and wonder what"s the point. The only one to gain from petty provocation is Fidel himself, who milks these moments for all they"re worth.
Here I am, minding my own business, when those darn Miami exiles show up in planes and boats, picking another fight ...
But turn on the radio in Dade County and you"ll realize that, after 36 years, the mere act of annoying Castro is considered a great moral victory. It"s sad, like a little kid who stands outside the window, making faces until he finally gets your attention.
A genuine heartfelt protest is one thing, invigorating in its dignity. But a prank is just a prank.
Nothing that takes place this weekend off Havana will bring Cuba one bit closer to democracy, or push Castro one day closer to exile, or move the suffering Cuban people one step nearer to freedom.
As thrilling as it might be to provoke Fidel"s regime face to face, it accomplishes zero. The flotilla simply becomes a floating pep rally for one faction of the exile community and a dangerous pep rally at that.
In a battle against inflatable rafts, Castro"s gunboats won"t even need bullets. A knitting needle will do the job.
Immigration priorities are warped January 8, 1998 Every kid who wants to get out of Cuba should be taking batting practice, because baseball is their best ticket to the United States.
Cuban pitcher Livan Hernandez defected and became a World Series hero. His half-brother Orlando escaped by boat to the Bahamas last week, and was promptly offered a humanitarian visa by U.S. officials. Soon he"ll be playing in the majors.
No other country can match our mania for professional sports and the way we idolize athletes. It"s an obsession that warps our immigration priorities, among others.
A Cuban jock has a better chance of getting into the United States than a Cuban doctor, engineer or schoolteacher does. That"s hard to justify, and one reason for the mixed reaction in South Florida to the special way Orlando Hernandez was treated.
No one disputes that El Duque, as he is known, was persecuted in Cuba-kicked off the national baseball team after Livan"s defection. Likewise, no one doubts that Orlando would have faced prison or other retribution from the Castro government had he been sent back.
That"s exactly what has happened to others who were not blessed with a 90 mph fastball.
Three years ago, the United States began repatriating Cuban rafters intercepted on their way to Florida, a move designed to deter another chaotic Mariel exodus. The policy shift was necessary and overdue.
For a long time the United States had used a double standard for Caribbean refugees, routinely turning away Haitian boat people while accepting most Cubans without question. Yet the dream they carried on their journeys was the same: to escape economic hardship caused by political repression.
The world is full of people in similar grim predicaments. The United States cannot absorb them all, but it makes room each year for a fixed number from each country.
Exceptions to the rules are commonly made for sports stars. Ballplayers are always welcome. So are tennis prodigies and ice dancers and champion weight lifters.
These aren"t political activists; they"re jocks looking for a payday. Nothing wrong with that. Unfortunately, the same opportunity cannot be promised to everyone who wants to come here. It"s just not possible.
Every year, 20,000 U.S. entry visas are offered in Havana, and the demand far outstrips the supply. El Duque turned down his special visa and is instead headed for Costa Rica, a move that allows him to negotiate more fruitfully with American baseball clubs. Soon he"ll be rich, and good for him.
But I can"t help thinking of a woman I met near Havana a few years ago. She lived in a small apartment with her husband, children and mother. Though she expressed no interest in moving to Miami, the woman had big-league credentials.
She couldn"t throw a slider, but she was as valuable as any athlete for whom we"ve rolled out the red carpet.
This woman was an eye surgeon. She specialized in caring for children and the elderly. For her skill and dedication, she was rewarded by the Cuban government with a salary equivalent to about $ a month.
In this country the woman would be wealthy, of course. In this country she could afford $ for a daiquiri.
Still, she didn"t speak of leaving Havana; she had her family and patients to think about.
But I"m wondering what would happen if she changed her mind; if she and her relatives ended up stranded on a Bahamian island, like Hernandez and his friends. I wonder whether anyone in Washington would make a fuss, or even notice.
I know visas are scarce, but maybe they"d let her use El Duque"s. If not her, then maybe somebody like her. Somebody without a sports agent leading them to freedom.
The War on Drugs