Dear Sir,--In consequence of your kind permission I send, or will send, a dozen copies of "Pauline" and (to mitigate the infliction) Sh.e.l.ley"s Poem--on account of what you mentioned this morning. It will perhaps be as well that you let me know their safe arrival by a line to R. B.
junior, Hanover Cottage, Southampton Street, Camberwell. You must not think me too encroaching, if I make the getting back "Rosalind and Helen" an excuse for calling on you some evening--the said "R. and H." has, I observe, been well thumbed and sedulously marked by an acquaintance of mine, but I have not time to rub out his labour of love.
I am, dear sir, Yours very really, R. Browning. Camberwell: 2 o"clock.
At the left-hand corner of the first page of this note is written: "The parcel--a "Pauline" parcel--is come. I send one as a witness."
On the inner page is written:
"Impromptu on hearing a sermon by the Rev. T. R.--p.r.o.nounced "heavy"--
"A _heavy_ sermon!--sure the error"s great, For not a word Tom uttered _had its weight_."
A third letter, also undated, but post-marked March 29, 1833, refers probably to the promise or announcement of a favourable notice. A fourth conveys Mr. Browning"s thanks for the notice itself:
My dear Sir,--I have just received your letter, which I am desirous of acknowledging before any further mark of your kindness reaches me;--I can only offer you my simple thanks--but they are of the sort that one can give only once or twice in a life: all things considered, I think you are almost repaid, if you imagine what I must feel--and it will have been worth while to have made a fool of myself, only to have obtained a "case" which leaves my fine fellow Mandeville at a dead lock.
As for the book--I hope ere long to better it, and to deserve your goodness.
In the meantime I shall not forget the extent to which I am, dear sir, Your most obliged and obedient servant R. B. S. & O."s, Conduit St., Thursday m-g.
I must intrude on your attention, my dear sir, once more than I had intended--but a notice like the one I have read will have its effect at all hazards.
I can only say that I am very proud to feel as grateful as I do, and not altogether hopeless of justifying, by effort at least, your most generous "coming forward". Hazlitt wrote his essays, as he somewhere tells us, mainly to send them to some one in the country who had "always prophesied he would be something"!--I shall never write a line without thinking of the source of my first praise, be a.s.sured. I am, dear sir, Yours most truly and obliged, Robert Browning. March 31, 1833.
Mr. Fox was then editor of a periodical called the "Monthly Repository", which, as his daughter, Mrs. Bridell-Fox, writes in her graceful article on Robert Browning, in the "Argosy" for February 1890, he was endeavouring to raise from its original denominational character into a first-cla.s.s literary and political journal. The articles comprised in the volume for 1833 are certainly full of interest and variety, at once more popular and more solid than those prescribed by the present fashion of monthly magazines. He reviewed "Pauline" favourably in its April number--that is, as soon as it had appeared; and the young poet thus received from him an introduction to what should have been, though it probably was not, a large circle of intelligent readers.
The poem was characterized by its author, five years later, in a fantastic note appended to a copy of it, as "the only remaining crab of the shapely Tree of Life in my Fool"s Paradise." This name is ill bestowed upon a work which, however wild a fruit of Mr. Browning"s genius, contains, in its many lines of exquisite fancy and deep pathos, so much that is rich and sweet. It had also, to discard metaphor, its faults of exaggeration and confusion; and it is of these that Mr.
Browning was probably thinking when he wrote his more serious apologetic preface to its reprint in 1868. But these faults were partly due to his conception of the character which he had tried to depict; and partly to the inherent difficulty of depicting one so complex, in a succession of mental and moral states, irrespectively of the conditions of time, place, and circ.u.mstance which were involved in them. Only a very powerful imagination could have inspired such an attempt. A still more conspicuous effort of creative genius reveals itself at its close. The moment chosen for the "Confession" has been that of a supreme moral or physical crisis. The exhaustion attendant on this is directly expressed by the person who makes it, and may also be recognized in the vivid, yet confusing, intensity of the reminiscences of which it consists. But we are left in complete doubt as to whether the crisis is that of approaching death or incipient convalescence, or which character it bears in the sufferer"s mind; and the language used in the closing pages is such as to suggest, without the slightest break in poetic continuity, alternately the one conclusion and the other. This was intended by Browning to a.s.sist his anonymity; and when the writer in "Tait"s Magazine" spoke of the poem as a piece of pure bewilderment, he expressed the natural judgment of the Philistine, while proving himself such. If the notice by J. S. Mill, which this criticism excluded, was indeed--as Mr. Browning always believed--much more sympathetic, I can only record my astonishment; for there never was a large and cultivated intelligence one can imagine less in harmony than his with the poetic excesses, or even the poetic qualities, of "Pauline". But this is a digression.
Mr. Fox, though an accomplished critic, made very light of the artistic blemishes of the work. His admiration for it was as generous as it was genuine; and, having recognized in it the hand of a rising poet, it was more congenial to him to hail that poet"s advent than to register his shortcomings.
"The poem," he says, "though evidently a hasty and imperfect sketch, has truth and life in it, which gave us the thrill, and laid hold of us with the power, the sensation of which has never yet failed us as a test of genius."
But it had also, in his mind, a distinguishing characteristic, which raised it above the sphere of merely artistic criticism. The article continues:
"We have never read anything more purely confessional. The whole composition is of the spirit, spiritual. The scenery is in the chambers of thought; the agencies are powers and pa.s.sions; the events are transitions from one state of spiritual existence to another."
And we learn from the context that he accepted this confessional and introspective quality as an expression of the highest emotional life--of the essence, therefore, of religion. On this point the sincerest admirers of the poem may find themselves at issue with Mr. Fox. Its sentiment is warmly religious; it is always, in a certain sense, spiritual; but its intellectual activities are exercised on entirely temporal ground, and this fact would generally be admitted as the negation of spirituality in the religious sense of the word. No difference, however, of opinion as to his judgment of "Pauline" can lessen our appreciation of Mr. Fox"s encouraging kindness to its author.
No one who loved Mr. Browning in himself, or in his work, can read the last lines of this review without a throb of affectionate grat.i.tude for the sympathy so ungrudgingly, and--as he wrote during his latest years--so opportunely given:
"In recognizing a poet we cannot stand upon trifles nor fret ourselves about such matters [as a few blemishes]. Time enough for that afterwards, when larger works come before us. Archimedes in the bath had many particulars to settle about specific gravities and Hiero"s crown, but he first gave a glorious leap and shouted "Eureka!"
Many persons have discovered Mr. Browning since he has been known to fame. One only discovered him in his obscurity.
Next to that of Mr. Fox stands the name of John Forster among the first spontaneous appreciators of Mr. Browning"s genius; and his admiration was, in its own way, the more valuable for the circ.u.mstances which precluded in it all possible, even unconscious, bias of personal interest or sympathy. But this belongs to a somewhat later period of our history.
I am dwelling at some length on this first experience of Mr. Browning"s literary career, because the confidence which it gave him determined its immediate future, if not its ultimate course--because, also, the poem itself is more important to the understanding of his mind than perhaps any other of his isolated works. It was the earliest of his dramatic creations; it was therefore inevitably the most instinct with himself; and we may regard the "Confession" as to a great extent his own, without for an instant ignoring the imaginative element which necessarily and certainly entered into it. At one moment, indeed, his utterance is so emphatic that we should feel it to be direct, even if we did not know it to be true. The pa.s.sage beginning, "I am made up of an intensest life,"
conveys something more than the writer"s actual psychological state. The feverish desire of life became gradually modified into a more or less active intellectual and imaginative curiosity; but the sense of an individual, self-centred, and, as it presented itself to him, unconditioned existence, survived all the teachings of experience, and often indeed unconsciously imposed itself upon them.
I have already alluded to that other and more pathetic fragment of distinct autobiography which is to be found in the invocation to the "Sun-treader". Mr. Fox, who has quoted great part of it, justly declares that "the fervency, the remembrance, the half-regret mingling with its exultation, are as true as its leading image is beautiful." The "exultation" is in the triumph of Sh.e.l.ley"s rising fame; the regret, for the lost privilege of worshipping in solitary tenderness at an obscure shrine. The double mood would have been characteristic of any period of Mr. Browning"s life.
The artistic influence of Sh.e.l.ley is also discernible in the natural imagery of the poem, which reflects a fitful and emotional fancy instead of the direct poetic vision of the author"s later work.
"Pauline" received another and graceful tribute two months later than the review. In an article of the "Monthly Repository", and in the course of a description of some luxuriant wood-scenery, the following pa.s.sage occurs:
"Sh.e.l.ley and Tennyson are the best books for this place... . They are natives of this soil; literally so; and if planted would grow as surely as a crowbar in Kentucky sprouts tenpenny nails. "Probatum est." Last autumn L----dropped a poem of Sh.e.l.ley"s down there in the wood,* amongst the thick, damp, rotting leaves, and this spring some one found a delicate exotic-looking plant, growing wild on the very spot, with "Pauline" hanging from its slender stalk. Unripe fruit it may be, but of pleasant flavour and promise, and a mellower produce, it may be hoped, will follow."
* Mr. Browning"s copy of "Rosalind and Helen", which he had lent to Miss Flower, and which she lost in this wood on a picnic.
This and a bald though well-meant notice in the "Athenaeum"
exhaust its literary history for this period.*
* Not quite, it appears. Since I wrote the above words, Mr. d.y.k.es Campbell has kindly copied for me the following extract from the "Literary Gazette" of March 23, 1833:
"Pauline: a Fragment of a Confession", pp. 71. London, 1833.
Saunders and Otley.
"Somewhat mystical, somewhat poetical, somewhat sensual, and not a little unintelligible,--this is a dreamy volume, without an object, and unfit for publication."
The anonymity of the poem was not long preserved; there was no reason why it should be. But "Pauline" was, from the first, little known or discussed beyond the immediate circle of the poet"s friends; and when, twenty years later, Dante Gabriel Rossetti unexpectedly came upon it in the library of the British Museum, he could only surmise that it had been written by the author of "Paracelsus".
The only recorded event of the next two years was Mr. Browning"s visit to Russia, which took place in the winter of 1833-4. The Russian consul-general, Mr. Benckhausen, had taken a great liking to him, and being sent to St. Petersburg on some special mission, proposed that he should accompany him, nominally in the character of secretary.
The letters written to his sister during this, as during every other absence, were full of graphic description, and would have been a mine of interest for the student of his imaginative life. They are, unfortunately, all destroyed, and we have only scattered reminiscences of what they had to tell; but we know how strangely he was impressed by some of the circ.u.mstances of the journey: above all, by the endless monotony of snow-covered pine-forest, through which he and his companion rushed for days and nights at the speed of six post-horses, without seeming to move from one spot. He enjoyed the society of St. Petersburg, and was fortunate enough, before his return, to witness the breaking-up of the ice on the Neva, and see the Czar perform the yearly ceremony of drinking the first gla.s.s of water from it. He was absent about three months.
The one active career which would have recommended itself to him in his earlier youth was diplomacy; it was that which he subsequently desired for his son. He would indeed not have been averse to any post of activity and responsibility not unsuited to the training of a gentleman.
Soon after his return from Russia he applied for appointment on a mission which was to be despatched to Persia; and the careless wording of the answer which his application received made him think for a moment that it had been granted. He was much disappointed when he learned, through an interview with the "chief", that the place was otherwise filled.
In 1834 he began a little series of contributions to the "Monthly Repository", extending into 1835-6, and consisting of five poems. The earliest of these was a sonnet, not contained in any edition of Mr.
Browning"s works, and which, I believe, first reappeared in Mr. Gosse"s article in the "Century Magazine", December 1881; now part of his "Personalia". The second, beginning "A king lived long ago", was to be published, with alterations and additions, as one of "Pippa"s" songs.
"Porphyria"s Lover" and "Johannes Agricola in Meditation" were reprinted together in "Bells and Pomegranates" under the heading of "Madhouse Cells". The fifth consisted of the Lines beginning "Still ailing, Wind?
wilt be appeased or no?" afterwards introduced into the sixth section of "James Lee"s Wife". The sonnet is not very striking, though hints of the poet"s future psychological subtlety are not wanting in it; but his most essential dramatic quality reveals itself in the last three poems.
This winter of 1834-5 witnessed the birth, perhaps also the extinction, of an amateur periodical, established by some of Mr. Browning"s friends; foremost among these the young Dowsons, afterwards connected with Alfred Domett. The magazine was called the "Trifler", and published in monthly numbers of about ten pages each. It collapsed from lack of pocket-money on the part of the editors; but Mr. Browning had written for it one letter, February 1833, signed with his usual initial Z, and ent.i.tled "Some strictures on a late article in the "Trifler"." This boyish production sparkles with fun, while affecting the lengthy quaintnesses of some obsolete modes of speech. The article which it attacks was "A Dissertation on Debt and Debtors", where the subject was, I imagine, treated in the orthodox way: and he expends all his paradox in showing that indebtedness is a necessary condition of human life, and all his sophistry in confusing it with the abstract sense of obligation. It is, perhaps, scarcely fair to call attention to such a mere argumentative and literary freak; but there is something so comical in a defence of debt, however transparent, proceeding from a man to whom never in his life a bill can have been sent in twice, and who would always have preferred ready-money payment to receiving a bill at all, that I may be forgiven for quoting some pa.s.sages from it.
For to be man is to be a debtor:--hinting but slightly at the grand and primeval debt implied in the idea of a creation, as matter too hard for ears like thine, (for saith not Luther, What hath a cow to do with nutmegs?) I must, nevertheless, remind thee that all moralists have concurred in considering this our mortal sojourn as indeed an uninterrupted state of debt, and the world our dwelling-place as represented by nothing so aptly as by an inn, wherein those who lodge most commodiously have in perspective a proportionate score to reduce,*
and those who fare least delicately, but an insignificant shot to discharge--or, as the tuneful Quarles well phraseth it--
He"s most in _debt_ who lingers out the day, Who dies betimes has less and less to pay.