It was almost like a child"s wail. His brow contracted still more painfully.
"My darling," he said; "my darling--my dear dear wife!" and he bent his head down to her as she lay against his breast, kissing her hair with a pa.s.sion of pity, of remorse, of tenderness, which seemed to rend his whole nature.
"Tell me--tell me--Robert!"
He guided her gently across the room, past the sofa over which her work lay scattered, past the flower-table, now a many-coloured ma.s.s of roses, which was her especial pride, past the remains of a brick castle which had delighted Mary"s wondering eyes and mischievous fingers an hour or two before, to a low chair by the open window looking on the wide moonlit expanse of cornfield. He put her into it, walked to the window on the other side of the room, shut it, and drew down the blind. Then he went back to her, and sank down beside her, kneeling, her hands in his.
"My dear wife--you have loved me--you do love me?"
She could not answer, she could only press his hands with her cold fingers, with a look and gesture that implored him to speak.
"Catherine," he said, still kneeling before her, "you remember that night you came down to me in the study, the night I told you I was in trouble and you could not help me. Did you guess from what I said what the trouble was?"
"Yes," she answered, trembling, "yes, I did, Robert; I thought you were depressed--troubled--about religion."
"And I know," he said with an outburst of feeling, kissing her hands as they lay in his--"I know very well that you went upstairs and prayed for me, my white-souled angel! But Catherine, the trouble grew--it got blacker and blacker. You were there beside me, and you could not help me. I dared not tell you about it; I could only struggle on alone, so terribly alone, sometimes; and now I am beaten, beaten. And I come to you to ask you to help me in the only thing that remains to me. Help me, Catherine, to be an honest man--to follow conscience--to say and do the truth!"
"Robert," she said piteously, deadly pale, "I don"t understand."
"Oh, my poor darling!" he cried, with a kind of moan of pity and misery.
Then still holding her, he said, with strong deliberate emphasis, looking into the gray-blue eyes--the quivering face so full of austerity and delicacy,--
"For six or seven months, Catherine--really for much longer, though I never knew it--I have been fighting with _doubt_--doubt of orthodox Christianity--doubt of what the Church teaches--of what I have to say and preach every Sunday. First it crept on me I knew not how. Then the weight grew heavier, and I began to struggle with it. I felt I must struggle with it. Many men, I suppose, in my position would have trampled on their doubts--would have regarded them as sin in themselves, would have felt it their duty to ignore them as much as possible, trusting to time and G.o.d"s help. I _could_ not ignore them. The thought of questioning the most sacred beliefs that you and I"--and his voice faltered a moment--"held in common was misery to me. On the other hand, I knew myself. I knew that I could no more go on living to any purpose, with a whole region of the mind shut up, as it were, barred away from the rest of me, than I could go on living with a secret between myself and you. I could not hold my faith by a mere tenure of tyranny and fear.
Faith that is not free--that is not the faith of the whole creature, body, soul, and intellect--seemed to me a faith worthless both to G.o.d and man!"
Catherine looked at him stupefied. The world seemed to be turning round her. Infinitely more terrible than his actual words was the accent running through words and tone and gesture--the accent of irreparableness, as of something dismally _done_ and _finished_. What did it all mean? For what had he brought her there? She sat stunned, realising with awful force the feebleness, the inadequacy, of her own fears.
He, meanwhile, had paused a moment, meeting her gaze with those yearning sunken eyes. Then he went on, his voice changing a little,--
"But if I had wished it ever so much, I could not have helped myself.
The process, so to speak, had gone too far by the time I knew where I was. I think the change must have begun before the Mile End time.
Looking back, I see the foundations were laid in--in--the work of last winter."
She shivered. He stooped and kissed her hands again pa.s.sionately. "Am I poisoning even the memory of our past for you?" he cried. Then, restraining himself at once, he hurried on again: "After Mile End you remember I began to see much of the squire. Oh, my wife, don"t look at me so! It was not his doing in any true sense. I am not such a weak shuttlec.o.c.k as that! But being where I was before our intimacy began, his influence hastened everything. I don"t wish to minimise it. I was not made to stand alone!"
And again that bitter, perplexed, half-scornful sense of his own pliancy at the hands of circ.u.mstance as compared with the rigidity of other men descended upon him. Catherine made a faint movement as though to draw her hands away.
"Was it well," she said, in a voice which sounded like a harsh echo of her own, "was it right for a clergyman to discuss sacred things--with such a man?"
He let her hands go, guided for the moment by a delicate imperious instinct which bade him appeal to something else than love. Rising, he sat down opposite to her on the low window seat, while she sank back into her chair, her fingers clinging to the arm of it, the lamplight far behind deepening all the shadows of the face, the hollows in the cheeks, the line of experience and will about the mouth. The stupor in which she had just listened to him was beginning to break up. Wild forces of condemnation and resistance were rising in her; and he knew it. He knew, too, that as yet she only half realised the situation, and that blow after blow still remained to him to deal.
"Was it right that I should discuss religious matters with the squire?"
he repeated, his face resting on his hands. "What are religious matters, Catherine, and what are not?"
Then, still controlling himself rigidly, his eyes fixed on the shadowy face of his wife, his ear catching her quick uneven breath, he went once more through the dismal history of the last few months, dwelling on his state of thought before the intimacy with Mr. Wendover began, on his first attempts to escape the squire"s influence, on his gradual pitiful surrender. Then he told the story of the last memorable walk before the squire"s journey, of the moment in the study afterwards, and of the months of feverish reading and wrestling which had followed. Half-way through it a new despair seized him. What was the good of all he was saying? He was speaking a language she did not really understand. What were all these critical and literary considerations to her?
The rigidity of her silence showed him that her sympathy was not with him, that in comparison with the vibrating protest of her own pa.s.sionate faith which must be now ringing through her, whatever he could urge must seem to her the merest culpable trifling with the soul"s awful destinies. In an instant of tumultuous speech he could not convey to her the temper and results of his own complex training, and on that training, as he very well knew, depended the piercing, convincing force of all that he was saying. There were gulfs between them--gulfs which, as it seemed to him, in a miserable insight, could never be bridged again. Oh, the frightful separateness of experience!
Still he struggled on. He brought the story down to the conversation at the Hall, described--in broken words of fire and pain--the moment of spiritual wreck which had come upon him in the August lane, his night of struggle, his resolve to go to Mr. Grey. And all through he was not so much narrating as pleading a cause, and that not his own, but Love"s.
Love was at the bar, and it was for love that the eloquent voice, the pale varying face, were really pleading, through all the long story of intellectual change.
At the mention of Mr. Grey Catherine grew restless; she sat up suddenly, with a cry of bitterness.
"Robert, why did you go away from me? It was cruel. I should have known first. He had no right--no right!"
She clasped her hands round her knees, her beautiful mouth set and stern. The moon had been sailing westward all this time, and as Catherine bent forward the yellow light caught her face, and brought out the haggard change in it. He held out his hands to her with a low groan, helpless against her reproach, her jealousy. He dared not speak of what Mr. Grey had done for him, of the tenderness of his counsel towards her specially. He felt that everything he could say would but torture the wounded heart still more.
But she did not notice the outstretched hands. She covered her face in silence a moment, as though trying to see her way more clearly through the mazes of disaster; and he waited. At last she looked up.
"I cannot follow all you have been saying," she said, almost harshly. "I know so little of books, I cannot give them the place you do. You say you have convinced yourself the Gospels are like other books, full of mistakes, and credulous, like the people of the time; and therefore you can"t take what they say as you used to take it. But what does it all quite mean? Oh, I am not clever--I cannot see my way clear from thing to thing as you do. If there are mistakes, does it matter so--so--terribly to you?" and she faltered. "Do you think _nothing_ is true because something may be false? Did not--did not--Jesus still live, and die, and rise again?--_can_ you doubt--_do_ you doubt--that He rose--that He is G.o.d--that He is in heaven--that we shall see Him?"
She threw an intensity into every word, which made the short breathless questions thrill through him, through the nature saturated and steeped as hers was in Christian a.s.sociation, with a bitter accusing force. But he did not flinch from them.
"I can believe no longer in an Incarnation and Resurrection," he said slowly, but with a resolute plainness. "Christ is risen in our hearts, in the Christian life of charity. Miracle is a natural product of human feeling and imagination; and G.o.d was in Jesus--pre-eminently, as He is in all great souls, but not otherwise--not otherwise in kind than He is in me or you."
His voice dropped to a whisper. She grew paler and paler.
"So to you," she said presently in the same strange altered voice. "My father--when I saw that light on his face before he died, when I heard him cry, "Master, _I come!_" was dying--deceived--deluded. Perhaps even," and she trembled, "you think it ends here--our life--our love?"
It was agony to him to see her driving herself through this piteous catechism. The lantern of memory flashed a moment on to the immortal picture of Faust and Margaret. Was it not only that winter they had read the scene together?
Forcibly he possessed himself once more of those closely locked hands, pressing their coldness on his own burning eyes and forehead in hopeless silence.
"_Do_ you, Robert?" she repeated insistently.
"I know nothing," he said, his eyes still hidden. "I know nothing! But I trust G.o.d with all that is dearest to me, with our love, with the soul that is His breath, His work in us!"
The pressure of her despair seemed to be wringing his own faith out of him, forcing into definiteness things and thoughts that had been lying in an accepted, even a welcomed, obscurity.
She tried again to draw her hands away, but he would not let them go.
"And the end of it all, Robert?" she said--"the end of it?"
Never did he forget the note of that question, the desolation of it, the indefinable change of accent. It drove him into a harsh abruptness of reply.
"The end of it--so far--must be, if I remain an honest man, that I must give up my living, that I must cease to be a minister of the Church of England. What the course of our life after that shall be is in your hands--absolutely."
She caught her breath painfully. His heart was breaking for her, and yet there was something in her manner now which kept down caresses and repressed all words.
Suddenly, however, as he sat there mutely watching her, he found her at his knees, her dear arms around him, her face against his breast.
"Robert, my husband, my darling, it _cannot_ be! It is a madness--a delusion. G.o.d is trying you, and me! You cannot be planning so to desert Him, so to deny Christ--you cannot, my husband. Come away with me, away from books and work, into some quiet place where He can make Himself heard. You are overdone, overdriven. Do nothing now--say nothing--except to me. Be patient a little, and He will give you back Himself! What can books and arguments matter to you or me? Have we not _known_ and _felt_ Him as He is--have we not, Robert? Come!"
She pushed herself backwards, smiling at him with an exquisite tenderness. The tears were streaming down her cheeks. They were wet on his own. Another moment and Robert would have lost the only clue which remained to him through the mists of this bewildering world. He would have yielded again as he had many times yielded before, for infinitely less reason, to the urgent pressure of another"s individuality, and having jeopardised love for truth, he would now have murdered--or tried to murder--in himself the sense of truth for love.
But he did neither.
Holding her close pressed against him, he said in breaks of intense speech: "If you wish, Catherine, I will wait--I will wait till you bid me speak--but I warn you--there is something dead in me--something gone and broken. It can never live again--except in forms which now it would only pain you more to think of. It is not that I think differently of this point or that point--but of life and religion altogether. I see G.o.d"s purposes in quite other proportions as it were. Christianity seems to me something small and local. Behind it, around it--including it--I see the great drama of the world, sweeping on--led by G.o.d--from change to change, from act to act. It is not that Christianity is false, but that it is only an imperfect human reflection of a part of truth. Truth has never been, can never be, contained in any one creed or system!"