11,073. Have you had any case of as early a discharge in the case of a whaling voyage?-Here [showing] is the crew of the "Polynia"
last year. Nineteen men were landed on 26th October, and they were all paid off and discharged by 29th November, or in about a month. When the men don"t come to be discharged, it is entirely their own fault, not ours. We can"t compel them to come. We wish them to come as soon as possible and to settle; but sometimes they don"t find it convenient. Some of them may live 20 or 30 miles from Lerwick, and they don"t care about coming until they have to come deal about some other business.
11,074. Is it not often more than a month before they are discharged?-Perhaps it is. Two or three of them may stay away till the end of the year, but that is the men"s fault, not the agent"s. Mr. Hamilton says in the same paragraph: "When he (the agent) does pay to the man the balance of wages due to him before the superintendent, the man has no option but to hand it all back to the agent at once, to whom he is indebted in an equal or greater amount." I deny that. The man he may hand it back or not, as he chooses, but if he is an honest man he will pay his debt.
11,075. But you don"t deny that in most cases there is a debt due to the shop?-In most cases they have an account with the shop, but in some cases it is very small.
11,076. Can you give me an idea from your books what is the average amount of the debts due by the men engaged in the Greenland fishing?-I could not do that just now; but I can state that, in 1865,-which was before we were compelled to settle with them in the Custom House, we paid to the men of the "Camperdown"-42 men-1120, 12s. 3d. in cash; and out of that number Mr. Leask had only one tenant.
11,077. That would be about 25 apiece?-Yes, on an average; but some of these men had upwards of 50 to get. One of them had 54, 18s. 5d. to get, and he got it in cash.
11,078. Was that a very successful year?-Yes; and the following year was somewhat similar to it.
11,079. What would be the amount of goods supplied to these men at starting, or to their families during their absence?-About 400 for the whole crew.
11,080. That would be about 9 apiece for the 42 men?-Yes, about that.
11,081. Would that be the average amount of a Greenlandman"s account for the season?-No; it would be much more than the average. Less than the half of that would be nearer the average.
11,082. But the amount of receipts due upon that voyage was considerably above the average?-Yes; it was it very exceptional voyage.
11,083. Was it twice as much as usual?-Yes; perhaps about that.
11,084. Do you mean that 4 or 5 is the average amount of the account due by a seaman engaged in the whaling?-I never made any calculation about it but I should think it would be somewhere about that.
11,085. In what way are your accounts with these men kept? Is there an account kept in the name of each man?-Yes. [Produces book.] There [showing] is the account I have been referring to of the "Camperdown."
11,086. You have a ledger for each ship?-Yes.
11,087. And this account shows the whole transactions for 1865?-Yes.
11,088. This [showing] is the account of Hercules Hunter, Lerwick, who was engaged in the seal fishing of 1865 at 50s.
per month, and 2s. 6d. per ton of oil-money; 2s. 6d. per 1000 skins, and 2s. 6d. per ton of bone?-Yes.
11,089. The first entry on March 4, 1865, consists of two advances of 20s. each to account of his first month"s pay, and 3s. as his subscription to the Shipwrecked Mariners" Fund, for which Mr.
Leask was agent?-Yes.
11,090. The next entry is half of note to Mr. Hay for rent, 1, 18s.
11/2d. Had Mr. Leask undertaken to pay his rent?-Yes.
11,091. The following entries, to the amount of 2, 0s. 31/2d., are for outfit at starting, consisting both of clothing and private stores?-Yes.
11,092. Then follows-insurance, 5s. 10d.: what is that?-The insurance is on the outfit, and it is charged over and above the month"s advance. The advance is made by the owner of the ship; and what is over that is at risk, which is covered by insurance.
We get it done for them, and they refund the premium.
11,093 Do you employ a broker to effect an insurance on all your advances of that kind?-Yes.
11,094. Then the 5s. 10d. is the amount of insurance paid by you upon the sum of 3, 10s., which was the amount of cash and goods advanced to this man at the time of, or after, his sailing?-Yes.
11,095. There is also a balance of the old debt: was that not included in the insurance?-No.
11,096. On April 27 the man returns from his voyage and receives a payment in cash of 20s., with certain additional supplies; and on 28th April you enter to his credit the sum of 30, 8s. 4d. for wages, oil-money, and skin-money due to him upon that voyage?-Yes; that is the first payment.
11,097. His account runs on from 2d May till 4th December of the same year, when it is settled, during which time he has been upon a whaling voyage?-Yes.
11,098. At the commencement of that voyage on 2d May he receives 5 in cash?-Yes; that is to account of oil-money.
11,099. On 8th May he receives 5 in cash; on 16th May, 3; November 1, 3s.; November 18, 2s.; and on November 1 also there is 1, 16s. entered as having been paid at Dundee: that would be advanced by the shipowners there?-Yes.
11,100. On November 22d he receives 8 in cash, and a balance was paid on December 4 of 18, 8s.?-Yes.
11,101. The rest of the debits in that account consist of supplies for himself during the voyage in the captain"s account and supplies to his family of meal, sugar, soap, tea, and other items; and the total amount of his credit for wages, oil-money, bone-money, for the two voyages, was 58, 19s. 2d.?-Yes.
11,102. In that case the settlement took place in December?-Yes, the final settlement.
11,103. The whaling voyage would come to an end in November?-Yes, not sooner; so that the man had only been at home about a month when he was settled with.
11,104. But during all that time you had in your hands the proceeds of his first successful sealing voyage?-Yes, except what he had got. I think he got 19 in cash out of the 30, besides his goods up to the 16th May.
11,105. And the balance of 11 remained in your hands as a security for the advances he was getting up to the settlement in December?-Yes.
11,106. Then, on November 20, he was credited with the additional sums due for the whaling voyage, amounting to 28, 4s. 10d.; so that, in addition to supplying him with goods, upon which you had your profit you were, during all that time acting as his banker?-No; he had got 19 to account by 16th May.
11,107. But to the extent of 11 you were acting as his banker?- Yes.
11,108. And he was not getting interest for it?-I think he should have paid interest.
11,109. Not when you had 11 of his in your hands?-No; but we charged him no interest when we advanced him more.
[Page 272]
11,110. But you charged insurance upon the goods he got, and you had your profit upon the goods?-Yes; but we had to lie out of the money, for some time. We might have lain out of that money for eight or nine months.
11,111. Had you sold him these goods at a cash price, and not at a credit price?-At a cash price; we have only one price. We make no difference between cash and credit.
11,112. Was the oil-money that is credited to the man on 20th November the first payment of oil-money?-It was the first payment of oil-money for the Davis Straits voyage.
11,113. When was the second payment of oil-money made?-It is credited on 19th February 1866.
11,114. It only amounted to 15s.?-Yes. I don"t believe that we had received the first money at the time when we paid the man, so that we had no money on hand.
11,115. Take the case, now, of a man living in the country, George Georgeson in Walls. He receives, in like manner, on 4th March, 2, 13s. in cash, and he gets supplies, and is debited with insurance in the same way. On April 27 he has the same amount to receive for the sealing voyage, and on May 17 he gets 12,10s.
in cash; on September 9, 1 per order: was that an allotment note?-It was money to account.
11,116. It would be advanced to his wife upon the security of the voyage?-Yes.
11,117. On November 20 there is 5; and 1, 6s. for cash at Dundee and Aberdeen. He is credited with the same amount of wages as Hunter, and on December 4 he is credited with second payment for the sealing voyage 3, 15s. Then, on December 26, he receives 28, 2s. 6d. in cash; and the rest of his debits consist of supplies to his family in sugar, tea, aqua, canvas, and other small article, but to a very small extent. I suppose the supplies taken out in that way by people living out of Lerwick are usually less than in the case of those who live in town?-Yes. It costs them both expense and trouble to get them from Lerwick.
11,118. There is also the case of James t.w.a.tt, Sandness, who is debited on March 4 with 2, 3s. to advance; and then on March 4 and 9 he gets supplies to the amount of 3, 38. 71/2d., upon which there is charged 6s. 51/2d. of insurance. On April 27, on his return from the sealing voyage he gets 20s. in cash, and he is credited with 20, 10s., for wages, oil-money, and skin-money?-Yes; I think he was only at the sealing voyage.