[Page 305]
12,337. Did you think these restrictions were such that the people might reasonably complain of them?-I thought they had not much to complain of.
12,338. At that time the lease of Messrs. Hay & Co. was within a year or two of its termination?-Yes. I think it was the last year of it.
12,339. The letter was dated 5th April 1869, and think the lease expired in November following. Has it been renewed since?-No.
The tack has been continued on the old plan for two years, as a sort of intermediate arrangement. There is just a missive which expires in November next. Indeed I had some difficulty in getting Messrs. Hay to renew the arrangement, even for two years.
12,340. Were they unwilling to resume their liability for the rents upon the same terms?-Yes. The reason they gave to me was, that the great bulk of the people were fishing where they chose, and that they did not have much profit by the island.
12,341. Do you mean in the ling fishing, or in the Faroe fishing?- I mean in the fishings generally. There were only a few old men remaining at home for the fishings, and it was not a great deal of the produce of the island that they had anything to do with.
12,342. Do Messrs. Hay pay the tack duty annually or half-yearly to the proprietors?-Half-yearly.
12,343. The tenants, I suppose, as is usual in Shetland, pay only once a year?-Yes, they pay in November.
12,344. If the proprietors were taking the ground into their own hands, is it probable they would require the tenants to pay half-yearly, or has that been in your contemplation?-The money would require to be raised half-yearly, because it has to be paid half-yearly. There are heavy liabilities such as interest on bonds to be paid out of it every half-year, and the money must be raised for that purpose.
12,345. Do you believe it to be possible for the tenants in Havera, or on such an island, to pay their rents half-yearly?-I don"t think such a system would work. Spring and summer is the time when they earn their money to pay their rents with, and we would not be able to collect the rents at Whitsunday from the tenants.
12,346. Are you aware whether the tacksmen of Burra interfere with the tenants in the sale of their cattle hosiery, or eggs?-I know they do not interfere with them in that way.
12,347. Are you aware whether the tacksmen insist on the tenants taking their supplies from their shops at Scalloway or Lerwick?-I am sure they do not. n.o.body ever alleged that to me.
12,348. Would you as trustee for the proprietors, object to such a restriction?-Certainly.
12,349. Are you the factor on the estate?-I am trustee. I have to collect the money from the property, and pay the burdens, and account to the ladies for the residue.
12,350. Do you suppose the Burra islanders would be benefited by the establishment of shops in Burra by the tacksmen?-I don"t think that would be any particular benefit to them.
12,351. Is there a population there to support shops?-Not shops.
12,352. Or a shop?-I daresay a shop might pay; but I don"t think it would be any advantage to the people. They are so near to Scalloway that a shop in Burra would only get a portion of the custom of the island.
12,353. Do you think the Burra men have an opportunity of purchasing their goods at other shops than Messrs. Hay & Co."s?- Certainly; they don"t deal exclusively with them. They can buy their goods where they like and I think they divide their custom very much.
12,354. Where else do they buy?-In the other Scalloway shops and in Lerwick.
12,355. Did you ascertain that in the course of the inquiry which you made in 1869?-It is a fact well known to me from my intercourse with the people, I am meeting them every month, not on the island, but elsewhere.
12,356. Do they tell you that they purchase their goods elsewhere than from Messrs. Hay & Co.?-I never put the question to them, because I was quite aware of their dealings being divided. A great many of the men are fishing to smack owners in Lerwick, and probably have a good deal of their dealings with the merchants they fish to.
12,357. Are some of them in your own Faroe vessels?-Yes, we have two or three.
12,358. Is that your reason for believing that they are not confined in their dealings to the shops of Messrs. Hay & Co.?-I know that to be a fact, from various circ.u.mstances.
12,359. But you know it from the circ.u.mstance that they are engaged in fishing to other merchants?-No; that does not follow.
12,360. It does not follow as a necessary consequence that they do not deal with Messrs. Hay & Co. but it is a reasonable presumption, that if they are fishing to another merchant they get some of their supplies from his shop?-Certainly.
12,361. Are you prepared to say that the bulk of the dealings of the Burra men is not at Messrs. Hay"s shops?-I should think that much more than one half of their dealings must be with other people. That is speaking of the whole population of the island, and including those men who go to Faroe.
12,362. Are the greater number of the men in Burra engaged in the Faroe fishing?-There are more of them engaged in the Faroe fishing than in any other.
12,363. And more on an average than in other districts in Shetland?-Yes. They have taken to that kind of fishing more readily than others.
12,364. How, does it happen that they have taken to it?-I don"t know; I suppose it is just from their position, and their early training in boats. They take to a good fishing rather than to the Greenland trade. They are generally good fishermen. Taking them as a cla.s.s, they are better fishermen than in any other district that I know of in Shetland.
12,365. Would it be a reasonable presumption to suppose that they had taken to the Faroe fishing in order to avoid the restrictions which are laid upon them with regard to the ling fishing?- Certainly not. These young men would not have remained at home about the sh.o.r.e fishing. If they had not gone to Faroe they would have gone to the merchant service or to Greenland.
12,366. Do you think the restriction had anything at all to do with it?-Nothing whatever.
12,367. But you ascertained in the course of your inquiries, and you know now, that there is a restriction by the terms of their leases upon the Burra men with regard to the ling fishing?-Yes, they hold their land under condition that they are to deliver their fish to Messrs, Hay.
12,368. Your largest shop is at Reawick, and you have also two small ones at Foula and Sandness?-Yes.
12,369. Do most of the fishermen engaged in the ling fishing usually deal at one or other of the stores you have mentioned?- Yes; there is no other store near.
12,370. Do you mean that there is no other store near Reawick?- No. I thought you referred to the two smaller shops. All the men get the whole of their supplies from our stores there.
12,371. At Sandness and Foula there are no other stores within reach of the fishermen residing there?-No.
12,372. Is there any restriction upon the opening of other shops in Foula, or on the sale of goods there by any other party who chooses to attempt that?-As acting for the proprietor, I don"t think we would allow it. We would not allow small shops in either of these districts if we could help it.
12,373. Would you allow a trader from Scalloway or Lerwick to sell goods out of his smack there?-Yes; and I have known instances of them going there from [Page 306] Walls and Scalloway. There is no restriction upon the like of that.
12,374. Are the inhabitants sometimes supplied with meal and articles of dress and provisions by other merchants from the mainland?-The Foula people, annually, when their fishing is over, come to the mainland, and they can then lay in what supplies they are in need of.
12,375. Do they come in every year themselves?-Not the whole of them, but many of them do.
12,376. Do you know whether or not any traders visit the islands for the purpose of selling provisions or goods?-No; they have not done that lately. They could have no object in going there.
12,377. Why?-Because they could not compete with us. We have a shop there for the supply of goods, and we supply them to the people on as moderate terms as other parties could do.
Therefore the men have no object in dealing elsewhere.
12,378. I suppose it would be a very small trade that could be driven with 40 families?-Yes, rather.
12,379. But I presume you consider it fair that, as you supply these families year by year, and are in a sense responsible that their supply shall not run short, you should in return have the bulk of their business?-They may go where they choose.
12,380. But would you continue to supply them if you did not have the bulk of their dealings?-No, we would not keep a shop there if we did not have the bulk of their dealings; it would not be worth our while. I may explain that, a few years ago, some of the young men wished to cure their own fish, and go out with them to the mainland. There was a little discussion amongst them about it, and we put it to them whether they would wish to have that liberty or not and in order to ascertain their views, we sent in a paper to the schoolmaster, and asked him, to circulate it among the men.
[The witness put in a doc.u.ment in the following terms, signed in the affirmative by 65 men:-
"Garriock & Co., who have for the last fourteen years kept a curing establishment on the island of Foula, and found the undivided produce small enough to pay for the trouble and risk of it, while furnishing the necessaries of life, fishing material, etc., at ordinary rates, would, now that some parties have shown an inclination and even begun to cure their own fish, wish to ascertain the views of the people as to whether they desire G. & Co. to continue their establishment as before; or would they prefer each to cure as it suits him, and provide his necessaries as he can? Whilst there is always the most perfect freedom to all to fish, labour, and sell their produce in what appears to them the best market, the isolated position of the island appears to require that one system be followed by all.
"The heads of families and other fishermen will therefore please indicate their views by subscribing below, adding yes if the former system be preferred; or no if otherwise.-1867."]
12,381. Were there any negatives to the paper?-No. It created