13,029. Did you pay as much higher a price for cod and tusk?- No. We paid 7s. for cod and tusk, and I understand the current price of the country has been 6s. 6d. We paid 4s. 3d. for saith, and I understand the current price has been 4s.
13,030. Do you generally pay as much above the current price as you have done last year?-No, not as general thing.
13,031. Can you a.s.sign any reason for your price this year being so much higher?-No, I cannot a.s.sign any particular reason.
13,032. Is it not in order that you may get as many fishermen as you require?-The great reason is to try to please the fishermen as far as possible; and in our quarter they are very bad to please.
13,033. Why do you want to please them?-To get them to fish for us. We are anxious to have as many fishermen as possible. There is one thing which enables Mr. Tulloch and I to pay somewhat higher prices than the currency; which is, that our curing places are very near to ourselves, and we can always see the curing carried on, and can cure cheaper.
13,034. Do any of the fishermen in your district cure for themselves?-Yes.
13,035. Do you buy from them?-Sometimes. They sell to us if they choose.
13,036. Do you think the fish which they cure are as good as yours?-Not unless they have a factor. When they cure them by their own hands they are never so good.
13,037. What do you mean by them having a factor?-A man set over the fish to look after the curing of them, the same as I have.
13,038. Do the fishermen who cure for themselves have a factor?-Yes; the men at our place have a man to whom they pay so much per ton per every ton of dried fish which are produced.
13,039. In that case, where the fishermen agree to employ a factor, do you think the curing is as well done as it is by you?-It is, when they get an experienced man for the purpose.
[Page 323]
13,040. In that case do the men club together in order to buy implements, vats, and other things for curing?-Yes.
13,041. It is it sort of co-operative system?-Yes.
13,042. Do you do anything in hosiery?-No.
13,043. Do you buy eggs, and pay for them in goods?-Yes.
13,044. Are the prices of the goods in your shop the same as in Mr.
Tulloch"s?-They are generally the same.
13,045. What is the price of meal at present?-Scotch oatmeal is 20s. a boll, or 5s. a quarter; Shetland meal is only 3s. or 3s. 6d.
13,046. Is the Shetland oatmeal of much inferior quality?-As a general thing, it is much inferior. There is not much of it sold.
The people generally use their own meal, and it is much to be regretted that they require a great deal more than what they can grow.
13,047. Do you think you could manage to pay your people, without much inconvenience, as the fish are landed?-I think I might manage that, but I don"t think it would be for the public good. In the first place, the fishermen would not be able to get the fishing articles and the quant.i.ty of meal they require before the fishing commenced, because they would not have money to pay for them. Another reason is, that if they had the money they don"t very well know how to manage it, and it would be spent before rent time came. Then, if they had no money, the landlord would have to go and take their corn or their cattle and roup them in order to get his rent, and the people would be losers.
13,048. Do you think one advantage of the present system is, that it carries the men through a bad year?-Yes. Last year we had a very good fishing, but the majority of them had their rents to get. For as few fishermen as I have, I had to advance them in order to help them to pay their rents.
13,049. Do you sometimes pay their rents for them?-I do so, as a general thing. It is expected that the fish-merchant will not see them at a loss; but, of course, if a ready-money system was introduced, they could not look to the fish-merchant for any help.
13,050. Why should they not look to him then?-If I only had the men engaged from voyage to voyage, or from week to week, and did not have the advantage of knowing that they were to fish for me next year, it could not be expected that I would advance them 140 to help them in paying their rents for this year.
13,051. But perhaps they would not need it if they were in the habit of getting their money?-In my opinion, they would need it more than they do now.
13,052. Have not other people than fishermen sometimes to pay rents?-Yes.
13,053. And they manage to have it in hand when the rent day comes?-Yes; but these people, as a general rule, have bigger farms, and cattle and ponies that they sell, and that helps them on with their rents.
13,054. But there are rents to be paid by people who have small farms, or no farms at all; and if they manage to gather up for their rent day, might not the fishermen do so as well?-They might do so; but in our quarter-and I can only speak for it-the great majority of the people have enough to do when there is a good season, and when there is a bad one they are far short.
13,055. Then I suppose the reason which you are now a.s.signing for keeping up the present system is rounded upon your opinion, that the people of Shetland are less careful and less sensible than people of the same cla.s.s in other parts of Scotland?-I don"t believe they are less sensible than the fishermen or men of the same cla.s.s elsewhere. I believe there are as competent men in Shetland, as a general rule, as in any other part of Scotland; but the fishing is a very fluctuating piece of business, and I think that very often they could not manage to save up money for their rent if there was a cash system. Of course there are differences among them. There are some men in our quarter who are laying past money, while there are others who are overhead in debt, in spite of all that can be done for them.
13,056. I understand you have been frequently at Fair Isle?-I think it is about six or seven years since I was there last, but I was very often there before. I had a small vessel of my own, and I went to the Isle to barter goods with the people. I bartered them for cash, not for fish.
13,057. Did you go there every year for some time?-I went three or four times in some years, and I continued going for seven or eight years.
13,058. Did you go as a private speculation of your own?-Yes.
13,059. What kind of goods did you take?-Tea, sugar, tobacco and cottons.
13,060. Was there any particular reason for giving up that trade?- No; I was getting tired of it.
13,061. Did you find it a hazardous sort of thing?-It was very much so: I ran many a risk of losing my life. It was an open vessel, without a deck, that I went in, and in the winter time the coast there is very dangerous.
13,062. Was the market open at that time at Fair Isle?-Generally in the winter time it was.
13,063. Was it not open in the summer time also?-Not so much, because the man who had it in tack generally supplied the fishermen at that time with their stores and meal. I made one or two trips there with meal, because the people sent for me to bring it, as their master could not get their meal forwarded so quickly from Orkney as they required it.
13,064. Who was the tacksman then?-John Hughson from Orkney.
13,065. Have you been there since he ceased to be tacksman?- Never.
13,066. Was your trade with the Fair Isle people objected to by him?-He never objected to me.
13,067. Did he object to any one else?-Not to my knowledge.
13,068. Then you could trade with the people as much as you pleased?-Yes; there was no restriction whatever. I very often spoke with Mr. Hughson himself.
13,069. Did you stop at the time when Hughson ceased to be tacksman?-I was almost giving up the trade before he ceased to be tacksman. His time was not quite run out the last time I was there.
13,070. Who succeeded Mr. Hughson as tacksman?-Mr. John Bruce, jun., of Sumburgh.
13,071. You have not been there since he became tacksman?- Never as a trader. I was there once when a ship was wrecked on the Seil. I have made a mistake there: I have been once at the island trading since Mr. Bruce bought it, and I had full liberty from him to go.
13,072. Did you get express permission from him?-Yes.
13,073. When was that?-I don"t remember; it may have been four or five years ago.
13,074. Why did you ask permission?-He wished me to go in with goods to the people, and I told him I did not like to go with freight there unless he would allow me to trade for myself; and then he gave me full liberty.
13,075. Was Mr. Bruce not sending a vessel of his own at that time?-He could not get a vessel to go. It is such a nasty coast for inexperienced men, that it is difficult to get men to venture there.
13,076. You agreed to go only on condition that you had the trade in your own hands?-Yes; and I had his freight in the meantime.