13,409. Were you entrusted with that cotton to sell it?-Yes. I got about 50 worth of cloth and furnishings about five years age to supply to such tenants as had not the means to go to any other place; and although the prices of cotton and wincies fluctuated since I have continued to sell at the same price. Of course most of it is gone now.
13,410. But you have been selling it at that advanced price?-Yes.
The fishermen have taken it who had no other way of getting it.
13,411. Have they taken it on credit?-Yes; most of it has been given on credit. There were very few who have taken any of it except those who had no money to go to any other place.
13,412. If they had had money, would they have been able to get exactly the same article at a cheaper rate?-The cloth was pretty moderate, because, when I brought it from Grutness, Mr. Bruce asked me how it would range with the cloth Mr. Henderson had. I told him it was dearer, and he said he would take off some of the price of it, for he meant to give the fishermen the same advantage which they got in another shop; and the three pieces of cloth which I got were reduced 1s. upon each yard. In that case no one complained about the price of the cloth, only the furnishings were higher.
[Page 334]
13,413. Is there any other article with regard to the price and quality of which you can speak?-I have not dealt in Grutness for some time, because I generally had money, and I bought my goods elsewhere, where might get them cheaper. I got most of them from Mr. Henderson, and some I got from Lerwick.
13,414. Do you sometimes buy from Hay & Co."s, shop at Dunrossness?-Yes,
13,415. Are some things cheaper there than at Grutness?-Some things are and other things are much about the same.
13,416. What things are cheaper?-Tea and sugar, and such things as these.
13,417. Is Hay & Co."s shop nearer to you than Grutness?-Yes.
13,418. Is it nearer to most of the people than Grutness?-Yes.
Grutness is rather out of the way.
13,419. Do you know anything about a meeting that was held at Grutness, some time ago?-I know there was a meeting of fishermen held at the schoolhouse but I was not there. After the meeting several of the men came to my house on their way home, and spoke about what had taken place. They were generally dissatisfied with the way in which the meeting had been conducted.
13,420. What was the occasion of the meeting?-It was in order that they might lay their grievances before the commissioner at Lerwick. I believe one of the men actually went there.
13,421. Did you understand that the others were unwilling or afraid to go?-I understood, from what they said, that they were unwilling, for fear of offending their masters. They told me that at the time.
13,422. What did they say?-They accused some of their number of cowardice. Some were frightened for one thing, and some for another.
13,423. What were they afraid of?-Just of offending their masters; that was their princ.i.p.al idea. They were afraid they might be warned.
13,424. What was the complaint they had to make?-I believe their princ.i.p.al complaint was about the bondage which they are under.
13,425. Do you think they have not so much to say about being settled with only once a year?-Of course that was discussed too and they thought it was not right. They thought the settlement was made too late in the year. That was one of their objections; but the princ.i.p.al thing was, that they wished their liberty to sell their produce to any person who would pay the best price for it.
13,426. Have you lived in Dunrossness all your life?-I have been in Dunrossness all my life except twelve years, when I was south.
13,427. Was your father a farmer or crofter and fisherman in Dunrossness?-Yes.
13,428. Before Mr. Bruce took the fishing into his own hands, I believe, the tenants were free?-No; the fishermen were bound some forty-three years ago. My father held a croft then on the estate of Brough, of which Mrs. Sinclair was proprietor, and she bound him over to fish for Mr. Bruce at that time, although she did not take the fishing herself. That fishing came to be the most ruinous concern that ever happened to my family, because it brought my father into debt that he might otherwise have been clear of.
13,429. How did it bring him into debt?-Because the fish were not managed properly, and of course they came to be sold as bad fish, and the men got nothing for them, or next to nothing. I heard my father say that they got 3s. 11d. for dry fish in the last year of the fishing, and they had to pay for salt and cure out of that.
13,430. Could a free man, at that time have got more?-A free man was getting from 9 to 10 a ton; and things came to such a pa.s.s that the people got desperate. There were poor years at the same time, and the men applied to their landlord, and got their liberty on condition of paying 15s. a head of liberty money. That was kept on until a few years ago, and then it was put into the rent again.
13,431. But it has only been since 1860 that the men have been bound again to fish in this district for their landlord; they were free before that time?-Yes, they were free for about twenty years. Of course I have always been a free man, because I have not been a fisherman.
13,432. Have you known many men in your district being warned in consequence of fishing for others than their landlord?-I have not known many.
13,433. Have you known men who would have fished for others if they had not been afraid of being warned?-I suppose they would have preferred that but warning comes to be a very serious thing here. In the south a man can shift from town to town and get employment: but here, if he leaves his house and farm, he has no place to go to except Lerwick, and there is no room to be got there, either for love or money.
13,434. Do you know of any case where compulsion has been used to oblige any of the men to deal at any of the stores in the district?-I cannot say that I have.
13,435. Do the men never get a hint to that effect?-No; but I suppose they are obliged to go through necessity, because they have no money with which to go anywhere else.
Boddam, Dunrossness, January 26, 1872, GEORGE M"LACHLAN, examined.
13,436. Are you the princ.i.p.al lightkeeper at Sumburgh Lighthouse?-I am.
13,437. Where do you get the supplies for your house?-I get most of them from Aberdeen and Granton.
13,438. Do you purchase them yourself?-Yes.
13,439. They are not supplied by the Commissioners?-no.
13,440. Have you got any supplies at the neighbouring shops?-I have got very little from Grutness.
13,441. Have you got any from Hay & Co."s shop, from Quendale?-No. I opened an account with Mr. Henderson after I came; but I have only been here since 1st. July.
13,442. Have you found Mr. Henderson"s goods reasonable in price?-Quite reasonable in price, and good in quality.
13,443. How far is his shop from you?-About six or six and a half miles.
13,444. How far is Grutness from you?-About one and a quarter mile, or a little more.
13,445. How far is Hay & Co."s shop?-About two and a quarter miles.
13,446. How far is Quendale from you?-I think about four miles.
13,447. Why do you go so far as Mr Henderson"s or Aberdeen, or Granton for your supplies?-I opened an account at Mr Henderson"s shop, because I could get anything there that I wished, and because Mr. Henderson was highly recommended to me before I came to the country at all.
13,448. Have you found the supplies at Grutness to be expensive?-I never bought much there.
13,449. Did you find that that shop was understood in the neighbourhood to be an expensive one?-I have heard people say so.
13,450. Was that the reason why you did not get your goods there?-Not particularly. One reason was because it was dear, and another reason was that they cannot supply us with general articles such as we want. I thought it was much better to open an account with man who was reasonable in his charges, or who at least was recommended to me as such, and a man who could supply me with anything I wanted.
13,451. What have you bought at Grutness or at the other shops?- Sometimes I have bought small things such as tobacco, but my wife has got most of the things we required.
13,452. Have you bought any tobacco at Hay & Co."s?-Yes. I found it to be of ordinary quality. I think [Page 335] the price was 4s. 4d. per lb., as far as I can recollect but I am not quite sure, because I never bought much there. I could have got tobacco of about the same quality at Mr. Henderson"s for 3s. 6d. I now produce a piece of Mr. Henderson"s very good tobacco.,
13,453. Have you bought tobacco at Grutness also?-Only very little. I don"t like the sort of tobacco that is kept there. There are two kinds kept at Grutness: but the best quality is too small in twist for smoking, and I don"t care about teasing it up.
Boddam, Dunrossness, January 26, 1872, LAWRENCE GARRIOCK, examined.