1811. Is it not rather a favour to you that the merchant gives you money when you ask it?-I don"t know whether it is a favour to me, but I always get it when I ask it. But I don"t have such a great run of shawls as some of the other women have.
1812. It is rather out of your ordinary way to be selling shawls?- Yes; but when I do make one and ask money, I get it.
1813. Have you ever got the whole price of a shawl in money?- Yes.
1814. From the whole of merchants you have named?-No, only from Mr. Johnston; and that was for a country girl, because she was in need of it.
1815. That was a case in which you went out of your usual way, because the girl required it?-Yes.
1816. Have you asked the whole money from any of the other merchants?-No, I never did.
1817. You have only asked a part of it in money?-Yes.
1818. On a shawl worth 25s. that you were selling for yourself or for a girl, how much might you, in a general way, ask in money?- I have got as high as 10s. or 7s. 6d. or 5s., just as I asked it.
1819. But you never thought of asking the whole price of it in money?-No; but I was always requiring something that the merchants had to give me.
1820. Supposing you had a shawl to sell, would you give it to a merchant for a lower price if he paid it down in cash, than if he paid you in goods for it?-Yes; if I was requiring the cash, I would.
1821. Would you not do it in any case?-I would be glad of the money, certainly.
1822. Do you think it would be worth while for the knitters, as a rule, to take a less price for their shawls and to get money for them, rather than to go on in the present way?-I don"t know about that. For my own part, I should like if the people were to get part of both-both money and articles. n.o.body can live without articles; and it is just as well to get them from the merchants who buy our shawls, as to get the money.
1823. But if the merchants did pay all the price of the shawls in money, it would just come back to them, because, as you say very truly, people cannot do without some of the merchants" goods, and the money would return to them in payment for their goods. Don"t you think, that would be a better system for all parties than the present?-Those who need money would like to get it; but some people don"t stand so much in need of money as others. For instance, if I were knitting shawls only, I would need most of the price in money, because I have no other way of living but I don"t mean to say that girls who work merely for the sake of getting clothing, require to get the whole price in money.
1824. But suppose they got all the price of their work in money, might it not be easier for them to make the purchases of the goods they require?-They would not get so much for their shawls then; they could not expect it.
1825. That is because the merchant makes a profit upon the goods he sells, as well as upon the shawls?-Yes.
1826. Are you aware whether it is a common thing in Lerwick, to sell shawls cheaper for money than they would be given for goods?-Yes, any person who required money would rather sell a shawl for 1s. or 2s. less, in order to get it.
1827. Have you often seen that done?-Yes.
1828. Have you often done that yourself on behalf of the country girls?-Yes.
1829. You mentioned a case where you got the whole price of a shawl in money from Mr. Johnston: did you, in that case, say you would give it for 2s. or 3s. less if you could get the whole price in money?-Yes; because the girl required it, and told me to do that.
She wanted the money to pay her rent with.
1830. Was the price you got a fair price for the shawl?-It was at that time.
1831. Is there anything else you wish to say on this subject?-I have only to say that I think the girls ought to be very thankful to the merchants, for they have done more for them than any one in the place has done yet. They have bought their work, and then they have gone and distributed it throughout the country. This knitted work is not worn here; but the merchants have got a market for it, and therefore I think the girls ought to be very grateful to them.
[Page 36]
1832. Do you think they would not have got a market for their goods themselves?-No; plenty of them would never have been able to have gone to the market, even if they had thought of it.
1833. How long is it since that trade became general here?-I can hardly tell; I was a little girl when it began. The first shawl I made I got 7s. 6d. for, and I was very proud of it.
1834. How much would you get for that now?-They would not buy such a thing now, the work was so open. I can just recollect of it. I don"t think I was much more than ten years at the time. I sold it to Mr. Harrison, and he and Mr. Laurenson were about the first who began to buy them. We got groceries and everything we wanted then for our shawls.
1835. You do not get these things now, because the merchants who buy the shawls don"t have them?-They have them all except groceries.
1836. With regard to the girls in town who sell the shawls to merchants and get only goods in return, how do they do for a living?-Some girls live with their parents, and can do very well.
1837. But a number of them live in rooms by themselves, and perhaps have a parent or some other person to support out of their earnings: how do they generally do for their food?-I can hardly answer that. I don"t know how they do; but I know that some of the girls that I am in the habit of dressing the shawls for, come and tell me they have sold a shawl today, and what they got for it, and that they have got some money. Some of the merchants give them money, and some of them tea, and worsted to knit another shawl with; and that is just money.
1838. But if they have to make shawl with the worsted, they cannot turn it into provisions?-No; but they will make another shawl.
1839. And they may get 1s. or 2s. in money?-Yes.
1840. But if they only get 1s. or 2s. on each shawl, that is not sufficient either to pay their house rent or to supply them with provisions?-No; but I think there are some of them who may get a shawl sold for all money, and then that pays the rent.
1841. They do happen to get that occasionally?-Yes; some lady who wants one for a present to a friend might buy it from them.
That is the only way I can think of in which they can get their provisions; but if it was the case that the merchants had groceries in their shops, people would not require very much money, and then they would get their livelihood.
1842. What kind of goods do you generally get for your country girls in exchange for their shawls?-I do not buy them; they buy them for themselves.
1843. You get lines, and they choose the goods for themselves when they next come to town?-Yes.
1844. In that way you do not know what they get?-No; but I always hear them say that they got very good bargains, and they are generally well pleased.
1845. You say shawls are sometimes sold to a lady or gentleman pa.s.sing through the town; I suppose, in that case, there will be two prices for them?-No.
1846. Would you ask from them the same price that you get from the merchant in goods?-We might ask it, but, seeing the money, we might give the shawl for less. Some people don"t ask to have the price reduced, but others do.
1847. You just make the best bargain you can, in each case?-Yes.
Lerwick, January 3, 1872, Mrs. ELIZABETH MOODIE, examined.
1848. Are you in the habit of knitting for any one in Lerwick?- Yes; for Mr. Sinclair.
1849. Has any one asked you to come and give evidence here to-day?-Yes; I was summoned.
1850. Did any one ask you besides that?-No.
1851. Do you knit with your own wool, or is it with wool supplied to you by Mr. Sinclair?-Partly both, I generally have a shawl of my own in hand, but I always knit for Mr. Sinclair.
1852. Do you keep a pa.s.s-book?-No; I never had a pa.s.s-book with him.
1853. Are you paid in the same way both for your own shawls that you sell, and for those that you knit for him?-No; generally when I knit a shawl for Mr. Sinclair, he allows me so much for the knitting of it; but when I sell a shawl, I price it myself.
1854. Is that price paid in the same way that the wages are paid to you for knitting?-No.
1855. Is it paid to you in money in both cases; or in goods?-It is paid in goods in both cases.
1856. Is there not a certain part of it, in both cases, that you can get money for?-Yes. When I knitted for Mr. Sinclair before I was married, he generally gave me money whenever I asked for it; but since I had a house of my own, I generally manage my affairs so that I do not have to ask him for money. I usually take clothes for my children and myself from him without getting money at all; but if I did ask him for money, I have no doubt he would give it to me.
1857. Have you always got money when you asked for it?-Yes; whenever I asked I got it.