14,147. Is there a different price when it is paid for in cash?-Mr.
Sutherland manages that matter; but I am pretty sure that he pays only 4s. in cash, and anybody can get that who chooses.
14,148. But I suppose most of them take it in goods-Many of them do. It is it very convenient way for them, and the goods are not charged any higher in consequence, but we consider that the profit on the goods enables us to give a higher price.
14,149. How many of the women may be employed in that way?- Perhaps about sixty, taking it as a rough guess.
14,150. All these people, I presume, have accounts open at the shop at Vidlin, as I have seen to be the case in other parts of Shetland?-Yes. We would be very glad if the accounts were less, but really it is impossible to work with the people without them. It is almost impossible to get the balances brought down, but we never refuse them cash when they have it to get.
14,151. Do you purchase wool to any extent?-No, I don"t do anything in the hosiery line.
14,152. Do you think it would be possible to carry on the fish-curing business here profitably without combining it with the other business in the shop at Vidlin?-I don"t see how it could be done.
14,153. But supposing it could be done,-supposing the people could get their supplies elsewhere,-would the fish-curer be able to carry on his business at profit?-All they would do in that case would merely be to take a commission, as they now do, for selling the fish. They calculate upon getting that commission at present, and that is what they would expect under another system; but the people unfortunately cannot do without these supplies. Some of the men, however, are well off. For instance, the man Laurence Simpson, who was examined today, is very well off and can do without advances. He can buy his meal wherever he chooses.
14,154. Would it be a profitable thing for the fish-curer if he were content with that commission, without having a profit on his goods?-Perhaps that might be done, but I don"t know.
14,155. Is there any other point you wish to mention?-I have heard some of the men who have been examined here, saying that they would like their freedom. I have no objection to any man having his freedom and being allowed to cure his fish for himself, but I suspect such a system would destroy the character of the fish in the country if it were gone into. The fish would be injured by it; I know that by experience. The cure would not be so good as it is at present.
14,156. But if the men had their freedom, would they not employ a factor for themselves or would it not come to this in the end, that the men would sell their fish to any curer who was most convenient for them?-Many of them would cure their own fish, which they do now in some places, but we never can get the quality of the fish good enough when they are cured in that way.
They cannot be put in among fine fish, because the men do not dry them so well as they ought to be, and they will not keep for any length of time.
14,157. Would they not very soon find that out, and either employ a fish-factor for the curing of their fish upon the co-operative system, or return virtually to the present system and sell their fish to any merchant who would take them, with the exception that he would pay for them in ready money?-I am afraid any change of that kind would affect the quality of the fish.
14,158. But if it affected the quality of the fish, the men would soon find that they did not get so good a price for them?-Yes.
14,159. And they would either return to the old system, or to some one under which the curing of the fish would be equally good. The men would not be content permanently to take a lower price?-They might be obliged to take a lower price, although they did not know it.
14,160. But I have been told today that the Shetland people are a very intelligent cla.s.s, and they would surely have intelligence enough to discover that they were getting a lower price than they might get for their produce?-Some of them are intelligent, and no doubt they would discover that.
Lerwick, January 27, 1872, ANDREW B. JAMIESON, examined.
14,161. Are you a clerk in the employment of Mr. Leask?-I am.
14,162. How long have you been in his service?-About nineteen years.
14,163. Have you been princ.i.p.ally concerned with the engagement and settling with seamen employed in the Greenland whale fishing?-Princ.i.p.ally, of late, since the settlement at the Custom House was commenced. That was five years ago.
14,164. Were you not employed in that way before?-Yes; not altogether, but along with others.
14,165. Before that time, the accounts of the men, I understand, were always settled at Mr. Leask"s office?-Always.
14,166. And the men were paid merely the balance in cash?- They were paid the balance, but they had to get cash during the currency of their account besides that. They always got advances of cash in the course of the year if they wanted them.
14,167. The balance that was paid to them at the end in cash was the settlement for their wages and their first payment of oil-money?-Yes.
14,168. Was the settlement for the final payment of oil-money generally made at a later period?-Always at a later period.
14,169. Was there always a settlement before the last payment of oil-money became due?-Always, except when they happened to be in debt.
14,170. They might be in debt to a greater amount than anything that was due to them?-They might, but of course, if a man had money to get, he was sure to come forward when he required it.
14,171. Were the accounts which were run with the men at that time larger than you now allow them to incur?-I should say not.
[Page 354]
14,172. Are there some men even now who are indebted at settlement to the full amount of their wages and oil-money?- Very few.
14,173. But that does occur?-It may be the case with some of the young hands.
14,174. Does that happen now as often as formerly?-I daresay it does. It depends on the success of the voyage; but we are rather more particular now than we used to be.
14,175. In what way are you more particular now?-We know better what time the voyage will occupy and we always keep within the mark as far as possible.
14,176. Is there less security now for getting your money paid at the proper time than there was formerly?-I cannot say that we have experienced that.
14,177. Previous to 1867, you said the settlement of the men"s accounts generally took place before the last payment of oil-money was due?-Yes, always.
14,178. Was that not so only in the greater number of cases?-It was always the case. The final payment was only a few shillings in general, and it was usually a considerable time before the owners advised us what amount of oil the vessel had turned out; so that if a man had the bulk of his wages to get, he generally got them a long time before the second payment of oil-money came.
14,179. Was the second payment usually made before the man engaged for another voyage if he was going?-In some cases; but if the man lived at a considerable distance from Lerwick, he would not come in for the few shillings which were due him for his second payment until he was about to engage again.
14,180. How was that second payment made? Was it in money, or generally in goods?-If the man had the money coming to him, it was usually paid in money; but sometimes he may have got a little advance on his second payment.
14,181. If that was the case it would be in his account?-Yes, a continuation of his previous account; but we did not care much about advancing on second payments, because they were so uncertain. The vessel might not turn out nearly so much as was expected.
14,182. You are aware that a new system was introduced about 1867 or 1868?-Yes.
14,183. And since that time you have been employed in going up to the Custom House to settle with the men?-Yes.
14,184. Do you take a quant.i.ty of cash up with you and hand it over to the men in presence of the superintendent?-Yes.
14,185. Have you, since that system began, invariably taken up your ledgers containing the men"s accounts, or any note of the amount of their accounts, with you?-Of course we have never taken up the books.
14,186. Did you at any time take any notes or abstracts of the men"s accounts?-I always took a note of the sum which each man had to get.
14,187. Was that a note of the sum which each man had to get for wages and oil-money?-No; it was a note of the actual amount due to the men, because each man had an account of wages furnished to him previously.
14,188. Had he received that from the captain?-No; the account of wages was made up by the agent on sh.o.r.e from the captain"s store-book.
14,189. Is that account of wages always made up by the agent and handed to the men before settlement?-Yes.
14,190. Is it not sometimes taken up with you to the settlement?- The man always carries it up with him.
14,191. When you go up to the Custom House, are you provided with any note of the amount of the man"s account due to Mr.
Leask?-In the first years, I think we had that occasionally.
14,192. In what form did you take that up?-Just slip.