14,193. Was that a note of all the items in the account?-No
14,194. It was just a note of the total sum due to Mr. Leask?-Yes.
14,195. Have you not done so since the first year?-I think not.
14,196. When did you last take such a slip with you to the Custom House?-I think not after the first year, so far as I can recollect.
14,197. The first year of what?-The first year, say, 1867; I think I have not done it since that time.
14,198. Can you not tax your memory so far as to say whether or not you had it in 1870?-I did not have it in 1870; I am quite sure of that.
14,199. Nor in 1871?-Nor in 1871.
14,200. May you have had it in 1869?-I think not.
14,201. Was the last time you had it in 1868?-To the best of my recollection I think it was.
14,202. May you have had it in 1869, although you don"t remember?-I think not, but I cannot be quite positive.
14,203. But you are quite clear about 1870, that you had no note whatever of the men"s accounts with you, except what was entered in the account of wages?-Yes. I did not require it then. It could do no good.
14,204. Why was it required in 1868?-Because sometimes the men settled their accounts at the Custom House.
14,205. Would that be done often?-Sometimes; but not as a rule, I think.
14,206. When these regulations were introduced, and you first went up to the Custom House to settle, was it not intended that all the accounts should be settled there and then?-That was the regulation.
14,207. Was it intended that all Mr. Leask"s accounts should be paid at the same time that the men got their money handed over in presence of the superintendent?-There was no formal proposal about that.
14,208. Was it not done in some cases?-In some cases it was, when the men agreed to do it.
14,209. Did the superintendent object to that?-He did not object.
The whole money was paid down to the men, and sometimes they gave back what they knew they had to give back.
14,210. Would that be done in one half of the cases?-I could not speak to a proportion.
14,211. When they did not hand back then what was due to Mr.
Leask, what was done?-They handed it back when they came down to the office afterwards.
14,212. Do they come down to the office now and pay their accounts after being settled with at the Custom House?-Yes.
14,213. Do you settle with five or six or a dozen of them at a time, as the case may be?-Yes, any number, from one up to a dozen, or perhaps more.
14,214. Is the settlement with these men after they have got their cash always carried out and finished on the same day at Mr.
Leask"s office?-Yes, invariably.
14,215. Do they come straight down from the Custom House to the office and pay their accounts there?-They generally come in the course of the day.
14,216. Do they come down along with you?-If it is only one man who has been settled with, perhaps we will come down together, and perhaps not, just as it happens. I have no fear for them coming down. I never bother my head about them after I give them the money.
14,217. Do you leave them to come down or not as they please?- Decidedly.
14,218. Is there never a black sheep to whom you have to suggest the propriety of coming straight down?-The men know they have the money to pay, and they look upon it as a just debt.
14,219. Is there not a note kept if a man fails to come down?-We are not likely to forget that. There is no note of it kept.
14,220. Do you note the fact that you have settled with him for his wages and oil-money?-Yes. The account is squared at once as soon as we come down from the Custom House.
14,221. Do you not note the fact in some form or [Page 355] other, that the man has not come down to settle his account when he has failed to do so?-No, the book would show that without any note.
I may say, however, that I have scarcely ever had a case of that kind, except it may be one.
14,222. Was that Robert Grains?-Yes; and even he did come down ultimately and settle his account. He was settled with along with about a dozen others, and they all went down. Some of them had been settled with before I came down from the Custom House, but he did not come until I came myself.
14,223. Did he come down with you?-No; he came down himself. I believe the other lads induced him to come back to the shop and settle his account.
14,224. Had he at first refused to do so?-He had been telling the lads that he was going to keep the money or most of the money. I think they said he wanted to go right away and never come near the shop at all, but they induced him to come.
14,225. Did he give any reason for wanting to go away?-Nothing, except that he wanted the money for some other purpose.
14,226. Was his account for goods equal to the whole amount of his wages?-He had about 1 to get.
14,227. That means that he had all his money to hand over to you except 1?-Yes.
14,228. Did you speak to him on the subject?-I did. I asked him if he meant to swindle us out of the money for the outfit that he got to enable him to go to Greenland.
14,229. Was it at the Custom House you said that to him?-No, it was at the office after he had come down. He said no, but that he required money to pay for a boat or to buy a boat, or something of that kind.
14,230. Did that happen on the day of settlement?-Yes.
14,231. Had you understood before that he was intending to go away without paying your account?-No, I had no idea of it.
14,232. Then how did you happen to ask him that question?-He came back to the office after he came out from the Custom House, and he was going to give back part of the money, but he wanted to keep more than he actually had to get after paying Mr. Leask"s account.
14,233. But how did you know that he required persuasion to induce him to come back and pay his account?-I recollect the other lads telling me that they had induced him to come back.
14,234. Had they told you about that before Grains came down?- I scarcely think so. I think there were several of them there along with him when I came down.
14,235. Did he come down from the Custom House along with you?-No.
14,236. Was he at the office when you came down from the Custom House?-I am not quite sure whether he was actually there when I came down, but most of that crew were discharged that day. They had been landed the day before, and most of them were discharged on the day after they landed.
14,237. I don"t quite understand how you knew about Grains having been unwilling to pay his account?-I knew it when he came to the office to give back the money that I had paid him at the Custom House.
14,238. Did he refuse to give you back the money?-He did; not all, but part of it.
14,239. Did he want to pay only a portion of his account?-Yes.
14,240. Did he say that to you when he came to the office?-Yes.