3156. You think there is not so much difference in the cost to you, in the case of shawls, as in the case of veils?-No; because we don"t get job shawls, and we don"t require to guard against that.
3157. Are there no job shawls at all?-It is extremely seldom that there are any.
3158. Therefore, in that case, you require to make the margin less?-Yes.
3159. What do you think would be the percentage of profit upon the lots of veils and shawls mentioned in this account [showing]?-I really could not say. I am quite sure that no person in the trade could tell that.
3160. You have never made an exact calculation of it?-Never.
3161. Can you give me an approximation to it? Will it be 10 per cent.?-Yes; it will be more.
3162. Will it be under 15?-I think it will be.
3163. That is not taking into consideration the fact that they are paid for in goods?-There is nothing like 15 per cent. in that view.
I am taking the whole profit in every way connected with them.
3164. But the question I am asking is, whether, calculating the cost of production in money as I have done just now, and calculating the selling price in money, the profit realized upon these two invoices you have handed to me will amount to 10 or 15 per cent.?-I don"t exactly understand the question.
3165. We have been calculating the cost of the article to you?- Yes; and the real cost to us, I would say the profit will be 15 per cent.
3166. Then, in addition to that, you sell goods to the parties who bring in the articles?-Not in addition to that.
3167. You don"t mean to say that you give your goods in return for these articles at cost price?-No, we don"t.
3168. You have a profit upon the goods?-Yes; but we don"t have a separate profit of 15 per cent. on the hosiery.
3169. But the purpose of the calculations we have been going into just now is to show what the hosiery costs?-Yes; what is the cost to Mr. Linklater.
3170. How do you get at the actual cost?-I cannot get at it exactly. I really don"t know what it is.
3171. But when you say you pay a woman 10s. for knitting, that is marked down in your book as the price paid to her for knitting, just in the same way as if it had been paid in money?-Yes; but I say that we don"t have 15 per cent. of profit on these goods over and above the profit we have on the goods given to the knitter.
3172. But, setting aside in the meantime the fact that the women are paid in goods, and supposing that the 10s. entered in your book is paid to the knitter in cash, do you mean to say that your profit is not 10 or 15 per cent.?-If it was cash, I should say it was 10 or 15 per cent.,-on some things a little more, and on some things a little less.
3173. I am speaking of the hosiery exclusively at present; but in point of fact the 10s. that is entered in your book as the cost of knitting is invariably, or almost invariably, settled for by means of goods on the other side of the account?-Yes.
3174. Are these goods charged to the knitter at wholesale prices or at retail prices?-At retail prices.
3175. Then that retail price implies that there is a profit on the goods?-That is what I am saying; but I say that we don"t have 15 per cent. profit on the shawls, and a profit on the goods besides. I say that if we were paying the actual cash for the knitting of the shawls, then we might have 15 per cent. of profit.
3176. Do you mean that if you were paying actual cash for the knitting of the shawls, you would allow smaller profit on your goods?-I do.
3177. Then when you said with regard to the grey veils No. 1, at 18s., that the cost of knitting was 9s. a dozen, that payment to the knitter was higher than if you paid her in cash?-Yes.
3178. How much higher?-I think that one would not be safe in that case to pay more than 7s. or 7s. 6d., but some knitters make rather better things than others. Of course that is only my own opinion, and it is a thing I have never discussed either one way or another.
3179. You don"t sell the Shetland worsted?-No.
3180. And you say an average price for it is 3d. a cut?-Yes; fine worsted may be from 3d. to 6d. a cut.
3181. The payment for that is generally in goods?-No, it is generally in cash, but we do sometimes get it for goods.
3182. You pay for it generally in cash: how do you account for that deviation from your general practice in Shetland?-We buy a good lot of it from merchants, and there are a good many old women who spin for a living, who we think require the cash. There is also such a demand for it that we are very glad to get it for cash, when the market is generally overstocked with everything else.
3183. Is there much Shetland wool sold in the southern markets?-No; we only send very small quant.i.ties of it south, for darning purposes.
3184. Are you aware whether there are merchants in Shetland, either in Lerwick or in the country, who send Shetland wool to the southern markets?-I know it has been sent from Yell.
3185. To a large extent?-No; it is not produced to a large extent.
All that is produced in Shetland is very trifling.
3186. How did it happen to be sent from Yell?-Because a hosiery merchant in the south, who was selling their goods, got an order for worsted, and it was sent to him. I only know or that one instance.
3187. Was it sent by a proprietor?-I am not sure. It was Mr. Pole of Greenbank who sent it. I rather think his father is proprietor of Greenbank. Mr. Pole is now at Mossbank.
3188. What is the cost per pound of that worsted which sells at 3d.
per cut?-Ordinary good 3d. worsted should be about 20s. a pound.
3189. Therefore it is not so dear as the English worsted?-It is much dearer.
3190. But there is some of the English worsted high as 32s. a pound?-Yes; but we have bought Shetland wool at 96s.
3191. Is that the finest quality of Shetland worsted?-Yes
3192. How much is that per cut?-I think about 7d. We have paid 7d. a cut for it, and on weighing it out I have found there were 12 cuts to the ounce. A cut is 100 threads, and a reel is about a yard long, or scarcely so much.
3193. There will be a greater number of cuts in a pound of fine worsted than in a pound of coa.r.s.e worsted?-Yes.
3194. So that the proportion between the price per [Page 71] cut and the price per pound will differ very much?-Yes
3195. In your trade is there any quant.i.ty of goods sold for cash?- Yes.
3196. Are these marked and sold at the same price as those which you give in return for hosiery?-Yes; they are marked at the same price, and generally sold at the same price. On rare occasions there is a slight discount given for ready cash.
3197. How much is that discount?-I should say about 1s. per 1.
3198. Why is that not allowed when the settlement with hosiery?-Because we consider that in our transactions throughout the year we do not realize for our hosiery goods the full price which we pay.
3199. Have you two shops?-Yes.
3200. In one of these is hosiery kept and bought?-In one of them hosiery is kept; it is only in bought that shop now on very rare occasions. When Mr. Linklater or I happen to be there, we may buy something, and send the customer to the other shop to settle for it.
3201. Then the buying of hosiery is only conducted in the drapery shop?-The settlement for hosiery is only conducted in the hosiery shop.
3202. As a rule, a person selling a shawl or veil would go to the drapery shop?-Yes; and if Mr. Linklater or I was not there, she would go to the other shop to see if we were there.
3203. How do you settle with them if the purchase is made in the hosiery shop?-Generally one of us goes across with them, and on other occasions we give a line to the other shop such as this: "12s.