NOTE F. See p. 188.
THE ETHICS OF CATHOLICISM.
The world at large is fully aware of the claim of "Catholicism," i.e.
the claim of the one visible church for all sorts of men. But the ethical meaning of the claim has been strangely subordinated to its theological and sacerdotal aspects. Its ethical meaning seems to me to require developing under heads such as these:--
1. The requirement of mutual forbearance if men of all races and cla.s.ses and idiosyncrasies are to be bound {272} to belong to one organization and to worship in common, "breaking the one bread."
Herein lies the moral discipline of Catholicism: see above, pp. 123 foll.
2. The consequent obligation of toleration in theology, ritual, &c., on all matters which do not touch the actual basis of the Christian faith. St. Cyprian, though he believed that those baptized outside the church were not baptized at all, yet deliberately remained in communion with those bishops who thought differently, trusting to the mercy of G.o.d to supply the supposed deficiency in those who, outside his jurisdiction, were admitted into the church, as he believed, without baptism. And St. Augustine, who, most of ancient writers, understands the moral meaning of Catholicism, repeatedly holds up this toleration of Cyprian as an example to the Donatist separatists of his own day: "If you seek advice from the blessed Cyprian, hear how much he antic.i.p.ates from the mere advantage of unity: so much so that he did not separate himself from those who held different opinions: and, though he thought that those who are baptized outside the communion of the church do not receive baptism at all, yet he believed that those who had thus been simply _admitted_ into the church could on no other ground than the bond of unity come under the divine pardon." Then he quotes Cyprian"s words: "But some one will say: what will happen to those who in the past, when coming from heresy to the church, have been admitted without baptism? (I reply): G.o.d is powerful to grant them forgiveness by His mercy, and not to separate from the gifts of His church those who, after being thus simply admitted into her, have fallen asleep." And again: "judging no man and separating no man from the rights of communion because he thinks differently." And St.
Augustine continues: "All these catholic {273} unity embraces in her motherly bosom, bearing one another"s burdens in turn and endeavouring to keep the unity of the spirit in the bond of peace, until, in whatever respect they disagreed, the Lord should reveal (the truth) to one or the other of them[1]." Not to St. Paul then, only, but to St.
Cyprian and St. Augustine, doctrinal toleration is an essential of Catholicism. Would to G.o.d the claim of the one church had not come to be a.s.sociated so generally with the opposite tendency! See above, pp.
158 f.
3. Catholicism, as meaning a church of all races and sorts of people, postulates a constant missionary enthusiasm in all the members of the church till this ideal be realized. "To do the work of an evangelist,"
to have the "feet shod with the preparation of the Gospel of peace," to be content to leave nothing but evil outside the church--that is to be a real catholic.
4. To St. Paul"s mind the Catholicism of the church is to lead the way to an even wider "reconciliation." Through the catholic union of men in the church the whole universe is to come back into unity. The kingdom of G.o.d is to be something wider than the church which exists to prepare for it. This principle once recognized secures that the church shall feel and exhibit a constant interest in all departments of knowledge and progress. The universe is one, and redemption is for the whole.
5. Catholicism is the ant.i.thesis of esotericism. All--men and women, slave or free, Greek or Scythian--are capable of full initiation into Christianity. All--not apostles and presbyter-bishops and deacons only--but all Christians make up the high priestly body and have on their foreheads the anointing oil: see above, pp. 111 ff.
Forbearance between divergent cla.s.ses and races and individuals--doctrinal toleration--missionary {274} enthusiasm--universal sympathy--recognition of a universal priesthood of Christianity--these const.i.tute the moral content of Pauline Catholicism.
[1] S. Aug. _de Baptismo_, ii. [xiii.] 18, [xiv.] 20.
NOTE G. See p. 190.
THE LAMBETH CONFERENCE AND INDUSTRIAL PROBLEMS.
The "Report of the Committee of the Lambeth Conference appointed to consider and report upon the office of the Church with respect to industrial problems--(_a_) the unemployed; (_b_) industrial co-operation," is so much to the point as a statement of Christian social duty that I venture to reproduce the _first part of it_ here.
"The Committee desire to begin their Report with words of thankful recognition that throughout the Church of Christ, and not least in the Churches of our own Communion, there has been a marked increase of solicitude about the problems of industrial and social life, and of sympathy with the struggles, sufferings, responsibilities, and anxieties, which those problems involve.
"They hope that they rightly discern in this some increasing reflection in modern shape of the likeness of the Lord, in whose blessed life zeal for the souls, and sympathy for the bodily needs of men were undivided fruits of a single love.
"The Committee, before proceeding to touch upon two specific parts of the subject, desire to record briefly what they deem to be certain principles of Christian duty in such matters.
"The primary duty of the Church, as such, and, within her, of the Clergy, is that of ministry to men in the things of character, conscience, and faith. In doing this, she also does her greatest social duty. Character in the {275} citizen is the first social need; character, with its securities in a candid, enlightened, and vigorous conscience, and a strong faith in goodness and in G.o.d. The Church owes this duty to all cla.s.ses alike. Nothing must be allowed to distract her from it, or needlessly to impede or prejudice her in its discharge; and this requires of the Clergy, as spiritual officers, the exercise of great discretion in any attempt to bring within their sphere work of a more distinctively social kind.
"But while this cannot be too strongly said, it is not the whole truth.
Character is influenced at every point by social conditions; and active conscience, in an industrial society, will look for moral guidance on industrial matters.
"Economic science does not claim to give this, its task being to inform but not to determine the conscience and judgement. But we believe that Christ our Master does give such guidance by His example and teachings, and by the present workings of His Spirit; and therefore under Him Christian authority must in a measure do the same, the authority, that is, of the whole Christian body, and of an enlightened Christian opinion. This is part of the duty of the Christian Society, as witnessing for Christ and representing Him in this present world, occupied with His work of setting up the Kingdom of G.o.d, under and amidst the natural conditions of human life. In this work the clergy, whose special duty it is to ponder the bearings of Christian principles, have their part; but the Christian laity, who deal directly with the social and economic facts, can do even more.
"The Committee believe that it would be wholly wrong for Christian authority to attempt to interfere with the legitimate evolution of economic and social thought and life by taking a side corporately in the debates between rival social theories or systems. It will not (for example), {276} at the present day, attempt to identify Christian duty with the acceptance of systems based respectively on collective or individual ownership of the means of production.
"But they submit that Christian social duty will operate in two directions:--
"1. The recognition, inculcation, and application of certain Christian principles. They offer the following as examples:--
(_a_) The principle of Brotherhood. This principle of Brotherhood, or Fellowship in Christ, proclaiming, as it does, that men are members one of another, should act in all the relations of life as a constant counterpoise to the instinct of compet.i.tion.
(_b_) The principle of Labour. That every man is bound to service--the service of G.o.d and man. Labour and service are to be here understood in their widest and most inclusive sense; but in some sense they are obligatory on all. The wilfully idle man, and the man who lives only for himself, are out of place in a Christian community. Work, accordingly, is not to be looked upon as an irksome necessity for some, but as the honourable task and privilege of all.
(_c_) The principle of Justice. G.o.d is no respecter of persons.
Inequalities, indeed, of every kind are inwoven with the whole providential order of human life, and are recognized emphatically in our Lord"s words. But the social order cannot ignore the interests of any of its parts, and must, moreover, be tested by the degree in which it secures for each freedom for happy, useful, and untrammelled life, and distributes, as widely and equitably as may be, social advantages and opportunities.
(_d_) The principle of Public Responsibility. A Christian community, as a whole, is morally responsible for {277} the character of its own economic and social order, and for deciding to what extent matters affecting that order are to be left to individual initiative, and to the unregulated play of economic forces. Factory and sanitary legislation, the inst.i.tution of Government labour departments and the influence of Government, or of public opinion and the press, or of eminent citizens, in helping to avoid or reconcile industrial conflicts, are instances in point.
"2. Christian opinion should be awake to repudiate and condemn either open breaches of social justice and duty, or maxims and principles of an un-Christian character. It ought to condemn the belief that economic conditions are to be left to the action of material causes and mechanical laws, uncontrolled by any moral responsibility. It can p.r.o.nounce certain conditions of labour to be intolerable. It can insist that the employer"s personal responsibility, as such, is not lost by his membership in a commercial or industrial Company. It can press upon retail purchasers the obligation to consider not only the cheapness of the goods supplied to them, but also the probable conditions of their production. It can speak plainly of evils which attach to the economic system under which we live, such as certain forms of luxurious extravagance, the widespread pursuit of money by financial gambling, the dishonesties of trade into which men are driven by feverish compet.i.tion, and the violences and reprisals of industrial warfare.
"It is plain that in these matters disapproval must take every different shade, from plain condemnation of undoubted wrong to tentative opinions about better and worse. Accordingly any organic action of the Church, or any action of the Church"s officers, as such, should be very carefully restricted to cases where the rule of right is practically clear, and much the larger part of the matter {278} should be left to the free and flexible agency of the awakened Christian conscience of the community at large, and of its individual members.
"If the Christian conscience be thus awakened and active, it will secure the best administration of particular systems, while they exist, and the modification or change of them, when this is required by the progress of knowledge, thought, and life.
"It appears to follow from what precedes that the great need of the Church, in this connexion, is the growth and extension of a serious, intelligent, and sympathetic opinion on these subjects, to which numberless Christians have as yet never thought of applying Christian principles. There has been of late no little improvement in this respect, but much remains to be done, and with this view the Committee desire to make the following definite recommendation.
"They suggest that, wherever possible, there should be formed, as a part of local Church organization, Committees consisting chiefly of laymen, whose work should be to study social and industrial problems from the Christian point of view, and to a.s.sist in creating and strengthening an enlightened public opinion in regard to such problems, and promoting a more active spirit of social service, as a part of Christian duty.
"Such Committees, or bodies of Church workers in the way of social service, while representing no one cla.s.s of society, and abstaining from taking sides in any disputes between cla.s.ses, should fearlessly draw attention to the various causes in our economic, industrial, and social system, which call for remedial measures on Christian principles."
Abundant ill.u.s.tration of the kind of matters with which such Committees might deal will be found in the report.