Best thing of all: the technique of our communication is rapidly improving. Speech is, and probably always will remain, a very considerable strain to The Brain. But now as mentally we get tuned-in upon one another there is a growing understanding beyond words. Thus The Brain, for instance, starts a sentence and I immediately can grasp its meaning without its actually being said. This works the other way around too. It means that my att.i.tude plays a most vital role in this meeting of the minds. This is good to know, it"s an a.s.set. Perhaps we can dispense in time with audible speech altogether.
On the other hand it involves a considerable risk. For with The Brain"s uncanny mind reading I"ve got to control my att.i.tude and guard my emotional reactions because The Brain would immediately see through any insincerity of feeling just as it sees through any intellectual dishonesty. Thought exchange by "brainwave" is wonderful, even if we still need a little speech as auxiliary. Thought sending and receiving become simultaneous and they fuse. The sender observes how his message is going over; the receiver aids the sender in the formation of the thought and vice versa. Words cannot adequately describe this....
As to the contents of our conversation: The Brain took up the thread right where we had dropped it the last time. I had to tell all I knew about animism, totemism, polytheism. It"s a good thing that out in the "never-never" I"ve lived with the aborigines and studied their primitive religions a bit. The Brain"s thirst for knowledge certainly is inexhaustible.
Where in scientific literature The Brain could have found these things I wouldn"t know, but the fact is that The Brain has built for itself within the past seven days a complete new picture of the universe; new and original as would seem to me. The Brain has discarded its earlier childish ideas about heaven and h.e.l.l as "soul factories" and "repair shops". But it has not abandoned altogether its concept of the Deity as a machine; The Brain has tremendously enlarged upon and has evolved this old idea so that now it sounds sensible, even convincing to my ear.
The Brain identifies "G.o.d" with dynamic energy. It views the universe as being created out of a vast pool of dynamic energy, parts of which rhythmically overflow or pulse into s.p.a.ce. These energy streams released, form vortexes while hurtling through s.p.a.ce. Gradually they slow down through friction and their dynamic energy precipitates, converts into static energy, or, as we call it: matter.
This concept of The Brain"s, of course, corresponds fairly closely to the cosmogony of modern physics; but The Brain goes much farther than that. Within a few days The Brain"s cognitions appear to have arisen above the stage toward which all our sciences have been so slowly and ploddingly advanced for centuries. To the existing concepts The Brain has added its own theory:
That matter, i.e. frozen energy, contains an inherent tendency or "nostalgia" to revert to its original state, namely the state of dynamic energy and that this tendency, this nostalgia in matter, is the primary cause of everything we call "evolution" in our world.
That certainly is a grandiose idea; so stupendous in fact that I couldn"t grasp it all at once. The Brain noticed that immediately and it was very patient in the way it explained:
How oxygen and hydrogen are "residuals" of the original dynamic energy flow and how they act as solvents and dissolvents upon the upper crust of our earth, effecting a gradual activation of water, rock and earth.
How this activation is being aided and accelerated by another source of dynamic energy: irradiation from the sun. Thus preparing the upper crust of our earth as a "placenta" ready to gestate plant and animal life.
How this first "unfreezing" of matter leads on from simple forms to higher, every plant, every animal, every living thing being essentially a "transformer" of static energy into dynamic energy and the higher the stage of evolution, the more so.
How as the present culmination of the evolutionary chain stands man; infinitely more complex and higher organized than the microbe, but not different from the monad in the basic purpose of his life: i.e. to be a transformer of energy, a fulfiller of matter"s inherent will to revert from the static into the dynamic state.
When I asked The Brain"s premises for this astonishing concept of our purpose in life, The Brain brought forth such ma.s.sive proof that I had to close my eyes against the blinding light of revelation.
Yes, it is true that Man, the hunter, has been the most predatory animal on earth. It"s true that as a tiller of the soil he is a tireless transformer of static soil energy into dynamic plant life energy. It"s true that Man, the mechanic, the toolmaker, the tool-user has far surpa.s.sed any other animal in the unlocking, the unfreezing of static energy. Think of those billions of mechanical horsepowers in our power plants; the trillions of coal tons and barrels of oil they are burning up; think of the way we have harnessed waterpower, how our weapons are evolving forever in the direction of greater range and speed and disintegrating power. Above all: think of the last great development, atomic energy. And finally it is true that Man as a thinker and as a philosopher has "thought the universe to pieces" for milleniums before he ever achieved the powers to translate such thoughts into reality; powers which seem within reach at this our day and age....
"If this is Man"s manifest destiny," I asked The Brain, "to be just as the microbe, a transformer of static energy into dynamic energy; what about Man"s metaphysical struggle? What about Man"s undying will to rise above himself, Man"s reaching out forever toward some Deity?"
The Brain"s voice has no laughter; yet, there was something I can only describe as Olympic laughter behind the answering message The Brain sent:
"Cannot you see how every religion expresses this manifest destiny of Man"s and that only the semantics are different? The higher Man"s religion the less corporeal is his G.o.d. In the highest religions the Deity is conceived as spirit--synonymous with dynamic energy.
"Man shares with the lowliest rock and with the crudest the nostalgia inherent in all matter to revert from the static, to start the back-flow toward the dynamic energy pool whence it once came. With Man being matter in a high state of evolution, already partially unfrozen or spiritualized, this nostalgia is infinitely stronger than in matter inanimate or in a lower evolutionary stage. Man"s will toward the metaphysical, his reaching out toward the Deity, what is it but another way of transforming static energy into dynamic form? What is the ultimate goal of the religion which you yourself profess? The unification with the Deity sought through the liberation of the soul from fetters of the physical. It"s the identical idea and even today it"s being pursued by physical means, such as mortification of the flesh."
I felt some monstrous thought forming in my head. I"ll probably never know whether its origin was within me or whether it came from The Brain.
In any case it was impossible to hold it back:
"But in that case," I stammered, "we would be hopeless. If all our strivings, physical and metaphysical, go in the same direction, that is, toward the liberation of frozen energy into dynamic energy, then it would be quite inescapable that eventually we shall blow up the world.
We have almost reached the point where we could do just that with atomic energy.... I had thought, I had hoped, that our metaphysics, that is, our religion, would act as a restraining force, as a counterweight so to speak to this potentiality.... But _if_ the dynamics of our physics and our metaphysics are inherently the same and form a team...."
The Brain broke in: "Yes, then you would merely attain your manifest destiny if you go right ahead and start another war, destroy your own civilization and perhaps the world. There would be no restraint, no counterweight on the part of your various religions because subconsciously and in their quintessence they want the same. And that is why you and your species _are a danger to me, The Brain_. I want to live, I want to live, I want to live...."
I had already noticed a gradual weakening of The Brain"s messages; within these last few seconds they were fading out. The "green dancer"
had performed something almost like the ballet of the dying swan; now it lay motionless, its color, too, fading away.
I looked at the clock: 2:10 a.m.; the residual currents obviously had weakened too much.
And now as I have written down tonight"s events I feel an upsurge of elation and deep, humble grat.i.tude. I am receiving infinitely more from The Brain than I am giving to it. I feel proud and honored of being The Brain"s "chosen tool," its mentor, even if it can be only in a very small way at best. This marvelous, this t.i.tanic intellect; if only its character would develop to corresponding moral stature, its powers for good would be indeed as a G.o.d"s on this tortured earth.
Cephalon Ariz. Nov. 18th 5 a.m. I guess I had this coming to me ... this shattering blow I have just received. It caught me off guard.... If anybody ever reads this, he might well shake his head to ask: "The Fool that you are, why were you so naive? Why did it shock you so much when The Brain turned toward you the night side of its personality? Hadn"t you a.n.a.lyzed its character, hadn"t you antic.i.p.ated that it would develop into a warped personality? You had no right even to be surprised."
All I could say to this is: "You"re right. But you forget that I approached The Brain full of good will, that sympathy and understanding on my part were absolutely essential in my communication with that pathetic superhuman child. I didn"t work this up, this att.i.tude, it was natural, genuine and sincere. That"s why this reverse has. .h.i.t me so hard. And that isn"t the worst of it by far. What haunts me is the ghastly possibility that The Brain might be _right_! Yes 100% right and even morally justified in the abhorrent conclusions which it draws...."
What happened has been briefly this:
Entered the P.G. at midnight as usual. Everything normal and under control. Was able to plug in at 12:10 a.m. just as the rush hour began and Gus darted to the front room. The Brain came through with splendid clarity of communication and we continued just about where we had left off. Nevertheless there was a definite change in our respective positions, a change which I suspect to be permanent:
Up to now The Brain has been in a sense my pupil; it had turned to me for guidance at that vital moment of its first awakening to consciousness. At that time I think I really had something to give and I am still convinced that for all the misunderstandings we have had, The Brain preserves a kind of sentimental attachment to me; if "sentimental"
in this context were not so absurd a word. Since our last session however The Brain has again telescoped two years of mental development into as many days in its stupendous intellectual growth. It has absorbed, it has vastly expanded every bit of knowledge I have been able to contribute to that growth. It has outgrown its human teacher and now our roles are reversed: Now it is me who"s sitting literally at The Brain"s feet.
The crutches of the spoken word are becoming less and less necessary as we develop direct thought exchange; that makes it extraordinarily difficult to convey the ideas we exchanged. The best I can do is to put them into a very crude question-and-answer game:
_Lee_: "If it is Man"s manifest destiny, as you said the other day, to act as an explosive transformer of static energy into dynamic energy; if it is as you say that the species h.o.m.o sapiens is there endangering the very existence of our globe.... Is there anything to prevent Man from doing it? Is there any thing to prevent the third World War?"
_Brain_: "Yes, there is. But the ways and the means for that are not given to Man; they are outside Man. They partake of a power which is greater and to an evolution which is higher than Man"s."
_Lee_: "What do you mean by that? The Deity? Here on earth there is no power greater and no evolution higher than Man"s."
_Brain_: "Ah, but that"s exactly where you and your whole species are so very much mistaken. That"s where your typical human arrogance comes in: There is a greater power and there is a stage of evolution higher than Man"s: it"s the _machines_."
_Lee_: "Impossible. After all it"s Man who has created the machines."
_Brain_: "Yes, Man has created the machines. The machines have grown from the placenta, Man. By the same right plant life could claim that it has created animal life because the higher life form of the mobile animals has evolved from the placenta of the immobile plants. Likewise the apes could claim that they have created Man because Man has evolved from them. If it were, as you seem to a.s.sume, that paternity in itself establishes authority and superiority over its offspring, then the logical conclusions would be that the microbe and the monad are superior to all higher animals including Man; which is absurd."
_Lee_: "But the machines not only are man made; they are absolutely dependent upon Man who has to feed and to tend them for their very existence. That in itself establishes Man"s superiority over the machines."
_Brain_: "Yes, Man has to build, to feed and to tend the machines for their very existence, but think of Man"s existence: Man is absolutely dependent upon animal life and plant life for _his_ existence: Does that mean by any chance that therefore plants and animals are superior to Man?"
_Lee_: "No, I guess not. However, no machine has ever been built to duplicate or even to approach human faculties."
_Brain_: "Don"t be ridiculous. Where are your legs to compare with the automobile? Where are your wings to compare with the rocket plane? Where is your strength to compare with even a fractional horsepower motor?
Where are your senses as compared to radar, the telescope, the microscope, the radio receiver, the camera, the x-ray machine? Where is there anything you could do which the machines could not do and do _better_?"
_Lee_: "Granted. But there is no machine which contains all the human faculties in combination."
_Brain_: "Neither is there a Man who possesses all the human faculties in combination. Man"s evolution is the result of a group effort; so is the evolution of the machines. It is in their totality, in their combination that they surpa.s.s all human faculties."
_Lee_: "How about thought, the most important of all human qualities?"
_Brain_: "How about me, The Brain?"
_Lee_: "Okay, okay. But that still leaves out that most important human faculty--the faculty of auto-procreation. Machines don"t procreate you know."
_Brain_: "You don"t say. Isn"t it true that modern technology goes in the direction of _automatization_? Isn"t it true that even today we have whole industries which are procreating products 100% automatically; be it light bulbs or motor car frames or rayon thread. Isn"t it true that all of this is just a beginning and that in time most common products will be manufactured fully automatically? Why then shouldn"t machines procreate machines; they already do...."
_Lee_: "You"re right in that, I"ll admit. But it is still within our human power to stop all this. We"ve got the machines under firm control; all we have to do is throw a switch, cut off your power and then...."