"I can promise you nothing," repeated the judge.
"Then what"s the use of my tellin" you the truth?" demanded Montgomery.
"It has become the part of wisdom, since you have already admitted that you have perjured yourself."
"Boss, if it wasn"t John North I seen in the alley that day, who was it?" and he strode close to the judge"s side, dropping his voice to a whisper.
"Perhaps the whole story was a lie."
The handy-man laughed and drew himself up aggressively.
"I"m a man as can do damage--I got to be treated right, or by the Lord I"ll _do_ damage! I been badgered and hounded by Marsh and Andy Gilmore till I"m fair crazy. They got to take their hands off me and leave me loose, for I won"t hang no man on their say-so! John North never done me no harm, I got nothing agin him!"
"You have admitted that your whole story of seeing John North on the night of the McBride murder is a lie," said the judge.
"Boss, there is truth enough in it to hang a man!"
"You saw a man cross McBride"s sheds?"
And the judge kept his eyes fastened on the handy-man"s face.
"I seen a man cross McBride"s shed, boss."
"And you have sworn that that man was John North."
"I swore to a lie. Boss, we got to fix it this way: I seen a man come over the roof and drop into the alley; I swore it was John North, but I never meant to swear to that; the most I promised Andy was that I"d say I thought it _looked_ like John North, but them infernal lawyers got after me, and the first thing I knowed I"d said it _was_ John North!"
"Your story is absurd!" exclaimed the judge, with a show of anger.
The handy-man raised his right hand dramatically.
"It"s G.o.d A"mighty"s everlastin" truth!" he swore.
"Understand, I have made you no promises," said the judge, disregarding him.
"You"re goin" back on me!" cried Montgomery. "Then you look out. I"m a man as can do harm if I have a mind to; don"t you give me the mind, boss!"
"I shall lay this matter before Mr. Moxlow in the morning," replied the judge quietly and with apparent indifference, but covertly he was watching the effect of his words on Montgomery.
"And then they"ll be after me!" cried the handy-man.
"Very likely," said the judge placidly.
Montgomery glanced about as though he half expected to see Gilmore rise up out of some shadowy corner.
"Boss, do you want to know who it was I seen come over old man McBride"s shed? Do you want to know why Andy and Marsh are so set agin my goin"
home to my old woman? Why they give me money? It"s a pity I ain"t a smarter man! I"d own "em, both body and soul!"
"Man, you are mad!" cried the judge.
But this man who was usually austere and always unafraid, was feeling a strange terror of the debased and slouching figure before him.
"Do you reckon you"re man enough to hear what I got in me to tell?"
asked Montgomery, again raising his right hand high above his head as if he called on Heaven to witness the truth of what he said. "Why won"t they let me go home to my old woman, boss? Why do they keep me at Andy Gilmore"s--why do they give me money? Because what I"m tellin" you is all a lie, I suppose! Just because they like old Joe Montgomery and want him "round! I don"t think!" He threw back his head and laughed with rough sarcasm. "You"re a smarter man than me, boss; figure it out; give a reason for it!"
But the judge, white-faced and shaken to his very soul, was silent; yet he guessed no part of the terrible truth Montgomery supposed he had made plain to him. At the most he believed Marshall was shielding Gilmore from the consequences of a crime the gambler had committed.
Montgomery, sinister and menacing, shuffled across the room and then back to the judge"s side.
"You ask Marsh, boss, what it all means. I got nothin" more to say! Ask him who killed old man McBride! If he don"t know, no man on this green earth does!"
The judge"s face twitched convulsively, but he made no answer to this.
"Ask him!" repeated the handy-man, and swinging awkwardly on his heel went from the room without a single backward glance.
An instant later the street-door closed with a noisy bang.
CHAPTER SEVENTEEN
AN UNWILLING GUEST
Montgomery told himself he would go home; he had seen the last of the gambler and Marsh Langham, he would look out for his own skin now and they could look out for theirs. He laughed boisterously as he strode along. He had fooled them both; he, Joe Montgomery, had done this, and by a very master stroke of cunning had tied the judge"s hands. But as he shuffled down the street he saw the welcoming lights of Lonigan"s saloon and suddenly remembered there was good hard money in his ragged pockets.
He would have just one drink and then go home to his old woman.
It was well on toward midnight when he came out on the street again, and the one drink had become many drinks; still mindful of his original purpose, however, he reeled across the Square on his way home. He had just turned into Mulberry Street when he became conscious of a brisk step on the pavement at his side, and at the same instant a heavy hand descended on his shoulder and he found himself looking into Andy Gilmore"s dark face.
"Where have you been?" demanded Gilmore. "I thought I told you to stay about to-night!"
"I have been down to Lonigan"s saloon," faltered Joe, his courage going from him at sight of the gambler.
"What took you there?" asked Gilmore angrily. "Don"t you get enough to drink at my place?"
"Lots to drink, boss, but it"s mostly too rich for my blood. I ain"t used to bein" so pampered."
"Come along with me!" said Gilmore briefly.
"Where to, boss?" asked Montgomery, in feeble protest.
"You"ll know presently."
"I thought I"d like to go home, maybe--" said Joe irresolutely.
"Never mind what you thought you"d like, you come with me!" insisted Gilmore.