ST JAMES"S SQUARE, _27th February 1851._ (_Four o"clock_ P.M.)
Lord Stanley, with his humble duty, awaits your Majesty"s commands at what hour he may be honoured with an audience, to explain the grounds on which, with the deepest regret, he feels himself under the necessity of resigning the important trust with which your Majesty has honoured him.
_Queen Victoria to Sir James Graham._
BUCKINGHAM PALACE, _27th February 1851._
The Queen sanctions Sir James Graham"s making any statement to the House of Commons which he thinks necessary, to explain the part which he and Lord Aberdeen took in the late Ministerial negotiations, and indeed hopes that these explanations will be as full as possible on all parts, in order that the country may fully appreciate the difficulties of the crisis.
[Pageheading: LORD STANLEY"S REASONS]
[Pageheading: THE PAPAL BILL]
_Memorandum by the Prince Albert._
BUCKINGHAM PALACE, _27th February 1851._
Lord Stanley arrived at half-past five o"clock. We were struck by the change of his countenance, which had lost all the expression of care and anxiety which had marked it at the previous interviews.
He a.s.sured the Queen that he had been labouring incessantly since he had seen her last, but that he was sorry to say without any success.
He had seen Mr Gladstone, who declined joining his Government on account of his previous pledges in Parliament respecting the Commercial Policy of Sir R. Peel, but evidently also on account of his peculiar views with respect to the Papal Aggression, which he did not seem disposed to look upon as in any way objectionable.
Lord Canning had given him some hope at one time, but finally declined in order not to risk his credit for political consistency.
Mr H. Corry, whose opinions on Free Trade were by no means decided, and who had only filled a very subordinate situation in Sir R. Peel"s Government, he had offered high office, but was refused, Mr Corry expressing his fears that the Government had no chance of standing against the opposition it would have to meet in the House of Commons.
The Duke of Northumberland was the only person not properly belonging to the Protection Party who had accepted office (First Lord of the Admiralty). At one time Lord Ellenborough had accepted, but having been sent on a mission to Mr Goulburn in order to see whether he could convert him, he came home himself converted, and withdrew his acceptance again.
In this situation Lord Stanley called his friends together, and after some discussion concurred in their opinion that it was not possible for them to form such an Administration as ought to be offered to the Queen. Lord Stanley then qualified this expression again, and said that though he could have offered a very respectable Government if he had had a majority in the House of Commons, or the means of strengthening himself by an immediate Dissolution, he could not form such a one which could have withstood an adverse majority and such a formidable array of talent in the Opposition. He therefore returned the trust which had been committed to him into the Queen"s hands, expressing at the same time his deep sense of grat.i.tude for the kindness with which she had treated him, the support and confidence she had given him, sorry only that it should have led to no result.
He thought, however, that the prolongation of the crisis had not inconvenienced the public service, as Her Majesty"s _present_ Government were const.i.tutionally enabled to carry on all necessary business.
The Queen rejoined that she was very sorry that this attempt had also failed, that she had tried every possible combination, and still was without a Government. Lord Stanley answered as if he considered it natural that Lord John Russell"s Government should now quietly proceed; but on the Queen"s observation, that it was now necessary that all Parties should join in the support of some measures at least, and particularly the Papal Bill, he stated what he was prepared to support, and would have been prepared to propose had he taken office, viz. a fuller recital in the preamble of the Bill and no penal clause in the body of it. (The present Bill looked pettish and undignified, as if framed in anger as a return for the insult, and not a correction of the state of the law.) He thought the Law very complex and obscure, and never found it acted upon. He would have proposed therefore that Committees of both Houses should enquire into the whole subject; the state of the Convents; whether subjects were detained against their will; whether people were forced to bequeath their property to the Church on the deathbed, etc., etc.; he knew that the Roman Catholic laity felt severely the oppression which the Priests exercised over them, and would be willing to give evidence.
Lord Stanley asked whether it could be of use if he were to state all this in his explanation to-day, which the Queen strongly affirmed. I added that I hoped he would explain what he was prepared to do on all the subjects in dispute--the Commercial and Financial Policy as well.
He promised to do so, and entered into his views on the Income Tax, which he called a War Tax, which had been imposed for temporary purposes only in 1842, and ought to be taken off again when practicable in order to keep faith with the public; but if, as often as there was a surplus, this was immediately absorbed by remission of other burdens, this object could never be fulfilled. He would propose that by degrees, as surpluses arose, the Income Tax should be decreased, and so on to its final repeal.
I disputed with him for some time on the advantages of an Income Tax, but without coming to any result.
On his enquiry whether there was anything else the Queen might wish him to state--perhaps the rumour that he had been refused the power of dissolving--we agreed that he should say the question had never been seriously entertained, but that the Queen had been ready to give him the same support and advantages which any other Government might have enjoyed.[9]
ALBERT.
[Footnote 9: The Prince thereupon, at the Queen"s request, communicated with Lord John Russell, and after recounting to him the various successive failures to form a Government, wrote that the Queen must "pause before she again entrusts the commission of forming an Administration to anybody, till she has been able to see the result of to-morrow evening"s Debate." He added, "Do you see any Const.i.tutional objection to this course?"]
[Pageheading: THE DUKE OF WELLINGTON]
_The Prince Albert to the Duke of Wellington._
BUCKINGHAM PALACE, _28th February 1851._
MY DEAR DUKE,--Lord Stanley has likewise resigned his task, not being able to gain over any of Sir R. Peel"s friends, and being incapable of forming a Government out of his Party alone.
So Lord John Russell has declared his inability to carry on the Government. Lord Stanley has then declared his inability to form one until every other combination should have failed. We have tried all possible combinations between Whigs and Peelites, and have not succeeded, and now Lord Stanley throws up the game a second time!
The Queen would be happy to consult you and hear your advice in this dilemma. Possibly to-night"s Debate may define the position of Parties more clearly, and give a clue to what may be best to be done under the circ.u.mstances. Ever yours, etc.
ALBERT.
_Lord John Russell to the Prince Albert._
CHESHAM PLACE, _28th February 1851._
SIR,--The former Cabinet meet at eleven, at Lansdowne House.
It appears to me that the Queen might with advantage see Lord Lansdowne. He was in office with Mr Fox and Lord Grenville in 1806; he has been distinguished and respected in political life ever since; he is now desirous of retiring, and has therefore no personal object to gain. If the Queen approves, Lord Lansdowne might wait on Her Majesty soon after twelve o"clock. I have the honour to be, Sir, your Royal Highness"s very dutiful Servant,
J. RUSSELL.
[Pageheading: LORD LANSDOWNE]
_Queen Victoria to Lord Lansdowne._
BUCKINGHAM PALACE, _28th February 1851._
It would be a great satisfaction to the Queen to hear Lord Lansdowne"s advice in the present critical state of affairs, and she would be glad if he could come to her at twelve this morning. The Queen has sent to the Duke of Wellington in order to hear his opinion also; but he cannot be here before to-night, being at Strathfieldsaye.
_Memorandum by the Prince Albert._