The matter has also been considered from a religious point of view. I am not ashamed to confess that I also serve G.o.d, but G.o.d has given us reason, and if we see that, humanly speaking, there is no prospect of our deliverance, we cannot expect that G.o.d will simply grant us our desire. If we desire to have our independence for the honour of G.o.d, He will let us retain it, but I fear that we desire it more for ourselves, more for our own honour, than for the honour of G.o.d. Unless some other light is thrown on the matter, I fear it will be wrong of us to continue the struggle. Reference is made to the blood that has been shed and to the sacrifices that have been made; but what about the women and children who will still have to give up their lives if we now continue, and yet ultimately have to give the matter up as hopeless? The persons who are still living are of more importance to me than those who have already given their lives. I say we may not proceed unless we can give ourselves and our people good reasons for doing so.
At this stage the Committee appointed to draft a resolution handed in their draft. It was read, and after some discussion, adopted.
The draft resolution was as follows:--
"This meeting of representatives of the people from both Republics, having considered the correspondence and the negotiations that pa.s.sed between the Governments of both Republics and His Excellency Lord Kitchener on behalf of the British Government;
"Having heard the information supplied by the delegates from the various parts of both Republics;
"Having heard the latest reports from their Representatives in Europe;
"Considering the fact that the British Government has refused to conclude peace, on the basis of their independence, and has refused to accept the proposals of their Governments made on that basis; yet, in spite of the above-mentioned refusal of the British Government, this meeting nevertheless desires to comply with the ardent wishes of the people to retain their independence, for which so many material and personal sacrifices have been made;
"RESOLVES, on behalf of the people of both Republics, to authorise the Governments to conclude peace on the following basis, to wit: The retention of a limited independence with the offer, in addition to what has already been offered by the Governments in their negotiations, dated April 15th, 1902, of:--
(_a_) Surrender of all foreign relations and emba.s.sies;
(_b_) acceptance of the protectorate of Great Britain;
(_c_) surrender of portions of the territory of the South African Republic;
(_d_) the conclusion of a defensive treaty with Great Britain with reference to South Africa."
During the discussion of this draft resolution the Governments were clearly given to understand that the portions of the territory which they could surrender were those already mentioned, namely, the Gold Fields and Swazieland.
The question was put whether the South African Republic alone should have to pay for the retention of independence, as these areas formed a portion of that territory.
To this Mr. de Clercq (Middelburg) replied "Yes, and if I could secure the independence of the Orange Free State with all I possess, I would do so." Other Transvaal delegates spoke in the same sense, indicating that the sacrifices made by the Free State during the war were most highly appreciated by them.
General Froneman thanked the Transvaal delegates on behalf of the Free State, remarking that there could be no further mention of the two States having divergent interests.
With reference to the resolution, General de la Rey declared that he was opposed to the surrender of Johannesburg.
Commandant Ross (Vrede) remarked: "I am surprised that the meeting takes such a resolution. What the people demand is total independence, and we can do nothing else but comply with that demand. Otherwise we act in a childish way. My commando is prepared to do everything to secure peace provided they retain their independence. If we part with that we cease to be a people."
Commandant J. J. van Niekerk (Ficksburg) declared that the meeting could not even think of surrendering their independence.
General H. A. Alberts (Heidelberg) said: I have a free hand to act according to circ.u.mstances. We shall be committing suicide if we continue the war without any hope and without any prospect of attaining our object, and not only suicide, but a murder also of women and children. If I could to-day purchase the independence of the Free State with all that I still possess, even with my life, I would do it with pleasure, but we cannot do what is impossible.
General P. R. Viljoen (Heidelberg) agreed with what General Alberts had said, and was of opinion that they had to reckon with facts.
The meeting was now adjourned to two o"clock in the afternoon.
The meeting resumed at two o"clock p.m.
After some discussion, the following proposal, made by General Brand and seconded by Mr. de k.o.c.k, was carried with the dissentient vote of General Kemp:--
"This meeting of representatives of the people of both the Republics resolve to instruct the two Governments to appoint a Commission with instructions to negotiate with His Excellency Lord Kitchener on behalf of His Britannic Majesty"s Government on any subject in order to try to arrive at a satisfactory peace, and to submit their attempts through the two Governments to this meeting for approval."
After this the meeting was closed with prayer.
In pursuance of the above-mentioned resolution the two Governments appointed the following gentlemen as a Commission to negotiate with Lord Kitchener:--
Commandant General Louis Botha.
Chief Commandant C. R. de Wet.
General J. H. de la Rey.
General J. C. s.m.u.ts.
General J. B. M. Hertzog.
CHAPTER V.
FURTHER NEGOTIATIONS AT PRETORIA.
Conference between the Commission appointed to represent the meeting of Delegates at Vereeniging, and Lord Kitchener and Lord Milner.
Lord Kitchener was informed that the Meeting representing the two Republics had delegated Commandant General Louis Botha, Chief Commandant C. R. de Wet, General J. H. de la Rey, General J. C. s.m.u.ts, and General J. B. M. Hertzog to confer with the representatives of the British Government, and in the afternoon of Sat.u.r.day, May 17, the Governments received a reply from Lord Kitchener that he and Lord Milner, on behalf of the British Government, were prepared to meet the Commission, who were requested to proceed to Pretoria immediately for that purpose.
The Commission left Vereeniging that same evening for Pretoria, where they arrived at 8 o"clock p.m. They were accommodated in "Park zicht,"
the residence of Mr. Carl Rood, corner of Mare and van der Walt Streets.
On Monday morning, May 19, 1902, the Commission a.s.sembled early and wrote the following letter to be submitted to Lord Kitchener and Lord Milner, and in which the wishes of the peoples" Representatives were expressed:--
_To their Excellencies_ Lord KITCHENER _and_ Lord MILNER, _Pretoria_.
PRETORIA, _May 19, 1902_.
YOUR EXCELLENCIES,
With the object of finally terminating the existing hostilities, we have the honour, by virtue of the authority from the Governments of both the Republics, to propose the following points as a basis of negotiations, in addition to the points already offered during the negotiations in April last:--
(_a_) We are prepared to give up our independence as far as foreign relations are concerned;
(_b_) We wish to retain internal self-government under British supervision;
(_c_) We are prepared to give up a portion of our territory.
If Your Excellencies are prepared to negotiate on this basis, the above-mentioned points can be more fully set forth.
We have the honour to be, Your Excellencies" obedient servants, LOUIS BOTHA, C. R. DE WET, J. H. DE LA REY, J. B. M. HERTZOG, J. C. s.m.u.tS.