"_From pa.s.sion"s power alone_," etc.--P. 26.
This very mysterious kind of pleasure, which is often found in the exercise of pa.s.sions generally counted painful, has been taken notice of by several authors. Lucretius resolves it into self-love:--
"Suave mari magno," etc., lib. ii. 1.
As if a man was never pleased in being moved at the distress of a tragedy, without a cool reflection that though these fict.i.tious personages were so unhappy, yet he himself was perfectly at ease and in safety. The ingenious author of the _Reflections Critiques sur la Poesie et sur la Peinture_ accounts for it by the general delight which the mind takes in its own activity, and the abhorrence it feels of an indolent and inattentive state: and this, joined with the moral approbation of its own temper, which attends these emotions when natural and just, is certainly the true foundation of the pleasure, which, as it is the origin and basis of tragedy and epic, deserved a very particular consideration in this poem.
ENDNOTE S.
"_Inhabitant of earth_," etc.--P. 31.
The account of the economy of Providence here introduced, as the most proper to calm and satisfy the mind when under the compunction of private evils, seems to have come originally from the Pythagorean school: but of the ancient philosophers, Plato has most largely insisted upon it, has established it with all the strength of his capacious understanding, and enn.o.bled it with all the magnificence of his divine imagination. He has one pa.s.sage so full and clear on this head, that I am persuaded the reader will be pleased to see it here, though somewhat long. Addressing himself to such as are not satisfied concerning divine Providence: "The Being who presides over the whole," says he, "has disposed and complicated all things for the happiness and virtue of the whole, every part of which, according to the extent of its influence, does and suffers what is fit and proper. One of these parts is yours, O unhappy man, which though in itself most inconsiderable and minute, yet being connected with the universe, ever seeks to co-operate with that supreme order.
You in the meantime are ignorant of the very end for which all particular natures are brought into existence, that the all-comprehending nature of the whole may be perfect and happy; existing, as it does, not for your sake, but the cause and reason of your existence, which, as in the symmetry of every artificial work, must of necessity concur with the general design of the artist, and be subservient to the whole of which it is a part. Your complaint therefore is ignorant and groundless; since, according to the various energy of creation, and the common laws of nature, there is a constant provision of that which is best at the same time for you and for the whole.--For the governing intelligence clearly beholding all the actions of animated and self-moving creatures, and that mixture of good and evil which diversifies them, considered first of all by what disposition of things, and by what situation of each individual in the general system, vice might be depressed and subdued, and virtue made secure of victory and happiness with the greatest facility and in the highest degree possible. In this manner he ordered through the entire circle of being, the internal const.i.tution of every mind, where should be its station in the universal fabric, and through what variety of circ.u.mstances it should proceed in the whole tenor of its existence." He goes on in his sublime manner to a.s.sert a future state of retribution, "as well for those who, by the exercise of good dispositions being harmonised and a.s.similated into the divine virtue, are consequently removed to a place of unblemished sanct.i.ty and happiness; as of those who by the most flagitious arts have risen from contemptible beginnings to the greatest affluence and power, and whom you therefore look upon as unanswerable instances of negligence in the G.o.ds, because you are ignorant of the purposes to which they are subservient, and in what manner they contribute to that supreme intention of good to the whole."
--_Plato de Leg_. x. 16.
This theory has been delivered of late, especially abroad, in a manner which subverts the freedom of human actions; whereas Plato appears very careful to preserve it, and has been in that respect imitated by the best of his followers.
ENDNOTE T.
"_One might rise, One order_," etc.--P. 31.
See the _Meditations_ of Antoninus and the _Characteristics_, pa.s.sim.
ENDNOTE U.
"_The best and fairest_," etc.--P. 32.
This opinion is so old, that Timaeus Locrus calls the Supreme Being [Greek: demiourgos tou beltionos], the artificer of that which is best; and represents him as resolving in the beginning to produce the most excellent work, and as copying the world most exactly from his own intelligible and essential idea; "so that it yet remains, as it was at first, perfect in beauty, and will never stand in need of any correction or improvement." There can be no room for a caution here, to understand the expressions, not of any particular circ.u.mstances of human life separately considered, but of the sum or universal system of life and being. See also the vision at the end of the _Theodicee_ of Leibnitz.
ENDNOTE V.
"_As flame ascends_," etc.--P. 32.
This opinion, though not held by Plato nor any of the ancients, is yet a very natural consequence of his principles. But the disquisition is too complex and extensive to be entered upon here.
ENDNOTE W.
"_Philip_."--P. 44.
The Macedonian.
BOOK THIRD.
ENDNOTE X.
"_Where the powers Of Fancy_," etc.--P. 46.
The influence of the imagination on the conduct of life is one of the most important points in moral philosophy. It were easy, by an induction of facts, to prove that the imagination directs almost all the pa.s.sions, and mixes with almost every circ.u.mstance of action or pleasure. Let any man, even of the coldest head and soberest industry, a.n.a.lyse the idea of what he calls his interest; he will find that it consists chiefly of certain degrees of decency, beauty, and order, variously combined into one system, the idol which he seeks to enjoy by labour, hazard, and self-denial. It is, on this account, of the last consequence to regulate these images by the standard of nature and the general good; otherwise the imagination, by heightening some objects beyond their real excellence and beauty, or by representing others in a more odions or terrible shape than they deserve, may, of course, engage us in pursuits utterly inconsistent with the moral order of things.
If it be objected that this account of things supposes the pa.s.sions to be merely accidental, whereas there appears in some a natural and hereditary disposition to certain pa.s.sions prior to all circ.u.mstances of education or fortune, it may be answered, that though no man is born ambitious or a miser, yet he may inherit from his parents a peculiar temper or complexion of mind, which shall render his imagination more liable to be struck with some particular objects, consequently dispose him to form opinions of good and ill, and entertain pa.s.sions of a particular turn. Some men, for instance, by the original frame of their minds, are more delighted with the vast and magnificent, others, on the contrary, with the elegant and gentle aspects of nature. And it is very remarkable, that the disposition of the moral powers is always similar to this of the imagination; that those who are most inclined to admire prodigious and sublime objects in the physical world, are also most inclined to applaud examples of fort.i.tude and heroic virtue in the moral. While those who are charmed rather with the delicacy and sweetness of colours, and forms, and sounds, never fail in like manner to yield the preference to the softer scenes of virtue and the sympathies of a domestic life. And this is sufficient to account for the objection.
Among the ancient philosophers, though we have several hints concerning this influence of the imagination upon morals among the remains of the Socratic school, yet the Stoics were the first who paid it a due attention. Zeno, their founder, thought it impossible to preserve any tolerable regularity in life, without frequently inspecting those pictures or appearances of things, which the imagination offers to the mind (_Diog. Laert_. I. vii.) The meditations of M. Aurelius, and the discourses of Epictetus, are full of the same sentiment; insomuch that the latter makes the [Greek: Chresis oia dei, fantasion], or right management of the fancies, the only thing for which we are accountable to Providence, and without which a man is no other than stupid or frantic (_Arrian_.
I. i. c. 12. and I. ii. c. 22). See also the _Characteristics_, vol. i. from p. 313 to 321, where this Stoical doctrine is embellished with all the elegance and graces of Plato.
ENDNOTE Y.
"_How Folly"s awkward arts_," etc.--P. 47.
Notwithstanding the general influence of ridicule on private and civil life, as well as on learning and the sciences, it has been almost constantly neglected or misrepresented, by divines especially.
The manner of treating these subjects in the science of human nature, should be precisely the same as in natural philosophy; from particular facts to investigate the stated order in which they appear, and then apply the general law, thus discovered, to the explication of other appearances and the improvement of useful arts.
ENDNOTE Z.
"_Behold the foremost band_," etc.--P. 48.
The first and most general source of ridicule in the characters of men, is vanity or self-applause for some desirable quality or possession which evidently does not belong to those who a.s.sume it.
ENDNOTE AA.
"_Then comes the second order_," etc.--P, 49.
Ridicule from the same vanity, where, though the possession be real, yet no merit can arise from it, because of some particular circ.u.mstances, which, though obvious to the spectator, are yet overlooked by the ridiculous character.
ENDNOTE BB.
"_Another tribe succeeds_," etc.--P. 50.
Ridicule from a notion of excellence in particular objects disproportioned to their intrinsic value, and inconsistent with the order of nature.
ENDNOTE CC.
"_But now, ye gay_," etc.--P. 51.
Ridicule from a notion of excellence, when the object is absolutely odious or contemptible. This is the highest degree of the ridiculous; as in the affectation of diseases or vices.
ENDNOTE DD.
"_Thus far triumphant_," etc.--P. 51
Ridicule from false shame or groundless fear.