Then, stepping with astonishing softness, considering his bulk, he approached the door of Sinclair"s room. Into his left hand slid his .45 and instantly five guns glinted in the hands of the others. With equal caution they ranged themselves behind the big Swede. The latter glanced over his shoulder, made sure that everything was in readiness, and then kicked the door violently open.
Riley Sinclair was sitting on the side of his bed, tugging on a pair of riding boots and singing a hushed song. He interrupted himself long enough to look up into the muzzle of La.r.s.en"s gun. Then deliberately he finished drawing on the boot, singing while he did so; and, still deliberately, rose and stamped his feet home in the leather. Next he dropped his hands on his hips and considered the posse gravely.
"Always heard tell how Sour Creek was a fine town but I didn"t know they turned out reception committees before sunup. How are you, boys?
Want my roll?"
La.r.s.en, as one who scorned to take a flying start on any man, dropped his weapon back in its holster. Sinclair"s own gun and cartridge belt hang on the wall at the foot of the bed.
"That sounds too cool to be straight," said the judge soberly.
"Sinclair, I figure you know why we want you?"
"I dunno, gents," said Sinclair, who grew more and more cheerful in the face of these six pairs of grim eyes. "But I"m sure obliged to the gent that give me the sendoff. What d"you want?" Drawing into the background La.r.s.en said: "Open up on him, judge. Start the questions."
But Sandersen was of no mind to let the slow-moving mind of the judge handle this affair which was so vital to him. If Riley Sinclair did not hang, Sandersen himself was instantly placed in peril of his life. He stepped in front of Sinclair and thrust out his long arm.
"You killed Quade!"
Riley Sinclair rubbed his chin thoughtfully, looking past his accuser.
"I don"t think so," he said at length.
"You don"t think so? Don"t you know?"
"They was two Mexicans jumped me once. One of "em was called Pedro.
Maybe the other was Quade. That who you"re talking about?"
"You can"t talk yourself out of it, Sinclair," said Denver Jim. "We mean business, real business, you"ll find out!"
"This here is a necktie party, maybe?" asked Riley Sinclair.
"It is, partner," said big La.r.s.en, with his continual smile.
"Sinclair, you come over the mountains," went on Sandersen. "You come to find Quade. You ride down off"n the hills, and you come up to Quade"s house. You call him out to talk to you. You"re sitting on your horse. All at once you s.n.a.t.c.h out a gun and shoot Quade down. We know!
That bullet ranged down. It was shot from above him, plain murder! He didn"t have a chance!"
Throwing out his facts as he saw them, one by one, there was a ring of conviction in his voice. The six accusing faces grew hard and set.
Then, to their astonishment, they saw that Sinclair was smiling!
"He don"t noways take us serious, gents," declared the judge. "Let"s take him out and see if a rope means anything to him. Sinclair, d"you figure this is a game with us?"
Riley Sinclair chuckled. "Gents," he said easily, "you come here all het up. You want a pile of action, but you ain"t going to get it off"n me--not a bit! I"ll tell you why. You gents are straight, and you know straight talk when you hear it. This dead man--what"s his name, Quade?--was killed by a gent that had a reason for killing him. Wanted to get Quade"s money, or they was an old grudge. But what could my reason be for wanting to b.u.mp off Quade? Can any of you figure that out? There"s my things. Look through "em and see if I got Quade"s money. Maybe you think it"s a grudge? Gents, I give you my word that I never been into this country before this trip. How could there be any grudge between me and Quade? Is that sense? Then talk sense back to me!"
His mirth had disappeared halfway through his speech, and in the latter part of it his voice rang sternly. Moreover he looked them in the eye, one by one. All of this was noted by Sandersen. He saw suddenly and clearly that he had lost. They would not hang this man by hearsay evidence, or by chance presumption.
Sinclair would go free. And if Sinclair went free, there would be short shrift for Bill Sandersen. For a moment he felt his destiny wavering back and forth on a needle point. Then he flung himself into a new course diametrically opposed to the other.
"Boys, it was me that started this, and I want to be the first to admit it"s a cold trail. Men has been hung with less agin" them than we got agin" Sinclair. We know when Quade must have been killed. We know it tallies pretty close with the time when Sinclair came down that same trail, because that was the way he rode into Sour Creek. But no matter how facts look, n.o.body _seen_ that shooting. And I say this gent Sinclair ain"t any murderer. Look him over, boys. He"s clean, and I register a vote for him. What d"you say? No matter what the rest of you figure, I"m going to shake hands with him. I like his style!"
He had turned his back on Riley while he spoke, but now he whirled and thrust out his hand. The fingers of Sinclair closed slowly over the proffered hand.
"When it comes to the names, partner, seems like you got an edge over me."
"Have I? I"m Sandersen. Glad to know you, Sinclair."
"Sandersen!" repeated the stranger slowly. "Sandersen!"
Letting his fingers fall away nervelessly from the hand of the other, he sighed deeply.
Sandersen with a side-glance followed every changing shade of expression in that hard face. How could Sinclair attack a man who had just defended him from a terrible charge? It could not be. For the moment, at least, Sandersen felt he was safe. In the future, many things might happen. At the very least, he had gained a priceless postponement of the catastrophe.
"Them that do me a good turn is writ down in red," Sinclair was saying; "and them that step on my toes is writ down the same way. Sandersen, I got an idea that for one reason or another I ain"t going to forget you in a hurry."
There was a grim double meaning in that speech which Sandersen alone could understand. The others of the self-appointed posse had apparently made up their minds that Sandersen was right, and that this was a cold trail.
"It"s like Sinclair says," admitted the judge. "We got to find a gent that had a reason for wishing to have Quade die. Where"s the man?"
"Hunt for the reason first and find the man afterward," said big La.r.s.en, still smiling.
"All right! Did anybody owe Quade money, anybody Quade was pressing for it?"
It was the judge who advanced the argument in this solemn and dry form.
Denver Jim declared that to his personal knowledge Quade had neither borrowed nor loaned.
"Well, then, had Quade ever made many enemies? We know Quade was a fighter. Recollect any gents that might hold grudges?"
"Young Penny hated the ground he walked on. Quade beat Penny to a pulp down by the Perkin water hole."
"Penny wouldn"t do a murder."
"Maybe it was a fair fight," broke in La.r.s.en.
"Fair nothin"," said Buck Mason. "Don"t we all know that Quade was fast with a gun? He barely had it out in his hand when the other gent drilled him. And he was shot from above. No, sir, the way it happened was something like this. The murderin" skunk sat on his hoss saying goodby to Quade, and, while they was shaking hands or something like that, he goes for his gun and plugs Quade. Maybe it was a gent that knew he didn"t have a chance agin" Quade. Maybe--"
He broke off short in his deductions and smote his hands together with a tremendous oath. "Boys, I got it! It"s Cold Feet that done the job.
It"s Gaspar that done it!"
They stared at Buck vaguely.
"Mason, Cold Feet ain"t got the nerve to shoot a rabbit."
"Not in a fight. This was a murder!"
"What"s the schoolteacher"s reason!"
"Don"t he love Sally Bent? Didn"t Quade love her?" He raised his voice.
"I"m a big fool for forgetting! Didn"t I see him ride over the hill to Quade"s place and come back in the evening? Didn"t I see it? Why else would he have called on Quade?"
There was a round chorus of oaths and exclamations. "The poisonous little skunk! It"s him! We"ll string him up!"