Simon hated to admit it, but Ugolini"s words made perfect sense to him.
"They will do it everywhere!" cried someone in the audience.
Now David said through Ugolini, "What is more, the Tartars who rule in Russia have converted to Islam. They still dream of the conquest of Europe and may return to the attack at any time. Perhaps while your armies are occupied in Egypt or Syria."
Fra Toma.s.so raised his quill for attention. "How would you describe the character of the Tartars, Master David? What sort of men are they?"
David answered and then looked about with his bright, compelling gaze while Ugolini translated. "I have lived among the Tartars and traveled with them. The Tartar is unmoved by his own pain or by that of his fellows. The suffering of other people merely amuses him. His word given to a foreigner means nothing to him. He thinks his own race superior to all other peoples on earth."
Fra Toma.s.so said, "What you have told us has been most enlightening, Master David, because you have seen with your own eyes. But if your empire of Trebizond now trades with the Tartars, how is it that you come here to denounce them?"
"I came to Orvieto as a merchant bearing samples of silk from Cathay,"
said David. "It is only, as Cardinal Ugolini has said, G.o.d"s providence that I am here when you are deciding this great question."
Fra Toma.s.so turned to Pope Urban. "Holy Father, is there anything else you wish me to ask?"
Pope Urban shook his head. "I believe I have heard enough for now. We do not want to sit here all day." Smiling, he turned to David. "Master David, we thank you for coming all this way to bring us this warning."
"Your Holiness." David bowed, a fluid movement that made Simon grunt with distaste.
_Curse the luck! Why is there no one here who knows the Tartars to answer this David? How do we know he is not a liar? A Greek silk merchant is not the sort of person I would trust. He would say anything if he thought it would help him sell his wares._
But doubt cooled Simon"s anger. He did not want to admit it, but Cosmas"s and David"s tales had frightened him. He thought of the hard, cold faces of John and Philip. He _could_ see them beheading women, shooting children with arrows.
_Do we want to ally ourselves with such creatures?_
King Louis did. Count Charles d"Anjou, Uncle Charles, wanted the alliance. Simon had agreed to come here. How could he face Uncle Charles, what could he say, if he changed his mind?
A lifetime of scorn, that was what lay ahead of him if he were to turn back now.
David sat stiffly upright, his hands resting on his knees, as Cardinal Ugolini approached the pope, reaching out in appeal.
"Holy Father, your predecessor, Clement III of happy memory, declared a crusade against the Tartars after the battle of Mohi. I beg you to sound the alarm again, like that brave trumpeter of Krakow. A Christian prince should no more make a pact with the Tartars than with the devil. Let the nations of Christendom be warned in the sternest terms. Let us declare excommunicate any Christian ruler who allies himself with the Tartars."
Shocked outcries burst from all parts of the hall. Simon went cold. The thought of King Louis being excommunicated horrified him. But surely it would not come to that. King Louis was too loyal a Catholic to defy the pope. But that, then, meant that Simon"s mission would fail.
De Verceuil jumped to his feet. "You, Ugolini! You should be excommunicated for even suggesting such a thing!"
"Cardinal Paulus, you yourself have had much to say out of turn," Pope Urban said testily. "I give you leave now to speak in favor of this proposed alliance."
De Verceuil took his stand in front of the papal throne, and Ugolini returned to his place in the pews.
_If only the pope favored us more. He is a Frenchman, after all. What about this Manfred von Hohenstaufen? The pope needs French help there.
But what a disaster for us that he asks de Verceuil to speak. If any man can turn friends into enemies, it is de Verceuil. We need Friar Mathieu.
In G.o.d"s name, where is he? He could answer this David of Trebizond._
De Verceuil quickly dismissed the Hungarian"s testimony. All that, he said, happened a generation ago. Today the Tartars would not win such easy victories in Europe because we know more about them, and they would not invade Europe again because they know more about us. The Tartars have new leaders since those days, and that is why they have chosen to make war on the Mohammedans. Christian friars have gone among them, and many Tartars have been baptized. The wife of Hulagu Khan is a Christian.
Wherever the khan and his wife travel, they take a Christian chapel mounted on a cart, and ma.s.s is said for them daily.
"Yes!" Ugolini cried from his seat. "A Nestorian chapel. The khan"s wife and the other Tartars you call Christians are Nestorian heretics."
"From what I have heard of your dabblings in alchemy and astrology, it ill behooves you to speak of heresy, Cardinal Ugolini," said de Verceuil darkly.
Ugolini stood up and advanced on de Verceuil, who was twice his height.
"As for Christian friars going among the Tartars"--he held up a small book--"let me read--"
De Verceuil turned to Pope Urban. "Holy Father, you have given me leave to speak."
"True, but more than once you interrupted him," said Urban with a smile.
"Let us hear this."
"The Franciscan Friar William of Rubruk, at the command of King Louis of France, visited the court of the Tartar emperor in Karakorum," said Ugolini. "This is his account of his travels in that pagan capital. He says the Tartars were so stubborn in their ways that he made not a single convert." He opened to a page marked with a ribbon. "Here is his conclusion, after years among the Tartars--"Were it allowed me, I would to the utmost of my power preach war against them throughout the whole world."" Ugolini slapped the book shut and sat down, looking triumphant.
De Verceuil failed to respond immediately. What a poor advocate he was, Simon thought. If only Friar Mathieu were here. He, too, was a Franciscan like this William of Rubruk, and he might well have the answer to Rubruk"s words.
"Friar William," de Verceuil said at last, "wrote years before the Tartars conquered Baghdad. As for me, I count myself happy to have heard the words of this merchant from Trebizond." He pointed a long finger at David, who stood in the crowd about twenty feet away from Simon. David looked back at de Verceuil with a rigid face full of raw hatred that reminded Simon of what he had read about basilisks.
"Happy, I say," de Verceuil went on, "to hear every detail of the utter destruction of that center of the Satanic worship of Mohammed. I was reminded of the rain of fire and brimstone that wiped out Sodom and Gomorrah. My heart sang with joy when I heard of the caliph, successor of that false prophet, trampled by Tartar horses. I hold that the Tartars are G.o.d"s instrument for the final downfall of His enemies. What wonderful allies they will make as we liberate the Holy Land from the Saracens once and for all!"
"And who will liberate the Holy Land from the Tartars?" a cardinal, forgetting his Latin, shouted in Italian.
"Be still, you fool!" cried another cardinal in French.
The Italian advanced on the Frenchman. "Whoever says "Thou _fool_!""--he gave the French cardinal a vicious shove with both hands--"shall be liable to the _judgment_." Another shove.
Fra Toma.s.so rang his small bell furiously, but the furious prelates ignored him.
Now someone had seized the Italian from behind. Simon was shocked, having never dreamed the leaders of the Church could be so unruly. It seemed that anything the French cardinals were for, the Italians were against. And was the pope, though a Frenchman, likely to approve the alliance, with nearly half the cardinals against it? And even if he did, could it succeed in the face of that much opposition?
"Pax!" the pope cried, climbing a few steps toward his throne and lifting his arms heavenward. "Peace!" The angry sound of his voice and the sight of him slowly brought quiet to the hall.
Urban took them to task. The whole future of Christendom might be at stake, and they were brawling like university students. Perhaps he should treat them like students and have them whipped. Sheepishly the cardinals and bishops took their seats with much rustling of red and purple robes.
D"Aquino asked de Verceuil if he had finished. He said he had, and Simon"s heart sank.
_I promised Uncle Charles I would work to further the alliance. I want to believe in it._
But after listening to Ugolini"s two witnesses and de Verceuil"s feeble attempt to refute them, he was beset by frightening doubts.
He prayed he would not have to reverse himself. If he changed his colors now and repudiated the alliance, Count Charles might well feel himself betrayed and say that Simon was no better than his father.
"But did not a Franciscan named"--the stout Dominican consulted his notes on parchment--"Mathieu d"Alcon journey from Outremer with these Tartar amba.s.sadors? Why is he not here to tell us what he knows about them?"
Hope leapt up in Simon"s heart. Yes! If they would only hear Friar Mathieu, that might yet win the day for the alliance.
_And it might help me to feel I am doing the right thing._
"I a.s.sumed, before this august body, my testimony would be sufficient,"
said de Verceuil with a slight stammer. "After all, what could a mere Franciscan friar add--"