"You"re strong in theory but weak in proof."
That style of argument invariably nettled Furneaux.
"You must b.u.t.t into a few more mysterious suites of apartments in London and elsewhere, and you"ll supply proof in bucketfuls," he snapped.
"But was there an accomplice? Squirm as you like, you can"t get over the fact that Hilton was in his room when the bullet that killed his father came from the wood."
"He is not the sort of person likely to trust his liberty, his life even, to the keeping of any other human being. I start from the hypothesis that he alone planned and carried out the crime, so I do not lift my hand and cry "Impossible," but I ask myself, "How was it done?" Well, there are several methods worthy of consideration--clockwork, electricity, even a time fuse attached to the proper mechanism. I haven"t really bothered myself yet to determine the means, because when that knowledge becomes indispensable we must have our man under lock and key."
"Of course, the rifle is securely fixed in that----"
The door opened. Tomlinson came in, smiling blandly.
"I hope you are enjoying your dinner, gentlemen both?" he said.
"You have made your cook an artist," said Furneaux.
"I suppose you are happier here than in a big London restaurant," said Winter.
The butler appreciated such subtle compliments, and beamed on them.
"With a little encouragement and advice, our chef can prepare a very eatable dinner," he said. "As for my own ambitions, I have had them, like every man worth his salt; but I fill a comfortable chair here--no worry, no grumbling, not a soul to say _nem_ or _con_, so long as things go smoothly."
"It must have been _nem_ all the time," giggled Furneaux, and Winter was so afflicted by a desire to sneeze that he buried his face in a napkin.
"And how was the wine?" went on Tomlinson, with an eye on the little man. Furneaux"s features were crinkled in a j.a.panese smile. He wanted to kick Winter, who was quivering with suppressed laughter.
"I never expected to find such vintages in a house of the _mauvais riches_," he said. "Perhaps you don"t speak French, Mr. Tomlinson, so allow me to explain that I am alluding to men of wealth not born in the purple."
"Precisely--self-made. Well sir, poor Mr. Fenley left the stocking of his cellar entirely to me. I gave the matter much thought. When my knowledge was at fault I consulted experts, and the result----"
"That is the result," cried Furneaux, seizing the empty claret bottle, and planting it so firmly on the table that the cutlery danced.
A shoulder of lamb, served _a la Soubise_, appeared; and Tomlinson, announcing that his presence in the dining-room had been dispensed with, thought he would join them in a snack. Being a hospitable creature, he opened another bottle of the Clos Vosgeot, but his guests were not to be tempted.
"Well, then," he said, "in a few minutes you must try our port. It is not Alto Douro, Mr. Furneaux, but it has body and bowket."
Winter was better prepared this time. Moreover he was carving, and aware of a master"s criticism, and there are occult problems connected with even such a simple joint as a shoulder of lamb. Furneaux, too, was momentarily subdued. He seemed to be reflecting sadly that statues of gold, silver and bronze may have feet of clay.
"I have often thought, gentlemen," said the butler, "that yours must be a most interesting profession. You meet all sorts and conditions of men and women."
"We consort with the n.o.blest malefactors," agreed Furneaux.
"Dear me, sir, you do use the queerest words. Now, I should never dream of describing a criminal as n.o.ble."
"Not in the generally accepted sense, perhaps. But you, I take it, have not had the opportunity of attending a really remarkable trial, when, say, some intellectual giant among murderers is fighting for his life. Believe me, no drama of the stage can rival that tragedy.
"The chief actor, remote, solitary, fenced away from the world he is hoping to reenter, sits there in state. Every eye is on him, yet he faces judge, jury, counsel, witnesses and audience with a calm dignity worthy of an emperor. He listens imperturbably to facts which may hang him, to lies which may lend color to the facts, to well-meaning guesses which are wide of the mark. Truthful and false evidence is equally p.r.o.ne to err when guilt or innocence must be determined by circ.u.mstances alone.
"But the prisoner _knows_. He is the one man able to discriminate between truth and falsity, yet he must not reveal the cruel stab of fact or the harmless buffet of fiction by so much as a flicker of an eyelid. He surveys the honest blunderer and the perjured ruffian--I mean the counsel for the defense and the prosecution respectively--with impartial scrutiny. If he is a sublime villain, he will call on Heaven to testify that he is innocent with a solemnity not surpa.s.sed by the judge who sentences him to death....
Yes, please, a bit off the knuckle end."
The concluding words were addressed to Winter, and Tomlinson started, for he was wrapped up in the scene Furneaux was depicting.
"That point of view had not occurred to me," he admitted.
"You"ll appreciate it fully when you see Mr. Fenley"s murderer in the dock," said Furneaux.
"Ah, sir. That brings your ill.u.s.tration home, indeed. But shall we ever know who killed him?"
"Certainly. Look at that high dome of intelligence glistening at you across the table. But that it is forbid to tell the secrets of the prison house, it could a tale unfold whose slightest word would harrow up thy soul----"
Harris, the footman, entered, carrying a decanter.
"Mr. Hilton Fenley"s compliments, gentlemen, and will you try this port? He says Mr. Tomlinson will recommend it, because Mr. Fenley himself seldom takes wine. Mr. Fenley will not trouble you to meet him again this evening. Mr. Tomlinson, Mr. Fenley wants you for a moment."
The butler rose.
"That is the very wine I spoke of," he said. "If Mr. Hilton did not touch it, Mr. Robert evidently appreciated it."
He glanced at Harris, but the footman did not even suspect that his character was at stake. The decanter was nearly full when placed on the sideboard; now it was half empty.
Singularly enough, both Winter and Furneaux had intercepted that questioning glance, and had acquitted Harris simultaneously.
"Are the gentlemen still in the dining-room?" inquired Winter.
"Mr. Hilton is there, sir, but Mr. Robert went out some time since."
"Please convey our thanks to Mr. Hilton. I"m sure we shall enjoy the wine."
When Tomlinson and Harris had gone, the eyes of the two detectives met. They said nothing at first, and it may be remembered that they were reputedly most dangerous to a pursued criminal when working together silently. Winter took the decanter, poured out a small quant.i.ty into two gla.s.ses, and gave Furneaux one. Then they smelled, and tasted, and examined the wine critically. The rich red liquid might have been a poisonous decoction for the care they devoted to its a.n.a.lysis.
Furneaux began.
"I have so many sleepless nights that I recognize bromide, no matter how it is disguised," he murmured.
"Comparatively harmless, though a strong dose," said Winter.
"If one has to swallow twenty grains or so of pota.s.sium bromide I can not conceive any pleasanter way of taking them than mixed with a sound port."
Winter filled one of the gla.s.ses four times, pouring each amount into a tumbler. Furneaux looked into a cupboard, and found an empty beer bottle, which he rinsed with water. Meanwhile Winter was fashioning a funnel out of a torn envelope, and in a few seconds the tumblerful of wine was in the bottle, and the bottle in Winter"s pocket. This done, the big man lit a cigar and the little one sniffed the smoke, which was his peculiar way of enjoying the weed.
"It was most thoughtful of Mr. Hilton Fenley to try and secure us a long night"s uninterrupted sleep," said Winter between puffs.
"But what a vitiated taste in wine he must attribute to Scotland Yard," said Furneaux bitterly.
"Still, we should be grateful to him for supplying a gill of real evidence."
"I may forgive him later. At present, I want to dilate his eyes with atropine, so that he may see weird shapes and be tortured of ghouls."