I suggested to General Canby, that the capture of horses was in violation of the armistice, and that they should be returned. The general objected, saying, that they should be well cared for and turned over when peace was made.
Dr. Eleazer Thomas, of California, at the request of Senator Sargent, was added to the commission, as was, also, Mr. Dyer, agent of the Klamath Indians.
Dr. Thomas brought with him a long and successful experience as a minister of the Methodist Church. He had lived on the Pacific coast for eighteen years; but he had little experience or knowledge of Indians. Being a man of great purity of character and untiring energy, coupled with a humane heart and active hand, he threw himself into this new mission with earnestness, and was impatient to begin to do something towards the accomplishment of _peace_.
Gen. Canby was sending out exploring parties of armed mounted men occasionally,--the ostensible object of which was to obtain a better knowledge of the country around the Lava Beds, with a view to moving the army nearer the Modocs. The commission was not informed of these expeditions, or their objects, by Gen. Canby, but through other parties.
On one occasion, Dr. Thomas went out with a company, and while surveying the Lava Beds at a distance, they met several Modocs, with whom he talked, and succeeded in reopening communication.
A delegation of Indians visited the new camp at Van Bremens. Every effort made through them to secure a meeting with the Board of Commissioners and Modocs failed.
Gen. Canby notified the Modoc chief of his intention to change the position of the army, so that the communications might be more easily made; and, also, that he would not commence hostilities against them unless they provoked an attack.
Captain Jack"s reply was, that he would not "fire the first shot;" but, through his messengers, he asked a return of his horses.
Indians have great love for their horses. When a small company of the Modoc women came in asking for their ponies, they were denied them, but were permitted to go under guard to the corral and see them. It was a touching scene,--those Indian women caressing their ponies. They turned sadly away, when compelled, by orders, to leave the corral.
The fact is, several of these ponies had already been appropriated for the use of _young_ soldiers, at home, when the war should be over.
On the last day of March, 1873, the camp at Van Bremens was broken up, and the army was put in motion for the Lava Beds.
I was never shown any order from either department, at Washington city, that authorized this movement, though I do not doubt Gen. Canby felt justified in so doing.
The commission was notified--not consulted. We were under instructions "in no wise to interfere with the army movement, but always, as far as possible, to confer and co-operate with Gen. Canby."
Four days were occupied in moving. We arrived at the top of the bluff overlooking this now historic spot of rocks, about noon of the second day.
How little we knew then of the near future, when Gen. Canby and Dr. Thomas would be carried, in rough-made coffins, _up_ the zigzag road that we went down on that day!
Our new camp was pitched near the foot of this high bluff, and immediately on the sh.o.r.e of the lake. From it, with a field-gla.s.s, we could see Capt.
Jack"s people moving around their rocky home, not more than one mile and a half, air-line, though two miles around by land.
While my memory is still green with the scenes that followed, and I have not justified and will not justify or seek to palliate the crimes of the Modocs, still I cannot forget some of the meditations of the half hour I sat with Dr. Thomas, when half-way down the bluff, up which I was not to go at all, and the doctor only as a corpse.
I have recollections yet of a part, at least, of the conversation between us. We were representing one of the most powerful governments in the world, and bearing peace and human kindness in our hearts, while pa.s.sing us, as we sat, were the sinews of war,--armed soldiers by the hundred.
Cannon were being dragged down the hill, tents were being erected, and all the circ.u.mstance of military power and display was at our feet or above us, hastening to compel an infuriated, misguided people to acknowledge the authority of our Government.
Over yonder, within range of our gla.s.ses, were a half-hundred men, unlettered, uncivilized, and infuriated by a superst.i.tious religious faith, that urged them to reject the "olive-branch" which we came to offer them.
We could see beyond them another army of ten times their number, camping nearer to them.
The doctor was moved by deep feeling of compa.s.sion for them, and spoke very earnestly of their helpless condition,--benighted in mind, without enough of the great principles of Christian justice and power to recognize and respect the individual rights of others. Doomed as a race, hopeless and in despair, they sat on their stony cliffs, around their caves, and counted the men, and horses, and guns, that came down the hill to _make peace_ with them, turning their eyes only to see the sight repeated.
Look nearer at the boys with blue dress, as they pa.s.s us, bearing camp equipage. Many of the men are going down this hill to _stay_, unless we can make peace with the Modocs. Our hearts grow sick at the thoughts suggested by our surroundings.
Mutually pledging anew to stand together for peace as long as there was a hope, we slowly followed down to the camp.
I cannot forbear mentioning an accident of the evening.
Gen. Canby"s tent was partly up when I pa.s.sed near him. He said, "Well, Mr. Meacham, where is your tent?"--"It has not come," I replied.
The general ordered the men to pull up the pins and move his tent to the site we had selected for ours. It was only by the most earnest entreaty on our part that he countermanded the order, and then only on our promise to share his tent with him, if ours was not put up in time for us to occupy for the night.
On the day following our arrival a meeting was had with the Modocs. On our part, Gen. Canby, Gen. Gilliam, Dr. Thomas, Mr. Dyer and myself, Frank Riddle and Tobey as interpreters. Some of our party were armed; others were not. Riddle and his wife Tobey were suspicious of treachery, and said, as we went, "Be sure to mix up with the Modocs; don"t let them get you in a bunch."
"Boston," who had come to our camp to arrange for the meeting, led the way. We saw arising, apparently out of the rocks, a smoke. When we arrived we found Captain Jack, and the princ.i.p.al men of his band, and about half-a-dozen women standing by a fire built in a low, rocky basin.
Dr. Thomas was the first to descend. He did not seem to observe, indeed he did not observe, that we were going entirely out of sight of the field-gla.s.ses at our camp.
The place suggested treachery, especially after Riddle"s warning. I scanned the rocks around the rim of the basin, but did not see ambushed men; nevertheless, I had some misgiving; but it was too late to retreat then, and to have refused to join the council would have invited an attack. The greetings were cordial; nothing that indicated danger except the place, and the fact that there were three times as many Indians as "Boston" had said would be there. One rea.s.suring circ.u.mstance was the presence of their women. But this may have been only a blind. After smoking the pipe of _peace_ the talk opened, each one of our party making short speeches in favor of peace, and showing good intentions. The chief replied in a short preliminary talk; Schonchin also. We stated our object, and explained why the soldiers were brought so closely,--that we wanted to feel safe.
Thus pa.s.sed nearly an hour, when an incident occurred that caused some of our party to change position very quietly.
Hooker Jim said to Mr. Riddle, "Stand aside,--get out of the way!" in Modoc. Some of us understood what it meant. Tobey moved close to our party and reprimanded Hooker. Captain Jack said to him, "Stop that."
This lava bed country being at an alt.i.tude of four thousand five hundred feet, and immediately under the lee of high mountains on the west, is subject to heavy storms.
While we were talking, a black cloud overspread the rocks and a rain-storm came on.
Gen. Canby remarked that "We could not talk in the rain." Captain Jack seemed to treat the remark with ridicule, though the interpreters omitted to mention the fact. He said "The rain was a small matter;" that "Gen.
Canby was better clothed than he was," but "he (Jack) would not melt like snow."
Gen. Canby proposed to erect a council tent on half-way ground, where subsequent meetings could be held.
This proposition was agreed to, and just as the storm was at its height.
No agreement was made for another meeting, although it was understood that negotiations would be continued.
CHAPTER XXVII.
CAPTAIN JACK A DIPLOMAT--SHOOT ME IF YOU DARE.
On the following day the council tent was erected in a comparatively smooth plot of land, in the Lava Beds, care being taken to select a site as far as possible from rocks that might answer for an ambuscade.
This place was less than one mile from our camp, and a little more than a mile from the Modocs. Meanwhile the signal corps had established communication between the two army camps. The signal station at our camp was half way up the bluff, and commanded a view of the council tent, and of the trail leading to it from the Modoc stronghold, as it did of the entire Lava Beds.
Col. Mason"s command being on the opposite side of Captain Jack"s head-quarters, from our camp, the three were almost in a line.
Communication was also established between the army camps, with boats going from one to the other, and, in doing so, pa.s.sing in full view of the Modocs.
The Modocs were permitted to visit the head-quarters during the day, and to mix and mingle with the officers and men. The object of this liberty was to convince them of the friendly intentions of the army, and also of its power, as they everywhere saw the arms and munitions of war. They were also permitted to examine the sh.e.l.l mortars and the sh.e.l.ls themselves.
On one occasion Bogus Charley and Hooker Jim observed the signal telegraph working, and inquired the meaning of it. They were told by Gen. Gilliam that he was talking to the other camp; that he knew what was going on over there; they were also informed that Col. Mason would move up nearer to their camp in a few days, and that he, Gen. Gilliam, would move his camp on to the little flat very near Captain Jack"s. "But don"t you shoot my men. I won"t shoot your men, but I am going over there to see if everything is all right." Gen. Gilliam also informed them that, "in a few days, one hundred Warm Spring braves would be there."
These things excited the Modocs very much. Bogus Charley questioned General Gilliam, "What for you talk over my home? I no like that. What for the Warm Springs come here?" Receiving no satisfactory reply, they went to Fairchild, who was in camp, and expressed much dissatisfaction on account of the signal telegraph, and the coming of the Warm Spring Indians.