"It"s what the G.o.ds mean by justice that I must listen to."
"Justice is justice, whatever the G.o.ds might say!"
Almost Qing-jao rose up from the floor and slapped her secret maid. It would have been her right, for w.a.n.g-mu was causing her as much pain as if she had struck her. But it was not Qing-jao"s way to strike a person who was not free to strike back. Besides, there was a far more interesting puzzle here. After all, the G.o.ds had sent w.a.n.g-mu to her-Qing-jao was already sure of that. So instead of arguing with w.a.n.g-mu directly, Qing-jao should try to understand what the G.o.ds meant meant by sending her a servant who would say such shameful, disrespectful things. by sending her a servant who would say such shameful, disrespectful things.
The G.o.ds had caused w.a.n.g-mu to say that it was unjust to punish Qing-jao for simply hearing another person"s disrespectful opinions. Perhaps w.a.n.g-mu"s statement was true. But it was also true that the G.o.ds could not be unjust. Therefore it must be that Qing-jao was not being punished for simply hearing the treasonous opinions of the people. No, Qing-jao had to purify herself because, in her heart of hearts, some part of her must believe believe those opinions. She must cleanse herself because deep inside she still doubted the heavenly mandate of Starways Congress; she still believed they were not just. those opinions. She must cleanse herself because deep inside she still doubted the heavenly mandate of Starways Congress; she still believed they were not just.
Qing-jao immediately crawled to the nearest wall and began looking for the right woodgrain line to follow. Because of w.a.n.g-mu"s words, Qing-jao had discovered a secret filthiness inside herself. The G.o.ds had brought her another step closer to knowing the darkest places inside herself, so that she might someday be utterly filled with light and thus earn the name that even now was still only a mockery. Some part of me doubts the righteousness of Starways Congress. O G.o.ds, for the sake of my ancestors, my people, and my rulers, and last of all for me, purge this doubt from me and make me clean!
When she finished tracing the line-- and it took only a single line to make her clean, which was a good sign that she had learned something true-- there sat w.a.n.g-mu, watching her. All of Qing-jao"s anger was gone now, and indeed she was grateful to w.a.n.g-mu for having been an unwitting tool of the G.o.ds in helping her learn new truth. But still, w.a.n.g-mu had to understand that she had been out of line.
"In this house, we are loyal servants of Starways Congress," said Qingjao, her voice soft, her expression as kind as she could make it. "And if you"re a loyal servant of this house, you"ll also serve Congress with all your heart." How could she explain to w.a.n.g-mu how painfully she had learned that lesson herself-- how painfully she was still learning it? She needed w.a.n.g-mu to help her, not make it harder.
"Holy one, I didn"t know," said w.a.n.g-mu, "I didn"t guess. I had always heard the name of Han Fei-tzu mentioned as the n.o.blest servant of Path. I thought it was the Path that you served, not Congress, or I never would have..."
"Never would have come to work here?"
"Never would have spoken harshly about Congress," said w.a.n.g-mu. "I would serve you even if you lived in the house of a dragon."
Maybe I do, thought Qing-jao. Maybe the G.o.d who purifies me is a dragon, cold and hot, terrible and beautiful.
"Remember, w.a.n.g-mu, that the world called Path is not the Path itself, but only was named so to remind us to live the true Path every day. My father and I serve Congress because they have the mandate of heaven, and so the Path requires that we serve them even above the wishes or needs of the particular world called Path."
w.a.n.g-mu looked at her with wide eyes, unblinking. Did she understand? Did she believe? No matter-- she would come to believe in time.
"Go away now, w.a.n.g-mu. I have to work."
"Yes, Qing-jao." w.a.n.g-mu immediately got up and backed away, bowing. Qing-jao turned back to her terminal. But as she began to call up more reports into the display, she became aware that someone was in the room with her. She whirled around on her chair; there in the doorway stood w.a.n.g-mu.
"What is it?" asked Qing-jao.
"Is it the duty of a secret maid to tell you whatever wisdom comes to her mind, even if it turns out to be foolishness?"
"You can say whatever you like to me," said Qing-jao. "Have I ever punished you?"
"Then please forgive me, my Qing-jao, if I dare to say something about this great task you are working on."
What did w.a.n.g-mu know of the Lusitania Fleet? w.a.n.g-mu was a quick student, but Qing-jao was still teaching her at such a primitive level in every subject that it was absurd to think w.a.n.g-mu could even grasp the problems, let alone think of an answer. Nevertheless, Father had taught her: Servants are always happier when they know their voices are heard by their master. "Please tell me," said Qing-jao. "How can you say anything more foolish than the things I I have already said?" have already said?"
"My beloved elder sister," said w.a.n.g-mu, "I really got this idea from you. You"ve said so many times that nothing known to all of science and history could possibly have caused the fleet to disappear so perfectly, and all at once."
"But it happened," said Qing-jao, "and so it must be possible after all."
"What came to my mind, my sweet Qing-jao," said w.a.n.g-mu, "is some thing you explained to me as we studied logic. About first and final cause. All this time you have been looking for first causes-- how the fleet was made to disappear. But have you looked for final causes-- what someone hoped to accomplish by cutting off the fleet, or even destroying it?"
"Everyone knows why why people want the fleet stopped. They"re trying to protect the rights of colonies, or else they have some ridiculous idea that Congress means to destroy the pequeninos along with the whole colony. There are billions of people who want the fleet to stop. All of them are seditious in their hearts, and enemies of the G.o.ds." people want the fleet stopped. They"re trying to protect the rights of colonies, or else they have some ridiculous idea that Congress means to destroy the pequeninos along with the whole colony. There are billions of people who want the fleet to stop. All of them are seditious in their hearts, and enemies of the G.o.ds."
"But somebody actually did did it," said w.a.n.g-mu. "I only thought that since you can"t find out what happened to the fleet directly, then maybe if you find out it," said w.a.n.g-mu. "I only thought that since you can"t find out what happened to the fleet directly, then maybe if you find out who who made it happen, that will lead you to find out how they did it." made it happen, that will lead you to find out how they did it."
"We don"t even know that it was done by a who who," said Qing-jao. "It could have been a what what. Natural phenomena don"t have purposes in mind, since they don"t have minds."
w.a.n.g-mu bowed her head. "I did did waste your time, then, Qing-jao. Please forgive me. I should have left when you told me to go." waste your time, then, Qing-jao. Please forgive me. I should have left when you told me to go."
"It"s all right," said Qing-jao.
w.a.n.g-mu was already gone; Qing-jao didn"t know whether her servant had even heard her rea.s.surance. Never mind, thought Qing-jao. If w.a.n.gmu was offended, I"ll make it up to her later. It was sweet of the girl to think she could help me with my task; I"ll make sure she knows I"m glad she has such an eager heart.
With w.a.n.g-mu out of the room, Qing-jao went back to her terminal. She idly flipped the reports through her terminal"s display. She had looked at all of them before, and she had found nothing useful. Why should this time be different? Maybe these reports and summaries showed her nothing because there was nothing to show. Maybe the fleet disappeared because of some G.o.d-gone-berserk; there were stories of such things in ancient times. Maybe there was no evidence of human intervention because a human didn"t do it. What would Father say about that that, she wondered. How would Congress deal with a lunatic deity? They couldn"t even track down that seditious writer Demosthenes-- what hope did they have of tracking and trapping a G.o.d?
Whoever Demosthenes is, he"s laughing right now, thought Qing-jao. All his work to persuade people that the government was wrong to send the Lusitania Fleet, and now the fleet has stopped, just as Demosthenes wanted.
Just as Demosthenes wanted. For the first time, Qing-jao made a mental connection that was so obvious she couldn"t believe she hadn"t thought of it before. It was so obvious, in fact, that the police in many a city had a.s.sumed that those who were already known to follow Demosthenes must surely have been involved in making the fleet disappear. They had rounded up everyone suspected of sedition and tried to force confessions out of them. But of course they hadn"t actually questioned Demosthenes Demosthenes, because n.o.body knew who he was.
Demosthenes, so clever he has evaded discovery for years, despite all the searching of the Congress Police; Demosthenes, who is every bit as elusive as the cause of the disappearance of the fleet. If he could work the one trick, why not the other? Maybe if I find Demosthenes, I"ll find out how the fleet was cut off. Not that I have any idea even where to start looking. But at least it"s a different avenue of approach. At least it won"t mean reading the same empty, useless reports over and over again.
Suddenly Qing-jao remembered who had said almost exactly the same thing, only moments before. She felt herself blushing, the blood hot in her cheeks. How arrogant I was, to condescend to w.a.n.g-mu, to patronize her for imagining she could help me with my lofty task. And now, not five minutes later, the thought she planted in my mind has blossomed into a plan. Even if the plan fails, she was the one who gave it to me, or at least started me thinking of it. Thus I was the fool to think her foolish. Tears of shame filled Qing-jao"s eyes.
Then she thought of some famous lines from a song by her ancestor-of-the-heart.
I want to call back the blackberry flowers that have fallen though pear blossoms remain
The poet Li Qing-jao knew the pain of regretting words that have already fallen from our lips and can never be called back. But she was wise enough to remember that even though those words are gone, there are still new words waiting to be said, like the pear blossoms.
To comfort herself for the shame of having been so arrogant, Qing-jao repeated all the words of the song; or at least she started to. But when she got to the line
dragon boats on the river
her mind drifted to the Lusitania Fleet, imagining all those starships like riverboats, painted so fiercely, and yet drifting now with the current, so far from the sh.o.r.e that they can no longer be heard no matter how loud they shout.
From dragon boats her thoughts turned to dragon kites, and now she thought of the Lusitania Fleet as kites with broken strings, carried along by the wind, no longer tethered to the child who first gave them flight. How beautiful, to see them free; yet how terrifying it must be for them, who never wished for freedom.
I did not fear the mad winds and violent rain
The words of the song came back to her again. I did not fear. Mad winds. Violent rain. I did not fear as
we drank to good fortune with warm blackberry wine now I cannot conceive how to retrieve that time
My ancestor-of-the-heart could drink away her fear, thought Qing-jao, because she had someone to drink with. And even now,
alone on my mat with a cup gazing sadly into nothingness
the poet remembers her gone companion. Whom do I remember now? thought Qing-jao. Where is my tender love? What an age it must have been then, when the great Li Qing-jao was still mortal, and men and women could be together as tender friends without any worry about who was G.o.dspoken and who was not. Then a woman could live such a life that even in her loneliness she had memories. I can"t even remember my mother"s face. Only the flat pictures; I can"t remember seeing her face turn and move while her eyes looked at me. I have only my Father, who is like a G.o.d; I can worship him and obey him and even love him but I can never be playful with him, not really; when I tease him I"m always watching to be sure he approves of the way I tease him. And w.a.n.g-mu; I talked so firmly about how we would be friends, and yet I treat her like a servant, I never for a moment forget who is G.o.dspoken and who is not. It"s a wall that can never be crossed. I"m alone now and I"m alone forever.
a clear cold comes through the window curtains crescent moon beyond the golden bars
She shivered. I and the moon. Didn"t the Greeks think of their moon as a cold virgin, a huntress? Is that not what I am now? Sixteen years old and untouched
and a flute sounds as if someone were coming
I listen and listen but never hear the melody of someone coming ...
No. What she heard were the distant sounds of a meal being readied; a clattering of bowls and spoons, laughter from the kitchen. Her reverie broken, she reached up and wiped the foolish tears from her cheeks. How could she think of herself as lonely, when she lived in this full house where everyone had cared for her all her life? I sit here reciting to myself sc.r.a.ps of old poetry when I have work to do.
At once she began to call up the reports that had been made about investigations into the ident.i.ty of Demosthenes.
The reports made her think for a moment that this was a dead end, too. More than three dozen writers on almost as many worlds had been arrested for producing seditious doc.u.ments under that name. Starways Congress had reached the obvious conclusion: Demosthenes was simply the catchall name used by any rebel who wanted to get attention. There was no real Demosthenes, not even an organized conspiracy.
But Qing-jao had doubts about that conclusion. Demosthenes had been remarkably successful in stirring up trouble on every world. Could there possibly be someone of so much talent among the traitors on every planet? Not likely.
Besides, thinking back to when she had read Demosthenes, Qing-jao, remembered noticing the coherence of his writings. The singularity and consistency of his vision-- that was part of what made him so seductive. Everything seemed to fit, to make sense together.
Hadn"t Demosthenes also devised the Hierarchy of Foreignness? Utlanning, Framling, Raman, Varelse. No; that had been written many years ago-- it had to be a different Demosthenes. Was it because of that earlier Demosthenes" hierarchy that the traitors were using the name? They were writing in support of the independence of Lusitania, the only world where intelligent nonhuman life had been found. It was only appropriate to use the name of the writer who had first taught humanity to realize that the universe wasn"t divided between humans and nonhumans, or between intelligent and non-intelligent species.
Some strangers, the earlier Demosthenes had said, were framlings-- humans from another world. Some were ramen-- of another intelligent species, yet able to communicate with human beings, so that we could work out differences and make decisions together. Others were varelse, "wise beasts," clearly intelligent and yet completely unable to reach a common ground with humankind. Only with varelse would war ever be justified; with raman, humans could make peace and share the habitable worlds. It was an open way of thinking, full of hope that strangers might still be friends. People who thought that way could never have sent a fleet with Dr. Device to a world inhabited by an intelligent species.
This was a very uncomfortable thought: that the Demosthenes of the hierarchy would also disapprove of the Lusitania Fleet. Almost at once Qing-jao had to counter it. It didn"t matter what the old Demosthenes thought, did it? The new Demosthenes, the seditious one, was no wise philosopher trying to bring peoples together. Instead he was trying to sow dissension and discontent among the worlds-- provoke quarrels, perhaps even wars between framlings.
And seditious Demosthenes was not not just a composite of many rebels working on different worlds. Her computer search soon confirmed it. True, many rebels were found who had published on their own planet using the name Demosthenes, but they were always linked to small, ineffective, useless little publications-- never to the really dangerous doc.u.ments that seemed to turn up simultaneously on half the worlds at once. Each local police force, however, was very happy to declare their own petty "Demosthenes" the perpetrator of all the writings, take their bows, and close the case. just a composite of many rebels working on different worlds. Her computer search soon confirmed it. True, many rebels were found who had published on their own planet using the name Demosthenes, but they were always linked to small, ineffective, useless little publications-- never to the really dangerous doc.u.ments that seemed to turn up simultaneously on half the worlds at once. Each local police force, however, was very happy to declare their own petty "Demosthenes" the perpetrator of all the writings, take their bows, and close the case.
Starways Congress had been only too happy to do the same thing with their own investigation. Having found several dozen cases where local police had arrested and convicted rebels who had incontrovertibly published something under the name Demosthenes, the Congress investigators sighed contentedly, declared that Demosthenes had proved to be a catchall name and not one person at all, and then stopped investigating.
In short, they had all taken the easy way out. Selfish, disloyal-- Qing-jao felt a surge of indignation that such people were allowed to continue in their high offices. They should be punished, and severely, too, for having let their private laziness or their desire for praise lead them to abandon the investigation of Demosthenes. Didn"t they realize that Demosthenes was truly dangerous? That his writings were now the common wisdom of at least one world, and if one, then probably many? Because of him, how many people on how many worlds would rejoice if they knew that the Lusitania Fleet had disappeared? No matter how many people the police had arrested under the name Demosthenes, his works kept appearing, and always in that same voice of sweet reasonableness. No, the more she read the reports, the more certain Qing-jao became that Demosthenes was one man, as yet undiscovered. One man who knew how to keep secrets impossibly well.
From the kitchen came the sound of the flute; they were being called to dinner. She gazed into the display s.p.a.ce over her terminal, where the latest report still hovered, the name Demosthenes Demosthenes repeated over and over. "I know you exist, Demosthenes," she whispered, "and I know you are very clever, and I will find you. When I do, you will stop your war against the rulers, and you will tell me what has happened to the Lusitania Fleet. Then I will be done with you, and Congress will punish you, and Father will become the G.o.d of Path and live forever in the Infinite West. That is the task that I was born for, the G.o.ds have chosen me for it, you might just as well show yourself to me now as later, for eventually all men and women lay their heads under the feet of the G.o.ds." repeated over and over. "I know you exist, Demosthenes," she whispered, "and I know you are very clever, and I will find you. When I do, you will stop your war against the rulers, and you will tell me what has happened to the Lusitania Fleet. Then I will be done with you, and Congress will punish you, and Father will become the G.o.d of Path and live forever in the Infinite West. That is the task that I was born for, the G.o.ds have chosen me for it, you might just as well show yourself to me now as later, for eventually all men and women lay their heads under the feet of the G.o.ds."
The flute played on, a breathy low melody, drawing Qing-jao out of herself and toward the company of the household. To her, this half-whispered music was the song of the inmost spirit, the quiet conversation of trees over a still pond, the sound of memories arising unbidden into the mind of a woman in prayer. Thus were they called to dine in the house of the n.o.ble Han Fei-tzu.
Having heard Qing-jao"s challenge, Jane thought: This is what fear of death tastes like. Human beings feel this all the time, and yet somehow they go on from day to day, knowing that at any moment they may cease to be. But this is because they can forget something and still know it; I can never forget, not without losing the knowledge entirely. I know that Han Qing-jao is on the verge of finding secrets that have stayed hidden only because no one has looked hard for them. And when those secrets are known, I will die.
"Ender," she whispered.
Was it day or night on Lusitania? Was he awake or asleep? For Jane, to ask a question is either to know or not-know. So she knew at once that it was night. Ender had been asleep, but now he was awake; he was still attuned to her voice, she realized, even though many silences had pa.s.sed between them in the past thirty years.
"Jane," he whispered.