11,487. What was the name of the person from whom you bought the soap on the occasion you have mentioned?-I think it was either Margaret or Catherine Irvine.
11,488. Was that a very exceptional case?-I should think so.
11,489. Have you not frequently bought from women the goods which they had got in shops at Lerwick?-No, not frequently.
That is the only case I remember of distinctly. I remember something being said about the women bringing goods for sale at other times, but I have no distinct recollection about that. It would hardly do for me to make a practice of that, because I have to live and support my family by my profits.
[Page 282]
11,490. But if the women were disposed to sell the goods to you at such a price as would enable you to derive a profit on your re-sale of them, that would be quite legitimate and fair?-Yes; but they could not do that.
11,491. Why?-Because it would cause them a considerable loss.
I suppose the goods are priced at an advance before they get them, and they could not afford to sell them to me at a less price than they had paid for them themselves.
11,492. You said you had heard of other cases being mentioned, in which women had offered their goods for sale: what have you heard about that?-I have heard some of my family speaking about the women getting their goods exchanged for provisions, or something of that kind.
11,493. Is your shop generally attended by yourself, or by some of your family?-It is generally attended by mny brother-in-law; he is not here.
11,494. Can you say that he has not bought goods in that way from knitters?-I think not. I don"t think he would do that without letting me know about it.
11,495. Do you know of any person here who purchases goods in that way from women who have got them for their hosiery?- There may be such persons but I am not aware of any one who makes a trade of it, or who could make a trade of it. There may be some who do that in order to oblige a woman or to relieve her necessities, but I don"t think they could make a practice of it. I have heard of Mrs. Tait doing it in that way.
11,496. Would you show me where you keep your accounts with these women?-Yes. [Produces book.] It is only a small part of that book which I use for that purpose. This [showing] is an account of a woman who dresses for me. Besides what is entered to her account, she is sometimes paid by goods which do not appear in the book at all.
11,497. I see here an entry: "To amount from line:" do you give lines?-I sometimes give a line to her when I do not care about entering it in the book. I should like better to pay her at once what I was due to her, if I could possibly do so.
11,498. What was the purpose of giving the line?-Just as a security.
11,499. She did not want the goods at the time, and you did not want to open an account?-No.
11,500. You would rather that these women would take the goods at once than have the trouble of keeping an account with them?- Yes.
11,501. What was the form of the line you gave?-It was just a credit note, bearing the name of the party and the amount for which they had to get credit from me.
11,502. Is the amount of that note understood to be paid in goods or in money?-It is never understood to be paid in money. I could not give the same price in money as I could give in goods.
11,503. Does the line express whether it is to be paid in goods or in money?-No.
11,504. Do you issue many of these lines?-Not many; very few require them. They generally take out goods to the full amount at once.
11,505. How did you happen to enter that line in your book?-The woman was getting fully more work from me than she could take out in goods at once, and she preferred to continue working for me and to get things for her family as she required them.
11,506. I see that the bulk of the entries in these accounts are for provisions?-Yes, and for such other goods as we keep-tea, sugar, loaves, b.u.t.ter, meal, flour, soda and other things.
11,507. Where do you get your supplies of worsted?-Princ.i.p.ally from Edinburgh or Leith.
11,508. Do you buy any Shetland worsted?-No; I cannot get it to buy.
11,509. Have you tried to get it and found it difficult?-Not often.
It was only last spring that I began the hosiery trade at all.
11,510. Do you import all your worsted direct from Edinburgh, or do you get any of it through the Lerwick houses?-I get it all from a wholesale house in Edinburgh.
11,511. What is the quality of the worsted you get from there?-It is generally the finest quality, but not mohair. I don"t deal in mohair at all. We generally use two qualities for veils, and these qualities are distinguished by numbers, but I don"t remember the numbers just now. I buy it by the pound, and I think it costs me from 5s. to 8s. per pound.
11,512. Do you sell the worsted to knitters?-Yes, when I have an extra supply of it.
11,513. Are you paid for it in hosiery articles or in cash?-In either way; I give it for either when I do sell it. When they have a quant.i.ty of hosiery to sell, I prefer them to take an a.s.sortment of goods, because provisions are a thing that most people have very little profit upon. If they take the whole price in meal or in anything of that kind, I would not have much profit upon it.
11,514. You would rather have them to take some of the price in soft goods?-Not in soft goods, but in an a.s.sortment of groceries.
11,515. When a woman brings her hosiery to you first fix the price, and then, I suppose, you ask her what she wants?-Yes.
11,516. When you come down to a balance of 1d. or 2d, how do you settle that?-If they want nothing else, I often give them the balance in cash. It is the understanding that they are to take the price for their hosiery in goods, but still I don"t hesitate to give them 1d. or 2d., or any small thing in money.
11,517. You may give them a penny, or a postage stamp, or a package of sweeties, or anything of that sort?-Yes.
11,518. Have you any accounts with fishermen?-No; they generally run their accounts at the places where they are employed. I would not like to run the risk of supplying them.
I think those who are getting the benefit of their fishing ought to run the risk of giving them what supplies they want. I deal with a good many of them in ready money for bread and provisions; not to a very large extent but just in a general way.
11,519. Do you find that they always have ready money with which to pay you for provisions and bread?-Most of those who deal with me have.
11,520. Do you think businesses such as yours would be improved if the fishermen were paid in ready money for the fish they take?-It is possible they might.
11,521. Don"t you think you would have a better chance of succeeding in business if the fishermen did not have such long credits?-It is very likely.
11,522. They would have more ready money in their hands throughout the year?-Some of them would.
11,523. At what season of the year have you the largest receipts in your ready money business?-In summer and harvest, I think; but I attribute that more to the weather than to anything else. The country people cannot get to the place in all weathers; they have often to come by sea, and then if they leave home at all it is generally just as easy for them to get to Lerwick as to go to Scalloway.
11,524. Still I don"t see how that accounts for your ready money business being larger in summer and harvest than at other periods of the year?-The boats can come from the west side and from the islands in summer more readily than they can in winter, when, perhaps, they cannot get away for weeks. It is chiefly upon people in the country that my business depends. The village of Scalloway is small, and the business from it is also small, so that it is only when the weather is suitable that my customers from the country cannot in to deal with me.
11,525. Do you have a larger amount of business from your immediate neighbours in the spring than at other seasons?-No, I have not noticed that. The business is so mixed up that I can hardly say.
11,526. You don"t think the fishermen round about you come to deal with you to a larger extent after settling time in spring than at other periods of the year?-I am not aware of that.
[Page 283]
Scalloway, January 22, 1872, CLEMENTINA GREIG, examined.
11,527. You live at Braehead, Scalloway, with your sister?-Yes.
11,528. Your mother died about two years ago a very old woman?-Yes; she was 95.
11,529. Have you supported yourself for a long time by knitting?-Yes; I began to knit thirty-three years ago, and since then I have not earned a sixpence by anything else, except my own family work. My mother also depended on me.
11,530. What kind of knitting do you do?-Shawls and veils.
11,531. Have you ever got any money for your work?-I have sold several shawls and veils to gentlemen who were travelling through the country in July and August, and got money for them; but I never got a penny in all my life from any of the merchants in Lerwick. I was the first individual in Scalloway who commenced to knit, and I have taught many of the people here.