10,885. Were they desired to inform the tenants that Mr. Leask was undertaking the fishing himself, and that he expected the tenants to engage in his boats" crews?-At that time Mr. Leask could get more men amongst his tenants than he could employ, and there was no need for any pressure. More men were anxious to go than he had boats for at that time.
10,886. Had you any correspondence with Mr. Williamson about him leaving Ulsta?-Yes, a very long correspondence, and rather an amusing one. He implored Mr. Leask to allow him to remain for another year, as his business was so extensive that he could not wind it up in so short a time.
10,887. What was Mr. Leask"s objection to allow him to remain?-He required the premises as a dwellinghouse for the incoming man, William Hughson; and of course it would not do to have opposition.
10,888. But he had made no arrangements for that at the time when Williamson was requested to prepare for removal?-He had not.
10,889. Then when was the correspondence? Was it when Williamson first got the notice or afterwards?-It was not until long afterwards. I think Williamson was of opinion that Mr.
Leask would not remove him, and he trusted to that until the very last. I think he had some idea of getting the new premises, notwithstanding what had pa.s.sed.
10,890. Were new premises built?-Yes, they were built last year.
They were begun in June and only completed in December 1871.
10,891. Was Williamson still carrying on the fishing in 1871 while these new premises were being built?-Yes. He was fishing and carrying on the business the same as before.
10,892. How many men had he fishing for him last year at Ulsta?-I think he had about the same number of boats that he had formerly.
10,893. And he still had the same premises?-He occupied the same premises all along. The premises which Mr. Leask is occupying now for business purposes are altogether new.
Williamson continued to occupy the old premises until November 1871, when he had to leave.
10,894. Where did he manage to get fishermen when Mr. Leask had put on three new boats?-I think he got some from Mr.
M"Queen"s estate, and also some of Mr. Leask"s own tenants.
10,895. Does Mr. Leask intend to put on a larger number of boats this year?-I think he intends to put on one or two more.
10,896. But the boats" crews that he employed last year had formerly been in the employment of Williamson and Johnston?- Yes.
10,897. Is Johnston still carrying on business?-Yes, he is carrying on business at Sound, in West Yell, where he has a small property.
10,898. Do you know how many boats he has?-I think he has two but I am not sure. Some of Mr. Leask"s tenants fished for Johnston last year also.
10,899. Will Mr. Leask"s tenants be allowed to fish for Johnston and Williamson in future?-I don"t think they would do so if Mr.
Leask would give them employment.
10,900. But will they be allowed to fish for any other than Mr.
Leask?-I don"t think Mr. Leask would force any one to fish for him.
10,901. The tenants have received no intimation to the contrary?- No.
10,902. And no hint?-No hint whatever. In fact, there were tenants applying in November last for new boats, and requesting Mr. Leask to build new boats for them, because there are a good many men who would like to be employed by him, in preference to being employed by Johnston or any other body.
10,903. Do you know whether many of the men were in debt to Williamson when he left Ulsta?-I don"t know.
10,904. Was that one of the reasons why Williamson was anxious not to quit in a hurry?-He alleged that reason; but I am of opinion that there were not many of them in debt.
10,905. Did he ask you to relieve him of any of these debts?- Never.
10,906. Do you suppose he has any chance of recovering any debts that may exist now?-Certainly he has. The men have all got effects of some kind or another, so that he may easily take them into court and recover what they are due him. They are all in very good circ.u.mstances; there are none of them who could not pay their debts.
10,907. Has Mr. Leask any property in Sandsting?-Yes; he has the property of Sand and Inner Sand. There are between 40 and 50 tenants upon it.
10,908. Are most of them engaged in the summer fishing?-A good many of them are. Some of them fish for Garriock & Co., and some for Mr. Leask, and I think some for Charles Nicholson.
10,909. Is that property in the south side of the parish?-Yes; it is near Reawick.
10,910. Has Mr. Leask any station in that district?-No.
10,911. Then where do they fish for him?-They go in some of his vessels to the Faroe fishing. He has no home-fishing station in Sandsting.
10,912. Are they at liberty to go to the home fishing or to the Faroe fishing for anybody they like?-Yes. They are under no obligation to fish for Mr. Leask. They can go where they like, and they have always done so.
10,913. Do they hold their land as yearly tenants?-Yes.
10,912. What other property has Mr. Leask?-South Whiteness, to the north-west of Scalloway, in the parish of Tingwall. I think there are about seventeen or eighteen tenants on that property.
They fish princ.i.p.ally for Mr. Leask in the Faroe fishing, and in the spring fishing, which occupies about a month or a little more.
10,915. Then they are not generally engaged in the home fishing?-No; they are generally engaged in the Faroe fishing.
10,916. How many of them may have gone to that fishing last year?-There may have been above a dozen.
10,917. These men, I presume, have accounts at Mr. Leask"s shop at Lerwick?-Yes.
10,918. Is there any stipulation made with them that they shall man his Faroe smacks?-None. They are not bound at all. They may go where they please and engage themselves with whoever they please.
10,919. Has Mr. Leask any other properties in Shetland?-He has some small properties in other places-in Quarff, North Roe, and Aithsting. He has two tenants in Quarff, three in Aithsting, and one in North Roe. These tenants do not fish for Mr. Leask at all, and never have done so, or been asked to do so.
10,920. Then Mr. Leask"s business consists in sending smacks to the Faroe fishing?-Yes.
10,921. And in sending boats to the summer fishing?-Now it does, but not formerly. It was only last year that he commenced the home fishing at Ulsta.
10,922. Has he commenced that business anywhere else?-No.
Ulsta is the only summer-fishing station that he has.
10,923. Mr. Leask is also engaged in the whale fishing, both as an owner of ships and as an agent?-Yes.
10,924. I believe it is specially with regard to the agency business that you wish to make some statement?-Yes. I wish to make a statement with regard to Mr. Hamilton"s Report to the Board of Trade in November 1870. Some of it is so utterly absurd that I should like to have it contradicted. He says, "I ought to mention that the truck system, in an open or disguised form, prevails in Shetland to an extent which, I believe, is unknown in any other part of the United Kingdom." Now, that I deny ; and I think I will be able to prove before I am done that it is not correct."And makes its depressing influence felt in all the ramifications of the industrial and social life of the natives."
10,925. He says, "Almost every fisherman in the islands is in debt to some shopkeeper; and not only is [Page 267] the head of the family in debt, but frequently his wife also, and other members of his family, down to children of twelve or fourteen years of age, for whom the shopkeeper opens separate accounts in his books." Is that the case?-There may be some cases of that, but it is not general. I deny that almost every fisherman in the islands is in debt. Then he says, "These fishermen, for the most part, also rent small farms of from three to four acres." That also I deny Mr.
Leask has about 120 tenants, and I think the average quant.i.ty of land they hold is about twelve acres of enclosed ground, besides common.
10,926. What is the amount of their rent?-The rent is something less than 10s. an acre, on the average. Some have as much as twenty-three acres, and in some cases they have about seven. The rental I have given is for the enclosed ground within the township; and in addition to that, the people have extensive commons.
10,927. On Mr. Leask"s estates are the scattalds still left to the people without any payment?-Yes, except in Yell, where they have to pay 6d. per annum for every sheep. They also pay something for ponies, but nothing for cattle.
10,928. I omitted to ask whether Mr. Leask has the management of any properties except his own?-No.
10,929. He is not tacksman of any property, and he holds no property in lease?-No. I may mention that he has an a.s.signation of the rents of a small property in Mid Yell, in security for debt.