Cauchon sinks back in his chair with a heavy sigh. The Inquisitor purses his lips and frowns. Ladvenu shakes his head pitifully.
D"ESTIVET. She imputes to the Church the error and folly of commanding the impossible.
JOAN. If you command me to declare that all that I have done and said, and all the visions and revelations I have had, were not from G.o.d, then that is impossible: I will not declare it for anything in the world. What G.o.d made me do I will never go back on; and what He has commanded or shall command I will not fail to do in spite of any man alive. That is what I mean by impossible. And in case the Church should bid me do anything contrary to the command I have from G.o.d, I will not consent to it, no matter what it may be.
THE a.s.sESSORS [shocked and indignant] Oh! The Church contrary to G.o.d! What do you say now? Flat heresy. This is beyond everything, etc., etc.
D"ESTIVET [throwing down his brief] My lord: do you need anything more than this?
CAUCHON. Woman: you have said enough to burn ten heretics. Will you not be warned? Will you not understand?
THE INQUISITOR. If the Church Militant tells you that your revelations and visions are sent by the devil to tempt you to your d.a.m.nation, will you not believe that the Church is wiser than you?
JOAN. I believe that G.o.d is wiser than I; and it is His commands that I will do. All the things that you call my crimes have come to me by the command of G.o.d. I say that I have done them by the order of G.o.d: it is impossible for me to say anything else. If any Churchman says the contrary I shall not mind him: I shall mind G.o.d alone, whose command I always follow.
LADVENU [pleading with her urgently] You do not know what you are saying, child. Do you want to kill yourself? Listen. Do you not believe that you are subject to the Church of G.o.d on earth?
JOAN. Yes. When have I ever denied it?
LADVENU. Good. That means, does it not, that you are subject to our Lord the Pope, to the cardinals, the archbishops, and the bishops for whom his lordship stands here today?
JOAN. G.o.d must be served first.
D"ESTIVET. Then your voices command you not to submit yourself to the Church Militant?
JOAN. My voices do not tell me to disobey the Church; but G.o.d must be served first.
CAUCHON. And you, and not the Church, are to be the judge?
JOAN. What other judgment can I judge by but my own?
THE a.s.sESSORS [scandalized] Oh! [They cannot find words].
CAUCHON. Out of your own mouth you have condemned yourself. We have striven for your salvation to the verge of sinning ourselves: we have opened the door to you again and again; and you have shut it in our faces and in the face of G.o.d. Dare you pretend, after what you have said, that you are in a state of grace?
JOAN. If I am not, may G.o.d bring me to it: if I am, may G.o.d keep me in it!
LADVENU. That is a very good reply, my lord.
COURCELLES. Were you in a state of grace when you stole the Bishop"s horse?
CAUCHON [rising in a fury] Oh, devil take the Bishop"s horse and you too! We are here to try a case of heresy; and no sooner do we come to the root of the matter than we are thrown back by idiots who understand nothing but horses. [Trembling with rage, he forces himself to sit down].
THE INQUISITOR. Gentlemen, gentlemen: in clinging to these small issues you are The Maid"s best advocates. I am not surprised that his lordship has lost patience with you. What does the Promoter say? Does he press these trumpery matters?
D"ESTIVET. I am bound by my office to press everything; but when the woman confesses a heresy that must bring upon her the doom of excommunication, of what consequence is it that she has been guilty also of offences which expose her to minor penances? I share the impatience of his lordship as to these minor charges. Only, with great respect, I must emphasize the gravity of two very horrible and blasphemous crimes which she does not deny. First, she has intercourse with evil spirits, and is therefore a sorceress.
Second, she wears men"s clothes, which is indecent, unnatural, and abominable; and in spite of our most earnest remonstrances and entreaties, she will not change them even to receive the sacrament.
JOAN. Is the blessed St Catherine an evil spirit? Is St Margaret?
Is Michael the Archangel?
COURCELLES. How do you know that the spirit which appears to you is an archangel? Does he not appear to you as a naked man?
JOAN. Do you think G.o.d cannot afford clothes for him?
The a.s.sessors cannot kelp smiling, especially as the joke is against Courcelles.
LADVENU. Well answered, Joan.
THE INQUISITOR. It is, in effect, well answered. But no evil spirit would be so simple as to appear to a young girl in a guise that would scandalize her when he meant her to take him for a messenger from the Most High. Joan: the Church instructs you that these apparitions are demons seeking your soul"s perdition. Do you accept the instruction of the Church?
JOAN. I accept the messenger of G.o.d. How could any faithful believer in the Church refuse him?
CAUCHON. Wretched woman: again I ask you, do you know what you are saying?
THE INQUISITOR. You wrestle in vain with the devil for her soul, my lord: she will not be saved. Now as to this matter of the man"s dress. For the last time, will you put off that impudent attire, and dress as becomes your s.e.x?
JOAN. I will not.
D"ESTIVET [pouncing] The sin of disobedience, my lord.
JOAN [distressed] But my voices tell me I must dress as a soldier.
LADVENU. Joan, Joan: does not that prove to you that the voices are the voices of evil spirits? Can you suggest to us one good reason why an angel of G.o.d should give you such shameless advice?
JOAN. Why, yes: what can be plainer commonsense? I was a soldier living among soldiers. I am a prisoner guarded by soldiers. If I were to dress as a woman they would think of me as a woman; and then what would become of me? If I dress as a soldier they think of me as a soldier, and I can live with them as I do at home with my brothers. That is why St Catherine tells me I must not dress as a woman until she gives me leave.
COURCELLES. When will she give you leave?
JOAN. When you take me out of the hands of the English soldiers.
I have told you that I should be in the hands of the Church, and not left night and day with four soldiers of the Earl of Warwick.
Do you want me to live with them in petticoats?
LADVENU. My lord: what she says is, G.o.d knows, very wrong and shocking; but there is a grain of worldly sense in it such as might impose on a simple village maiden.
JOAN. If we were as simple in the village as you are in your courts and palaces, there would soon be no wheat to make bread for you.
CAUCHON. That is the thanks you get for trying to save her, Brother Martin.
LADVENU. Joan: we are all trying to save you. His lordship is trying to save you. The Inquisitor could not be more just to you if you were his own daughter. But you are blinded by a terrible pride and self-sufficiency.
JOAN. Why do you say that? I have said nothing wrong. I cannot understand.
THE INQUISITOR. The blessed St Athanasius has laid it down in his creed that those who cannot understand are d.a.m.ned. It is not enough to be simple. It is not enough even to be what simple people call good. The simplicity of a darkened mind is no better than the simplicity of a beast.
JOAN. There is great wisdom in the simplicity of a beast, let me tell you; and sometimes great foolishness in the wisdom of scholars.
LADVENU. We know that, Joan: we are not so foolish as you think us. Try to resist the temptation to make pert replies to us. Do you see that man who stands behind you [he indicates the Executioner]?