10,609. Do you pay the same price there?-Much about it.
10,610. Is there any difference?-Not very much.
10,611. Is there any difference at all?-I don"t know; I have never seen much difference.
10,612. Is the price of meal the same at the two places?-I always bought meal in bolls, and paid so much per boll. I bought some from a farmer at Haroldswick, not from Spence & Co., and I paid him 21s. per boll for meal off his own farm. I have not bought any from Mr. Spence this year.
10,613. Is there no oatmeal in your account?-No.
10,614. Was there a balance in your favour at the last settlement after you stopped fishing?-Yes; I think I had 12 to get. I think my shop account for goods that year was about 4.
10,615. Who is the farmer from whom you got that meal?-Mr.
Hugh Inkster. I gave him money for it when I bought it.
10,616. Where did you get the 21s?-I got it from some ponies that I sold, and from some money that I had saved before I left the fishing.
10,617. Did you sell these ponies to Spence & Co.?-I sold one to William Manson, and another to Charleson, who comes from Yell Sound.
10,618. Do you sometimes buy your goods elsewhere than from Spence & Co. and Johnston?-I sometimes get them from Lerwick.
10,619. Do you get them cheaper there?-Very little. I never send for them unless I am going there myself.
10,620. Did you ever fish for any one else than Spence & Co?- Yes; I fished for the late Mr. Samuel D. Hunter, Lerwick.
10,621. Were you paid by him in the same way every year?-Yes.
10,622. You never were obliged to fish for any particular person?-No.
10,623. And you never were obliged to take your goods from any particular shop?-No.
Baltasound, Unst, January 19, 1872, DAVID EDMONSTONE, examined.
10,624. What are you?-I am factor on the Buness estate, and a farmer.
10,625. I understand you have had a great deal of experience of business in Shetland?-Yes. I was nine years in business as a fish-merchant, and I have lived in Shetland all my life, with the exception of a year or two.
[Page 259]
10,626. Were you the writer of a letter which was quoted in the evidence given in Edinburgh, Q. 44,511-Yes.
10,627. Do you still retain the same opinions as are stated in that letter?-I do.
10,628. Do you think it is a correct statement at this time, that the people do not receive in money one-fiftieth of their earnings?-In the way I look at it, I think that statement is correct, because I hold that when there is only a settlement once a year, in January or February, and the man gets his balance then, that is not a cash payment in any sense of the word.
10,629. You mean that it is only a cash payment so far as the balance is handed over to him?-Yes; and that he has not got cash for fish or any other produce during the season.
10,630. You don"t doubt, I suppose, that a fisherman can get an advance of cash during the season if he wants it?-No, I don"t doubt that.
10,631. Do you think that advances or payments of that nature in the course of the fishing season ought to be made compulsory, or to be required by law?-Yes, I have long thought so.
10,632. Do you think that would be practicable in the fishing business?-I think so most decidedly, so far as my experience goes.
10,633. Have you any opinion to give with regard to the system of combining land-holding with fishing in Shetland?-I think they must be combined to a certain extent. I have thought a good deal and I don"t think a man can earn a sufficient livelihood by fishing alone, because the weather in the winter time is so stormy that they cannot often get out for many days, and sometimes for weeks.
10,634. Would that difficulty not be removed to some extent if larger boats were introduced, and the men were trained to the use of them?-I think not. From the strong currents which run round the sh.o.r.e, I think larger boats are not adapted to the coast. In fact, I believe a good Shetland boat, well manned, would go through what a much larger one would not go through.
10,635. Do you know that to be the opinion of the best seamen in Shetland?-I believe it is. For instance, the large boats used in the neighbourhood of Lerwick for herrings have often been lost when the common six-oared boats came safely. These large boats are more unwieldy and more difficult to handle than the small ones.
10,636. At what period are the rents on the Buness estate paid?- At Martinmas.
10,637. Is it necessary to fix the payment at that period, from a consideration of the settling time between the merchants and the fishermen?-Yes. It has always been the habit to pay the rents at Martinmas.
10,638. It is universal in Shetland, I understand, to pay the rents only once a year?-Yes; the tenants have their holdings from Martinmas to Martinmas.
10,639. Can you explain why that arrangement has been made? Is it from anything connected with the fishing?-I think so. The men would then have an opportunity of completing their fishing and getting all the sales made which they have to make, and then they are supposed to be in funds. I suppose that is the reason, but I don"t know.
10,640. Is it usual for the proprietor to enter into any arrangement with the fish-curer for the payment of his rents?-We do that on the Buness estate, and I should like to explain the reason of it. The tenants have all been told that they are at perfect liberty to fish to whom they like; but after they have engaged to fish to a certain curer, we wish them to bring a guarantee from their curer or curers for the rent of the year on which they have entered, and during which they are to fish. One reason for that-in fact the only reason-is, that the men do not get money payments, and therefore a great number of them will be induced to run a heavy account at the shop, and when we collect the rents at Martinmas we would have nothing to get. If the men were paid in money, daily or weekly or fortnightly, then we would make no such arrangement, but would collect the rents directly from the men.
10,641. Then, in fact, that arrangement is made in order to limit the credit which the fish-merchant gives to his men?-Yes; and to secure that we are to get part of that money.
10,642. But it has the effect of limiting their credit?-Yes.
10,643. Are you aware whether that is a usual arrangement in Shetland?-I don"t know. The Buness estate was in tack or lease to tacksmen for twelve or fourteen years before 1868, first to Mr.
Hunter of Lerwick, and then to myself. Under that arrangement we paid a certain amount for the estate, and made the best we could of it.
10,644. You took the risk of the tenants paying their rents?-Yes, the entire risk.
10,645. Did Mr. Hunter and you employ most of the men as fishermen?-Yes, most of them.
10,646. Do you think the effect of the present system is to stunt trade, and keep other shops down except those of the fish-curers?-I think so.
10,647. Did you hear the evidence which Mr. Spence gave on that subject?-Yes.
10,648. Do you agree with his opinion that it would be better to have one large monopolist than a number of small shops?-No, I don"t agree with that.
10,649. You think that compet.i.tion would be wholesome?-I think so, if there were cash payments.
10,650. Have you any reasons, within your own experience, for maintaining that opinion with regard to Shetland?-I think, from my own experience, that the people would be very much more independent if they had cash in their hands. They are not entrusted with cash just now, as a general rule. I know they get their balances paid; but they are not entrusted with cash, and therefore they are not independent. They are like schoolboys; they lean upon other people, and I don"t think that is a good system. When a bad year comes, they expect that the fish-curer has to advance them meal; and they will tell him that if he won"t do it, they won"t fish for him again. In that way he must do it; in fact they think he is bound to do it. They have no self-reliance or independence.
10,651. Could they get supplies in any other way if the curer did not advance them meal?-There are very few tenants who have not stock of their own-cattle and horses.
10,652. But these are liable to the landlord for their rent?-Yes; and they are liable to be sold for supplies to themselves.
10,653. Do you think that even in a bad year their stock might carry them through?-I think so, in most cases.
10,654. Is there any restriction on the Buness estate upon the opening of new shops?-None whatever.